Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
chubei

What do you think happened?

18 posts in this topic

I shot a 12 point buck at 5yrds away at ground level with my 50 lbs compound bow with 75% let-off and easton alluminum arrow 2117 with venom steel broadheads. The deer ran hard for about 50 yards and trotted afterwards at a fast pace. Didn't get a good picture of how big he was. I had less than 20 seconds to make my decision. I'm about 5'6" and when he came to stop by me, I had my pin sight going right towards the heart right behind the shoulder bone. It was a quartering shot towards me; the deer coming right to left. I think it stuck the other side of his ribs. Tracking down blood trails and tracks. The tracks had blood spots ever other 10 yrds or so. But when the tracks were going uphill, there will be lots of blood. He laid down once in the middle of the hill and once at the top of the grassfield. Buck tracks looked like it jumped the fence into private land. Private land owner told us if there was blood on her land, then we were allowed to search her woods, other than that we were allowed to search her grassfield. Searched public land from 11am to sunset and no good. I think because of other people in the woods shooting guns and walking around, my deer was spooked from his first lay down. I had no permission to search her woods for my injured deer.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I might guess you hit him a little high and didnt hit a vital with that little blood.I question the landowner not letting you look for your deer as I thought the laws states you can retrive a wounded animal as long as you dont bring your weapon.If he ran up hill and then jumped a fence I would question he was hit that badf.How far did he travel before the hill and then jump the fence?Did you push the deer out of its bed right away or did you let it lay for some time?What color blood were you seeing?Was it bleeding out of one side or both?

Many questions need to be answered to figure out what might have went down.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Quote:

I thought the laws states you can retrive a wounded animal as long as you dont bring your weapon


Harv- I think a lot of people believe there is this law.. however, I think its myth... I think you still need permission and they can still say no to your entry even if you are trailing a wounded animal..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I need to know more details

Didn't find the arrow, right?

Was there any blood where it laid down?

Did the buck hunch up at all after you shot him?

Was there blood on one side or both side of the tracks?

If he was quartering towards you it is a good possibility that you may have gut shot him. If the arrow didn't exit, it may have wedged in his hind quarter not giving an exit wound.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

(Trespass law) Exceptions

• A person on foot may, without permission, enter land that is not

posted to retrieve a wounded animal that was lawfully shot, but

may not remain on the land after being told to leave.

• A person on foot may, without permission, enter private land

without a firearm to retrieve a hunting dog. After retrieving the

dog, the person must immediately leave the premises. This exception

does not authorize the taking of the wild animal.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The arrow is stuck in him. I waited an hour before tracking him. Other hunters and hikers were in the forest during that time and until sunset. It probably traveled a good 200 yards with a 80-95 yard uphill climb. The buck laid down once while he was going uphill because I see a spot where he laid down that had a lot of blood. There was a light laid down area on the top of the hill as well where I think he laid for less than 15 minutes. The buck laid down twice To as I found two areas where he laid down. About that tresspass law, it also says once told to leave private land you must leave. So I thought, once they say no to search the forest, it means NO.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thasnks Chuck,I was just going to look up what the law states.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Could you figure out what angle he was laying? If you can, it should tell you where the blood is coming from on the deer and in turn give you alot of intel on the shot placement.

Did he come in at the same direction that he was heading back too after the shot? If he did, I am guessing he is heading back too his bedding area from where he came from prior to the shot.

I wouldn't give up!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Could you see the arrow sticking out as he ran away? How much of it was sticking out? Where was it sticking out from, Low on the deer, in the middle of the deer, or high on the deer? Was it right on the front shoulder, slightly behind, or a few inches behind the front shoulder?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well yell at me or not this is one of those situations you that you need to get on that land with permission or no permission. I would go to the land owner and tell them the whole story again and make sure you tell them that the deer was most likely fatally shot. If they dont give you permission I would talk to a CO and see if he can persuade them to let you in there and look. If he can’t get them to budge well, I would go anyways. You owe it to the deer. I would take a $175 trespass ticket for a 12ptr that I shot legally any day.

Good Luck.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well said!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I can't understand why anyone would stop someone from retrieving game, it's just asinine.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The deer did go back to where he came from. I believed that he did go back to his bedding area. I could see at least 4 inches of the end on my arrow in the deer. I shoot a 32" arrow with 4" fletching. I could see my full fletch. I see that the shot was just right behind the shoulder and no more than an inch behind. The buck jolted SIDEWAYS atleast 3 feet away after I stuck him with my arrow at 5 yards (shot placement behind left front leg). I launched him 3 feet away with my shot. I think it was a good fatal shot, but my dad got mad at me for not taking a better fatal shot for the size of that buck. Like I said, I shoot a 32" arrow with 4" fletching and I could see the fletching of my arrow sticking out of him. I mean less than 6" of my arrow I saw. I stuck him good but wished that I could of done more to track him down. I believed I did my best legally to track him down. But I still feel bad that I could not fullfill the deer harvest of that particular buck.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

don't give up, if they wont let you on their land, give the CO a call like mentioned above from the Yooper smile.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree I'd be out there right now, work or no work, permission or no permission...

Just make sure you DONT have a compass with you, if some one asks you say you are "LOST"

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would definetly give the CO a call and see if he would be willing to help you out. You are only trying to do your duty and retrieve an animal that was wounded. See if the CO would be willing to make a call on your behalf to the owner to make the attempt to retrieve the deer. If the CO calls they might be a little more likely to allow you to go look for it. Also make sure they know you aren't hunting the land, only looking for the deer. They may be a little leary thinking you maybe seen one go in there and are trying to get in there to shoot it under the pretense of looking for a wounded animal.

I believe you are allowed to go on land to retrieve an animal as long as you don't have your weapon with you. They suggest you get permission first but I believe the law does allow you to go to retrieve the animal.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The law allows you to go on UNPOSTED land to retrieve an animal but you are not allowed to bring a gun/bow with you. On POSTED land you have to ask permission and then if they say no the CO should be called and he has the authority to take you on there to retrieve your game with him.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I know in Mich and Wisc you have to have your land posted PROPERLY and within the laws to make it a forsure deterant.

WAIT.... GET OUT THERE AND FIND THAT BUCK.... I am sure you can fight it in court even if you get a ticket. I am not trying to be a law breaker, just do what is ethical PLUS you owe it to that BUCK... Go to where you last saw it start doing circles and where ever you end up you end up... But get that buck.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

  • Posts

    • HunterFisher11

      Posted

      Thanks for the info!!! Will be up there on 10/5-10/8, have been looking at the weather and I hope they are wrong because looks like rain... Have you ever tried fishing out on pike island area? Brother inlaw drove down there this summer and said there were quiet a few people fishing there.

    • Minnesota motorists can support conservation with a new critical habitat plate featuring a wild turkey.
      The new plate displays a colorful tom turkey and is the ninth critical habitat plate offered. Other plates display a moose, loon, pheasant, chickadee, showy lady’s slipper, a fishing scene and two with white-tailed deer. There is also a specialty license plate for state parks and trails.

      “Wild turkey restoration in Minnesota is one of our great conservation success stories,” said Kim Hennings, wildlife land acquisition coordinator. “The critical habitat plates are a great way for motorists to show their interest and support for Minnesota’s fish and wildlife resources.”

      Wild turkeys are native to southeastern Minnesota, but disappeared by 1880 because of habitat loss and unregulated hunting. Successful reintroduction efforts starting in the 1970s led to turkeys now living over a wide range of Minnesota.

      “The wild turkey critical habitat plate has been long awaited for by our membership in Minnesota and turkey hunting enthusiasts,” said Tom Glines, National Wild Turkey Federation regional director. “We love the wild turkey resource and want to do everything we can do to keep wild turkey populations healthy and thriving.”

      The Minnesota Legislature created the critical habitat license plate program in 1995 to provide additional opportunity for Minnesotans to contribute toward conservation. Motorists who purchase a critical habitat plate pay a $10 initial fee, plus a minimum annual contribution of $30 to the Reinvest in Minnesota (RIM) program. Every dollar generated through the sale of the license plate is matched with private donations of cash or land. The annual $30 contribution is not tax deductible.

      Critical habitat license plate revenue has generated more than $59 million to acquire or improve 22,000 acres of critical habitat and helped fund non-game wildlife research and surveys, habitat enhancement and educational programs. Information about the program and details about how to order plates are available on the DNR website at www.mndnr.gov/plates.

      The new license plates are now available at deputy registrar offices statewide. For questions about ordering critical habitat license plates, call the Department of Public Safety-Driver and Vehicle Services at 612-297-3166.

      Discuss below - to view set the hook here.

    • The Minnesota Department of Natural Resources recently honored two youths for their outstanding conservation efforts during a ceremony at the 2016 Minnesota State Fair.

      Eliza Sankovitz from Waseca in Waseca County received the 4-H award and Melissa Schilling from Frazee in Becker County received the Future Farmers of America (FFA) award.

      The DNR Commissioner’s Youth Awards are given annually to an FFA student and 4-H member who have demonstrated initiative, leadership, creativity and achievement in conservation and wise use of natural and agricultural resources. This is the 25th year of the award program.

      Curious about the quality of the water in Clear Lake, Eliza Sankovitz asked the question, “What pollutants might be entering the lake?” This was the beginning of Sankovitz’s 4-H project titled “How Clear is Clear Lake.” Sankovitz found three locations around Clear Lake and took water samples after rain events. She then tested the water samples for bacteria, nitrates, chlorine, lead and pesticides. Sankovitz said she did find some pollutants entering the lake.

      Sankovitz is the daughter of Tom and Gretchen Sankovitz.

      Schilling grew up on a farm in rural Becker County. As a member of her FFA Fish and Wildlife Management team, she placed as top individual multiple times at regional competitions. Schilling also placed first in her area and third at state in the Minnesota Senior Envirothon.

      As a member of the Youth Conservation Corps, Schilling worked at the Tamarac National Wildlife Refuge. While on the job, she assisted with prairie restoration, bird surveys, goose banding, invasive species control and refuge facility maintenance. Schilling is currently enrolled at the University of Minnesota Crookston, and is pursuing a degree in wildlife management.

      Schilling is the daughter of Charles and Regina Schilling.

      Discuss below - to view set the hook here.

    • BringAnExtension

      Posted

      11 hours ago, ZachD said:

      I am sure Johnny P is all booked up on weekends by now and for some reason some of the guys don't like sleeper houses all though I may push for it this year last year was such a hassle packing everything up for the night loading the trucks having to bring sleds and wheelers. I much rather bring my flasher couple rods and lots of beer. I go fishing enough running and gunning its nice to have a break where you just show up and fish.

      Yes, he probably is.  I book with him early.  I think that he offers guide service in December up until he opens the sleepers up.  Might align with your portables.

    • I was on Namakan yesterday and kept 4 eyes 14" to 15" caught in under 20' of water. Water temp is 60. I was rigging with a half crawler. However, I had friends out using jigs and minnows in 40+ ft and they did well. He said he found a school and using his I Pilot just hovered over the top of them. So it seems the fish are scattered and all methods are working.

      1 person likes this
    • monstermoose78

      Posted

      I hope this weekend is better than last!!  I know there is a  lot of ducks around but they have so many places to hide.

    • If you want to stay away from the crowd I would suggest Beacon Harbor I think after jan 1st they don't allow day passes its only beacon harbor and outdoor authority who have houses there. Then they allow only a limited amount of yearly passes.

      Now they don't have all the bells and whistles like a bar and food ect but John and Ann are some of the nicest people you will ever meet. Not to mention I personally think it is some of the best.

       

      Now if you needed a bar and food and all that my choices would be Rogers or Westwind

    • fins_n'_feathers

      Posted

      Today was the complete opposite of yesterday. The current coming out of light house gap made a pocket of clear water out in the lake overnight, fished right on the edge of the muddy water in 14 feet of water and went through 3 bags of frozen shiners and caught a bunch on plastics after the minnows were gone. Nothing fantastic for size, only 3 in the slot but nice limits of 14-17 inchers and a ton of smaller fish. Once that muddy water gets blown out or clears up the bite is going to be crazy good!

      1 person likes this
    • eyeguy 54

      Posted

      212 wondering the same thing maybe?? ;)   

       

    • Agronomist_at_IA

      Posted



  • Posts

    • HunterFisher11
      Thanks for the info!!! Will be up there on 10/5-10/8, have been looking at the weather and I hope they are wrong because looks like rain... Have you ever tried fishing out on pike island area? Brother inlaw drove down there this summer and said there were quiet a few people fishing there.
    • Rick
      Minnesota motorists can support conservation with a new critical habitat plate featuring a wild turkey.
      The new plate displays a colorful tom turkey and is the ninth critical habitat plate offered. Other plates display a moose, loon, pheasant, chickadee, showy lady’s slipper, a fishing scene and two with white-tailed deer. There is also a specialty license plate for state parks and trails. “Wild turkey restoration in Minnesota is one of our great conservation success stories,” said Kim Hennings, wildlife land acquisition coordinator. “The critical habitat plates are a great way for motorists to show their interest and support for Minnesota’s fish and wildlife resources.” Wild turkeys are native to southeastern Minnesota, but disappeared by 1880 because of habitat loss and unregulated hunting. Successful reintroduction efforts starting in the 1970s led to turkeys now living over a wide range of Minnesota. “The wild turkey critical habitat plate has been long awaited for by our membership in Minnesota and turkey hunting enthusiasts,” said Tom Glines, National Wild Turkey Federation regional director. “We love the wild turkey resource and want to do everything we can do to keep wild turkey populations healthy and thriving.” The Minnesota Legislature created the critical habitat license plate program in 1995 to provide additional opportunity for Minnesotans to contribute toward conservation. Motorists who purchase a critical habitat plate pay a $10 initial fee, plus a minimum annual contribution of $30 to the Reinvest in Minnesota (RIM) program. Every dollar generated through the sale of the license plate is matched with private donations of cash or land. The annual $30 contribution is not tax deductible. Critical habitat license plate revenue has generated more than $59 million to acquire or improve 22,000 acres of critical habitat and helped fund non-game wildlife research and surveys, habitat enhancement and educational programs. Information about the program and details about how to order plates are available on the DNR website at www.mndnr.gov/plates. The new license plates are now available at deputy registrar offices statewide. For questions about ordering critical habitat license plates, call the Department of Public Safety-Driver and Vehicle Services at 612-297-3166. Discuss below - to view set the hook here.
    • Rick
      The Minnesota Department of Natural Resources recently honored two youths for their outstanding conservation efforts during a ceremony at the 2016 Minnesota State Fair. Eliza Sankovitz from Waseca in Waseca County received the 4-H award and Melissa Schilling from Frazee in Becker County received the Future Farmers of America (FFA) award. The DNR Commissioner’s Youth Awards are given annually to an FFA student and 4-H member who have demonstrated initiative, leadership, creativity and achievement in conservation and wise use of natural and agricultural resources. This is the 25th year of the award program. Curious about the quality of the water in Clear Lake, Eliza Sankovitz asked the question, “What pollutants might be entering the lake?” This was the beginning of Sankovitz’s 4-H project titled “How Clear is Clear Lake.” Sankovitz found three locations around Clear Lake and took water samples after rain events. She then tested the water samples for bacteria, nitrates, chlorine, lead and pesticides. Sankovitz said she did find some pollutants entering the lake. Sankovitz is the daughter of Tom and Gretchen Sankovitz. Schilling grew up on a farm in rural Becker County. As a member of her FFA Fish and Wildlife Management team, she placed as top individual multiple times at regional competitions. Schilling also placed first in her area and third at state in the Minnesota Senior Envirothon. As a member of the Youth Conservation Corps, Schilling worked at the Tamarac National Wildlife Refuge. While on the job, she assisted with prairie restoration, bird surveys, goose banding, invasive species control and refuge facility maintenance. Schilling is currently enrolled at the University of Minnesota Crookston, and is pursuing a degree in wildlife management. Schilling is the daughter of Charles and Regina Schilling. Discuss below - to view set the hook here.
    • BringAnExtension
      Yes, he probably is.  I book with him early.  I think that he offers guide service in December up until he opens the sleepers up.  Might align with your portables.
    • Dusty
      I was on Namakan yesterday and kept 4 eyes 14" to 15" caught in under 20' of water. Water temp is 60. I was rigging with a half crawler. However, I had friends out using jigs and minnows in 40+ ft and they did well. He said he found a school and using his I Pilot just hovered over the top of them. So it seems the fish are scattered and all methods are working.