Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
bearplott

Bear Hunt

11 posts in this topic

How everyone doing up that way this year? Any success yet?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's been getting slower and slower the past 5 years but this year is amazingly slow. I think it is real safe to say that the bear numbers are down 70% to 80% from what they were 5 years ago.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Would you care to offer your thoughts on why that is so? Is the state giving out too many permits?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

30-06,

Maybe to many sows and cubs are being killed.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Cubs can't be legally harvested can they? In Wisconsin, sows with cubs are also protected. Is Minnesota the same?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My feeling is that there has just been way too much hunting pressure in this area. I think many people "discovered" this area when they were here crappie fishing, looked at a highway map and thought that there was a tremendous amount of remote areas that should be great for bear. The problem was that these huge remote areas are mainly bog and not bear habitate. All of the hunters ended up clustered on the narrow ridges of high ground running through the bog. It has been commen the past 3 years for the baits to be 100 to 150 yards apart for miles down these higher ridges. It would be interesting to compare the number of bait stations registered in this area 8 years ago to the number registered now. I feel it could be 10 times more bait stations now.

For example some friends had a bait station in great bear country in the same exact place for many years. It used to be commen to sit there and watch 5-6 bears on the site at one time. That place has been baited the past 3 years and has not even had a single hit. 5 years ago every bait I had was within 5 miles of my house and every hunter had a bear by the 2nd night. Now I am driving the pickups 20+ miles in 4 different directions and then taking the wheeler further and having less success with 1/2 the hunters.

I wish MN would not allow sows with cubs to be shot. I do not think that the cubs have a chance to live with out Mom. Most areas do not the high numbers of Timber wolves like we do. They will catch the cub on the ground or dig it out of it's den and kill it. Also these cubs do not have Mom to show them where the berries are at one time of year or where the acorns are at now. This cubs end up just waundering around lost and can not find natural foods so they go to where people are and eat the pie on the window sill. When the MN DNR says that we have too many "problem" bears I wish that they would realize that with every Mom killed we are creating more "juvenile delinquent" little bears. frown.gif

In any case it looks to me like this area has never had the bear numbers this low. My father and the "oldtimers" can not remember it ever being like this. I think the DNR's high bear numbers are more likely in areas with a lot of private land and less hunting pressure.

On a little bit more happy note Labs got his bear last night. A nice 300+ pound chocolate. We think it must have been retarded or suicidal for Labs to get it. grin.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think I can count the hits on our four baits on both hands. There have only been 4-8 bear registered in Blackduck this season. I think Kelly is correct about the amount of pressure in the woods. For us the Saturday of labor day was like sitting next to a 4wheeler motocross. And that was on both private and public ground. My friend in Onterio feels they lost alot of bear this past January with the mild temps. The bear came out of their dens and then were caught with the February/March cold snap. The other thing is I have never seen as many acorns for as long (mid August untill and through now).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well, hopefully things get turned around and like the walleyes on Red Lake the bears become plentiful again. Sad to know that people can legally harvest sows with cubs. Congrats on the #300 chocolate. That's a nice bear anywhere! cool.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

First off....who shoots sows with cubs? I know a lot of bear hunters, and not one of them would even think about taking a sow with cubs. I just don't think it happens much. I've never even shot a sow in my life.

Secondly I agree that bearhunting has become a harder game. Specifically when compared to Wisconsin. The obvious reasons are that we have way too many people hunting. If we restricted the number or hunters, I think we'd harvest more bears. The second thing that hurts bear hunting is the proliferation of 4-wheelers. Now every tom dick and harry can get a bait back in the woods without much work. It used to be only the guys that worked hard.

Personally I haven't had a downturn in my bear hunting. Sitings and bears taken have remained steady. I certainly have had to work much harder to get away from the crowds though.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Quote:

It's been getting slower and slower the past 5 years but this year is amazingly slow. I think it is real safe to say that the bear numbers are down 70% to 80% from what they were 5 years ago.


I'm going to have to disagree with this! I hunt in and around that area and there are more bear then ever. Sometimes they just are not on your bait. I had some nice pictures of 8 different bear, however, the weekend of opening it rained a lot and then the acorns fell, that is why bear hunting sucked this year. The bear are out there. Put up a camera and you'll see what i'm talking about.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't know if there is an abundance of bear by red lake or if the numbers are down. I do know that the 40 acres I own 3/4 of a mile from the south shore has bear on it. Last year we had many on the camera. This year our moultree deer feeder was completely destroyed along with some other things. I learned my lesson not to put up the deer feeder once they come out of hibernation. They sure are a nuisance.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Bdeanpete
      I want to give an honest review of Steve and north county auto. He saw my post on here of a fisherman in need and offered his service. I looked around and could have taken my hub to get repaired at multiple places closer to me than Crystal, but decided to give another fisherman a try.    This was a perfect experience.  He was willing to meet me outside of normal business hours to accommodate my schedule. The stitch up appears totally solid (double stitched) and Steve even warranteed the repair. The price was more than fair and he's a nice guy to boot.    I'd definitely recommend this place if you're in need of canvas repair. He does a bunch of other things for the open water fisherman as well.    My apologies if this somehow violates any rules on the forum (I never looked) but my experience was a good one and wanted to pass it along. 
    • RainyRat
      We did not go all the way out this weekend so I can't say for sure where 'most' were fishing.  Since you can literally go anywhere, there were no real "concentrations" of houses that I saw.  Everyone was spread out real nice except I did see quite a few houses fishing in closer to Pine, near the snowmobile trail, based on the distance (maybe a mile or mile and a half out?) I would guess they were "shallow" and not out to the basin.  Distance can be tough to judge so this is my approximation.   Some friends road sleds WAY north and were surprised that shortly after they set up a suburban came from the south and fished near them.  Like I was saying people are spread out.   Adrian's road now only goes out 11.5 vs. the 16 miles they were out a week ago.   Good Luck!
    • loadmaster
      Hey Jim do you guide for pout on Cass Lake and North Bay????
    • mrpike1973
      Was on the boat Sunday got a little further past the 49 bridge. Is the 22 landing opening up at all? Anyone know how much ice is even out there? I would think we made a little.
    • bturck
      Great posts again this year.  Always interesting, looking forward to crappie reports