Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Knute78

Muzzleloader Scopes and Regular Fire Arms Season

23 posts in this topic

I don't want to debate the ethics and use of muzzleloaders with scopes on them. I just have a question regarding the use of muzzleloaders and scopes during the regular firearm (shotgun/rifle)season to settle a debate my friend and I are having. I will not mention which side of the debate I am on.

Can scopes be used on muzzleloaders during the regular fire arm (shotgun/rifle) season in MN?

Thanks for any and all responses.

Chad

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yes, Scopes are allowed during the regular firearms season on muzzleloaders. Open sights only during the designated muzzleloaders season.

JEV

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Agree, scopes are a-ok in the regular firearm season.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

3rd that. Scopes allowed during regular gun season, not allowed unless by special medical permit during the muzzleloader only season.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks guys, that solves it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well, I 4th that if it matters.

100% legal during regular firearms season.

Take it off for ML season though. Simple as that.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Now that it's solved, do we get to hear what side of the argument you were on wink.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What is the reasoning behind not putting scopes on muzzleloaders? I don't know why it would hurt the hunting any. I just think there would be less wounded deer if scopes were alowed.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I was on the side that agrees that they are perfectly legal with scopes during the regular gun season. I am not completely sure how I feel about the scope issue during the actual muzzleloader season. I'll just stay within the laws as they are now and be happy with it. If I am in the woods and hunting legally I am happy.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

No, there will be more. Scopes are legal during the regular season because so called hunters are lobbing 12 gauge sluggs at 45 degree angles and shooting white horses with riders on them with the excuse that they thought they were shooting at a deer. It happened a couple of years ago! If you can not make a clean shot with open sights from 20-40 yrds. hunt the regular season. I do not think that extending the free for all into mzzl. season will do anything other than have a bunch of deer die slowly from infection from leg wounds tossed out from hunters taking shots that were well beyond the range of the weapon.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is exactly where I did not want this post to go.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

But that is your opinion and I do respect that.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Accidents happen too often but the old fart shooting a horse didn't have anything to do with the scope/no scope question

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think the reason they don't allow scopes during the muzzle season is to keep it more of a primitive weapon. That is the whole point of the muzzle season, to offer a challenge to hunters where you only get one shot with open sites. I agree the kill rate would be better with a scope on muzzleloaders but just because you have the ability to kill out to 150 yards doesn't mean you should do it with open sites. Besides, I like the fact that you have to challenge yourself and only take the shots you know you can make to kill a deer.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Xedge, I could not agree with you more.

A person needs to know their own personal limits when hunting with whatever weapon they choose, scope or not. Clean safe kills should always be the #1 priority when deciding to take an animal.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Nicely put Xedge. I couldn't agree more.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

During Regular Firearms season scopes are allowed on whatever legal weapon you decide to take with you to the field.

I don't think that incident with the guy shooting that horse had anything to do with whether their was a scope on that gun or not. I don't know for certain but I kind of remember that the story made it sound like he had a regular shotgun he was shooting slugs out of. I didn't think it was a scoped gun. I don't know for certain though.

Hunter's can wound animals by taking to long a shot with iron sights the same as they can by taking to long a shot with a scope. It's having the common sense not to shoot that makes the difference.

I like the idea of the new headlamps that deer can't see. I can think of 2 incidents I know of from last year that if they had been walking to their stand wearing one of those green headlamps they would have lived.

Ryan

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree that the purpose of having a muzzleloader season is not for the purpose of taking more deer but to offer a more pristine hunting experience. After all, if you are merely just hunting with black powder and not interested in the atmosphere, you can use it during the regular firearms season.

Also, even though the orginal poster expressed the intention of this thread was not to go down this route, the original poster's questions were ansered and then the thread took a new turn. Whether a new thread is started or this one continues, I don't see any difference. In either case, I do think it could evolve into an interesting exchange of viewpoints.

Bob

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Though I know this is yet another turn in this thread, I still feel compelled to comment. I have noticed several posts containing the word "weapon" describing a firearm. As a MN Firearm Safety Instructor this is one topic we try to instill in youngsters from day one. The word "weapon" is not to be used to describe a firearm in the instance of hunting and shooting sports. Maybe if this could become common language for adults children will learn early the difference in a weapon and a firearm. I see the difference from a law enforcement and military standpoint because firearms are used differently in their line of work. So...as ethical hunters working to protect the sports we love please try to use the terminology in its correct meaning! sorry just an opinion!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

BobT

I didn't mid the thread taking this new turn. I just know I have read similar fourms about muzzleloading in years past that got very heated and I'll just say "boarderline" in conversation. I like debates about issues like this when they are done respectively and both sides of an argument can be heard without attacking peoples individual selves. I prefer to hear a debates about the issues not, the what ifs, and the I know a guy who said that he saw, etc... I like straight facts and opinions.

I agree that the muzzleloader season should be a more "pristine GUN hunting experienc", and if that means I cannot use a scope during muzzleloader season I am fine with that. There are so many seasons and options out there and that is why I originally asked the question if scopes were legal on muzzleloader during the regular firearms season. They are, and now I know I have that option if I choose to use it.

Anyways, gun season is too far off at the moment, I am just going to keep practicing with my bow, and cannot wait to get into the woods and enjoy the quiet solitude of mother nature bow in hand.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I like your response and agree. To me it is as simple as not bringing a knife to a gunfight. Both are weapons, so is a sharpened end of a tooth brush. There has to be a line drawn. If I can't make a fatal shot without any sights at all at 20-30yrs I will watch canned hunts on tv. If you can not do it anymore don't.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

At the onset, separation of these two terms seems a little...well...petty but after giving it more thought I can see your point and agree it is a good one. One way this is important is that the anti-gun proponents like to use this term when describing firearms and for good reason. It instills the idea in others that a firearm is always a weapon but in reality this is by far the least used purpose of a firearm.

Good point!

Bob

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks Bob, I agree..before I ever bacame a FAS instructor, I would have felt very similar to most hunters in the sense that calling a firearm a weapon made no difference to me, but after time and thought you see the point. Most of the anti's use this term and just giggle every time we as sportsmen use the term, it only fuels there cause. I guess it's just a little thing many individuals can do to protect our right to own firearms in America.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • fishingstar
      I use a big zip tie that will slide on and off.
    • OhioVike
      Nice catch Cliff. Were you rigging or bobbering?
    • hayseed
      Probably not what your wanting to hear,  but I bit the bullet for an LX High speed transducer a couple years ago for my LX-6. Run it a couple times before removing it from my boat and going with a Lowrance. I found that on plane I frequently lost sonar and hard to see in bright sun. Hard to eliminate the excess noise as well. Ended up taking a real hard beating on getting rid of it also. Just my opinion, but I recommend checking out the Garmin Strikers or comparable Lowrance instead for the money. Love my LX for the ice, but it will remain my ice unit. 
    • ZachD
      How did you do?
    • ZachD
      So I am torn I want to put a graph in my smaller boat.. I love my lx 6 flasher and am thinking about getting the high speed transducer for it and just going with that but I don't get why they charge $199 for it when bird and lowrance ducers are far less   I almost pulled the trigger on the lowrance hook 4 with down scan and chart plotter at gander for $179  I don't care about the chart plotter really as I have a big hand held gps that I use in that boat and that screen is larger than the hook 4 when you have it split plotter and graph they only had the display model left and wouldn't go lower price so I passed   If I can find the hook 4 at another gander that doesn't have the chart plotter for cheaper I may go with that   Does any one have experience with the lx on open water I hear it is at par with an lowrance elite 5 I am kind of wanting to go with that but don't know   What would you do run the lx open water or go with hook 4 with down scan  
    • bmc
      We survived our trip!  LOL   Fishing was steady.   We caught 30 walleyes in 3 days of fishing.  Usually fished from 11 am to 4 pm.  The 'eyes were running small, lots of 11 to 13 3/4" fish, but we did get 3 keepers.  We also kept a few nice perch and crappies.  We also caught a few snake northerns.   Jigging w/ chubs produced the best, but I did catch a few 'eyes on the crawler lindy rig combo.  Mid lake structure and underwater points off of islands all produced fish.  Mayflys were hatching, but the fish were still hungry. I did catch a 4-5 lb channel cat in the Savanna River one evening.   We stayed in the south loop of the Army Corp campground.  We liked that we were w/in about 30 yds of our boat which we kept at the dock.  The river on the north side of us and the lake on the south side offered a nice breeze to keep things cool and the bugs away for the most part.  Con's were the campsites are small and were too close together.  Also no turn around at the end of the south loop road.  The north loop was beautiful, spacious campsites, but surrounded by swamp and we heard the skeeters were bad at dusk.  Definitely want some thermacells or a screen tent to enjoy the evening by the sounds of things.  Also the docks aren't close/in view of the campsites.   We would definitely stay there again, on the north loop, in May or Sept. after the skeeters have died down a bit.   Staff was friendly, shower houses were nice, boat landings were nice.     Brian
    • MedicineMan
      Went out Thursday for a few hours. Caught a 28" Walleye along with a handful of nice sized Bass.
    • knoppers
      thanks for the report.
    • JBMasterAngler
    • JBMasterAngler
      Just got back from our 34th annual Grand Marais trip. Weather, and how bad it was, was the theme. At one point or another, it rained every single day we were there! The wind was miserable he last couple days as well. Really affected our fishing plans, as we had to cancel out on some of our normal lakes, and fish some less than desirable backup lakes.   As per tradition, we left in the middle of the night and pulled up to the Lester River just a few minutes before sunrise. Didn't catch anything there. Also got skunked at the Talmadge and French rivers. I got free admission at Tom's logging camp on account it was Father's Day  and as always, kids had fun feeding the animals. I did catch a few little rainbows out of sucker, knife, and Stewart rivers. Had our traditional "fisherman's breakfast" at McDonalds in Two Harbors. We stopped at the silver creek tunnel, and that was the first time I've been at the overlook since it was actually part of the highway back in '94. We rolled into Grand Marais at about 3:30 and had to wait out a rain storm before putting the boat out on Kimball Lake. We lost several trout, and in the end, only my 6 year old son caught 2 rainbows.   Monday we fished Greenwood Lake, and as was the case with my 2 older kids, my 3 year old daughter caught her very first fish here...a smallmouth bass! Between all of us, we caught about 130 bass, all of which were pretty small. Unfortunately no lake trout. However, a big surprise occurred...while casting for bass, I caught a herring! Then a few minutes later, my son caught one also! Never would have guessed I'd ever catch one in the summer, let alone 2!   Fished a "secret lake" on Tuesday and caught quite a few northerns. They were all either 5 pounds, or 6 inches long, nothing in between. My son caught an 8 pound, 33 incher, which ended up being the biggest fish of the trip. We was screaming, and excited, and wanted me to take his fishing pole. But after about 10 minutes he finally got it in so I could net it. He's still bragging about it. My 3 year old also caught her 2nd ever fish, a perch, which ended up being the only one of the trip.   Went up to Saganaga on Wednesday. I spent I don't know how many hours trying to catch lake trout, but didn't find any!  Finally gave up and ventured deep into red rock bay for the first time ever. Really nice back there, wish I would've went there first. Fishing was ok, considering the weather was starting to get bad. Caught the biggest bass of the trip, a hair over 18 inches. On the drive back we seen a bear. Ironically it was walking down the road to black bear lodge at Poplar Lake.   Biggest disappointment came on Thursday. The plan was to fish both Hungry Jack and West Bearskin lakes. The wind was terrible, and coming straight from the west. Had hungry jack not had the reputation as a big bass producer, I wouldn't have went here. Unfortunately the big bass weren't around, nor any bass for that matter. Only caught 4 small bass. Kids caught about a dozen or so sunnies from the dock at the resort, some of which were decent size. We didn't even bother with bearskin. There's no way we would be able to launch our boats in that wind. We went to Loon Lake instead. In the limited time we were there, we caught about 30 tiny bass. My 9 year old daughter also caught her first rock bass. I tried for lakers, and marked a lot of them, but didn't catch any.    So since we didn't fish West Bearskin as planned, we penciled it in for Friday. Knowing the weather was going to be bad, we picked Poplar Lake as our backup. I drove up to Mayhew Lake to start, because I wanted to check out the launch. I was able to get my boat down the launch, but it was a real tight fit. Nice little lake. We saw a mommy moose with 2 babies laying right on the shoreline. I got sick of trolling, so I decided to cast cranks along the drop offs of the one small stretch of shoreline that was out of the wind (relatively speaking). Hooked into a big fish! Got excited because I thought I finally had a lake trout! It was a northern!  never thought I'd be disappointed in catching a 5.5 pound pike, but that's what I was. Didn't bother going to Bearskin, as I knew the wind was too bad again. Went to Poplar, which is a lake I do not like! As is typical, the fishing was no good! He weather was bi polar! It would be bright and sunny, then rain for 20 minutes. Did that the whole rest of the day! Only caught 1 little pike and  1 little bass. Got excited for a minute, as whitefish started surfacing around my boat in the evening. I was hoping I could catch 1 or 2, but nope!    Saturday we were supposed to fish Two Island for a few hours before going home. But it was pouring rain. We didn't even bother driving around to different boat launches. So the trip ended on a sour note, but we still had lots of fun, seen a moose, had our donuts (I highly recommend the bacon maple longjohn by the way), and went to Sven & Ole's. I was going to go camping in Ely in July, but I think we'll come back to Grand Marais instead, and try to make up for what we missed out on due to the weather. IMG_6122.MOV