Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
saintmark

Detroit Lake...Fact or Fiction!

4 posts in this topic

I heard some guy say that there were only about 60 muskie in Big and Little Detroit. That seems far fetched. Heck I caught a 42" and a 48" on thur and fri respectively. Don't worry....I caught, photoed, and released very carefully. It does my heart good to watch those monsters swim off looking back at me with their middle fin held out of the water. I also heard his claim that him and a buddy caught a 60" a couple of season ago, but couldn't get it in the boat. Seems that 60 is being repeated alot. Now I'm not looking to stir up the lake water. I've been accused of that before. I'm just looking for some facts not fish tales. YES I've seen stocking reports, so don't quote those. I know some muskie die from poor handling and the taxidermist, BUT only 60!! In the few years I've fished on D, I've never seen a dead muskie. I'm sure there is some local lore around the lake, guides that see the water regularly, and guys like me that love that lake and wonder!! Anything posted would be apreciated for all to read and see.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

that guy is full of hogwash, there is no way there are only 60 muskies in that lake. There were 4 muskies sampled in the 2003 survey. There were about a dozen gill nets and trap nets placed. While they are good as estimating the approximate size structure and distribution of the fish in the lake, it is difficult to get a true population estimate. but 60? no way! I can tell you that if there were only 60 muskies in Detroit, there would be a closed season for Muskies.

As far as a 60" muskie in Detroit, it's possible, however, pretty unlikely. It takes up to 17 or 18 years for a fingerling to top out between 50 and 56 inches. Muskies fingerlings were first stocked in Detroit in 1989, putting the oldest fish at about 17 years old. Even with the abundant forage in Detroit, it is unlikely a muskie is pushing 60" already.

Call 218 847 1579 and talk to Dave Friedl (DNR Fisheries Area Mgr). If he is not available ask to speak to one of the Specialists. They will set you clear on the Muskie population in Detroit.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yep, what DeadHead said. 60? Nope. Also, when you hear stories about the 60" fish that got away, it should pique your skepticism-detector in a big way. I sure wish I had a dollar for every time I heard somebody tell the story of the 60" fish they saw or had on, but just couldn't quite get in the boat. I'd be rich!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think 60 inches is a little far fetched, maybe 56 inches. As far as 60 fish in the lake, that's pretty funny laugh.gif. I guess I caught half the lakes population a few years back out of only 4 spots shocked.gif. There's over 3000 acres and even if there was only one fish every 10 acres, that's over 300.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • OhioVike
      With social media the new normal is for people to rant the open airways.  Unfortunately, some times people cross the line. I don't think that has happened here, but I would also say that I have sympathy for the new owners of the Landing.  I continue to go there knowing I will pay more than I generally would want to.  I would probably go more if their prices were lower as they are much closer to me than The Crescent.  
    • cookie129
      Another sunrise and another sunset made my day yesterday as I  enjoyed a day on such a grand lake. I spent part of the morning in old Minnesota making some phone calls, planning my day and even wetting a line.
       Berry and his crew Ted, Mike  and Scott had left early do to the weather conditions in southern Minnesota. They only managed 3 more fish after the move. "Stupid fish".
       I hung out in old minnesota until the generator ran out of gas so I could figure out how long it ran on a tank. !0 1/2 hours as she quit running at 8:30 am. Sure would be nice to have that burg system? Oh that's right its in the snow bank . "Stupid thing" not sure why it fails.
       After fueling up the generator I made the morning rounds to be a little disappointed with the fishing report "Stupid fish" Oh well as Wayne always says if we caught them all there would not be any to catch.
       I then went over to clean and prep Montana for Brian and Stacy as they were coming up for there 25th anniversary.
        I also gave Reid and Jason a couple tips as they were off to find the very elusive yet still catchable upper red lake crappie. They only caught one walleye in North Carolina so I told them when they came back it would be in a new spot.
       I then said goodbye to Steve from Michigan  and his crew in Florida. They did horrible on low and did not fair much better in florida the third night. They did have some action on tip ups though just outside the house.
       Then over to north Dakota where again no fish "stupid fish" what a horrible spot that turned out to be. We talked and I told them I would be back at 10:30 to move the house. Arriving back at 10:38  we were on the move. I told them if all went well they would be wetting a line again by noon. I also said if they wanted they could ride in north Dakota. Scott ask if I had any more shovels and I said sure do I have 3  so they all pitched in to dig her out. The move went well and just like I promised they were wetting a line  by noon. Cory said the ride was way smoother then he expected.
       The phone rings and its Stacy and Brian 2 hours early, perfect as the house is ready to go. At the same time Buddy Hillmen calls and says he is over the pressure ridge and were going to open another mile of road. OH! Oh! plan A is now switched to plan B. I get them checked in and I'm off to help with the new road.
       It did not take long to burn up a 1/2 tank of gas. I checked in with Buddy Hillmen and headed home to  gas up, check the fluids and get back out to the houses as I still had more work there. Moving north Carolina went well other then a few issues with the extension cords. As my very good pal Wayne says. "Here at Cookies we do it right cause we do it Twice"
       Once North Carolina was all set I was back out to Hillmen's highway where we would keep plugging away on the new mile of road. 2 hours later and I was heading home for a quick bite before making the evening rounds.
      Stacy and Brian were the first stop where Stacy had lost 5 fish at the hole. I gave her a tip on landing them so we will see if that pans out.
       Reid and Jason found north Carolina and had a blast fishing outside all day. They landed a few walleyes but no" elusive yet still catchable upper red lake crappie". I guess that's why I call them elusive.
       Last stop was at North Dakota ! I had played a round of Texas Hold um with them the night before and wanted another shot. 
        Scott did not play, he sure deserves to catch a few fish as he was always holding his fishing rod and jigging  when I stopped in. One fish was all they caught on the new spot "stupid fish".
       I lost a second time in hold um and headed home where I ran into a local Dave him and his son had set up just to the north east of us where they landed 3 nice fish.
       Well back to the grind again today. we have mike coming for north Dakota and Kieth and his kids coming for florida. I told both them that check in was at 2pm.
       
    • ZachD
      Lundeens was out of shiners when I was there granted it was Sunday
    • ZachD
      I believe that one in Monticello closed down
    • BassThumb.
      Most of our fish came on minnows under bobbers. I spooked countless fish with even subtle jigging.