Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
SartellMN

Why are there so many deer?

3 posts in this topic

A few of us were discussing the huge number of deer in the state. One of the guys in his 50's commented that when he was a kid, in the Alexandria area, seeing a deer was a special occasion. Apparently, back in the 1970's there wasn't even an open season on Deer. Now, there are so many deer that people call them "wood rats".

What accounts for the huge increase in the deer population? I cannot imagine that there has been an increase in forage or decrease in natural enemies. Is it mild winters?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

While I'm no wildlife biologist, I do have a background in it, and am very familiar with the problem in addressing it with various local, state, and federal agencies.

Mild winters play a role, predominantly in the northern regions of the state when successive mild winters occur.

However, from the evidence I've seen and sources I've studied, I think fragmentation of habitat is perhaps the single greatest reason. Deer are an "edge" species, and simply put, there is more "edge" out there than ever before. Along with that, our forests are sporadically younger (rather than clear-cut style younger, as in the turn of the century) than they ever have been before. Again, this applies primarily to the northern forest.

Farm country is a different beast altogether, and I don't feel comfortable in speaking to populations observed here.

I would be curious to hear lcornice's views on this, but I think that state/local pressures to curb excessive deer numbers are counter-acted by private individual's actions in trying to promote more deer.

There still is an imbalance in buck:doe ratios, and I think that tradition and social habits are more to blame for this than anything. The will to kill a buck is so strong in many, that it often includes passing on several does to do so.

Wisconsin has a larger problem than do we, in that their deer numbers are typically many-tens-more per square mile than there were presettlement.

That said, I still think we "select" for deer by land-use choices that overly-favor their success. Is this a problem? That's for each of us to come to their own conclusion about, but I strongly believe that it could be the strongest factor concerning the high number of deer in Minnesota.

I'll climb down from my soapbox now smile.gif

Joel

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I live out by Appleton and what we are seeing out in this part of the prairie is a noticable decline in our deer population.

First I was thinking it was just me but then after talking to several farmers and hunters the concensus is the deer numbers are at best spotty.

Now I am not saying that there are no deer out here but the numbers appear to be way down, at least in this part of western MN.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • jeff_s
    • leech~~
        Are you from Canada? Too?
    • Cliff Wagenbach
      I always use only 1/2 crawler mainly because it is all that is needed to get walleyes to bite. It also more closely resembles the molting rusty crayfish and Mayfly nymphs that the walleyes are eating. The 1/2 crawler also works well when the walleyes are feeding on young-of-the-year perch. It works much better then using a crappie minnow on my rigs for some reason. I have tried both on different lines at the same time and the crawler will out fish the crappie minnow every time! Does not make sense when they are eating minnows, but that is the way it is. I always had problems with the walleyes stealing my bait when I used a whole crawler too. If I fed a whole crawler to the fish long enough for them to eat it, I almost always gut hooked the fish. One of my clients boated a 27-1/2 inch walleye today using 1/2 crawler, a red hook, and a green glow bead. Cliff  
    • Chevy Nation
      I was wondering if and there is any good fishing in Hastings during the summertime lake Rebecca, lake Isabella, Vermilion River, or anywhere off the banks of the Mississippi? I haven't caught anything yet this year and I am itching to catch anything now. Just a fyi I just bank fish.   Thanks in advance!
    • ZachD
    • ZachD
      No I have not been able to fish the Rum lately been crazy busy with work have not had a day off in 20 days my next day off wont be until July 1st but I will be going up north. Been meaning to but the couple days I was able to get out it was always raining!
    • sartellangler05
      I'm debating whether to bring my small fishing boat on a camping trip with the inlaws last weekend iinJuly. Is it worth it fishing this time of year. We are staying in the Whipolt bay. If I do fish it may be after dark when kids are sleeping. Would be open to catching both walleyes and/or panfish. Send me advice please as I have fished the lake only once. 
    • sartellangler05
      I'm debating whether to bring my small fishing boat on a camping trip with the inlaws last weekend in August. Is it worth it fishing this time of year. We are staying in the Whipolt bay. If I do fish it may be after dark when kids are sleeping. Would be open to catching both walleyes and/or panfish. Send me advice please as I have fished the lake only once. 
    • jeff_s
      Cliff, Why do you use a 1/2 crawler and not a whole one? I usually use a whole crawler on my Lindy. I caught this nice 27" tonight on a red #2 with a green soft bead and a big fat whole crawler.
    • eyeguy 54
      when They're bigger...     sheesh leech