Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
not_nuf_time

Youth Gun Help

9 posts in this topic

I have a 12 year old son about a hundred pounds. This will be his first year deer hunting with a gun. I bought him the 20 ga. youth shot gun. I have also been offered a Rem 25-06 with vari III scope for him for $600.00. Witch I am going to buy for him for future use.(opinion on this gun OK, to)

My question is this, I don't think he is ready for that 25-06 this year(even though I've been told they don't kick like a 30-06). So do I go out and buy the rifled slug barrel for the 20 ga. for $70.00 or use just the smooth bore, and is their a big difference? Or Force feed him the 25-06? Thanks.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

if you already have a 30-06 you could try the managed recoil rounds from remington. i have heard that the kick is very tolerable and perfect for smaller frame people.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just to tell you from experience that the 20 guage will kick more then the 25-06. I bought my son a 20 guage combo last year and it is a great gun and since we can only hunt deer with a shotgun it works good but I own a 25-06 and I sure think it kicks less then the 20 guage. Now if they are shooting at a deer there will be no notice in how they kick but practicing they will notice a kick. It is not bad but my son is about the same size and he says the kick from the 20 guage is not bad but let your son shoot them both and decide for himself. maybe tyr different load and recoil pads and see what works best.

Froggy.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

To be honest, I'd say find a 30-06 and use the remingon managed recoil. I switched to that last year, and 125 grains is plenty to drop a deer. Then, your son has a gun that will last him a lifetime and can get used for bigger game if, and/or when he chooses to go for larger game like elk or moose. The gun you choose might be a little heavier too, which will also aid in reduction of felt recoil.

If your options are there for different calibers, a .308 or a 7mm-08 would be great choices as well. big enough for deer but not overly powerful to blow off a shoulder.

Steve

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for ideas, I just went and looked at the 25-06 and passed on it. I forgot he shot left handed, it had a cheek plate on the stock and to sight in correctly you had to have your cheek about a half inch from the stock. Plus the right side bolt would have been a hassle. I figure I'ld rather get him the perfect fit gun for him so it does last him a lifetime, and he'ld really enjoy hunting rather than fight with a misfit gun for him. I'll keep looking. Thanks.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Being a lefty myself, I started with a Browning model 81 BLR. easy enough to add a little attatment to the hammer to make it easier to cock with the thumb and he'd be all set. The other nice aspect about it is the BLR has a clip rather than having to load it into a tubular magazine like the marlins or winchesters. The gun is light enough and short enough to use as well which made it a really good brush gun. And...with the selection of calibers, and a decent price point he'd have a great gun.

The A-bolt micro is a little shorter as well and a 60 deg bolt throw which if he goes with a scope, his hand would not get so close to the scope...

man...talking about this makes me want to go out and do some shopping again.

Steve

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Great advice on the managed recoild rounds. They work very well to about 150 yds and the kick is very tolerable.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have a fair amount of experience with slug guns. The 20 guage with slugs will kick as hard as a lot of bigger rifles. Slugs kick much harder than standard shotgun loads. If he is a lefty, go to a lever gun. A 30-30 is a light kicker and easy to handle. Hornady just developed new ammo that makes the 30-30 into a legitimate 250 to 300 yard gun. Pretty amazing. I was at a store the other day and Marlin even has a gun out that is made to match that ammo. It has a loner barrel than most 30-30's.

The .308 and .270 are not real heavy kicking guns and you could get by with a .243 for whitetails (and predators!) I personally started with a .270 at age 12.

If you do decide to go with the 20 guage, buy the slug barrel so that he has the best chance he has to hit his target if he gets an opportunity. I now hunt in the slug zone and my slug gun, with a rifled barrel and scope shoots good groups at 100 yards. It also kicks like a .338 Win Mag with the new hot slugs that I use and isn't really very fun to shoot.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I guess it depends on which .308. At age 14 (& 180 lbs) my first rifle was a .308 Savage 99 and ended up selling it because of the recoil. I still hate heavy recoil 40 years later and shoot a .270 now - no comparison to that .308.

At 100 lbs. my recommendation would be something with light recoil - .243 & .260 are 2 of many options - or a caliber for which managed recoil loads are available. The size of the caliber isn't nearly as important as a well placed shot.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

  • Posts

    • I second the Vermilion Club-great food and they always welcome the dog (black lab) on the deck and give her water. We have been over on major holidays (July 4th, Memorial day, etc) and can always squeeze in somewhere and if not, there's "the kid" who charges $10 for "their dock".....love the place! 

    • monstermoose78

      Posted

    • You are right, it's a grouse.

    • BringAnExtension

      Posted

      I am not a hunter and I live in southern Minnesota, so I don't know how to identify this bird.  It walked into our campsite at Tettegoche State Park last week.  I am thinking a grouse?

      20160917_105407.jpg

      1 person likes this
    • BringAnExtension

      Posted (edited)

      I don't have much to report, as I have not been fishing much lately, but wanted to add a topic on our quiet forum.

      I finally got a chance to go out on Mazaska this past weekend.  I tried my usual methods with almost no luck.  Fatheads on a jig and under a slip bobber.  From 9 feet down to about 25 feet.  I had a couple of bites, but that was it.

      Water temperature was still a balmy 68 degrees and a stiff wind was coming out of the southeast.  Even though I caught nothing, it was a beautiful day to be on the water last Saturday.

      One day closer to hard water season ...

      Edited by BringAnExtension
    • phillyfacks

      Posted

      We've got a cabin up on Pelican and I've definitely noticed less cormorants on the lake this summer.  The state did grant the owner of Gooseberry Island a permit to kill cormorants, which was done this Spring.  I talked to a DNR officer on the lake this summer and he said they had shot almost 400 birds, I don't recall the exact numbers but it was somewhere between 350-400. 

    • Consider me in on a personal boycott of The Landing. Horrible horrible horrible customer service skills by the owners/management.

      1) it is much quieter on the water without the big blasters running up an down the lake from the Landing.

      2) Had a craving for wings while out fishing one night. Called ahead ordered up some wings- great taste- tiny crappy wings. Asked for a side of Blue Cheese and Celery - upcharge of like $3.00 for those. Washed it down with a bottle of Coors Light. $23.50

      Large group went in one night and they usually tear up the bar. Were told they can't play jukebox until after 10 pm it was 9:40 PM- ONLY GROUP IN THE BAR.  "They are trying to build up an Ambiance"

      Got their bar tab and they were done. Yearly group that dropped a lot of cash in the past. Never again until new ownership is on board.

      Unfortunately they have deep pockets.

      As soon as new ownership / management takes over the crowds will return.

    • Big V Bobcat

      Posted (edited)

      That place is sinking faster than a boat anchor! I couldn't figure out why they were putting in so much money into it, especially since every time I'd drive by at dinner hour, there'd be at best 5 cars parked there. Always a good crowd at the Crescent of course. I don't mind the lack of view...since I'm usually on the lake most of the day already. I remember the days of Judd and Jack, and the place was lively and included the locals. Now it is mostly oblivious resort guests who see it as the only option. Very "pretentious" place that would be better suited in the Brainerd lakes area. My wife's co-worker told her that he was there this summer and they charged him $2 for a glass of water and .75 for mustard (in a stainless steel cup of course). I'd like to check out Wolf Bay, but I need a faster boat first! Don't even get me started on the $7 beers....

      Edited by Big V Bobcat
    • OhioVike

      Posted

      My entire family loves coming up to the lake. We make it part of the routine to stop at the landing at least once per trip.  At the end of the day a few extra bucks per entree is no big deal. Our meals have always been good, service has varied with the crowds which is true everywhere up there.  Run the per pound cost on your walleye catch. The few meals a year you eat there would pale in comparison.  I hope they stay open, it is a fun part of our trips!

    • FrazerBay

      Posted

      Have to agree..food is great..best place in the winter on snowmobile..

      but..the dock situation could use a big upgrade.

      1 person likes this


  • Posts

    • PSU
      I second the Vermilion Club-great food and they always welcome the dog (black lab) on the deck and give her water. We have been over on major holidays (July 4th, Memorial day, etc) and can always squeeze in somewhere and if not, there's "the kid" who charges $10 for "their dock".....love the place! 
    • monstermoose78
      Ruffed grouse
    • DANR
      You are right, it's a grouse.
    • BringAnExtension
      I am not a hunter and I live in southern Minnesota, so I don't know how to identify this bird.  It walked into our campsite at Tettegoche State Park last week.  I am thinking a grouse?
    • BringAnExtension
      I don't have much to report, as I have not been fishing much lately, but wanted to add a topic on our quiet forum. I finally got a chance to go out on Mazaska this past weekend.  I tried my usual methods with almost no luck.  Fatheads on a jig and under a slip bobber.  From 9 feet down to about 25 feet.  I had a couple of bites, but that was it. Water temperature was still a balmy 68 degrees and a stiff wind was coming out of the southeast.  Even though I caught nothing, it was a beautiful day to be on the water last Saturday. One day closer to hard water season ...