Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
WKSparrow

Crowding

13 posts in this topic

Not a new topic, but a new twist...

I put my permanent shack out the first weekend in Jan... at least 400 yards from anyone else. Was isolated for awhile, and did fairly well until 2nd weekend in Feb - when I went up and found six wheel houses (in 2 groups of 3) within 75 yards of house. Had worst weekend yet.

Until this weekend, when we went up and found the wheel houses gone, but TWO RENTAL HOUSES within 50 yards of my front door.

The twist?? The owners of the rental houses are persons whom I have seen on this forum many, many, many times complaining of people crowding their houses.

The 'rules' these people create to attack others apparently don't apply to them. I have patronized the same access point exclusively for the last 5 years. I will be looking for a new place to access URL for next year.

Just had to vent. Thanks.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't know if this is directed at me or not but this past weekend we only had 3 houses in new places. 2 of them 1/4 mile apart 7 miles out and the other 1/2 mile south from them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Not you Kelly-P...

I dont want to get into trouble by naming names, so...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The law says 10 feet, so any place is free game I guess. grin.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't think its funny mad.gif- what ever happened to just plain old good sportsmanship? Are people that desperate to catch a fish that they need to be in someone's lap?

Laws are laws yes, but where is the common sense?

Justin

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I never could understand it. I like to fish out by myself. Often the fishing is better and I get some peace and quite along with some privacy. I don't want somebody fifteen feet away when I am cussing at "stupid fish", picking my nose, scratching or slipping and falling on my...

grin.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks WK. That's something I always try to avoid but as fast as we are moving around it's all kinda turning into a blur. One thing to keep in mind that is that this year when Agassiz road runs across Hillman's road there are now 10 or so rental outfits in an area where in the past there were only Foster, Buddy and me. There's a lot of shoulder rubbing and headbutting going on. blush.gif I can almost guess where your house is from your desciption of what has happened. Unfortunately it looks like you ended up right between 2 rental outfits going nose to nose. 2 well respected bothers that like to scout around and find places off by themselves have been in that same area(I think) as you the past month. (Lite tan wheelhouse maybe 8X10 or12) Last week they had some trouble with a rental outfit with wheel houses that setup right alongside. They walked over and complained and that night someone dumped a pile of walleye carcases on their door step. mad.gif That's when the 2nd rental outfit moved in to back up their friends in the lite tan house.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I couldn't believe when we pulled up to our permanent house this last weekend. It was on the ice and we hadn't been up there in 2 weeks. There were marks where portables had been set up and holes that had been drilled right next to the house. They couldn't have been any farther than 10 feet from our front door.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I was up over the weekend in a portable and I guess I have a little different take - I really didn't see anyone crowding me at all! smile.gif

I did have one guy almost drive over my tip-up when driving to me to ask how fishing was...you couldn't get out of your truck and walk 50 feet? I felt like telling him that fishing was good unless you drive right next to the hole.

Overall folks were very polite and seemed to keep their distance - always appreciated.

Good Luck!

Scott

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Crowding on the lake can definately be a problem, especially if someone does rely on the 10 foot rule, but a little perspective on the 50 yard distance would not hurt.

50 yards/150 feet, away from any side of you, gives you over a 100 yard/300 foot diameter, which makes you the only house within about 1.6 acres. I would call that pretty generous considering that the law allows for only a little more than 314 square feet of privacy, plus the square footage of the house.

Put that on a more practical square grid of 300X300 and you have over 2 Acres.

With the 400 yard distance that you set up on, you are talking about hoping to reserve over 103 Acres for your group on the radius basis, and over 132 Acres on the more practical 800X800 square grid.

Lets see, approximately 48,000 Acres East of the Line, divided by 132 Acres, equals just over 363 Fish houses that would be allowed under these parameters. shocked.gif

I don't think it will happen. There are about that many rental houses out there. They generally get out there first, and stay till the last, so I guess no one else would be able to go out once they are set up.

A lot of people are complaining about not being able to fish west of the line, yet are unwilling to share the 48,00 Acres east of the line.

Let us not forget, many have fished the same spot we set up on. There is no telling how many people have this as their favorite spot, or as a reliable spot punched into their GPS.

As much as I would like to be the only one on the lake, it is neither fair nor reasonable to expect that because we set up a certain distance away from others that all others following should remain that same distance away.

On most lakes one could only wish there was enough room to set up 50 Yards away from every one, let alone still being able to be close enough to a good spot.

As we well know, on Red, even 10 feet can make all the difference, let alone 10 yards. blush.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've been going icefishing at URL every year for nine years now. Some of those years I made as many as 6 different trips to URL during ice season.

I've used/paid for access at Hillmans, Hudecs and WestWinds and have always been satisfied with each of them.

My number of trips to URL this year will be zero. . . hmmmm ? ? ? crazy.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for the insight Kelly P and for the math Moby...

However, I would never expect to keep a 400 yard cushion... as you've eloquently pointed out, that's not realistic. However, I think 100 yards is not too much to expect. Less than 50 is way too close - this isn't much further than archery deer range! smile.gif

As pertains to the law involved, let's keep in mind that the law is written to be universal to all lakes - and has to work for even small lakes near the metro area. URL is a totally different story in terms of the available fishing acreage. I think that most people who have fished URL a lot believe that there is enough room not to set up 50 yards away - especially this year, which I think, (and real veterans like Kelly can feel free to correct me) because of the lack of snow cover, has the most accessible acreage I've seen in the last five years, and likely even more...

Thanks for the dialog!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

48,000 acres to fish, 80% of that within 1 foot of the same depth. Need anyone say more.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • monstermoose78
      I will check
    • monstermoose78
    • eyeguy 54
      fun time today  2 beasts still swimmin to get bigger
    • biff
      The quality of walleye on fish has really amped up since the slot. I would put it up there with the St. Louis River now as far as local waters that produce quality walleye. Sometimes it's hard to catch an eye under 17"...its kinda the opposite of Island Lake. I wish the protected slot was a little longer as I don't see many over 26".
    • JBMasterAngler
      I never got a chance to get down to Superior in the morning to fish from shore, as it was always a little too rough every day. I did get up early enough to make it to the devil track river, finally for the first time. Was nice to check it out, although my time was short. Caught 1 little rainbow, and lost 6!    Also checked out the Poplar River for the first time, off the caribou trail, at the campgrounds. Only fished it for a little bit, but caught 2 brook trout, one of which was about 12 inches. River was surprisingly deep, was wading in waste deep water.    My dad and my son are still up there. But they haven't really been able to fish due to the rain on Saturday and Sunday. If it was nice today, they were going to go back to Greenwood Lake. Otherwise, if the weather was bad, they were coming home a day early. Haven't heard from them yet, so hopefully they were able to get out.
    • portageguy
      Yes just north of Cook.  They are open 7 days 8:00-4:30. Y-store is open 5am - midnight.  
    • curt quesnell
      Wind was howling when we left the dock this morning and I was pretty shook up about it. A nice steady bite with decent fish made the day a real pleasure.   Good news going into the big weekend, the fish are biting.
    • Fish Head
      Is it the LaCroix Ranger Station where you pick up the permits now?
    • ozzie
      not something I consider when eating as I don't eat fish weekly.  I feed them to my kids and my wife ate it while pregnant.  Not sure if there really is a concern or not but the basic guidelines are out there more for kids and pregnant women.  Unless you are eating fish daily or every other day then I don't think you need to worry a whole bunch.  Heck if you die because of mercury poisoning from eating too many fish, well at least you had one hell of a time before you died! HAHAHA   A few years back a local lake close to the metro started producing a lot of crappies and people drove all over to fish.  A lot of fish were taken and eaten.  The lake had been traditionally known as a dumping pond for farm runoff and other things like that...I ate a limit or 2 from said lake and never had issues with anything and the fish tasted like they should.  Point being that unless they say "DON'T EAT FISH FROM THIS LAKE" just follow the state guidelines for your kids and prego wife but other than that enjoy a meal or 2 a week if you are lucky to catch enough!!  Good Luck- Ozzie
    • delcecchi
      I think day use motor or camping requires a permit, not self service.