• RECEIVE THE GIFTS MEMBERS SHARE WITH YOU HERE...THEN...CREATE SOMETHING TO ENCHANT OTHERS THAT YOU WANT TO SHARE

    You know what we all love...

    When you enchant people, you fill them with delight and yourself in return. Have Fun!!!

Sign in to follow this  
Hammer Handle

Keeping bigger fish can create giant fish???

Recommended Posts

Hammer Handle

This article says that fish can grow faster if smaller fish are kept, but keeping only the "big fish" can cause some to grow into giants.

I think the article says that we don't know anything yet....

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/20037483/

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
polarsusd81

Reading the story, it says the data was produced by a computer model. I am thinking that I will trust what is proven to be by the biologists that deal with the ecosystems on a daily basis versus a machine that will not function in water up to its knees. It sounds like a bs story with results that had to be published to get paid for doing a study.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Questor

It sounds plausible until you start to factor in fishing pressure. The big ones are usually the most vulnerable, so they don't last long when fishing pressure is applied.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
chrisduc

Very interesting thought. I have to believe each system is different and a lot of different factors will effect the outcome. Definately something to consider.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Fishin Beast

Bigger panfish do eat different things than smaller panfish so there is one point. But you will kill the genes in the fish. What happens when those few trophys die? The young of the trophy fish will automatically become stunted as there are only small fish left. What you do is just control the overall population. That happens by having big predatory fish in the lake. They will weed out the weeker fish and keep only the strongest panfish.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
slipperybob

Umm cannibals...giant fish eats big fish, big fish eats little fish.

Take big fish out of equation

Giant fish eats what? little fish...Ecosystem change/crash.... crazy.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
nofishfisherman

The logic just seems very flawed.

If you catch and keep the big fish what will be left to grow into giant fish?

There might be one or two elusive big fish that people couldn't catch which will probably grow into giants but they got that way becuase they couldn't be caught so from a fishermans perspective why would I want to manage a lake so that it maintains a very small population of giant fish that no one is able to catch?

I think the accepted method of releasing the bigger fish is working just fine and will continue to keep working.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
castmaster

I think whats best is a balanced population of fish in all year classes and sizes.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
HateHumminbird

Most likely, there's a reason that the research in question was not published in a well-respected, peer-reviewed fisheries science journal. Rather, it was published in a very broad-brush journal with a less notable track record than many of the more mainstream fisheries biology publications.

Along with questions regarding modeling vs. sampling real populations, some of the major concerns I have are:

1. Interactive effects amongst different game species - i.e. predator/prey relationships - Cannibalistic or not

2. Assumption that fishing pressure, size structure, and environmental variables hold constant

3. Long-term sustainability of this approach

It seems to me that this flies in the face of years of fisheries research regarding selective harvest, fishing opportunity, and pressure. In other words, it's far too soon to suggest that harvesting large fish help what's left become giant; especially when based on an untested artificial sample.

Joel

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Dave B

I dont think that they are saying that the overall fishery will have big fish, but that there will be a handful of fish that will be much larger than what is in a typical lake.

I saw an example of this growing up in Eden Prairie. We caught a ton of very small fish from Round Lake (which is about 30 acres, just under one mile around). They killed it off 2-3 times and there would be HUGE fish in there each time it was killed off. We would also stumble into schools of 1lb+ sunnies where the rest were tiny. It was extremely rare to catch a "regular" size fish, they were huge or stunted.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Muskiefool

Computer generated Mother Nature confused.gif Heres a abstract of a study that shows how that theoretical computerized management system fails

Source: Blackwell Synergy

Populations where large fish were selectively harvested (as in most fisheries) displayed substantial declines in fecundity, egg volume, larval size at hatch, larval viability, larval growth rates, food consumption rate and conversion efficiency, vertebral number, and willingness to forage. These genetically based changes in numerous traits generally reduce the capacity for population recovery.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
papabear

It is intersting to try and theories fish size managemnet. We can guess and dream that wecan do things to produce trophies for us to catch. But genetics, lake classification, weather, overall fish population, development, and fishing pressure all have an effect on the lakes. We have lakes that will never grow trophies and lakes that consistently do. I wonder more of why must we produce trophies to catch. If that is your sole purpose of fishing you may be missing the boat. And we wonder why we are not recruiting as many young fishermen/girls.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  



  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • mrpike1973
      Did real good on cats today got 4 wife 4 and I got a huge sucker that was fun. Horseshoe sure opened up today.
    • eyeguy 54
      Sure glad you had some help moose and all turned out well ! 
    • Rick
      Impressive, both Tom and Jeremy
    • eyeguy 54
      Almost time but maybe not quite... Although I did get the yak out of the backyard today, on to the trailer and up front to spend some time prepping it for time on the water soon.  Indeed it was fun getting out with you and the gang a few times this winter and looking forward to the next outings whenever they may be. WIll share what worked for me and look forward to reading some more info from others. Panfish is what I love going after and I had great fishing with gold jigs almost all winter. Did use a few other colors that worked also but that gold was hard to not use. Tear drop style tungsten in and 4 mm from Widowmaker Lures. Tried some from sportsmens direct also the last couple outings and liked them also. For plastics, the wishbone was good and also impulse mayflies and slug bugs. Tried and bought too many different things to try... LOL. Fished with shrimp for the first time ever this winter and that was a challenge and fun to try something different.  Started out with my good old ultralight gander mountain rods with the frabil titanium spring bobber and then bought a couple of the TUCR Inferno with the orange tip. I really like them for the 4mm and prefer the old ganders with a 3mm. Won a custom 32 inch power noodle from Kichler Custom Rods in Elk River at an event in Wisconsin and used it a few times yesterday. Very nice and looking forward to playing with it more. CGI inline reels still doing their job fine and I did grab one of the new Descent inlines and it worked sweet also. Nice that it now has a pop off spool instead of the gold screw off knob. 10 1/4 was my biggest gill and 14 for the crappie. Even went after catfish 3 times. Saw my first catfish tornado on the vex and iced a lot of fish after being taught how to use a bobber right for those super light biters. thx RickG   My highlight of the winter was getting a PB northern on a tip up up on Mille Lacs with stick in the mud. Fun City! My good old FL 18 is still working dandy and although I am tempted to upgrade, not sure if I will. Nills 6 inch saved my back from the hassles of the gas and when I put the Milwaukee on it life got even better. All in all a fantastic winter fishing with great guys and learning how to be a better fisherman.   Fish On! 
    • monstermoose78
      Well monstermoose78 is done ice fishing around here for the year. Why you ask I fell through yes there was 28-30 inches of ice on the lake, but the shoreline nope. Went fishing with @Cret Jigs and we had fun fishing. I cut lots of holes and we got some good ones for the knife. Cret jigs brought a plank for the way out but on the way in I did not make it to the plank. Cret jigs helped me get my stuff the shore and out. I worry about the guy on the wheeler and they guy who used the plank to get out too. Thanks Cret jigs for a fun day. 
    • redlabguy
      To all you guys who’ve been keeping us posted, thank you. I’m an islander so I don’t have much hope for the opener, but I’ve been reading all the posts (read them year around), including entertaining posts on new gear, and, again, thanks for letting a lot of guys know what’s going on there. The current weather, forecast and web cams, give me hope! I’m thinking I may get back home in three weeks, maybe four. Keep the sun shining, Dick
    • jkrash
      What a difference a day makes, yesterday the dam was locked up tight and today it's roaring. Walleye should be running this week...
    • IceHawk
      Well this morning was officially the end of the ice season for me.   Its been a lot of days on the ice this winter and I have to admit I'm  a little burnt out.   It wasn't easy but it was time to end it.  Have to admit It was a sad moment putting the gear away but it was time as needed space today to put the boat in the garage   Learned a lot of new water and reacquainted myself with some old standbys. Fished 10 different counties this winter so definitely fished a lot of different areas.  Fished many species on the ice this winter so there never was a dull moment. Didn't take a ton of pics just a few need to take more just have never been a pic type of guy LOL.   Iced 7 walleyes between 26-28 3/4 all on local lakes.  So just a tip if you dedicate some time locally big eyes can be found. Fished panfish everywhere in the state highlight area for big fish being Becker and Ottertail Douglas counties. Biggest gill this winter was 10 3/4    many 10's came topside but couldn't break 11 this winter. Craps 15 inchers were tops. Good fish but had goals set at a 16.  Some things learned this ice season where number one lure for the eyes was a old school hammered silver Swedish pimple. It far out produced anything else.   Kenders tungsten where my mainstay for gills and crappies. The plastics of choice were power bait wishbones,  chigger frys, and Northland impulse mayfly's.  The catfish were a hoot and a  change of pace did well on Maynards slammers Glow red. The equipment and gear I was running and never failed me all season were Thorne Bros Rods- For eyes Perch sweethearts. For the Panfish I was running  Power Noodles, panfish sweethearts,  and my favorite the Tripwire. Reels Pflueger Presidents, Prestige ,and Supremes.. Did use some inlines also from 13 fishing The free falls where worth every penny. Ran a K-Drill 8 inch early and late and During the thick ice Ran my strikemaste Lazer.  Vexilar Electronics the old trusty FL18 my eyes underwater, Please Don't  think that I'm pushing these products because I'm sponsored by them, I'm Not. Just want to give a thumbs up and honest opinion on  some top notch equipment that has worked and weathered the storm of a good hardwater season. Realize we all work hard for our dollars and I can honestly say these products where worth every penny and never let me down!  Well Off to the Garage to start getting the boat ready for the Next season  By the Way big Shout out to some of the best Anglers I had the chance to share the ice with this season from FM.  Thanks  Borch,  Bass Thumb,  Moose,  Eyeguy, Rick G , Tom Sawyer for shareing some ice time with me.  Hopefully I get to meet and fish with a few other FMer's this summer or next hardwater.  We had some great Times great laughs and managed to even ice a few fish   Looking forward to having a few summer outings in the future.  BYE BYE Ice Hello open water 
    • Cliff Wagenbach
      Thank for the update and photo Dave and Diane! Cliff
    • Cliff Wagenbach
      I was out on Vermilion fishing today again. Big bay still has about the same amount of ice but the ice is a lot softer now! Small patches of 4" to 6" deep slush pockets on it. Pike bay seemed solid when we went out but when we returned almost the entire bay had about 6" of very soft slushy ice on top! That will be my last trip out this winter. Talked to one Native that I saw checking a  net that he had  out under the ice in Pike Bay. He had caught around 15 walleyes and a pike today and 8 or so walleyes yesterday. Tough way to catch fish! Cliff