Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

  • Announcements

    • Rick

      Members Only Fluid Forum View   08/08/2017

      Fluid forum view allows members only to get right to the meat of this community; the topics. You can toggle between your preferred forum view just below to the left on the main forum entrance. You will see three icons. Try them out and see what you prefer.   Fluid view allows you, if you are a signed up member, to see the newest topic posts in either all forums (select none or all) or in just your favorite forums (select the ones you want to see when you come to Fishing Minnesota). It keeps and in real time with respect to Topic posts and lets YOU SELECT YOUR FAVORITE FORUMS. It can make things fun and easy. This is especially true for less experienced visitors raised on social media. If you, as a members want more specific topics, you can even select a single forum to view. Let us take a look at fluid view in action. We will then break it down and explain how it works in more detail.   The video shows the topic list and the forum filter box. As you can see, it is easy to change the topic list by changing the selected forums. This view replaces the traditional list of categories and forums.   Of course, members only can change the view to better suit your way of browsing.   You will notice a “grid” option. We have moved the grid forum theme setting into the main forum settings. This makes it an option for members only to choose. This screenshot also shows the removal of the forum breadcrumb in fluid view mode. Fluid view remembers your last forum selection so you don’t lose your place when you go back to the listing. The benefit of this feature is easy to see. It removes a potential barrier of entry for members only. It puts the spotlight on topics themselves, and not the hierarchical forum structure. You as a member will enjoy viewing many forums at once and switching between them without leaving the page. We hope that fluid view, the new functionality is an asset that you enjoy .
Sign in to follow this  
cw642

Pointing Labs?

Recommended Posts

cw642

Has anyone had any success with what they call a pointing lab? Just trying to see what the rate of pointing verses nonpointing is.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
fishroger

Yes, a friend has pointing lab. It does point, not all th etime, if a bird is running he flushes it

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
fisherking01

I had a pointing lab, Dusty, she was an amazing dog. Out of four female labs. she is the only one that truly pointed. You could put her on a bird and she would tip over before flushing a bird. I never lost a bird with her either. She was an awesome retreiver. if the bird ran on account of my inferior shooting, I could sit down and wait. She would come back with it. The other labs i have had point incidently, as most dogs will when on a hot scent. The one i have now will point for 30 seconds or so, then flush, or catch the bird. At 2 years old, she catches her fair share of birds. You'd be lucky to get a true pointer. I've hunted behind a lot of labs that were supposed to be pointers, fact is not many are. If you've got one that will point for over five minutes, I'd love to hunt with it, it's amazing. Brent

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
IRISHSOBNO4

i have a great pointing lab, she is the daughter of riks risky raider. she is 9 now and still acts like a pup when out hunting the drive is amazing. the only problem is she has a hard time settling down in a duck blind.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Walleye Guy

I also have a great pointing lab. He is a 7.5 year old male that is the son of Rik's Risky Raider as well. Anybody that has ever hunted with my dog cannot believe how well he points. To be honest I think my dog is an exception rather than the rule. If you do your research so should be able to find a good pointing lab.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
AlexRM

I have two PL's both point really well! Stella came from Kelloggs bloodlines and she is great, she has probably the best retrieve drive in any dog I have ever owned. She is a strong instinctive scent pointer and and doesn't miss a bird. I have never ever lost a bird with her, she has a great nose. The only thing I have a problem with her is she never wants to quit hunting she wants to go go go, now thats fine with me because she is kenneled outside. She would not be a good house dog. When she gets bred she is going to be bred to a male who will compliment all of her natural abilities, but he will also have to be a very calm relaxed dog around the home, but then flip the switch and turn into a hunting machine within seconds.

My other PL Annie is out of Black Forest Kennels in Texas. So far she has a great temperment and also great pointing abilities. The only thing about her is, she has is not as good of a retriever as Stella, but I think she will come around, she is only 9 months and has some time to mature. She is also very athletic, she can flat out run, she is very fast and its quite frankly amazing how she covers ground.

I think pointing labs are the real deal. They are without pier as retrievers and also point game! And most of the time they are also great family dogs. What more could you want?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
kgpcr4

I have a Pointing Lab as well. She was 4 months old and pointing. She did well in ND last year and 5 and 6 months old. She is going to be a good one from the looks of it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
CFD200

I have a four month Lab from pointing parents. I have not seen her pointing unless she is taking a bowel movement. I guess if she does it will be a plus but I will not be disa(pointed) if she doesn't. The retrieving drive is amazing compared to the English Cockers I had in the past. This will force me to do more fowl hunting I think but my first love is watching the dog work pheasants. It may take live birds to get her to point, but it is not a guarantee.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
AlexRM

Get her on live birds and she will start pointing.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
cw642

The reason I posted this question is I have a friend that bought a "pointing" lab puppy. His dog has yet to show any pointing and it is about 9mo. He has asked me to help to train his dog to point, but I could not give him an answer with out laughing. You see, all of my dogs (pointers) come out of their mother on a rock solid point. There is no need to "teach" them anything, and I believe pointing is an instinct not a taught skill like retrieving. Yes I do train my dogs to be solid to shot but never had to teach them to point rather than flush. I guess from what I've read is that the labs are sort of hit or miss. Some do some don't, but at 6mo when you relize this dog doesn't point and it is part of your family what do you do? I have a second question why did you choose a lab over all the other pointing breeds?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
gspman

Has your friend shot birds over this dog that it did not point? If he has then the situation will be more difficult to correct.

If you have remote launchers here is what I'd do. Plant birds in the launchers and checkcord the dog in from a distance and crosswind from the launcher. When the dog smells the bird and turns in towards it you launch the bird. Restrain the dog with the cord and don't let it chase. Do this a 3-5 times each session. Hopefully the dog will realize it needs to stop when it first smells the bird. If the dog doesn't point say nothing and work the next bird. If it points then flush the bird and restrain with the check cord. Then give it a quiet "good boy" and some petting. After each session whether it points or not throw the bumper for a few retrieves to make it a fun thing.

If you have no manual launchers or no launchers then you'll have to restrain the dog when it first scents the bird and have a training buddy go in and launch/flush the bird. Since the timing isn't going to be the same I'm not sure how well this may work.

Hopefully over time it'll "get it" and start pointing. But I'm not a pointing lab guy so I offer no guarantees. I think this could be a lot of work but if he really wants it to point this is how I'd do it. He needs to not shoot birds the dog intentionally flushes too because that will encourage the dog to flush instead of point.

Good luck to your buddy.

gspman

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
AlexRM

The reason I choose pointing labs over traditional pointing breeds is, I am a not just a pheasant hunter I am a duck hunter also, and the traditional pointers are not hardy enough in our cold MN weather, and do not have the retrieve drive or desire a lab has. I also want a dog that can cover ground farely quickly and thoroughly, that will also point and hold point on wild birds. And also be great family dogs, they are not as high strung as some tradional breeds IMHO. That is why I choose PL's over other dogs.

Some people claim they have pointing labs, and breed them to so called pointing labs and say they are selling pointing labs, when in reality they are nothing more than just regular flushing labs. People that sell pups like that give PL breeders a bad name. You have got to do your research and make sure you are buying a true pointing lab. I am by no means saying the person your friend bought his pup from isn't breeding pointing labs, some pups will just not point and thats that.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
IRISHSOBNO4

i used to work my pups with a wing on the end of a fishing pole i would cast it out when they were looking the other way. then walk them in that direction and twitch the wing.

they would all go on point.

the female i kept from that litter didn't point when i hunted her the first year, the second year something clicked

and she has been solid ever since.

my wife said she was pointing the chickens for over an hour yesterday before she finally called her into the house.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
AlexRM

I just saw that a pointing lab won Dog of the Yr in the in the puppy division in the Wisconsin run & gun competition, and also took 5th Place overall in the open Pointing division. This is against tradional pointing breeds

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
cw642

Never realized anyone had Dog of the Year for a class that the max age is 12mo. Seems kind of weird that a 12mo dog could take 5th also. Must be one heck of a dog to beat out a bunch of "real" pointers. Or is it a really poorly advertized and run event, never been I can't say. Alex for some reason you post a regional dog event result to prove what? Look at a National field trial such as the one at Ames Plantation. This trial is one of the oldest, and is concidered by most the granddaddy of them all. It has never had a PL even listed as running among the 60 best pointing dogs in the country. I don't think that PL are a joke, but the feedback I get from most is if it doesn't point it's still a good retreiver. My Pointers are good retrievers too, so is my friends yorkie. Until they can consistanly produce dogs that NAUTURALY point as all pointing breeds do I think of them as more of a fad than a breed. Are they their own breed in the AKC or are they just labled by breeders as POINTERS?

If you could, post where you saw those results. I googled and yahoo searched it but couldnt find anything.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
AlexRM

I wasn't posting that to prove anything. Here is the site [Note from admin: Please read forum policy. No unauthorized links. Thanks.]

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
gundoglily

The " puppy class" is for dogs that are 24 months or younger on Jan. 1 of the competition year. The dog can also run in the Top Gun, which is why she finished 1st in the puppy and 5th in the top gun. The dog has to follow all the "pointing dog" rules. Has to maintain a point for 3 seconds, cannot be "whoaed" into a point, penalized for trapping or catching birds. The dog points solid. The dog has also had 1000's of birds shot over it.If you want to do a google search type in "Wisconsin Series" and it is about the 8th one down the list. The dog also runs in the "National Bird Dog" series and does well there also.

In the AKC they are registered as "labrador" and sold by the breeders as "pointing labs".

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
kgpcr4

My Pointing Labe will never run with the pointers but they will never work the cattails like my lab. also when it comes do any water work I win hands down, My buddy busted a rooster than fell in a pot hole and his setter would not go get it. Also if you do want to do some duck hunting you are better off with a lab. Also its very hard to beat the personality of a Lab!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  



  • Posts

    • leech~~
      Fun for some folks that went exploring early ice from a few years ago. 
    • tfin
      Hi Cookie,  a buddy and I are going up this weekend.  Will they bite much after dark or is the water too mucky this early.  I appreciate any info.  Thanks
    • papadarv
      Yesterday the MN DNR announced a license requirement change effective NOW for this ice season. All Wheel House and other fishing structures which cannot be folded / collapsed must be licensed even if you remove the house when you get off the ice. 
    • Rick
      Harvest climbs 16 percent from 2016 Minnesota firearms hunters registered 161,057 deer through the third weekend of deer season, according to the Department of Natural Resources.  Preliminary results through the third weekend show that the number of deer registered was up 16 percent from 2016. Of the deer harvested, 53 percent were bucks, compared to 63 percent during the same period in 2016. In Zone 1, in northeastern Minnesota, total firearms harvest was up 36 percent. In Zone 2, which covers the majority of the state and runs from Canada to Iowa, harvest was up 10 percent and Zone 3, in southeastern Minnesota, was down 5 percent. “The conditions were generally good for hunters participating in the last week of the Zone 1 season and for the start of the 3B season in the southeast,” said Erik Thorson, acting big game program leader, “which provided a boost to the statewide firearms harvest.” Based upon the number of antlerless permits available and the number of permit areas that allow multiple deer to be taken, the DNR is projecting the 2017 total deer harvest to be around 200,000. The 2016 total harvest was 173,213 and to date firearms and archery hunters have harvested about 180,000 deer this year. In much of Minnesota, the firearms deer season ended Nov. 12, and the northern rifle zone season ended Nov. 19. The late southeast firearms deer season is open through Sunday, Nov. 26. The muzzleloader season begins Saturday, Nov. 25, and continues through Sunday, Dec. 10. More information on deer management can be found at mndnr.gov/deer. Discuss below - to view set the hook here.
    • Rick
      Applications due by Saturday, Dec. 16  The Department of Natural Resources, the Metropolitan Council and the Greater Minnesota Regional Parks and Trails Commission are seeking qualified applicants to serve on the Parks and Trails Legacy Advisory Committee.  “The Parks and Trails Legacy Advisory Committee plays a critical role in helping us achieve the vision Minnesotans have for use of the Parks and Trails Legacy Funds and creates an accessible and equitable, integrated system of state and regional parks and trails in Minnesota,” said DNR Commissioner Tom Landwehr. The purpose of the committee is to promote and coordinate implementation of the 25-Year Parks and Trails Legacy Plan. Funding recommendations for individual projects is not a part of this committee’s work. The plan can be found at on the parks and trails legacy plan page. 2018 will mark the 10th anniversary of the passage of the Legacy Amendment by Minnesota voters. The committee is planning a series of regional events during the year to celebrate Legacy accomplishments and engage Minnesotans on the question, “Why Parks and Trails Legacy Matters.”  Information about the events will be available in January on Facebook (/PTLegacyMN) and on the committee website (www.legacy.leg.mn/ptlac). The deadline for applications is Saturday, Dec. 16. The committee is made up of 17 members, including, to the practical extent possible, diverse geographical and demographic representation. The committee has a mixture of park and trail professionals and Minnesota residents. Committee members should have expertise in two or more of the four strategic pillars of the plan: Connect people and the outdoors. Acquire land and create opportunities. Take care of what we have. Coordinate among partners. Terms are two years with the option of being reappointed for a maximum of three terms. Meetings are scheduled every two months around the state, with an option to attend remotely. Interested individuals may complete the application form online at www.legacy.leg.mn/ptlac/member-application or print it out and return it to Paul Purman, Department of Natural Resources, Box 39, 500 Lafayette Road, St. Paul, MN 55155. Anyone with questions can contact Paul via phone at 651-259-5643 or email at paul.purman@state.mn.us. Discuss below - to view set the hook here.
    • Cliff Wagenbach
      Big bay did not look to be completely frozen over yesterday afternoon. Broken up and refrozen by McKinley Landing. Cliff
    • TheTuna
      The wind today has eliminated the little ice we had.  
    • MUSKY18
      Thanks much Huntnfish and ZachD!!!  Had the wife pick me up some CCI 209 Magnum primers and seems to have fixed the issue.  Went out the other night and put 7 rounds through the ole CVA and didn't have a single hangfire.  I'm ready for the weekend.
    • JerkinLips
      Is Big Bay completely frozen over yet?
    • Rick
      Anglers and others interested in Department of Natural Resources strategies for managing Grand Marias area lakes and streams are invited to review and comment on management plans scheduled for review this fall. This annual process includes several waters located within the Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness (BWCAW). Comments on lakes within the BWCAW will be accepted until Dec. 20. The comment period for lakes and streams outside the BWCAW, will extend through Feb. 15. A management plan identifies specific management activities planned for a lake or stream over the next five to 20 years, including any proposed stocking or special regulations. “Management plans are our best single sources of information on past, present and desired future conditions in our lakes and streams,” said Steve Persons, Grand Marais area fisheries supervisor. “Comments and suggestions from those most interested in these waters are crucial when it comes to making plans and determining management success. For anglers this is the best opportunity to influence how these lakes and streams are managed.” In the Grand Marais area, plans for the following lakes and streams will reviewed this winter. Lake plans under review: The status and preservation of native lake trout populations will be the primary concern in plans being revised for Blue Snow and Gabimichigami Lakes. Both are located inside the BWCAW. Stream trout stocking and management strategies will be reviewed in Thompson, Thrush, Turnip, Olson, Kraut, Little Portage, Olga, Mavis (BWCAW), Missing Link (BWCAW), Meditation (BWCAW), Talus, Trout, Pine (near Two Island Lake), Unnamed (near Tom Lake), Chester, Extortion, and North Shady Lakes. Options to consider include changes in species, reductions in stocking frequency, and changes in the number or size of fish stocked. In Mine, Peanut, Weasel (Sled), Tomato, Trip, and Rog (BWCAW) Lakes, fisheries managers are considering eliminating trout stocking, due to the high cost of stocking remote lakes by air, poor survival of stocked fish, or use that appears to have been too low to justify the cost of continued stocking.  Angler feedback on fisheries in these lakes is critically needed for these important decisions. Plans for Devilfish, Gust, Hand, and Tom Lakes will be reviewed with attention to the status and needs of walleye fisheries in those lakes. Moore Lake will be reviewed to determine whether it offers any potential for panfish management. Plans for several lightly-used BWCAW lakes in the area, including Caribou (by Clearwater), Clove, Kiskadinna, Long, Mora, Morgan, Skipper, and Tepee Lakes will be reviewed. Those plans will be revised primarily to incorporate any new survey data that may have been obtained, and to establish survey schedules for the next few years. Streams plans under review: Plans for Beaverdam Creek and the Swamp River will be reviewed.  Both are marginal trout streams, and may be considered for removal from the State’s list of designated trout streams. Plans for the Cascade River, Elbow Creek, and the Onion River will also be reviewed. All three support thriving brook trout populations, with the Cascade and Onion Rivers also supporting steelhead and salmon in their lower reaches. Plans will focus on habitat and water quality, hydrology and watershed issues. The DNR is considering removing the portion of Elbow Creek above Elbow Lake from the State’s list of designated trout streams, since no trout have been found in that part of the stream in recent surveys. Current plans for lakes and streams in the area as well as recent fish population assessment information are available for review at the DNR’s Grand Marais area fisheries office, at 1356 E. Highway 61, Grand Marais, Monday through Friday, between 8 a.m. and 4:30 p.m. For more information, call or email Steve Persons at 218-387-6022 or steve.persons@state.mn.us. Public comments on management of BWCAW waters are due by Dec. 20. The comment period for lakes and streams outside the BWCAW will extend through Feb. 15. Comments, suggestions and other feedback on the management of these, and all other streams and lakes in the area are welcomed at any time and will be considered when those plans are next due for review. Discuss below - to view set the hook here.