Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
WxGuy

Caddis Dries

6 posts in this topic

How many varieties of a caddis dry to you keep in your fly box?

When fishing this past Saturday I fished a few reaches of water where the trout, while steadily rising, were more selective to the fly than on other stretches of water. The caddis that were hatching were the gray caddis, and their bodies were around a size 17 maybe even close to an 18 but their wings were closer to size 16. During the peak of the afternoon I could swear I saw a couple larger caddis closer to a size 14, but it could have been the cold brew I'd just enjoyed.

I have a couple friends who insist they only fish the "x-caddis" dry pattern, but I'd wonder at how well that'd actually work from day to day and stream to stream. Sometimes I wonder if I just need a caddis pattern that, as long as I can skitter it across the water and it has the profile of a caddis, would work in most situations.

I'm probably over thinking this WAY too much, but what the heck...it's caddis season.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I bet i have over 10 different stlyes of Caddis in my box. I use every pattern of them also.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Great question! Fishing to trout taking caddis can be an odd epxerience in that at times any old "bottle brush" flung out there and skated will work, while at other times the trout are almost impossibly selective.

For the larger adults (sizes 14 and 16), I like the Troth-style elk hair caddis in about three colors (more or less light, medium and dark). For size 18s, I like either the King's River caddis or a hair wing pattern with a collar hackle rather than the Troth palmer hackle.

I think the X Caddis is a good pharate adult pattern and I've really begun to hold the Matthews' Iris Caddis in high regard, too. It's hard for me to tie the Iris Caddis, with it's odd Zelon loop wing, in a way that duplicates the original one sees in the Blue Ribbon Flies catalog, but the ones I tie still work.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Don't forget the slow water cadis. You can vary this pattern for faster water by adding a dry hackle in front.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My favorite that is a caddis imitation per se is the elk hair caddis. Very effective and easy to tie. I also use other flies that imitate a variety of insects, and of those the Adams is my favorite.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have 3 diff styles(4 if you count one style tied with 2 diff materials). Traditional Elk hair caddis, EZ Caddis, and slow water caddis. Of course I have all of them in 2 or 3 sizes and 4 colors. In my experience it seems like any of the styles will work as long as they are basically the right size and color. I guess I'm not sure why I have multiple styles then.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • monstermoose78
      I will check
    • monstermoose78
    • eyeguy 54
      fun time today  2 beasts still swimmin to get bigger
    • biff
      The quality of walleye on fish has really amped up since the slot. I would put it up there with the St. Louis River now as far as local waters that produce quality walleye. Sometimes it's hard to catch an eye under 17"...its kinda the opposite of Island Lake. I wish the protected slot was a little longer as I don't see many over 26".
    • JBMasterAngler
      I never got a chance to get down to Superior in the morning to fish from shore, as it was always a little too rough every day. I did get up early enough to make it to the devil track river, finally for the first time. Was nice to check it out, although my time was short. Caught 1 little rainbow, and lost 6!    Also checked out the Poplar River for the first time, off the caribou trail, at the campgrounds. Only fished it for a little bit, but caught 2 brook trout, one of which was about 12 inches. River was surprisingly deep, was wading in waste deep water.    My dad and my son are still up there. But they haven't really been able to fish due to the rain on Saturday and Sunday. If it was nice today, they were going to go back to Greenwood Lake. Otherwise, if the weather was bad, they were coming home a day early. Haven't heard from them yet, so hopefully they were able to get out.
    • portageguy
      Yes just north of Cook.  They are open 7 days 8:00-4:30. Y-store is open 5am - midnight.  
    • curt quesnell
      Wind was howling when we left the dock this morning and I was pretty shook up about it. A nice steady bite with decent fish made the day a real pleasure.   Good news going into the big weekend, the fish are biting.
    • Fish Head
      Is it the LaCroix Ranger Station where you pick up the permits now?
    • ozzie
      not something I consider when eating as I don't eat fish weekly.  I feed them to my kids and my wife ate it while pregnant.  Not sure if there really is a concern or not but the basic guidelines are out there more for kids and pregnant women.  Unless you are eating fish daily or every other day then I don't think you need to worry a whole bunch.  Heck if you die because of mercury poisoning from eating too many fish, well at least you had one hell of a time before you died! HAHAHA   A few years back a local lake close to the metro started producing a lot of crappies and people drove all over to fish.  A lot of fish were taken and eaten.  The lake had been traditionally known as a dumping pond for farm runoff and other things like that...I ate a limit or 2 from said lake and never had issues with anything and the fish tasted like they should.  Point being that unless they say "DON'T EAT FISH FROM THIS LAKE" just follow the state guidelines for your kids and prego wife but other than that enjoy a meal or 2 a week if you are lucky to catch enough!!  Good Luck- Ozzie
    • delcecchi
      I think day use motor or camping requires a permit, not self service.