Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

  • RECEIVE THE GIFTS MEMBERS SHARE WITH YOU HERE...THEN...CREATE SOMETHING TO ENCHANT OTHERS THAT YOU WANT TO SHARE

    You know what we all love...

    When you enchant people, you fill them with delight and yourself in return. Have Fun!!!

Sign in to follow this  
Dahitman44

Stand choice -- wind

Recommended Posts

Dahitman44

A question I ponder too mucch -- need some thoughts. --

If I had a stand that was on the edge of the woods near a field and the wind was blowing in my face and sending my scent in to the woods, would that still be better than having the wind blow my scent into the field?

If they come from a different area, my scent is in the field and I am caught. If it blowing into the woods that will be worse because they come out of the woods, Right???

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
VMS

I would say much of that depends on where the trails are coming out of the woods relative to where your stand is (if you are looking to place your stand on the edge of the woods with the wind blowing into you). If your stand is directly over the trail or the trail passes behind and downwind of you that is not the best possible place to be. If you have a stand location that does not allow your scent to pass over the trail and you can get there without creating a scent line that crosses the trail, you should be fine.

If it's blowing away from you and out over the field, I would hope the shot can happen before they scent you, but again, I think this is dependent on the wind itself. If blowing directly away from you, I would set up so that the main path to the field will give you a shot before they scent you.

A good cover-up scent would be crucial in cases like this...especially for pressured animals.

Steve

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
harvey lee

If the stand is a evening stand and the deer sre coming from the woods to the corn,you do not want the wind blowing from the corn to the woods as your scent will then be to the deers nose.

What I always try to do is to have the wind blowing in the direction that the deer are not coming from.In other words maybe easier,have the wind blowing always the same direction that the deer are coming from.If the deer are coming from the west,then you want the wind blowing to the east and then your scent is away from them.

In the morning if you are hunting the edge between the corn and the woods,then I would want the wind blowing from the corn to the woods as that is the direction the deer will be traveling from the corn to thier bedding area in the woods.

You are always going to get winded from the deer not coming the right way.I do get busted a few times every year.

I will not hunt a stand no matter how good it is if the wind is wrong.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
snapcrackpop

I sat in the cattails with the wind in my face yesterday morning and this morning, downwind of a nice woods below a good sized slope.

I was surprized how much the wind swirled!

Yesterday I had 6 does and fawns walk within 30 yards but 0 today.

No bucks and the does were too small.

I'll try this spot again in a week or so.

Anyone else crazy enought to hunt the last 2 days?

Any other interesting setups?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Dahitman44

I hope to try it tonight -- not sure what to think.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
colonel42

I'll be in my stand in about 45 minutes. Even lucky enough to have the day off tomorrow so plan on doing my first morning hunt of the season. Look forward to seeing the sign in the woods on the new fallen snow. Would be great to stick one tonight and sleep in tomorrow.HMMMMMM

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Dahitman44

C-42 --

You lucky dog.

Enjoy.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
B mac

Welcome to the world of archery hunting! That's the biggest challenge we all face. You definitely want your wind blowing away from their bedding area when afternoon hunting. However, once they get past you out into the field, the does will blow you out in a hurry. Bucks will never be the first to the field...they will stage in the thicker cover before venturing out. If they hear a doe blow the whistle, good bye buck.

Find a stand location and wind direction that blows away from the field and bedding area. And only hunt the spot under those conditions.

Also, if you are set up directly on the field, it will be very challenging to get out of the stand. The only reasonable option is to have someone scoop you up in a vehicle. I do this from time to time. Just quickly jump in the back after the deer clear the field. I don't think I've ever heard them blow when a vehicle arrives...they just run into the edge of the woods.

Once you blow a spot out (spook a mature buck), you may as well stay home until next season.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
archerystud

With the wind we've had the last couple of days, I would say that there is no good stand choice.

Had a doe last night to the East of me at a touch under 30 yards. NW wind was so strong and gusty I couldn't hold the pin on her to shoot, the wind was knocking my pin completely off the deer as I was trying to aim. Decided to pass on the shot and hopefully see her another day.

Of course the 8 point buck was only 12 yards away at the same time but I couldn't use a doe tag on him!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
96trigger

Hitman, I hear you. I have this problem all the time. If you are hunting a field edge like I do, the deer seem to come from all over the place. I always seem to see deer entering the field close to me, but not always from my trail. Lets face it, deer will enter a field from a dozen different locations. You have to get really lucky for one to walk on your trail. It seems however that when they are in the field, they will often walk along the woodline, mill around, and many times come within shooting distance of your stand. For this reason, I usually try and have the stand on a corner of the field where the trail runs N and South. Where the field is on my west side. I hope for a wind that carries my scent to a corner of either the woods or the field, that way, I have 75% of the area covered and only a 25% chance that the deer will come from area where they can wind me. Its hunting, its a crap shoot, I've had some deer come real close. I also seem to kick out deer everytime I get out of the stand, I just have enough stands that I only do that at most once a week. I still usually see deer every night. I don't leave until its dark and sometimes I make noise when I get out of the tree stand (like drop something, or bump my bow a couple of times on the ladder) so the deer scatter but don't see me. Most of the time you will here them run in the woods a little ways, then I usually book it to my truck as fast as I can, as quietly as I can) I have went out and shined the field 20 minutes later and seen plenty of deer in the field. That said, you need to really have a good scent regimen, shower before going out with scent free soap, and I can't praise scent lok enough. Good luck, hope that helps a little. Its just what I have learned over the years.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
bigbucks

All the posters have made good points. I hunted last night in my spot that I go to when the wind is howling from the West or NW. It's a hayfield edge that starts well below the crest of a big hill to the West, so it's very protected. The first two I saw came from the North way down in the valley below me to the East. They were 250-300 yards. I should have just ignored them, but it was getting late, so I messed around trying to call to them & then decided to use the range finder on them as I had never ranged any critter far out since I got it last year. I had to hang up my bow to do that, so I wouldn't drop it. As I'm concentrating trying to range them suddenly I see out of the corner of my eye a nice younger doe, yearling or two year-old come walking fast into the field from the North. When I see her she's at about 20 yards, walking fast, trying to find the calling deer. Had I ignored the others I'd be cutting her up tonight... Even though I froze, she had me too pinpointed from the calling & saw me, ending my opportunity.

The spots for these conditions exist, there aren't many, but in some ways that makes it easier, you find one & you have a for sure place to go in this weather.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Dahitman44

96 --

Thanks.

A buddy of mione is just getting into bow hunting and he doesn't think the scent thing is a big deal. he said, "I have three big bucks on the wall, that must count for something."

I keep telling him there is a big difference between bow and rifle hunting.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
jltimm

You ain't a kidding about the difference between rifle hunting and bow!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
bigbucks

Yes, gigantic, good gun stands in our case usually are not good bow stands. The whole natural movement vs. pressured movement, on top of that, who sets up a gun stand to try to ensure shots under 30 yards?

Scent plays a much smaller role in gun hunting, at least in heavily hunted areas. There's scent everywhere, they have to rely more on hearing & vision.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Dahitman44

Right on guys.

Now convince my hard-headed friend.

The other day he met me out hunting with his little boy and I could smell them -- I'm sure the deer could as well. wink.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  



  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • smurfy
      i might also try getting there. thats the weekend spear chucking closes so if i dont get a chance to get back north that will dictate!
    • KidMoe
      I use a fish oil that comes in a pump bottle from Menards or FF. This stuff makes a huge difference for my dog. It calls for one tablespoon or 1 pump per 10 lbs so my pup gets 7 or 8 pumps on his kibble.  i also try to run the poor mans humidifier (boiling pot on the stove) on the really cold days. It has been extra cold and dry so far this year though. 
    • aczr2k
      Sounds like fishing has been good, that's always a great thing to hear.  Is there much snow on the lake away from the roads or pretty much impassable?  I can't believe no one has asked if we need an extension yet...a remembered frequent post back from the old days. ha ha.  
    • eyes55117
      It’s been over a week since I was out there last marked a ton of fish but but was really slow. Any improvement in the bite? 
    • Surface Tension
       Flooded,  inlet valve is not seating from being warn,  debris in the valve, or improper metering lever height. The later is what I would suspect since you've already had the carb apart.  The meter lever is the link from metering gasket to the inlet valve. This controls the flow of fuel.  That adjustment is normally level with the floor of the carb body.   An incorrect setting will allow fuel to freely flow into the carb with engine off. Or it can starve for fuel not allowing enough fuel into the carb.
    • cookie129
      The plan  this morning has again changed from plan a to plan b as yesterday afternoon.  The red  baron broke her front drive shaft, taking out the transmission pan to boot. Darn the luck! I may of heard it clunking if I had the exhaust fixed. Hindsight  I try and always look at these things as they are ment to happen for a reason and its part of the business.
       Sunday night after the Vikings game when I headed back on the lake, mother nature has pretty much taken out my 1/2 mile or more side road to the houses. When I was visited Dan and mel Robbie was on the phone with there friends that were on the way up and they were going to go meet them to bring them out in a car? So funny as they had no clue the road/trail was completely drifted in?  I had to plow a new trail to get the to Buddy Hillmen's Highway which was not drifted in. When I got back to old Minnesota I was standing there visiting nad look at the rattle wheel . For some reason they did not have it down so I said, Hey I'm fishing this one and put a minnow Tail hooked on this huge big pink banana looking jig. With in 3 minutes I had the big one of the day 18 1/2. Last night Robbie beat it out with a dandy just under 20.
       Last night the hammer and I went to check on snowbear Joshes customers so we took his truck out there, wow what a treat to have good heat in a truck. I'm so use to being in a cold truck I was baking in there. The family he has in his grand ice castle are having a grand time on a grand lake. Scott and Jen were playing a  game with the kids. Olivia and Conner. I took a pic of the game as it looked like a fun game for our grand kids. Grama Joe was worn out from all the fish they had caught I think. Grandpa Mike was watching all the lines. really nice family.
       joshes other customers called at the bewitching hour to see what the slot size was so they must of started to get some action. I'll swing in and check on them this morning.
       Jonny boy spent Monday night in florida and got his 4, crazy any other year and the house would of been burned out after 3 days. He was going to sleep in montana last night so it will be interesting to see how he does as there have been  at least 20 fish caught out of that house in two nights. The guys were also doing real good in north Carolina and that little 2 man sleeper seems to have some good ju ju when it come to catching fish. Phil sure built a cozy  house.
       Hoping to have all our parts by some time Friday to put the red baron back on the ice, It sure is nice having Jonny boy be able to help as I can not work like that anymore. Barny from Kellier is going to braise up the pan as its a specialdeep pan due to it being a fire rescure truck before it became a lake truck.
      The last thing is last nights sunset was spectacular, it just went on and on from a gorgeous pink, in to a dark orange glow. I got a couple pics I posted on our facebook page Cookies on upper red lake.  
    • fish_time
      He guys, just wanted to share a video of my kids fishing for crappie and sunfish. Be awesome outdoors!  
    • leech~~
      Thanks, for the info.  I'll just look at the Steelhead and Looper on my wall to refresh my memory!
    • oilandwater
      Have heard of very few.  An occasional rainbow (looper and steelhead, make sure to learn the difference) mixed in with the catch in Two Harbors, along with lake trout near the bottom on the right day.  I've seen a few cruising under the ice in McQuade, but pretty slow there.  Rainbow action will pick up as spring progresses. 
    • smurfy
      sheez got that right!!!!!!!!!
  • Share & Have Fun