Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
jjohnson5150

Special Reg's for Panfish?

18 posts in this topic

I have to ask this as it is burning me.

Does anyone think the DNR should consider special regulations on lakes high in quality panfish?

I was recently out on a smaller lake that has a nice population of 10' - 12' Crappies. Just about everyone out there in the 13 boats (launch parking over flowing) was catching their limits.

Everyone has the right to take their limits.

However, as word spreads more, this body of water will be fished out clean.

Why not protect it by bringing down the limit to 5 on these types of lakes? Better yet, make a slot limit to protect the biggens.

Ice fishing will make it even easier to get out there every night.

How kicken would it be to have a trophy Crappie lake to fish without having to drive to Red?

My $.02

The DNR got the same questions.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Dropping the limits to 5 on lakes like this would only make those that want to stock their freezers come back the next day or later the same day (double dipping). My guess is that if you are witnessing a hot bite that the same trucks and boats will be back there tomorrow.

If you are concerned I would call TIP and let them know of your concern. They might send someone out there to check.

I definately hear you about the lack of self discipline that some anglers have.

Let us know what happens,

Corey Bechtold

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I sent a note on Thursday to the DNR, but I have yet to hear back.

There is no evidence of the same folks going back. Perhaps a call to TIP could step up the watchful eye though.

Thanks for the suggestion.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

A person has to try. All we can do is try and promote Selective Harvest and/or Catch and Release.

Good luck,

Corey Bechtold

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There's a reason why URL had such a good stretch of crappie fishing, and it really had nothing to do with limits or regs or people having self control.

With all the walleyes gone, the fish could flourish. Now with the walleyes rebounding, the crappies numbers are coming down and stabilizing.

I really don't think a lake could sustain consistant trophy numbers of panfish. Even if it was strictly catch and release. Panfish are low on the food chain, and my thoughts are that predators in the form of other fish are just as big of factor as fisherman.

When you are dealing with fish on the upper end of the food chain, that don't have as many predators. That's when catch and release or selective harvest works much better.

Just my thoughts.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I know this is a touchy subject.. but don't we ALL get enough (too much!) to eat?

C&R for every lake in Minnesota!!

That's my suggestion.... of course we would have periodic week long 'hunting' times to keep fish (To regulate the populations).

Before anyone flames me, how is this any different than any other hunting season? Good idea eh? Might even make me keep MORE fish than I do now.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would have no problem with a 5 fish limit on pan fish. I think 10 is too many. 3 guys in a boat can really make a impact on these fish, especially when they are up shallow. 3 guys keeping 30 fish (10 each) a few times a week can really knock down the numbers. Multiply that by however many other guys are out there fishing for them and the numbers can get big in a hurry.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There is a lake I fish south of Alexandria that has had a 9" minimum legnth on crappies for about 10 years. The last few years the limit has been reduced to 5.

You catch very few small crappies, a lot in the 8" to 9" range and quite a few over 9".

It seems to be working there, so I would think they may try it on other lakes.

Pat K

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

my eyes light up lately when i see special panfish regs since that means to me there might actually be some non-stunted fish in there. Ten crappie fillets(5 medium to large fish) are enough for anyone in my opinion.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

thirty years ago i said sauk lake will never withstand the pan fish pressure yet i still see many people out there with counters with several people in the boat or pontoon. is this an exception to the rule for pan fish reproduction? would like to hear some comments castindad

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Back in the early 80's 1 lake up by us had a huge crappie and gil population. Word got out and people from all over the states came up and fished it HARD. Now the crappies are hard to find. The gils have bounced back the past few years and now we have a great population of 8-11" gils. Im hoping the crappies come back just as well soon.

Unless its a really big lake fishing pressure can really take its toll.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The DNR called me back today in response to my inquiry. They are aware of the body of water I mentioned and have a few conserns, but overall, they are alright with the preasure. The main reason being that this lake has a fast growth rate & short life span. He said that they could cut back on harvest or have a minimum harvest size, but there would be waste as a lot of the fish would die mainly due to lack of food. They have seen evidence of this body of water going in cycles & eventually getting back to the point it's at right now.

The one thing that blew me away is that he said there may be as much as 300,000 lbs of crappies there. 200 acres & 6 semi loads of crappies! shocked.gif Could I have heard that wrong?

I also asked him if the foul smelling water was normal. He said that there is "blue green algae" in the lake, which may be due to farm run off. He even sent me a pdf file about the nasty stuff. Keep your dogs away everyone!

Holy Crap! I'm not sure I want to ask any more questions.

lol. grin.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I know of a few panfish lakes not too far away that produce/produced lots of 9"+ 'gills and very decent crappies. Ive been keeping my eyes on the DNR surveys for one of the lakes and saw the size quality drop bigtime from 26 fish over 9" down to 2 fish. TWO!

I have no problem keeping fish but practice and preach selective harvest. Though sometimes it seems so useless to throw back 'gills 8.5"+ only to have the next guy keep it to stock his freezer. Atleast I can see Im changing my Dad's view. I see him throwing back those big fish with no hesitation now.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Where does a guy get ahold or email the DNR about this situation

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just google the Mn DNR and you will find it. I would say you then could go to the Contact page and e-mail away. It will give you e-mail access and a phone number.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Check out the DNR web page and click on the city where your area office is located. All the contact info for that area is listed there.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is definitely an interesting subject. My brother is a fisheries biology student at the U and we were talking about this a few weeks ago. Here's an idea:

1. Special regulations during the spawning time for panfish. Maybe catch and release only or a lower fish limit?

This is the time of the year when the really large bull 'gills are most vunerable. I love panfishing and I love eating fish, but I don't like seeing people taking huge bluegills (and crappies) off their nests and into a bucket. Any thoughts?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Quote:

This is definitely an interesting subject. My brother is a fisheries biology student at the U and we were talking about this a few weeks ago. Here's an idea:

1. Special regulations during the spawning time for panfish. Maybe catch and release only or a lower fish limit?

This is the time of the year when the really large bull 'gills are most vunerable. I love panfishing and I love eating fish, but I don't like seeing people taking huge bluegills (and crappies) off their nests and into a bucket. Any thoughts?


Actually this has been discussed within the DNR. The issue is that you'd have to close the Bluegill season during May and June and the Crappie season from ice out to June. Remember crappies are in shallow to feed after ice out, not to spawn. Anglers would never go for that though. I definitely think the limits needs to be lowered if we want any kind of qualty panfishing. Occassionally there is a hot lake with big gills but those are few and far bewteen these days. Our panfish populations just can't handle the harvest levels we put on them.

There used to be lakes that had nice panfish in them because they were winterkilling on occasion. These boom and bust fisheries provided great fishing. I wish the DNR would consider shutting off aeration systems when panfish populations get overpopulated.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • monstermoose78
      This is close to home for me. I love the dunes, but the refuge is messed up. The refuge told me they were brining native game birds back, so I was excited and said sharptailed grouse and the guy looked and me and said no ringnecked pheasants. I laughed at him and said really he said yes really. I told him ringnecked pheasants are invasive species he argued they are native and I walked out shaking my head.    The refuge could be a strong hold for sharptailed grouse, prairie chickens, and water fowl if they managed for them. The dune could extend this area. 
    • CaptainSeabass
      G'day guys, I've started up this post as I will be visiting Minnesota (to be specific the Stuart Lake in the Ottertail Lake area) and I would love to hook into some fish! I'm originally from the Netherlands, have lived in Australia for the last 8 years working as a fishing guide, I have moved to Dallas TX with my wife and now we will be visiting my in-laws in Minnesota. I would love to catch Musky, which I know West Battle Lake holds, and of course Walleye. I have been trying to look for areas that hold smallmouth but was unable to find any. I don't have a boat up there or anything so I know I will be in a massive disadvantage for musky but I will give it a try with waders. I would love to get as many tips as possible! Cheers!
    • thelars5
      This years West Central Bowhunter 60 will be held on August 12th and 13th with registration from 9am - 3pm Saturday and 9am - 2pm Sunday!   Come to enjoy the rolling hills and grasslands of the Prairie Woods Environmental Learning Center. Little Crow Archers of Willmar & Swift County Archers of Benson have teamed up to host this 60-Target 3-D shoot. Shoot it in one day, or make a weekend of it and shoot both days! Our promise is that you will not be disappointed!   Highlights include, Generous sized walking trails, On-site concessions, and seating deck! Stakes for : Adult, Youth, Traditional, and Cubs All on over 100 Acres! 90% Rinehart Targets   Full Course (60-Targets) $23 Adults ~ $15 Youth 16 & under ~ $60 Family Max 1/2 Course (30-Targets) $14 Adults ~ $8 Youth 16 & under ~ $36 Family Max   Shoot Location: Prairie Woods Environmental Learning Center 12718 10th St NE Spicer, MN 56288 GPS coordinates: N 45° 14.716 W 95° 1.777 @1.5 Miles West of Hwy 71 on County Road 29   www.littlecrowarchers.com
    • osok
         Personally I do seem to catch quite a few overs, some days it can be a challenge to find keeper fish ( stupid problem to have, huh?). One thing I notice is that all the fish seem to be very thick through out the classes.   While I was tackling some honey-do's I noticed that the breeze was a bit stiff, I'm sure it was a challenge to maintain a line or consistent  speed.   Over all was it a good day for you?
    • ZachD
      Nope that's exactly what I wanted to hear thank you probably will go to look at gander in forest lake to see if they have anything good left
    • ZachD
      There are good bass in Crooked too
    • DLD24
      Do you typically catch quite a few overs on fish? I fished it for the first time today and we got lots of gills and a few good quality eyes...The wind made boat control a pain.
    • monstermoose78
      lol I posted that Friday but with no service it must went when I ran into town for new hose
    • monstermoose78
      I was up over the weekend to do cabin duties. I did get laker trout at cascade river Friday mornings it was 17 inches but made for great trout and eggs breakfast. Agree with maple bacon longjohn and Chet's doughnut. Also a must stop for me is trail center for lunch the 3 Cheese grilled cheese is amazing with a chocolate and peanut butter milkshake. Just look at this lunch
    • Cliff Wagenbach
      Lindy rig with 1/2 crawler! 15' to 19' depth. Cliff