Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
WildBill33

Options For A 12 Gauge Pump Action Shotgun

18 posts in this topic

Hey All,

Looking into a new pump action shotgun and still debating on what to go with i will be using it for waterfowl and deer hunting wondering what the best options are for my price range of 300-600 dollars i was thinking of maybe the benelli supernova or the browning bps any feedback would be greatly appreciated..

WildBill

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What ever you decide on brand or models you'll want a rifled barrel for deer and a vented rib barrel with choke tubes for ducks and upland birds. Buying both in a package will save you money.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Remington Wingmaster!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

We have both Wingmasters and Brownings in our household. Wife shoots the Wingmaster. Excellent shotgun, and it has more than stood the test of time. I shoot her gun from time to time and really like the fit and feel.

I mostly shoot the Browning BPS, (in 12 and 10 ga) and like them for a couple reasons. One - I shoot left handed, and the BPS has bottom eject and an ambidexterous safety. No shell casings flying past my eyes when I cycle the action. Two- the shell casings tend to stay in the blind or boat if reloading is a concern.

The Nova looks like a nice gun, too, though I have no experience with them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The 870 wingmaster too!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Personally I would go with the Remington 870 Express. It's the same as the wingmaster without all the pretty stuff on it, and way less expensive. I would take the money saved and put it into a good rifled deer barrel to go along with it. I would also go with the Super Mag (shoots 2 3/4 inch up to 3 1/2 inch shells) Just in case you ever go for Turkey or Geese. Just my opinion.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's not the prettiest gun, but I've had a benelli nova for about 6 years now and have yet to have an issue with it. I shoot trap league with it and run quite a few shells through it (and have had since owning it) and have absolutely no regrets.

marine_man

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have three 870's (four if you count the boy's youth model...) that should tell you what my vote is for. By the way, the one I currently have a smooth bore slug barrel on was bought used by my father when he returned from Korea in 1952!!! It still works flawlessly!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would have to recommend the 870 also. I had a Nova for a couple of years and although it was a great gun, it felt kind of cheap to me. I also tried finding a slug barrel for it, but the ones that were available a few years ago were more than the gun was when I bought it. There are now more companies making barrels for them so that may not be too big a deal. I have had an 870 for about 15 years and have never had a problem with it and have put quite a few rounds through it without any problems. I haven't shot the new supernova, but I think they did refine them a little and have the recoil reduction for when you are shooting heavy loads. If I remember right, last year they had the slug barrel combo's for the Nova also. I have never cared for the BPS, but not for any real particular reason, I just have never cared for the company. I think you will be happy with whatever you decide. My advice would be to go to the stores and see which one fits you best. Bring the gun up with your eyes closed just like you would when you were going to shoot at a bird. When you get the gun up, open your eyes and see if you are looking right down the rib. I have had better luck shooting the guns that I am looking down the rib when I open my eyes. Good luck with your purchase.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

For waterfowl you will want to go with something that can run 3.5" shells. Remingtons Super Magnum will fit that bill. I have a buddy with one of these it is really good for the 3 and 3.5 shells but every now and then with the lighter loads for trap it would kind of lock up on him. He would really have to pull to get it to eject.

I have shot Marine Mans nova. I will agree that it isn't pretty at all grin.gif but it shoots in any condition. With mud, rain, snow, sleet. It also doesn't have problems with any type of shell that I have seen him use. Benelli's are a quality gun nothing to be scared of with them.

If I were a pump guy I wouldn't think twice about getting a Benelli Nova.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I also have a nova..bought one when they first came out...have shot trap league & hunted with it...no complaints..great gun...has more feautres than a 870..cant go wrong with an 870...but im sold on the nova

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Why not get both?? I have shot a Benelli Nova for the past 5 years going after ducks, geese, and turkey. A reliable gun that shoots great through the rain, mud, and abuse. For deer, I considered getting a slug barrel for the Nova, but ended up getting an 870 with a slug barrel - couldn't be happier with the accuracy of this gun out to 100 yards. My 2 cents...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would also go for the 870,only I might think about a Hastings rifled barrel for deer hunting.I have a couple for 2 different shotguns along with the factory barrel.Only problem is the Hasting is a few more clams.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I’ve got 2 Rem 870 s and there’s no doubt these are a premium grade gun at a reasonable price. They will shoot under any condition and require basically no maintenance besides some basic cleaning.

2 years ago, I was in the same debate as you. I wanted to buy a new gun (mainly a 3.5” for waterfowl). I was in the air between a Benelli Nova and the Browning BPS. I liked the Nova’s mechanism for ejecting only the shell that’s in the chaimber, but I didn’t care much for the paint job. See I wanted a full camo gun and the Nova has more of an army pattern. Also, the nova seemed more shaky and rattley when you grab the stock. It seemed to have a lot of “play” and clanked while working the action.

I decided to go with the 12 g. Browing BPS 3.5” with the Shadow Grass full camo pattern. I forget what that paint is called, but when you hold it, it feels rubbery and kinda just grips your hands perfectly. I went with the 26” barrel since it’s lighter and easier to maneuver. I like the bottom eject much more than the side eject as well, and the safety on the Browning is “safer” in my eyes.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Tough to beat a 870.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ah, the "ford vs. chevy" debate of pump shotguns. smile.gif

I recently went through this same process as to which pump gun to buy. With all the choices out there: Remington, Mossberg, Benelli, Browning, Stoeger, or Winchester....and each one makes a good pump, you then have to go to what you exactly want in a gun and most importantly what fits best. Swing into one of the "Big" sporting goods stores and shoulder each one.

After shouldering each one and getting a feel for the guns....I ended up picking up a Winchester 1300 in the shadow grass pattern for waterfowl hunting. It doesn't have the 3 1/2 option, but then again...I have never needed that option and the majority of my family and friends with the 3 1/2 inch option rarely ever step up and use it. For me, with shorter arms.....the others seem to really stretch me out for the pump. The 870 is a rock solid gun...but it didn't fit me...therefore I would have hated shooting it.

Good luck in your choice!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

To keep your post on track:

Your question was Benelli supernova or the Browning bps. I have the bps for the left handed reason, great gun but the SOB kicks HARD!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have a Browning BPS Sportsman (my wife bought it for me) that I really like, very solid gun in my opinion, and still looks good, just like it came out of the box. I hunt mainly upland game, so I have the shortest barrel possible on it, and really like it. A lot lighter than my old Mossberg shotgun, but that one is still the "old stand-by".

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • RainyRat
      'Pout   The 'Pout bite has been great   Adrian's has made yet another road to the east of the 2 previous, now abandoned, roads.  The new road is a bit rough for my liking but take it slower and no problems.  The good part about it is that the little snow that is out there (maybe an inch or two) is rock hard and you can now drive anywhere you want.  I saw 1 ton diesel trucks pulling wheel houses across the white and I doubt anyone was even in 4 wheel drive, its just not needed.  We can all spread out, anywhere we want.   BTW, stay off the old plowed roads where the ice looks smooth.  Some of them had a foot or so of water on them before it cooled off again and as of yesterday they were not all frozen back down to the original ice. I saw one truck got a little surprise.  Again take it slow and pay attention and you can go anywhere.   Good luck with those 'pout!   RR    
    • jkrash
    • CigarGuy
      Del, it looks like the first time posters are coming after us!  I wasn't going to say anything else on this topic, but as long as Vermilion Boater called me out, I'll say a few more things and be done.  I've been a lake home owner up here for only 5 years , but I've been to The Landing numerous times over the last 5 years.  I've taken part in fancy 4-course meals, had the daily special and just a burger or a cocktail. Sat at the bar and Bs'd with the bartenders Justin and I think her name was Jesse and they were great.   I've been to (not really my favorite) The Crescent less than 10 times total!  I don't go to the lake to spend time in a bar, but once in a while, it's a nice change of pace.  When we have company, I'll usually bring them to The Landing, because the setting is hard to beat.  The service, meals have been great at times and not so great.  You never know if there going to be open all week, Thur-Sunday or Friday-Sunday!  I'm not giving my "drive bye" opinion of the place!  I've talked to locals, people working on my place, fishermen and read reviews here, FB, Trip Adviser and see that reviews are in-fact, all over the place. So, it's not my "narrow-minded" view!  I don't seek out opinions, they come up in conversation.  I'm glad you, your neighbors and friends enjoy it!  BTW, your vast knowledge of the competition, leads me to believe, you might have a vested interest in the place.  Ok, I'm done with this thread! 
    • Cliff Wagenbach
      I just came back from checking ice conditions on Big Bay. I found about 22 inches of good ice out there and very easy going! No real snow cover left, no slush, and smooth ice almost every where! Cliff
    • cookie129
      Well another game fish season has came to a end. The dnr will be having a meeting this week in Kellier to discuss the up and coming open water season.. I be leave our cabins are wide open with narly a date penciled in this summer including opener?
      Grab a cup of java because this is going to be a long blog.
      The first thing is what a great ending to another game fish season .
      The biggest thing and this come from my heart is" Thank you" to all my new and repeat customers . With out all of you I would not be able to enjoy working on such a grand lake. When that old timer Dave shared that with me I was in Awe. "Its a grand lake and it owes me nothing, nothing was his quote and boy did that stick. The walleye fishing this year could of been better. I'm all most to the point of calling them the elusive upper red lake walleye?
      Just like every season for 14 years now we have had great fishing, good fishing and poor fishing. I guess its the luck of the draw when you come up. We caught a couple,, we caught some and we caught a few over the season. The fishermen have become a little more tight lip about there walleye catches over the last couple years. Its so funny when You ask a fishermen how they did. The ponder and say oh we got a few? I've always been like how many is a few? Its always well we got 18? To me a few is 3, a couple is two and some can be 1 or more.
      The dnr will be releasing a summery of what's happening on the lake in the next upper red lake association news letter. If your interested in joining and becoming a member its 25 dollars a year or 50 if you want your business listed on there web site.
      I have a few gripes I want to share also. Some you will have to read between the lines.
      The first thing is Saturday night I was coming off of the lake on Hillmens highway. Buddy Hillmen is so dedicated to his road and there is no one prouder when it comes to maintaining a ice road.
      As I was coming on to the landing a big wheel house turned off the highway. I new right away they did not pay 10 dollars and there's a sign right there that says 10 dollars. I rolled down my window and he was like wow I did not know where to pay. Where do you pay? He had no problem finding the access but did not see the lights on in the bar with a few vehicles there? Give me a break.
      Kelly, Buddy Hillmens mechanic got 3 Thursday night pulling in. If you can not afford 10 dollars a day for your wheel house ? I personally think wheel houses should have to pay more?
      I also had a few customers that tried to slide by this year and its very frustrating . The deal I have with buddy hillmen is I can use his access and in turn my customers have to pay 10 dollars a day. I'm on call 24 hours a day for any ice road work ,plowing, bridging, etc. Over the years I have been accused of fishing where some one was going to go? fishing on some ones way points? Cutting someone off. Every year its something and again this year was no exception? Any side roads I personally plow to my houses are always open. Do I want fishermen by my houses? Nope. My customers pay good money and I do not want them looking out the picture windows and seeing a wheel house 30 yards away. There is always plenty of room where I plow as I'm the rouge plower. I have no problem plowing out a driveway for a wheel house as it helps pay for my equipment as it takes a beating out there.
      Its been a crazy season and its not over for me as I again chase the elusive yet still catchable upper red lake crappie. to be continued