Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

  • Announcements

    • Rick

      1st Please Post Your Fishing Report - Then Join the NEW - Private Fishing Report Clubs   01/24/2018

      Private Fishing Report Clubs - Click Here - Post Your Fishing Report Before Joining
      1st, be sure you post a fishing report in the forums, then ask to join after you post a fishing report in your area forum. The Private Fishing Report Clubs are where folks can share private fishing information with club members who have proven they know what's going on. Fishing Report Clubs Link also in Menu above. Apply to become a member today, while it's still easy. 
  • RECEIVE THE GIFTS MEMBERS SHARE WITH YOU HERE...THEN...CREATE SOMETHING TO ENCHANT OTHERS THAT YOU WANT TO SHARE

    You know what we all love...

    When you enchant people, you fill them with delight and yourself in return. Have Fun!!!

Sign in to follow this  
Lunker

12 ga Inquiry

Recommended Posts

Lunker

I am looking to get a new 12 ga in the next year, and am wondering what others would suggest. Need something that's not strictly just a waterfowl or just an upland gun. Something I can use in the blind or pheasant field. Pump or Semi-auto. I have my preferences, but am open to some ideas. I'll probably do some shopping around and shoot some different guns so any ideas are appreciated.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
FarByondDrivn

If you can narrow it down to a price range and an action (semi or pump) your choice would be easier. Its hard to beat the gold old 870 Rem for affordability and dependability. Also the 835 by Mossberg is a good gun but is a little heavy for upland hunting. As you get farther up the price range of pumps you have the Benelli Nova and the BPS by Browning; both are good bets. As far as autos go, you'll be spending a little more money and have a little more maintenance but also less recoil and faster target reacquisition. Starting point for the autos would probably be Baikals or Stoegers followed by the Mossberg 935 (Which I have heard is a good gun.). As you go up the price range you hit the SX2 (I have one and it is my favorite shotgun)and then the Browning Gold. Even further up are the Benelli Super Black Eagle 2 and the Berreta Xtrema.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
love to hunt

I am really partial to the Banelli Nova for several reasons.

I have never had a pump jam, it points great, the price is right in there, and I can use it for anything from turkey to geese.

Nova gets my vote.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Ron Burgundy

The 870 combo with the rifled slug barrel would be a great buy. You can get it for around $390 and it will handle anything. The only problem I've had with mine in 11yrs is most likely my fault. I think I didn't screw down the magazine cap tight enough when attaching the barrel and shot it. Now I believe I'm getting a new ejector. Take care of it and it'll take care of you. Field and Stream also did a survey about the most popular and versatile guns. The 870 was the big winner by far. This was in the last few months or so.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
bigdog

I have always had good luck with Remington 1100's and 11-87's. Also like Beretta 391's.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
loosegoose

I'm with bigdog. If you're looking for a good all around gun I would recommend a Beretta auto loader. A very light gas operated gun that is very dependable and easy to clean.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Cooter

Vote Rem 870

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
CodyDawg

A Beretta auto. I have had my 870 jam, but never my 390 (15,000 rounds and counting). Ducks, geese, grouse, roos, trap, you name it, it does it flawlessly. If you are slug hunter, you can add a slug barrel and have a fantastic deer gun. my $.02

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
96trigger

12 gauge beretta A390. Identical to the old 390 only currently made. My 390 has never failed me, it is my trap gun, grouse gun, goose gun,and pheasant gun. It is easy to break down and clean. You can find one for about $650 new in the black synthetic. Used 390's run about $550. As for pumps, the benelli nova or the rem 870, standard guns, similar price. If you deer hunt with it, I'd look for a combo with a slug barrel. The slug barrel for the beretta is almost as much as the rem 870 and the benelli.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
JDM

I own three 870's and two Novas. Both are great and you can't go wrong. My main wingshooting gun is the Nova because I shoot better with it (despite being a little heavier than an 870). My main deer gun is a tricked up 870. I am a pump guy. Despite what the other guy said, they rarely jam - especially in cold or wet weather (bottom of duck boat), or heavy dust (Dakota's) Many of my hunting partners shoot auto's and the ONLY one I would consider is the Super Black Eagle. I have hunted with a pump my whole life and I am faster with it than most guys are with autos. It drives those guys nuts! I also own a BPS, but I am not a big fan of that model.

The pumps are also easier to clean and the Nova is a 3 1/2 inch gun, which is great for waterfowl. If you go with the 870, spend the extra money for the Wingmaster. It is worth it. I have had many great meals from both guns.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Lunker

Thanks for all the suggestions, always good to hear people defend their favorite gun. My current 12 is an older 870 wingmaster that went through rough times before it landed in my hands

(cracked stock, poly-choked barrel)and I was looking at guns like the 870,benellis and brownings suggested, totally forgot about beretta's but I have shot them and I like the gun, I've always shot pump but kind of want an auto. Definitley have some thinking to do. And shopping(the only shopping I like to do grin.gif)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
smg04

another vote 4 the 870express, if your outboard breaks down while duck hunting u can use ur gun as a paddle and it will still shoot strait as and arrow, best gun for the $ by far

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
jltimm

I bought a Stoeger semi-auto last year, and really like it.Comes with 5 chokes, is really light, throws up great, and shoots good also.Put one up to your shoulder while your in the store, you may be surprised!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Nova

Rem 870 or the Benelli Nova. By far the 2 best guns I have ever owned. I am currently using the Nova for everything and like it just a bit better than the 870. I would never own a auto, but that is just me. Late season cold weather hunting there is a chance of a jam. With the new guns it's a smaller chance, but it still exists. In 35 years of hunting ducks until the last day and pheasants into late december I have NEVER had a pump gun jam.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Rotwieler

I dont think for a pump you can beat a 870 express magnum. I love mine. I duck, and grouse hunt with mine. I even used it for trap shooting and i had a hit rate of 97.41% this year.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
45acpshooter

Another vote for the 870 Express. I've owned dozens of shotguns valued from a couple hundred dollars to thousands. My 870 has taken a ton of abuse and has never failed to work. The finish is extremely resistant to rust. I have other guns that I shoot better but the 870 will always have a place on my gun rack.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
BigWadeS

My vote is for Remington 870 or 880 pumps

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
LovenLifeGuy

Anyone know what the wieght is on the 870's? I own one and do not know.

Thanks, LovenLifeGuy

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
lunker651

Quote:

Thanks for all the suggestions, always good to hear people defend their favorite gun. My current 12 is an older 870 wingmaster that went through rough times before it landed in my hands

(cracked stock, poly-choked barrel)and I was looking at guns like the 870,benellis and brownings suggested, totally forgot about beretta's but I have shot them and I like the gun, I've always shot pump but kind of want an auto. Definitley have some thinking to do. And shopping(the only shopping I like to do
grin.gif
)


If I was looking for and auto shotgun I'll go with a Browning gold or benelli M1, M2,or super eagle. My buddies have these and they are awsome.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Bassboy1645

870 all the way!!!!!!! Had mine new since i was 12yrs old and even now in college its the best shotgun i have ever used....ive shot everythign from mice up to deer wiht it. Squsih it in the mud and its easy to dissaemble and wash out and put it back togther and its good as new. Best gun for the money and youll do better wiht a rifled barrel if u want it to double as a deer gun....oh and im american I like an american firearm.......i hate foriegn jap cars and rip off trucks smirk.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
IRISHSOBNO4

get a BPS and you can't go wrong.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Fish&Fowl

Just bought a Benelli M1 Super 90. Great gun for pheasants and ducks. Very reliable, light-weight gun. Dad's going on 7 years with his with zero problems. I find this remarkable as the gun never gets cleaned, at least not good, unless I do it after I do mine. Not a cheap gun, but as I've learned in my whole 20 years, you get what you pay for. Had a BPS before that, also a very good gun as most pumps are. I am a Browning guy but I am sure impressed by that M1.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  



  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • Fathom
      Set up deeper on rock reef for the rest of the weekend and only managed one fish (26" eye), missed a couple others. We wanted to stay deeper due to all the traffic on the lake. We did enjoy a good time at Fishing for Ducks, we saw a nice walleye pulled through the ice but it only measured 27.5". Talk about a bummer for that guy!
    • Jarrid Houston
      Roads to the islands always need to be taken very cautious and I would encourage going with someone who knows the area..  I believe they were shutting down the highway H extension due to this recent weather we just got?  Plenty of fish and opportune situtations in the bay.
    • cookie129
      Another crazy busy weekend is in the books. I really enjoy giving out my fishing/what's happening on the lake reports but finding the time has been tough. To say its a grind is a understatement.
       I can tell you again as the season winds down I'm never ready for it to end, as I truly love being out there in my trucks, moving houses, plowing the  hillmen highway, giving advise, helping other fishermen when they do something silly, Driving into a snow bank, dropping there gun down a hole or any other important object like there keys. Every year all the workers seem to get a little grumpy as fighting mother nature, going from sun up to sunset takes a toll physically and mentally. It also seems I ruffle a few feathers every year and its never my intent  so I have to chalk it up as a long season. If I stepped on anyone's toes it sure was not planned or intended as all most every day plan a turns to plan b and c. Mother nature dictates where I go sometimes as well as any plowed roads that can make our job easier. The cookie shuffle worked very well this year as I tell everyone that gets lost in my maze of trails. I'm not a road engineer.
       Man did we get overwhelmed with wheel house's this past weekend, any fish coming from southwest had to go threw a gauntlet of hooks to find my fishermen.
       I had two wheel house's  that I set up at the end of the hillmens highway and was surprised how bad they did. I guess I should of went south not east? The nw road has gotten to much to maintain, there's one lone house out that way that will need a new trail made .
       Its all started Thursday as jonnny boy and I prepped for the weekend with Joe, Zack, Adam and   his crew arriving fro florida. Zacks birthday wish was fishing red lake, they had a blast. They went to westwind where they enjoyed a fish fry, plus they took home a few fish with a couple even getting a ride in florida fish house as we moved a small distance to put it on fresh ice for there last night sunday. Last year when they came we landed on the elusive yet still catchable upper red lake crappie mother load? I think  they had dreams for a year of repeating that. Every year is different and again this year was no exception.
       Ben who proposed in old Minnesota to Shawna 8 years ago were in old Minnesota with there two adorable kids. Louie the fishing machine and his little sister Willa plus there friend Nelli.
       They had a blast also with Shawna getting a elusive yet still catchable upper red lake crappie to boot. They also managed to take home a nice batch of upper red lake walleyes.
       Hunter and his two buddies were in north Dakota. It was slow but they also managed to take home a batch of fish.
       Charlie and Rizzo were in montana , They were very serious about there fishing and went home with there 8.
      Jeromy and his gal were in north Carolina Saturday, sunday . They also managed to get there 8.
       Sunday was a very tough day as we had all 5 houses re rented. I was planning on moving all of them so we battled mother nature the whole time as a ne wind with 2 inches of snow made it impossible to see. At one point I was getting sea sick as I struggled to see, With the sky, horizon and the lake all the same color. wow what a struggle.
       It took us  7 1/2 hours but we got every thing cleaned, moved.
       Mother nature has given us another bout of snow so tomorrow I will let every one know how the houses did the last two days as its time to check the fluids and fire up the fleet
       
    • nickeleye
      Figured I should report back... I fished prime time on Saturday morning and Saturday evening. No action. It didn't help that I forgot to grab the vexilar on the first outing, but it didn't help to have it on the second outing either! ha! Marked a few but couldn't get them to bite. Used a GPS chip to punch some holes over structure, but when I came back with the vexilar, they weren't quite as deep as I hoped. Thanks for the pointers BrianF
    • LucasLongCaster
      Around this time last year this thread was started by @Royal_Dutchman. I got my trip planned for April but by the look of the extended forecast it's not looking to promising, especially compared to where it was at last year on Feb 23rd. 
    • osok
      Been a brutal hard water season for me as well, figured it was a continuation of my fall fishing luck. 
    • Wanderer
      Thanks guys.  I checked out Modis for ice coverage and Navionics to help understand how things are laid out.  Knowing what areas certain fish prefer and those typical depths is a big plus.
    • urbaniceteam
      My wife and I are hoping to get up to Mille Lacs this Saturday and spend the night on the ice.  Does anyone have any last minute availability?  All the resorts I've contacted are booked. Thanks!
    • Borch
      Lots of nice fish!  Central Mn is cranking out some nice panfish.
    • eyeguy 54
      I did till about 2 then just had to go for a bit. LOL 
  • Share & Have Fun