Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

  • RECEIVE THE GIFTS MEMBERS SHARE WITH YOU HERE...THEN...CREATE SOMETHING TO ENCHANT OTHERS THAT YOU WANT TO SHARE

    You know what we all love...

    When you enchant people, you fill them with delight and yourself in return. Have Fun!!!

Sign in to follow this  
Cicada

Rate Manny as a complete baseball player.

Recommended Posts

Cicada

I work with a high school kid that thinks Manny is the best ever. I keep telling him to find another idol. Tell me what you think of Manny as a COMPLETE baseball player. I rate him a 1.5 tops.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
buzzsaw

I'm with you, Manny is a clubhouse cancer.....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Spinner1

One of the best hitters currently in the game. One error this year. Would be one of the stars on any team in MLB. Personality definitely detracts as an overall player/person. Comes off as a very selfish person to me.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Cicada

The one error is deceiving. Hard to mess up what you don't go after. Saw highlights a couple of weeks ago where he kicked a couple of balls and just pointed at the ball so the center fielder could go get it for him. Embasrrassment to the game, period.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Reynolds

I will never forget in particular one of his mental lapses in the outfield. I believe a ball was hit to deep centerfield and was being fielded by Damon. Manny was somewhere in between Damon and the cutoff man. So Damon attempts to throw the ball to the cutoff only to have Manny dive to catch the throw, and then he proceeds to throw the ball to the cutoff man himself who is about 30ft away. What was he thinking??? confused.gif I don't believe I've ever heard of another outfielder cutting a ball.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
PierBridge

Your friend is a lot closer to reality then you are....to rate Manny Ramirez a 1.5 is ridiculous.......he could be the best hitter in the game, certainly one of the best....

I agree he's not very good defensively.....

I would also disagree he is a clubhouse cancer....I think he's extremely immature and has done some dumb things... he reminds me of a freshmen in high school....he's very well liked by his teammates....

I give him 9.5 as Major league ball player... grin.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Cicada

If he were a freshman in high school, they would bench him for all his best qualities. 1.Stupid 2.Selfish. 3.Childish. Can you give someone a 9.5 just bacause he can hit the ball? To me that's not a complete player. They talk about a five tool player. This guy has one tool.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Maximum12

Cicada, you're letting your dislike of a (Contact Us Please) color your logic.

Manny hits for average, power, & in the clutch. And he may be an *sshole, but his team has a World Series banner with that "cancer" on their team.

Is he sometime embarassing? Yup. Childish? Yup. Jerkish? Yup. But name me a single team who wouldn't jump at the chance to put Manny in their four-hole. You can't because there isn't one. If you want to give him a 1.5 for attitude, fine, go ahead. But as a ballplayer? Not even close.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
fisherman

I give him 9.5 as Major league ball player... grin.gif


That's where I'd rank him. He's also an above average fielder. He could be much better if he tried... He is one of the BEST PLAYERS in the game.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Cicada

My logic:

He's a one tool player out of five tools. That's 20% or a 2. Deduct .5 because he has David Ortiz hitting in front of him and probably wouldn't be as effective anywhere else. I'll stick with 1.5. I know I'm harsh but I think I'm fair. smirk.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
genegodawa

As to defense, I will say he is lucky to have that short porch behind him but I do believe he plays a very adequate OF. Hustle/attitude? - could be better but I wouldn't give up his power for those 2 traits. Overpaid? As an all-around, for sure. He sure is dangerous though and has been every yr. Historically he is up there with the best, but best ever, I don't think so. He is a darn good hitter for sure. You can name lots of guys who are as good all-around players, but for being dangerous at the plate - Manny is really up there so I for one would love to have him hittin' in front of anybody here in Wrigley.

I would normally say it would depend on how much I gotta pay them and who their supporting teammates are, but In my mind, him and ARod and Junior rank up there as guys you would love to have on your team.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Spinner1

"He's a one tool player out of five tools."

Cicada

Give us your assessment of each of the five tools, and back them up with some numbers. Otherwise you are just trashing him because you don't like him. BTW, I think he should be banned from All-Star Ballots for dissing the fans. But there is a reason he is one of the top vote getters. It's either because he puts up great numbers, or he is just popular with fans. Neither of those options supports your premise. Just go ahead and buy the kid a Manny bobblehead and tell him you were wrong. smile.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
fisherman

Quote:

My logic:

He's a one tool player out of five tools. That's 20% or a 2. Deduct .5 because he has David Ortiz hitting in front of him and probably wouldn't be as effective anywhere else. I'll stick with 1.5. I know I'm harsh but I think I'm fair.
smirk.gif


What the heck does it matter that David Ortiz hits in front of him? smirk.gif Manny has noone protecting him. If it were the other way in the batting order. I think Manny would probably have better stats then Ortiz.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
bassNspear

Manny is one of the best hitters in the game. He has a problem in the outfield. He might be able to play the game at a high level, but as a complete ball player, i would rank him 7.5. I dont like his skills away from the plate.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Cicada

Ok, I messed up. I had one of the five tools wrong. I thought there was only one hitting tool, there are two. They are:

1. Hitting for average. He's at .326, very good

2. Hitting for power. .628 slugging pct, very good

3. Running speed. Not sure, he doesn't choose to run.

4. Arm Strength. Has 7 assists, I had trouble separating left fielders on MLB.com. Probably could be better if he ran for any balls.

5. Fielding ability. One error in 118 games. You can't boot something you don't go after.

He's a great hitter, not a great, or even good complete player.

If he were traded to the Twins, would I change my mind? Yes, I would no longer follow the Twins. If I had a kid and he thought giving so little effort was worthy of the kind of worship Manny gets, I'd have to consider myself to be void of any parental skills. I'd rather someone value hard work, resect for the game, your teammates, and your fans. Being I was wrong with the five tool thing, I had to reconsider the 1.5 rating. I'll give him 2.5. grin.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
PierBridge

You sound like a politician backed into a corner......you LOSE.... grin.gif

Send me the kids address I'll send him the jersey you owe him..... grin.gif

Thanks, I forgot how strong his arm is... I'm upgrading him to a 9.7 as Major League Player...... shocked.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
bassNspear

He cant play the field. Hes one of the best hitters in the game. Its proven, Look at big papa stats, that should tell u right there.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
PierBridge

WOW..I just did some research there is nobody playing the game to today that's been a better hitter then Ramirez the last 12 years....he blows A-Rod out of the water......unreal stat's.....talk about consistency.

9.7 Manny

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Spinner1

Wow Pier, best hitter in 12 years? Even Albert? That's just amazing shocked.gif

I'm going with a 9.7 too. I'd go 9.8 if he wasn't such a butthead about the All-Star game. smile.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
bassNspear

Hes great hitter, bad fielder

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
PierBridge

Quote:

Wow Pier, best hitter in 12 years? Even Albert? That's just amazing
shocked.gif


Over the last 12 years......do you really think Albert Belle is a better hitter?...... grin.gifwink.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Spinner1

Nope Pier, I was referring to Pujols over a shorter time period. I figured Manny was near the top over the past ten or so, but was surpised to hear he is actually #1.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
juggs

His offense and defense are almost opposites. I've seen him look pretty embarrasing in the field. Can't argue with his bat, though. He's about as good as they come.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
nofishfisherman

as a complete player I wouldn't rank him very high at all.

Offesive= Stud

Defensize= Embarassment

Attitude= Chump

That doesn't make for a very all around player. He was built for the DH role.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
PierBridge

Quote:

Nope Pier, I was referring to Pujols


I knew who you were talking about... shocked.gifgrin.gif

Maybe you guy's are right, Denny Hocking was good fielder and probably a better all around player........ grin.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  



  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • DonBo
      Toying with the idea of heading up there Saturday morning. Only been there a couple times, never on the opener.
    • JBMasterAngler
      Anyone go out on the opener? I usually wait a week before heading up there, so curious to hear some ice/fishing reports.
    • Roscoe010
      Did any of you check out the pits for winter trout opener last weekend? Thanks!
    • leech~~
      Well hopefully you can still get out with Dad another weekend yet this winter. Building memories are things that last.
    • AaronTC05
      I upgraded from my Little Buddy to a Portable Buddy (not a Big Buddy which seemed like over kill for a 2-3 man portable).  I figured that would work best for my needs.  Turns out I was right.  The heater warmed my 949i enough that I could fish with my gloves off which was nice.  I definitely noticed though as soon as a tank ran out, it got chilly quick since I had a few holes open to allow some fresh air in. My dad chickened out since he would be coming from WI and it was snowing over there still the roads were slick (as they were here also).  Also made sense since we didn't know how well the shack would stay warm.  So I stayed close to home.  I was going to head to Cedar Lake near New Prague since it appears to have a healthy pan fish population to keep me entertained, but the guy I talked to at Prior Lake Bait & Tackle said Prior was a better bet, so I took his advice.  I started fishing about 10 am after finding a spot and getting setup in about 20 FOW in the basin away from the crowds.  I only managed to connect on a few dink perch, one that was borderline keeper size that I threw back just before heading home about 5:30.  I didn't mark a single suspended fish in my spot.  I drilled some holes in various depths not far from my shack but still didn't find any marks and got cold and headed back into my warm shack. I had a fathead on a tip up in case a hungry walleye came by but had no takers.  A tip I heard recently was to hook them through the butt and out the side, which makes them sort of upside down which they hate so they continue to struggle and move in the water the whole time trying to right them selves.  I dropped by camera down and watched this and it seemed to work to keep it moving, although I didn't catch anything so who knows if the fish actually like it.
    • cookie129
      Not sure what's going on  but I'm still loosing track of days. Bouncing around in the red baron, checking on customers ,enjoying the football game at Hillmens Tall tale Tavern man was that fun, getting a few games of pool in last night to practice for my next match. Playing a round of texas hold em with the wells fargo boys in north dakota, visiting with all the customers, moving houses, plowing new roads, plowing old roads, battling mother nature, the winds were howling  sunday night after another small dumping of snow.
       I wrote in my note book on Wednesday the 17th CLOSED.
       The fishing has been crazy good? Not sure what's that all about but will take it as its so nice to see everyone catching more then a  few.
       Stevejames won my giveaway on Minnesota Outdoorsman, I have been giving a way a free night as a prize on there fishing challenge for a few years. He arrived Friday for old Minnesota with his buddy Mike and there 2 boys Nolan and Ayden. They rented one day so they were here for 2 nights and did real well. I got a great pic of there stringer of fish, It was a treat seeing the kids  outside playing ,enjoying the great outdoors.
       Terry, Sarha ,Carl and Kenny were in florida for 3 nights. They also had a grand time on a grand lake. This was there third year with me. They said they will be back again next year if I will have them? There such nice people, I was able to visit off and on wth them as they fed me breakfast burritos , French dips after the Viking game. Carl got 4 deer  so they also brought me a care package of venison. I'm making my coleslaw for them next year and may treat them to a night of my cooking to boot. I mentioned to Sarah the first day she should tie a string to her fishing pole? OOPs darn if it did not go down a hole.
       Scott the wells fargo boys have also did well, they went to Westwind for fish and the Viking game and also had a hoot. Then when they got back to the house Scott got treated to "yes a elusive yet still catchable upper red lake crappie" A beautiful 14 a half inch masterpiece. Another great group of guys and they got my 10 dollars last night. I played a little to loose and lost all my chips.
       Mel, Dan and Dane arrived for old Minnesota sunday, I told Dan get a line down first thing. Before they were unpacked they had 2  in the bucket. Yesterday Dane was catching fish on the rattle wheel from the top bunk. They enjoyed Fish for dinner last night as Mel is a master chef, she also fed me hodgepodge for breakfast yesterday. They have been coming up here for 14 years summer and winter.
       Snowbear Josh headed home for a couple days so I'm taking care of a couple of his guest and they were slaying the fish the last two days.
       I just talked to Jarred and his buddie Jim they were in montana last night and got there 8.
       Angie and here hubbie and there friends were in montana sunday.  I think they ended up with 9 with there friends, The kids fished in one of Joshes 2 man houses and there friends went home sunday eve,.
        Mother nature has been kicking my but. Yesterday I plowed off and on all day, cleaning up the drifts. Buddy Hillmens Highway is again in great shape. I expect we will be making more main roads in the next day or two.
       I did here form Brandon I had set up in a secret spot and they also did real well Friday eve,
      Ken and his buddies also did well where I plowed them a spot. Throwing darts and hitting bulls eyes feel good. Well its past my starting time. we start at 9, so again its time to check the fluids and hit the ice on such a Grand lake that owes us nothing! Nothing!  
    • leech~~
      Needle valve is sticking open or bad diaphragm.
    • sparetime
      Seems to be flooding out.  I have pulled the plug after trying to restart and its wet, so yes flooding out. 
    • Surface Tension
      After it dies pull the spark plug. Is it wet or is it dry. 
    • leech~~
      oilandwater Welcome to the forum.  Thanks for the report. Any Loopers in the mix with the Coho's? 
  • Share & Have Fun