Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
trophychaser

feathers vs. vanes

15 posts in this topic

I use feathers. I have a buddy that uses vanes. He said he's got a bunch of arrows he needs refletched because his vanes are messed up!! I've never had any problems with feathers!!

What do you all prefer and why?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I prefer vanes because I shoot through a whisker biscuit. The biscuit does a number on my vanes as it is, but feathers would not stand a chance flying through there. I also prefer vanes because when the feathers get wet, they tend to get all matted down, where as the vanes will not. I fletch my own arrows so it is not a huge deal if I have to refletch an arrow or two at a time.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

you are a little vague with this. but first, nothing last forever. it can depend on what rest he is shooting also. the WB with wrinkle vanes. they can just break down over time too.

i had heard that one couldn't shoot feathers thru a WB, but the other night i was up talking to some guys at league, and many of them have been shooting feathers with the WB, with no problems for quite a while now.i didn't see the rough edges that you get when shooting feathers off many other rest.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I used to shoot feathers until I got a whisker bisuit. I switched to vanes because Everytime I would shoot, bits and pieces of feathers went everywhere.

I do like feathers because they won't wrinkle over time, but like I said earlier, they get matted down when wet. I use them same arrows for hunting as I do for league (no the exact same arrows, but the same brand/fletching) and don't want to worry about my feathers getting wet when I am in the deer stand. If one were to shoot strictly in doors where no moisture can get to them, I would probably use feathers if you are not shooting through a whisker biscuit, but since I don't shoot strictly in doors and use a whisker biscuit, I choose vanes.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I shoot with a WB and I use feathers!! I've never had a problem!! I've shot some of my arrows 100+ times and they still shoot great!! Some of my feathers are slightly damaged, but they still shoot!! That's my biggest concern!! Feathers will shoot yet when slightly damaged. I've never shot vanes but my buddy said as soon as one of this vanes gets any type of damage he can't shoot it! He shoots a drop-away rest with vanes and I shoot feathers with a WB. He has problems and I don't!!

Weird???

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I must have had some pretty crappy feathers, because I just talked to a buddy and he also has feathers with a WB and has no problem with them shredding, but feathers still suck when wet.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Switched to vanes about 25 years ago, I think they were pretty new back then. I had a dozen 2117 gamegetters arrows fletched with vanes and another dozen with feathers. The feathers were marginally more accurate at long ranges but not enough to worry about at normal hunting ranges. Definitely not enough to make up for the increased durability of the vanes. PS...Love my whisker biscuit !

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm a little undecided with my WB. It makes a little more noise than say a drop away, but it's pretty reliable!!

I shoot a lot of 3D shoots that's why I'm thinking of switching to a drop away!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Quote:

I use feathers. I have a buddy that uses vanes. He said he's got a bunch of arrows he needs refletched because his vanes are messed up!! I've never had any problems with feathers!!

What do you all prefer and why?


Not sure how this thread turned into a WB thread.. but if thats what people want to talk about its fine..

To answer the question... Feathers are usually a little more stable in the air. More resistance, which can also be a tad more noisy. Feathers are lighter so they are faster by a few FPS out of the bow. But once you reach 30 yards they are equal and then feathers are a tad faster past that as the less resistance takes over. Feathers are more water proof.

Which is better?.. depends on which things you feel are most important. Ive shot both, year before I shot quick spin vanes.. this last year I went back to feathers.. why?.. No reason.. just did.. next year I may shoot vanes again?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm shooting feathers now and they shoot great for me!! I don't plan on changing anytime soon!! I talked to my buddy and it sounds like he want to switch to feathers. I just want to make sure I didn't talk him into something he'll regret!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It doesnt cost much at all to fletch an arrow, its very cheep if you have the tools to do it. I fletch all my own arrows.

As stated, the only disadvantage of feathers is this...Not as water proof, and maybe slightly more noisy in flight.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am just getting in to bow hunting and I bought the quick spin vaned arrows from Cabela's. Cabela's just switched their arrow supplier from Carbon Express to Easton about 6 months ago and these seemed to be the real deal. I'm not sure I like them though, because the slightest thing wrong with the vanes or anything that may go wrong when you shoot sends the arrow flying off target. The spin magnifies the mistake.

I shoot at Mike’s archery in St. Cloud and they put on new 4” vanes for $3 an arrow. I like these vanes more because they are more consistent. I shoot a 2 prong rest that is spring loaded but not a drop away. Whisker Biscuits wear down the fletching more than I wanted so I am going to get a drop away someday.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've been an avid feather shooter until this past summer. Old habits/traditions can be hard to break/change. I've come a long way from the cedar arrows my pop used to build in the basement. I fletched up a few of my arrows with Duravanes and shot them at the range a half dozen times or so and I didn't notice any real difference. I hunted with feathers this past fall, but I'm in the process of switching completely over to vanes.

I also have 2 boys(soon to be 3) that are pretty hard on fletchings and I've found vanes just hold up better.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you consider vanes, consider a more rigid vane. I've gone thru a slew of vanes and one I've found to be worthy in terms of durability, consistency and sound is the PSE Pro-Fletch. Stand down range sometime and have someone shoot an arrow. What I mean is stand off to the side a safe distance and listen to them. Flimsy ones flap making a "fluttering" sound as they fly. A good rigid vane won't do that. It isn't a problem necessarily just for noise but it is in a mild breeze and certainly in a wind.

I'm also a fan of feathers. Yeah, they get dinged up easier. But I also like the traditional look of a barred feather and prefer how they fly in the wind/breeze.

Which ever you choose, get a good offset or a helical and both will stabilze quite well.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've been shooting feathers through a WB for the last couple years and have been fine. That said, I'm switching to vanes this season! I love being in the woods, so that means I'm out there rain, snow, sleet or shine! I'm sick of the special care I have to give the feathers trying to keep them dry while trucking through the woods or while sitting in the rain! And I'm sick of worrying about wet feathers shooting straight when I have a deer standing beneath my stand. Now if I was shooting in doors, I'd shoot feathers hands down. Best of luck this Fall fellas (and gals).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Capt. Quicksteel
      I hunt these WMA's routinely. It's not as bad as they say. Most of the time you're fine but you have to be prepared to have your hunt completely ruined and be able to laugh it off and move on. The land belongs to all of us. That said, if someone actually shot at a squirrel in a tree I'm sitting in, I might be tempted to shoot back.(kidding!)  Hard to imagine that really happened! I would say 75% of the time you have these places to yourself. It helps to pick areas that are a little harder to walk into.
    • TNtoMN_HuntFish
      I'd love to do this. I've never hunted them as we didn't have any where I'm from. Do you know if this opportunity is for a wild pheasant or a pen raised bird? 
    • JerkinLips
      Tough weekend fishing for me.  Caught only 5 walleyes.  I didn't see anybody else find a good bite around me.  I couldn't keep the crayfish and perch off my crawler.  I must have caught 20 crayfish and 10 perch for every walleye I caught.
    • Rick
      Youth ages 12 to 15 can apply to hunt waterfowl under the guidance of experienced mentors on Minnesota Youth Waterfowl Day on Saturday, Sept. 9.  “Helping a kid learn to hunt is a great way to share your skills and show what the outdoors have to offer,” said Mike Kurre, mentoring program coordinator with the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources. Ducks Unlimited, the U.S. National Wildlife Service, Minnesota Horse & Hunt Club, the Fox Lake Conservation League, the DNR and others have teamed up to offer the hunts, which will take place in four areas:     Southern Twin Cities metro area locations.     Sherburn private land between Fairmont and Windom.     Private land in Fergus Falls.     Sherburne National Wildlife Refuge near Zimmerman and Princeton. Application forms must be received at the DNR central office by Friday, Aug. 18. Applicants will be drawn in a lottery if a hunt is oversubscribed, with preference given to novice hunters. Successful applicants will be notified as soon as possible and must attend an orientation on Friday, Sept. 8, in the location for which they were chosen. Applications and more details about the hunt are available online at mndnr.gov/discover and by contacting Kurre at 651-259-5193 or michael.kurre@state.mn.us. Discuss below - to view set the hook here.
    • Rick
      Youth and families can apply through Monday, Aug. 21, to learn how to hunt pheasants with experienced hunters in October.  “These hunts can be the building blocks for a lifetime of rich experiences in the field,” said Mike Kurre, mentoring program coordinator with the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources. “Find out about equipment and skills you need to have safe and rewarding hunts.” Youth must be 12-17 years old as of the date of their hunt, have earned a firearms safety certificate and possess a small game license if required. Youth must have a parent, guardian or adult authorized by a parent or guardian accompany them as a mentor, without a firearm. The adult must also attend with the youth during the pre-hunt orientation. In the family hunt, all participants can hunt, but they need to be 12 and older, have little to no pheasant hunting experience, and have the appropriate safety certificate, stamp and license. The hunts are provided through Pheasants Forever and the DNR. Applications and more details about the hunt are available online at mndnr.gov/discover by contacting Kurre at 651-259-5193 or michael.kurre@state.mn.us. Discuss below - to view set the hook here.
    • Rick
      Youth can apply to hunt deer in select state parks and other refuge areas during 16 special deer hunts in October and November.  “These special hunts provide the opportunity for parents or other adult mentors to go afield with youth to hunt deer,” said Mike Kurre, Department of Natural Resources mentoring coordinator. “Deer hunting can be an extremely positive experience for youth.” Youth have through Friday, Aug. 18, to apply for the hunts. Of the 16 special hunts, 14 are firearms hunts for youth ages 12 to 15, and two are archery hunts for youth ages 12 to 17. Participation in other deer hunting seasons remains an option for youth who take part in the special youth deer hunts, but any deer harvested count against the youth’s season bag limit. An adult parent, guardian or mentor must accompany the youth at all times while hunting, but only the youth may hunt. Both youth and mentor must attend a mandatory pre-hunt orientation. A limited number of either-sex permits are available for each hunt. However, for the hunts in Buffalo River, Camden and Lake Shetek state parks youth need to harvest an antlerless deer before getting a permit to harvest a buck. Youth must apply for the hunt of his or her choice, which can be done anywhere DNR licenses are sold, at the DNR License Center, 500 Lafayette Road, St. Paul, or online at mndnr.gov/buyalicense. For archery hunts, apply with code 630; for firearms hunts, apply with code 631. If the number of applications exceeds the number of permits, the DNR will randomly draw names to choose participants. Youth may apply for one archery hunt and one firearms hunt. Successful applicants also must meet all firearms safety requirements, purchase appropriate licenses and follow hunting regulations. In addition to the 16 application-only hunts in state parks and refuge areas, any youth ages 10 to 15 also can participate in the youth deer season that runs Oct. 19-22, in 27 permit areas that encompass portions of southeastern and northwestern Minnesota and portions of the Twin Cities metro area. More information and a list of hunts and orientations can be found at mndnr.gov/discover. Discuss below - to view set the hook here.
    • HugeHogChaser
      Much appreciated JBMasterAngler! I saw a couple of your comments on another DevilsTrack lake post, but that was from 2007 so this updated information is AWESOME !! LOL! Thank you! I am looking forward to giving it a go.    I have a bunch of chartreuse  and fire tiger rapalas too. Got a couple that dive to 16 feet, and couple to around 7. Hopefully i can locate a couple eater walleye. thanks again man.
    • Gimp
      Beanies is a privately held beach and company. There is no way they would become a free public launch site--unless they sold to the DNR. I know nothing of that happening. However, if you're patient, the DNR is building one under the new HWY 36 bridge with 35 trailer parking spots to be completed in late fall 2019/early spring 2020. Here's the article: http://stillwatergazette.com/2017/03/20/dnr-plans-boat-launch-next-to-st-croix-bridge/. As for fishing, right now with the hot weather and the recent mayfly hatch, it's been a tough bite. Fish drop-offs or channels and try everything.  
    • JBMasterAngler
      Those islands are a good starting point. The mouth of the junco creek  (which is right at the campground) is a popular spot also. Gold is the go to color. Lake is full of cigars, but you should be able to find a few big enough to eat. Shorefishing at the access at night can be productive with leeches, but it's always those pesky cigars again. You might want to take a day and go over to nearby Two Island Lake. Has a much better population of eaters in my opinion. 
    • JBMasterAngler
      Wondering if there are any free campsites in the Ely area, preferably off of fernberg trail or hwy 1 within reasonable distance of town. I know there are a thousand sites on islands or lake shores that are "boat to", but I'm looking for drive to sites. Being on or near a lake would be nice, but I'm not too picky. Just looking to make a trip a little more affordable, as well as getting a chance to explore the area a little better