Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
pikehunter461

Small Lures for Large Pike

3 posts in this topic

Last season I had the oddest experience. We were trolling large lures in search of pike in the North Arm. We were in prime pike territory and tried a variety of depths, speeds, and lure types. Caught only a few small pike. Frustrated with the results I switched to a small shad rap that would normally be used to focus on smallmouth. Within minutes of putting on the small shad rap we experienced significant pike action. Caught 6 pike 30 inches or larger (largest was 38) in an hour, numerous smaller pike, and a half a dozen 10+ inch perch. The oddest thing is that the pike wouldn't touch the larger lures we tried (and we tried a good variety) yet be had large pike attacking perch and small pike we were pulling in. Has anyone ever experienced something like this? Still baffles me because for a 24inch pike to become a meal when it is being reeled in- it would seem like a larger lure would also be effective.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

We come up to Rainy the last week of August, so I sure can't speek for the majority, but we always clean up on pike using Blue Fox Vibrax lures size #3, #4, and sometimes #5's. Lots of bites on blue,yellow, and orange. We call them "bullits" down here. It's easily our best producing lures. We get lots of 30" and over pike, our best has been 43". It also catches lots of smallmouth and even a few walleyes. Only once have I ever did well on Large lures up there. I did have good luck last year with Salmo's Jointed Pike deep diver. Only coming one week a year doesn't give us a lot of experience, but after 20 years I'm still throwing bullits for big pike in the north arm.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That's odd about the fish hitting other smaller fish but not touching any big lures. What time of year was it? What was the weather like? All I can think is that the bigger lures you were throwing had a color or action that just didn't interest the fish. With that clear water up there, any unnatural, brighter colors may have turned them off.

Somedays though it just works that way and fish will ONLY bite certain things, just like walleyes, bass, or muskie. What bugs me the most is when I'm throwing big pike and ski lures and get hits from 22" pike that I have to drag in. That's fishing for ya.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Cliff Wagenbach
      Looks like a smelt to me. Cliff
    • nickmmatten
      No it was my brother who caught it on a little fly fishing jig. And he sent the one pic to me asking wtf is this lol. And thank you.
    • ANYFISH2
      Got more picks? Not sure with just this one. First glance, looks like an emerald shiner. Welcome to FM!
    • DLD24
      I have an Eskimo and love it. I fish a lot and punch a lot of holes most outtings. I had to rebuild the carb this year, but I've had the auger for 4 years or so... Always starts no matter how cold...I've drilled with jiffy and can't stand them... The blades on the Eskimos last a long time and are cheap when you have to replace them... I drilled with a SM last year and really liked it, but they are so pricey. I got my z51 shark dirt cheap ($220 shipped to my door) from Glens Army Navy in Rapids. I'd go Eskimo or Strikemaster if I was you.
    • nickmmatten
      This fish was caught under ice on a weight county MN lake what is it?