Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

  • Announcements

    • Rick

      Members Only Fluid Forum View   08/08/2017

      Fluid forum view allows members only to get right to the meat of this community; the topics. You can toggle between your preferred forum view just below to the left on the main forum entrance. You will see three icons. Try them out and see what you prefer.   Fluid view allows you, if you are a signed up member, to see the newest topic posts in either all forums (select none or all) or in just your favorite forums (select the ones you want to see when you come to Fishing Minnesota). It keeps and in real time with respect to Topic posts and lets YOU SELECT YOUR FAVORITE FORUMS. It can make things fun and easy. This is especially true for less experienced visitors raised on social media. If you, as a members want more specific topics, you can even select a single forum to view. Let us take a look at fluid view in action. We will then break it down and explain how it works in more detail.   The video shows the topic list and the forum filter box. As you can see, it is easy to change the topic list by changing the selected forums. This view replaces the traditional list of categories and forums.   Of course, members only can change the view to better suit your way of browsing.   You will notice a “grid” option. We have moved the grid forum theme setting into the main forum settings. This makes it an option for members only to choose. This screenshot also shows the removal of the forum breadcrumb in fluid view mode. Fluid view remembers your last forum selection so you don’t lose your place when you go back to the listing. The benefit of this feature is easy to see. It removes a potential barrier of entry for members only. It puts the spotlight on topics themselves, and not the hierarchical forum structure. You as a member will enjoy viewing many forums at once and switching between them without leaving the page. We hope that fluid view, the new functionality is an asset that you enjoy .
Sign in to follow this  
Hookmaster

Stock or NAPA gas filter?

Recommended Posts

Hookmaster    6
Hookmaster

I picked up the NGK spark plugs for the F100 Yamaha from NAPA. While there I asked him if they had the gas filter for it as well. They had one that looked like the stock one that is on it. I didn't have it with. Would you get the one from NAPA or get the Yammie part from a dealer? The applications on the back of the package said Mercury and Johnson. He said they don't always list all of the applications.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Whoaru99    0
Whoaru99

That's a tough call.

I work for a large OEM and have on many occasions checked into aftermarket filter compatibility for our products.

Let me be brief and just say that everything that fits does not have the same filtering quality as OEM. By the same token, some will-fit filters are as good as the OEM filters. I'm not implying anything brand-specific, it's merely a general statement.

So, it's sorta case-by-case and there is no clear answer without really digging in deep. Sometimes it's hard for the average consumer to get that detailed of specification from OEMs and from aftermarket suppliers.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Macgyver55    0
Macgyver55

Quote:

Let me be brief and just say that everything that fits does not have the same filtering quality as OEM. By the same token, some will-fit filters are as good as the OEM filters.


And, some are actually better than OEM. Most quality filters will often specify that they will "meet or exceed the OEM filter specifications"

In my line of work we use literally thousands of filters a year, so we have vendors trying to "sell" their product to us all the time. We always have them cut open a filter and show the quality of filter paper and the amount of folds (surface area) before taking bids. There is definitely a difference, but OEM isn't necessarily the best, it's basically just the minimum standard that needs to be met. Most "name brand" filters will usually meet that standard.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
iffy    0
iffy

I'm pretty sure that NAPA sells Sierra parts in their marine line. In my opinion they are 'will fit and work' quality, but are of a lower grade than OEM. Why take a chance on it?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Whoaru99    0
Whoaru99

Quote:

Quote:

Let me be brief and just say that everything that fits does not have the same filtering quality as OEM. By the same token, some will-fit filters are as good as the OEM filters.


And, some are actually better than OEM. Most quality filters will often specify that they will "meet or exceed the OEM filter specifications"

In my line of work we use literally thousands of filters a year, so we have vendors trying to "sell" their product to us all the time. We always have them cut open a filter and show the quality of filter paper and the amount of folds (surface area) before taking bids. There is definitely a difference, but OEM isn't necessarily the best, it's basically just the minimum standard that needs to be met. Most "name brand" filters will usually meet that standard.


I won't dispute that in all cases there are not better than OEM filters.

However, the OEM filters for our applications are some of the very best filters available this side of NASA. The filtration ratings are EXCEEDING stringent since they are protecting high pressure (6,000-7,000 PSI) hydrostatic drive systems and PWM/servo controlled hydraulic systems. In addtion, the fuel systems can run as high as 15,000 PSI.

And yes, you can get NAPA-branded filters that "will fit" and you can get NAPA-branded filters that are the same as our OEM, but with a different paint job on the can. The ones that "will-fit" and the ones that are the same are two completely different filters. They look virtually the same on the outside except the part numbers.

While my example is extreme, and may be the exception, it is a fact as far as I know. There are no commonly-available filters that are better than what we are using in our OEM application.

The problem we run into is that people buy the NAPA (and other) "will-fits" because they are much cheaper than the correct NAPA version. And, believe it or not, the correct NAPA version is actually a bit more expensive than the OEM we sell. We have priced accordingly because it is in our best interest to have our machine with reduced warranty cost. A contamination-related warranty claim that comes back to us on one of these hydrostatic drive systems can wipe out the profitability on several other machines. Thankfully, these are very rare due in part to the excellent filtration of the systems.

Again, I'm not tying to single out NAPA because it's the same situation with Wix, Baldwin, Fleetgard, etc.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Hookmaster    6
Hookmaster

I picked up the Yamaha filter today. I asked the guy if the Mercury or Johnson fuel filter would work if the barbed fittings fit, he said yeah. I may still buy the NAPA part and cut it and my old one open to compare. Curious minds want to know. If I do, I'll post results.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Eric Wettschreck    0
Eric Wettschreck

In the whole grand scheme of things, why risk it? At work I'm heavily involved in different types of filtration and membrane seperation.

If you're talking about your boat motor, car engine, lawn mower, etc, what really is the price difference between OEM and aftermarket? Not much, maybe a couple of bucks???? When you buy OEM, at least you know for certain it meets OEM specifications.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
hondavxr    0
hondavxr

I work in the parts industry and a lot of aftermerkat parts are just OEMs with differrent paint or no OEM part numbers. If you are buying Sierra parts from Napa, I will give you a little tip a lot of Sierra parts are just repackaged OEM parts.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
iffy    0
iffy

Homda: Thats not true at all. Where I worked as a marine mechanic we sold OEM merc and yamaha as well as sierra. Very few seirra parts were of the same quality as the OEM's. Impellers and seals were an exception and seemed close to the same quality, but those were priced close anyway, so why take the chance?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  



  • Posts

    • Sunset Lodge
      Hello from the NW Angle of Lake of the Woods!

      Water temps are hovering in the low 60’s despite the very fall like weather we are experiencing. 

      The scenic Canadian shore lines are coming to life with various critters. Otter, bear and more making preparations for the coming winter.

      Walleye fishing in Canada is excellent with a jig and minnow or shiner. The most productive environment has been gaps at 15-18’ with plenty of current present. Good numbers of perch are being caught off deep edges or reefs at 30’ or more. Crappies are a little more difficult this week, the best chances are on a light set up.

      Around Minnesota, walleyes can still be had with a crankbait but favored methods are switching over to a jig tipped with a shiner on main lake points between 20 and 24’. 

      Muskies are moving deeper with anglers transitioning from casting to trolling. There is still time to boat a big fall fish!

      We hope to see you soon!
      Sunset Lodge
    • leech~~
      Welcome to the forum. Give it a month and throw it on C/list, it should go then.
    • rundrave
        Im not a waterfowl guy and dont do a lot of it. But isn't that why you retriever guys do blind retrieves? My GSP's dont always mark down birds either and I just send them with hand signals. I think its just something we have worked on over time. Do you know anyone that has access to a zinger winger launcher etc. That's about the only other way to replicate it with out doing the real thing.
    • monstermoose78
      Thanks Dave this seemed to help with grouse, woodcocks,and ducks.  How does a guy get a dog to stay focused on the sky watching for birds? Finn did great at sitting or laying down for ducks but he does not watch for them so he does not mark the birds then. Any ideas to get him to do this?  
    • Mike89
      one of the  rivers will do ya...
    • jb bj
    • Guatican
      So a buddy and I are looking to see where we can get on some nice Pike action around the Kato area. We have no access to a boat so we'll be doing it from shore. Any insight on a good pike or any game fish bite would be awesome! Fall tends to be our Achilles's heel. 
    • Troy Smutka
      9/25/17     Hunted the hot, steamy MN duck opener on a public lake in central MN. Could see lightning to the west and north all morning until the sun came up. Must have been some serious lightning in those storms that were 100 miles away. Could still see the flashes, but of course could not hear any thunder. Saturday morning we saw the most bluewing teal I have seen on an opener since the 1980s. Must have seen a thousand teal and hundreds of mallards and wood ducks. Weren't in the best spot since we were the third boat on the lake, but still managed to shoot some teal and wood ducks. Busy watching ducks all morning. The teal I cleaned were migrators with quite a bit of fat--none on the wood ducks. Sunday morning was a different day--most of the teal were gone and the mallards and wood ducks were more wary. Managed two juvenile mallards. Think the shooting and the weather front moving in got a lot of the BWT on their way further south. All in all, a decent start to the MN waterfowl season, especially considering the temps were more like mid August. See what this weather and some cooler temps brings to the decoys this weekend. Good luck, and I will see you out there somewhere.
    • delcecchi
      Any thoughts as to which will hold up better, or be easier to fix?
    • Rick
      With 59 state forests that cover 4.2 million acres, Minnesota state forests are a great place to view fall color, according to the Department of Natural Resources.  “Forests with a mix of deciduous and coniferous trees offer a wonderful fall color experience,” said Jennifer Teegarden, DNR forestry outreach specialist. “The dark green needles of conifers accent the yellow, orange and red leaves of deciduous trees.” Here are a few routes to consider: Late September Bear Island State Forest From Ely head south on State Highway 1 toward Isabella for about 20 miles. Take a right on New Tomahawk Road toward Babbitt for about 17 miles. Turn right on County Road 21 for 15 miles back to Ely. Kabetogama State Forest From Orr head north on State Highway 53 for 4 miles. Turn right on County Road 180 to head east for 16 miles. Turn right on Forest Road 203 to head east for about 4.5 miles. Turn right on Vermillion Falls road to head east for 8 miles. Turn right on County Road 24/23 and follow to Orr for 26 miles. White Earth State Forest starting at Roy Lake head east on State Highway 200 for 1.5 miles. Turn right on Strawberry Mountain Road to head south for 5 miles. At Norris Trail turn left to head east for 3 miles. Turn left on Height of Land Road to head north back to Highway 200. For a longer loop follow Strawberry Mountain road to State Highway 113. Turn right on State Highway 113 to head east. Turn left on Height of Land Road to head north back to Highway 200. Early to mid-October Croix and Nemadji state forests loop. From I35, take Hinckley exit #183 and head east on State Highway 48 for 19 miles. Turn left to head north on County Road 24 and follow as it curves east and north for 7 miles. Turn right on County Road 25 to head east for 9.5 miles. At Markville, head north on County Road 31 for about 12 miles. Turn left on Park Forest Road/Park Truck Trail to head west for 13 miles. Turn right on County Road 171 to head north for 2 miles. Turn left onto County Road 154/Kerrick Road to head west for 5 miles. At Kerrick, head south on State Highway 23 for 18 miles to I35 exit #195. Richard J. Dorer Memorial Hardwood State Forest From downtown Red Wing head south on Highway 61 for 10.5 miles. At Frontenac take a right onto Country 2 to head east for 9 miles. Take a right onto County Road 3 to head east for 4 miles. Take a right onto State Highway 58 to head north for 1.5 miles. Take a left onto Hay Creek Trail to head north for about 4.5 miles. Hey Creek Trail turns into Twin Bluff Road at Pioneer Trail. Continue on Twin Bluff Road for 1.5 miles and turn left on East Ave to return to downtown Red Wing. Visit www.dnr.state.mn.us/state_forests/fall-colors.html for additional scenic routes and state forest information. Entrance into a state forest is free. State forest campsites are available on a first-come, first-served basis for $14 a night. Visit the Minnesota state parks and trails Fall Color Finder at www.mndnr.gov/fall_colors to find areas in Minnesota with peak fall color. The Fall Color Finder is updated every Thursday through the end of October.   Discuss below - to view set the hook here.