Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Hoytmystic

Beginner?

5 posts in this topic

Hey guys, I am looking forward to getting a new hunting dog. I have a few questions. I hunt everthing from grouse to pheasant to ducks and geese. I live in northern minnesota so I will most likely be hunting grouse the most. I like the idea of a pointer, but I am open to any ideas. I don't know what breed to buy, books to read, movies to watch, or when to buy a dog. Some good people to talk to. Please help me with my decisions.

Thanks,

Kyle

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Please go slow. Listen to the advice you get. Keep in mind you will have your new pal maybe 10-15 years. Lots of fun, pleasure and joy and some annoyance, pain and trouble. For three months in the fall you'll love having the dog. But how about the other nine months? Have the time? Does wife enjoy pets? neighbors to conside? Remember a couple hundred dollars a year (minimum) for vets bills. Is this the right time? Can I wait a season maybe?

We all owe a real obligation to our canine pals. I am NOT trying to discourage you Kyle, just offering food for thought.

Oh....breed. A BLACK Labrador. HA!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

join navhda, thats what I did. Get to experience several different breeds. Get first hand knowledge from several different breeders and trainers.

I was in your shoes not too long ago, and my dog and I definately wouldnt be where we are today without being in Navhda.

You cant go wrong researching and doing lots of reading. Its a big decision. Go slow take your time and most of all have fun.

good luck on your search!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I tried to hunt over as many different breeds as possible. All for grouse. I decided on a Setter and asked around about a good breeder. Most of the people I talked to pointed in the same direction and I went to whom I believe to be one of the top setter breeders in the country. I initially wanted to get an English Setter, but met and got to know some of his Red Setters and fell in love with the breed. I now have three of them and will probably run a litter through one of my females next spring.

Picking a breed is a tough decision. Keep an open mind. One thing I will suggest to be very aware of are the blood lines. Champion lines are going to give you a much better chance at getting a great dog. It might cost you a little more $$, but it WILL be worth it in the long run. Someone commented about having this dog for the next 10+ years.

Another thing you may want to consider is getting a pup that is a little older. Maybe even a "Started" pup. This way you will get a much better idea of what you are getting. That is what I did with my first. She was about 6 months when I got her. I hunted her on grouse at 9 months and she pointed at least 25 birds.

Yet another thing to consider. In my opinion (and probably in most peoples opinions) the females mature faster. This made it easier for me to train my girls. My male is over a year and it is taking longer for him to "get it". The girls are softer though.

Finally...When you find a breed/breeder you like. Ask to see the pup or dog on birds. Maybe even see the parents work birds. Get some time with the parents and the pups before you make your decision. If a breeder will not put the pup or parents on birds for you I would suggest finding one that will.

My 2 cents... If you are interested in Setters. Let me or Setter Guy know.

I will be hunting my dogs up around Nashwauk in early Oct, and around Northhome in later Oct.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

For a good book, I recommend picking up a copy of the sporting dog encyclopedia. It's a great hard copy with lots of pics and great detailed descriptions of all hunting breeds. I've owned brittanies all my life, and highly recommend them for great all around hunting dogs, although there are many to choose from. I prefer a pointing breed to a flusher in grouse woods, although I spoke with a breeder of springer spaniels up by Brainerd that hunts a lot of grouse and woodcock with his dogs.

As for different breeds though, there are many factors to consider. What size are you looking for? What type of coat? If you want a longer coat with a medium to large dog, I'd look at the Brittany, English Setter, Red Setter, Wirehaired Pointing Griffon. The Griffon may be the most hearty if you're planning on hunting ducks and geese late in the season up north. They're great retrievers too. Also look to the German Shorthair for an all around great hunting dog. The Vizsla and Weimaraner are supposed to be great dogs to for grouse, typically working closer and slower in the bigger woods. With these two breeds, make sure you talk to breeders that hunt. Also, I've been looking into the Pudelpointer a bit lately. It seems to be a great all around hunting dog. There's a breeder up north of the cities on 35. Hope this helps a little.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • CigarGuy
      Cook, MN facebook page has a picture and info on it.  I don't know how to post a link, but here's the post-minus the photo.   The combination of record mild temperatures in late February and more seasonable temperatures in early March, has prompted dramatic ice movement on Lake Vermilion.... The south shore of Birch Point, which faces Big Bay, has seen some of the most extensive damage, as the ice has twisted lift docks, damaged boat houses, downed trees, and rearranged sizeable chunks of shoreline. Only a handful of docks along the heavily-developed lakeshore have so far escaped damage from the ice. Many docks have been damaged beyond repair. The pressure of expanding ice is typically relieved out in the lake, where large pressure ridges often form. But those ridges didn’t form as usual this year, and that left the shorelines vulnerable to the immense power of expanding ice. Lake property owners are likely to be shocked when they arrive back at their cabins and lake homes later this year. And the cost of repairs could be especially painful since, in many cases, the damage is likely not covered by insurance. “It will depend on their individual policies,” said Donna Mosher, with the Tower-Soudan Agency, which serves many Lake Vermilion property owners. She said standard insurance policies typically don’t cover ice movement, which can be a frequent source of property damage in areas where thick ice builds up in winter. Many property owners on Vermilion and other larger area lakes have turned to lift-out docks to minimize their risk of damage, but this year’s unusual conditions are leaving many of those docks damaged or destroyed as well. Some property owners do obtain insurance that includes a specific schedule or rider to cover more expensive docks, according to Mosher, but that’s usually the exception rather than the rule. “I’ve had to tell people ‘no’ already,” said Mosher. “It’s unfortunate.”
    • T-water
      The good news is you can't lose!  Let us know what you decide.
    • tacklejunkie
          Downriggers are not necessary but if you use them this time of year, don't go down  deep. I used to use boards but they were more complicated for others on my boat to use so it's small dipseys off the side or a clean line straight back. Spoons and sticks work well this time of year   Shallow and high. One year, I ran DR in the spring with the counter reading 6 feet.  
    • Musky hunter 82
      No problem, I always try to help out another fisherman whenever I can.  Squarebill crankbaits 12# fluoro would be good, but if you're talking lipless crankbaits I'd run that on 17# as well.  Here's how I have my baitcasters setup:   6'6" MH - 50# braid (Swim jigs, and topwater frogs) 7' MH - 15# mono with a  18" - 17# fluoro leader (Spinnerbaits/Chatterbaits) 7' MH - 17# fluoro (Jigs, Lipless Crankbaits) 7' M - 12# fluoro (Squarebill crankbaits)   Worms, tubes, jerkbaits and topwater poppers I use a spinning rod
    • Big Country
        Jim, If ya get out give Frank or me a call on the cellular device.  We can compare notes.  Not much looking forward to it.  Heard there was a winter kill on the pond this year   BC