Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
iffwalleyes

Broadheads for Elk

6 posts in this topic

I am going to MT this fall bow hunting for elk. I am curious what some of you have used for broadheads for elk. I usually use Rockey Mountain Premium 125 Grain broadheads. Do you think those would be ok to use. Or should I look at something different? Should I consider expandable broadheads?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I used Muzzy 125's. When I talked with matthews and Easton a few years ago, I believe they suggested to have at a minimum of 450 grains total arrow weight.

Personally I'm not a fan of expandables as I have seen some bad things with the broadheads. Maybe the broadheads were cheap ones, I dont know. Those elk have big bones and are thick skinned and will take a darn good hit to put down.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have never used expandables and really don't want to start. But I figured if they were the next best thing maybe it would be worth a shot.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think Harvey hit it on the head, arrow weight (and shot placement) are the keys to elk. Any good fixed blade broadhead should work. Goto bowsite (Contact Us Please) com and pose the question, those guys are big time elk hunters.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Jason,

A lot of states don't allow expandables for elk hunting- I think Montana is one of them (can't remember for sure though). You'll be just fine with your Rocky's. You want to be sure to have about 60 or more pounds of kinetic energy in the punch you're packing. To calculate this, you'll need your arrow weight (with broadhead, knock, veins) and the speed of your arrow. Then do a search for "archery" and "kinetic energy" and you'll find a kinetic energy calculator. After that, like Harvey said- big, tough animal... make sure you have a sturdy broadhead (like the one you mentioned) and you'll be in great shape if you put your arrow where you should.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've used the Montec G5 in 125 grains for the last few years with good results. It's a heavy duty broadhead that is still cut on contact.

My first elk I used a smaller lighter built fixed blade broadhead. It centered on a rib and broke it, but the shaft of the broadhead bent right where it came out of the arrow. I think the bending of the shaft used up a lot of energy and it only penetrated 1 lung. It still dispatched the animal fairly quickly, but not as quick as 2 lungs! My last elk the Montec went completely through both lungs and out the other side with the arrow still in her and she only went about 40 yards.

So I'd recommend a cut-on-contact fixed blade broad head constructed of heavy duty materials in the correct weight for your bow and arrow setup!

Good Luck!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Cheers
    • leech~~
      Welcome Rachelkate21 to the forum.  "brooks/steams/rivers that would be full of trout?" That is a pretty high order around Lakeville or anywhere. You may have to go south of you around Whitewater or up north in the arrowhead area. Best bet is check out the MN DNR site for Trout streams and their locations within the state. Good Luck!
    • Sleder
      Wanderer ,I believe Ely seizure was something to do with the BWCA . Lots of articles in newspaper .Some law about no commercial activity ( an active viable fishery) in side of park unless it enhances park like canoe rentals ect.... They were trying to stop Fishery for last number of years. I believe DNR does not want to do away with Frozen Bait Market , they just don't want fish from the Great Lakes or other contaminated areas to bring diesese to inland lakes.  If fish does not have a VHS Certification Number on its package , I would not be using it for bait.  Grocery store stuff totally Illegal ...  I emailed a Bait Company that has VHS Certified Smelt and Alewifes   info@awesomeadventuresfisheries.com     They gave me a list of stores that carry their products ... Save hunting around for Legal Bait   Hope this Helps
    • Sushilicious
      We only fished for 5 hours (only 2 hours were worthwhile 29 ft).  
    • Sushilicious
      OK so day before father's day we had terrible weather. 1st spot was in 14 ft of current n we caught 4 eyes. Did c a sturgeon role but waste of time other than that. Next spot 6 eyes still a wasted time cause of the weather but the old man did caught a 20 in so it wasn't all that bad. But once the weather allowed we catch  26 eyes n in 29 ft of water n one was 24 in.
    • Sushilicious
      Definitely have 2 disagree with with u 2. I understand the drive n the worry but if you've fished the csn chain for 10+ years there shouldn't be a worry 2 find a campsite cause you've driven past plenty of them. Also we're in the same boat regardless of the travel distance to fine a campsite. Yes it is nice 2 have a guaranteed spot but since they went 2 paid 2 camp regulation they have taken out a number of campsites so it limits options. ALSO U R WAY WRONG ON SAYING MORE PPL R AT THE PARK NOW. I went last Saturday  (day before father's day) n we seen like 4 or 5 more boats than canoes. It's nice for ppl who don't know the csn chain but it's terrible for the economy.   Fyi. First time I went fishing on the chain I went lake trout fishing on David......... I was 6 weeks old ......... I'm 32 now..... my dad's been fishing the csn chain for 65+ years    P.s. love how there's less pressure=better fishing.
    • Rachelkate21
      Hey! Does anyone know any brooks/steams/rivers that would be full of trout? Preferably near lakeville, mn but ill travel!
    • redlabguy
      Nice fish, Jeff. And good lesson on 1/2 crawlers, Cliff. I'm off the water for a few days with family doings, but should report I've seen a lot of mayflies in Frazer and near the portage. Clouds on the sonar and slicks of the water. I'm guessing it's not the big hatch, but it's providing a lot of food for fish. good luck out there.
    • osok
      Just got back into town from a slightly too long "vacation" dealing with relatives. Anywho, how has the fishing been on Superior, are the fish local or have they migrated N.E? 
    • AaronTC05
      I just bought a new Elite 7TI and the sun cover it came with doesn't really snap on very securely.  I'd say it just rests loosely on the outside.  It won't fall off if I flip it upside down, but it feels like it wouldn't stay on going down the highway or withstand any sort of jarring.  It takes hardly any pressure to pull it off.  Is this normal or is it a defect?  I've never owned a graph with a sun cover so I'm not familiar, but I imagined it would be a lot more snug.