Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
certified jumbo

What size buck do you shoot???

80 posts in this topic

Just curious what everybodys personal thoughts are on what you shoot for bucks??? I personally believe its up to the individual on what they want to shoot, trophies are different for everybody and thats perfectly ok. For me, I now wait for bucks over 110 inches, generally where I live I find that to be a 3.5 year old deer. What are your thoughts???

Also, I have some great cam. pics, but I can't figure out how to send them, would someone want to send them for me??

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

With the area we hunt we have second crack at any deer. I have no problem with taking a doe and new kids anything with antlers but I try to let any thing that looks like a first year rack go. I know that does not sound like much but we have such pressure here that if a buck can make it past the first year the next time ANYONE probally sees him and is able to get a shot he is a 3 year buck. The second year racks just do not exist. I have about 8 bucks under my belt and all but two are atleast third year racks and one is a fourth year. The two first year racks are my fist bucks. One with bow one with slug gun.

As stated every deer should be a trophy or you might as well quit hunting.

Froggy

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Anything under eight gets let go.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The smaller, the tastier. I like fawns; could careless for antlers.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree with you on the fawns, I always take 2-3 with my bow. They are very good eating and they generally provide you with lots of shot opportunities.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am holding out for the monster this year as i have 5 or so that are ten or better picked out. usually i let anything under 8 walk and those 8's have to be big. I have 3 and half months with the all season license so i wait and shoot does till i get my buck. Hopefully this year he is a 12 and very wide and tall. How wide do you think they are when the look wider than there butt. He also was very big bodied as he made the 10 pointers with him look kinda dinky.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm still looking for that big rack you know wall hanger 8point or better but will settle for does because no matter how long you boil them horns they just dont taste so good. I've shot spikes thur basket 8s and I'm not ashamed of it. Just getting to see deer can be trophy like.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I decided to change the title a little bit so we dont have to listen to the old "horns dont taste good, so who cares" responses... grin.gif

Seriously, if I have the bow in hand, my standards are lower. I have not harvested a buck with antlers, so if I see a 6 pt in range, I will probably take it. Probably....

I have not harvested a buck with antlers while holding the muzzleloader. I would settle for a small 8ish point rack with that. But that depends. Is it the last day of the ML season? I might stoop to a 6 pt.

No forkees with bow or ML for me though. That much I know.

With the rifle, its got to have minimum 8 pts, and at least ear width and some tine length or decent mass.

Just me, and my goals. We each have our own personal goals.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I know its the age old horn response could'nt resist. but accually this year I'm going to bow hunt have'nt done it in 20+yrs so any deer will do. never shot one with a bow. as for rifle I'm going to hold out for 8pt or bigger same goes for muzzle loader until last day of season.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I believe it is personal choice.I shoot does to eat and with a bow will only harvest a Pope&Young or better.With the rifle it is only Boone&Crockett.I have deer hunted for many many years and shot alot of deer so a smaller one doesnt do anything for me.Now,for a guy that has never shot a deer or it doesnt matter what he shoots a buck or smaller one to me would be just. Any deer with a bow to me is a trophy.Its all what a hunter is looking for and personal choice.It use to be I had to shoot a buck,any buck.Now I only care if its a big one and if I dont shoot a buck with a gun or bow that year oh well.

The area I hunt is private property and hunters are controlled so the bucks have a very good chance of growing older.This makes it much easier to be picky versus some overhunted areas where you may see only one buck for the season.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It depends on whether its early season or late season. Early in the bow season I'll let a fork or 6 point walk, but that same buck the first week in November might get shot. Depends whether I have a doe in the freezer yet, and whether I've seen any big ones while hunting or on my trail cam. As I'm writing and thinking about this, last year I didn't get a deer with my bow, I may take the first one that comes along that doesn't have spots. The horn hunters will disaprove but most deer hunters realize that any deer with a bow is a trophy. Then again if I shoot a buck right away, there goes my fun of hunting the rut the first week of November. Mmmm, I need to think about this.

Slug hunting is only a two day deal, and I hunt with some meat hunters, if its brown its down. And frankly, I like venison, I like getting those nice white packages of steak and sausage back, I'm ok with that.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am probably going to hold out with the "stick and string" for a 3 1/2 yr old buck. I will shoot a doe in the first week of season though. Always need some fresh veni for the family. If I haven't shot anything with a rack with my bow; I will take a 8 pt or bigger with my rife...if I see one. Getting pretty excited; should be a good year. PS shoot those does!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm usually looking for something that would at least be in the 125 inch category, but it also varies based on the deer. The buck I shot last year doesn't score all that great but he had very long main beams and a 21 inch inside spread. Taxidermist figured him at 4.5 years old.

I'm hoping to raise my standards a bit and my dad and I just bought 120 acres. I know the deer won't "stay" there but it's river bottom property with very good cover all around. I'm hoping in a couple of years I can get some more mature whitetails in there.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Jumbo,

I'm curious. How do you judge that a rack will measure over 110"? I've heard about proposals to make laws to this effect and I can't imagine how it could be regulated.

Bob

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thats a very good question, basically its just a quess, I feel though if I see a deer clearly I can quess within 5-8 inches of what it would be. Where I live most 2.5 year olds are in that 70-90 inch range, which can be detected easily when they walk by in bow range, 3.5 year olds generally range from 100 - 130 inch range. So basically its making a split second decision when you see them. But you never now for sure. I also have pics of a lot of the deer and we've kinda pre determined which ones were going to shoot.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I hunt for food so I shoot does and as others have said they are all trophies to me. I hunt on private property as well and there is only one buck on there that I would shoot anyway. It's in a heavy harvest area so I am hoping to load up the freezer with doe meat this year.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

For me, it's really a matter of how much time I have to hunt.

If I've got four days to hunt the North Dakota prairies I can spend some time looking for a good 3-yr old buck, filling a doe tag as the opportunity presents itself. If I've got one day left of four and haven't filled the tag I'm probably going to drop the first decent bodied animal with horns that I see. If I've got two days to hunt, and a buck and doe tag to fill I'm not going to be too choosy. I just look for big bodied animals.

I simply can't afford to buy tags that I don't fill, neither financially, nor time wise. We eat lots of venison every year. If I could spend more time in the field I would definately invest it toward a bigger "trophy" animal.

I've hunted deer for the better part of 25 years, and last year my son and I finally bagged a nice ten-point buck. That was the first really outstanding deer I've harvested.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've got two goals for this season.

1)any deer with my two boys along.

2) the "big one" I saw last year

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Nice goals. This is my first year that I have a black powder and I can shoot 3 deer during rifle season so I am hoping to shoot 3 does if I'm fortunate enough and then after that I hope to shoot a deer with my black powder. If I get a buck I get a buck but if I get 5 does I don't care. They all taste the same. I haven't commented on this topic yet and I just want to say something.

Everyone has there own view/opinion on what they should take and what they should leave. If your on state land take it but if your on your own land let those little ones go bye. Some of the best maanaged lands I have ever seen they wont shoot any buck less then outside the ears. They have a rule that if you shoot a buck less then outside the ears you pay each group member 100 bucks and there are 6-7 group members. So there thinking is when you shoot a buck your going to end up paying a good chunk of change to get it mounted which is what they wanted the land intended for. I don't support them 100% but they have rules and they follow it and I think that is the important part of it. Find some rules for where you want your land to go and work hard to incorporate it (Food plots/taking only does for a year or two).

my .02C

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is my first year bow hunting and through a stroke of luck and a business deal I have access to a large tract of land that has been managed as QDM for 11 years. I will be shooting the first decent sized doe I see to get on the archery board. Assuming this happens I will be holding out for a trophy buck for the remainder of the archey and shotgun seasons. Shooting small bucks is frowned upon no matter your past success or current harvest standards.

In Wisconsin I rifle hunt on state land and can buy antlerless tags for $2. I have shot enough 2-8 pointers in the past so I will be holding out for a nice buck here as well. I will be filling antlerless tags whenever I get a chance as there are an abundance of deer in the area I hunt.

I endorse shooting any deer your are happy with hanging from your tree, eating or hanging on the wall. To each his own.

Be safe.

WG

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Opening weekend bow season new state record after that size drops fast

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If Brian lets me on his land on opener...it will be my name on the new state record grin.gif; then it will go down from there. Probably have to run fast if I stuck an arrow through the deer that he claims to be seeing! tongue.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

BobT

None of the proposals use B&C score for determining a legal buck. Some have what is called antler point restrictions, which means the number of points on a side (i.e. a minimum of 4 points on at least one side-think 8 pointer). Thus you will not have to worry about judging a B&C score on the hoof. Although it is not hard to become fairly accurate just by looking at a deer with a known score and guessing before you look at the score. If you look at 30-40 deer this way, you will be fairly accurate in your estimation. Going to the Deer Classic will teach it to you in an hour or less.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hey Ole you big stud. I am holding out for the one that I saw on July 1st at our spot. Got a great look at him for 10 mins with the spotting scope at 300yds. We've been seeing a bunch of shooters but time will tell. Send me them pics. I have seen the ones you sent PK- put me on that mail list.

To answer the question, in WI this year I will try very hard hold out for the buck we've seen until mid Nov. In MN I will shoot if he goes 130" gross or better.

JD

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • ZachD
    • ZachD
      So I am torn I want to put a graph in my smaller boat.. I love my lx 6 flasher and am thinking about getting the high speed transducer for it and just going with that but I don't get why they charge $199 for it when bird and lowrance ducers are far less   I almost pulled the trigger on the lowrance hook 4 with down scan and chart plotter at gander for $179  I don't care about the chart plotter really as I have a big hand held gps that I use in that boat and that screen is larger than the hook 4 when you have it split plotter and graph they only had the display model left and wouldn't go lower price so I passed   If I can find the hook 4 at another gander that doesn't have the chart plotter for cheaper I may go with that   Does any one have experience with the lx on open water I hear it is at par with an lowrance elite 5 I am kind of wanting to go with that but don't know   What would you do run the lx open water or go with hook 4 with down scan  
    • bmc
      We survived our trip!  LOL   Fishing was steady.   We caught 30 walleyes in 3 days of fishing.  Usually fished from 11 am to 4 pm.  The 'eyes were running small, lots of 11 to 13 3/4" fish, but we did get 3 keepers.  We also kept a few nice perch and crappies.  We also caught a few snake northerns.   Jigging w/ chubs produced the best, but I did catch a few 'eyes on the crawler lindy rig combo.  Mid lake structure and underwater points off of islands all produced fish.  Mayflys were hatching, but the fish were still hungry. I did catch a 4-5 lb channel cat in the Savanna River one evening.   We stayed in the south loop of the Army Corp campground.  We liked that we were w/in about 30 yds of our boat which we kept at the dock.  The river on the north side of us and the lake on the south side offered a nice breeze to keep things cool and the bugs away for the most part.  Con's were the campsites are small and were too close together.  Also no turn around at the end of the south loop road.  The north loop was beautiful, spacious campsites, but surrounded by swamp and we heard the skeeters were bad at dusk.  Definitely want some thermacells or a screen tent to enjoy the evening by the sounds of things.  Also the docks aren't close/in view of the campsites.   We would definitely stay there again, on the north loop, in May or Sept. after the skeeters have died down a bit.   Staff was friendly, shower houses were nice, boat landings were nice.     Brian
    • MedicineMan
      Went out Thursday for a few hours. Caught a 28" Walleye along with a handful of nice sized Bass.
    • knoppers
      thanks for the report.
    • JBMasterAngler
    • JBMasterAngler
      Just got back from our 34th annual Grand Marais trip. Weather, and how bad it was, was the theme. At one point or another, it rained every single day we were there! The wind was miserable he last couple days as well. Really affected our fishing plans, as we had to cancel out on some of our normal lakes, and fish some less than desirable backup lakes.   As per tradition, we left in the middle of the night and pulled up to the Lester River just a few minutes before sunrise. Didn't catch anything there. Also got skunked at the Talmadge and French rivers. I got free admission at Tom's logging camp on account it was Father's Day  and as always, kids had fun feeding the animals. I did catch a few little rainbows out of sucker, knife, and Stewart rivers. Had our traditional "fisherman's breakfast" at McDonalds in Two Harbors. We stopped at the silver creek tunnel, and that was the first time I've been at the overlook since it was actually part of the highway back in '94. We rolled into Grand Marais at about 3:30 and had to wait out a rain storm before putting the boat out on Kimball Lake. We lost several trout, and in the end, only my 6 year old son caught 2 rainbows.   Monday we fished Greenwood Lake, and as was the case with my 2 older kids, my 3 year old daughter caught her very first fish here...a smallmouth bass! Between all of us, we caught about 130 bass, all of which were pretty small. Unfortunately no lake trout. However, a big surprise occurred...while casting for bass, I caught a herring! Then a few minutes later, my son caught one also! Never would have guessed I'd ever catch one in the summer, let alone 2!   Fished a "secret lake" on Tuesday and caught quite a few northerns. They were all either 5 pounds, or 6 inches long, nothing in between. My son caught an 8 pound, 33 incher, which ended up being the biggest fish of the trip. We was screaming, and excited, and wanted me to take his fishing pole. But after about 10 minutes he finally got it in so I could net it. He's still bragging about it. My 3 year old also caught her 2nd ever fish, a perch, which ended up being the only one of the trip.   Went up to Saganaga on Wednesday. I spent I don't know how many hours trying to catch lake trout, but didn't find any!  Finally gave up and ventured deep into red rock bay for the first time ever. Really nice back there, wish I would've went there first. Fishing was ok, considering the weather was starting to get bad. Caught the biggest bass of the trip, a hair over 18 inches. On the drive back we seen a bear. Ironically it was walking down the road to black bear lodge at Poplar Lake.   Biggest disappointment came on Thursday. The plan was to fish both Hungry Jack and West Bearskin lakes. The wind was terrible, and coming straight from the west. Had hungry jack not had the reputation as a big bass producer, I wouldn't have went here. Unfortunately the big bass weren't around, nor any bass for that matter. Only caught 4 small bass. Kids caught about a dozen or so sunnies from the dock at the resort, some of which were decent size. We didn't even bother with bearskin. There's no way we would be able to launch our boats in that wind. We went to Loon Lake instead. In the limited time we were there, we caught about 30 tiny bass. My 9 year old daughter also caught her first rock bass. I tried for lakers, and marked a lot of them, but didn't catch any.    So since we didn't fish West Bearskin as planned, we penciled it in for Friday. Knowing the weather was going to be bad, we picked Poplar Lake as our backup. I drove up to Mayhew Lake to start, because I wanted to check out the launch. I was able to get my boat down the launch, but it was a real tight fit. Nice little lake. We saw a mommy moose with 2 babies laying right on the shoreline. I got sick of trolling, so I decided to cast cranks along the drop offs of the one small stretch of shoreline that was out of the wind (relatively speaking). Hooked into a big fish! Got excited because I thought I finally had a lake trout! It was a northern!  never thought I'd be disappointed in catching a 5.5 pound pike, but that's what I was. Didn't bother going to Bearskin, as I knew the wind was too bad again. Went to Poplar, which is a lake I do not like! As is typical, the fishing was no good! He weather was bi polar! It would be bright and sunny, then rain for 20 minutes. Did that the whole rest of the day! Only caught 1 little pike and  1 little bass. Got excited for a minute, as whitefish started surfacing around my boat in the evening. I was hoping I could catch 1 or 2, but nope!    Saturday we were supposed to fish Two Island for a few hours before going home. But it was pouring rain. We didn't even bother driving around to different boat launches. So the trip ended on a sour note, but we still had lots of fun, seen a moose, had our donuts (I highly recommend the bacon maple longjohn by the way), and went to Sven & Ole's. I was going to go camping in Ely in July, but I think we'll come back to Grand Marais instead, and try to make up for what we missed out on due to the weather. IMG_6122.MOV
    • CaptJohnWis
      I have not been on Rainy much as of late. On June 12, I got 75 walleyes in about 6-8 FOW. On. June 15 (Sanctuary opener) I hit Stangi for several hours and only got four fish. June 17, got 20 fish in about five hours - mostly walleyes on a weed edge in about 8 feet of water. Many on jig with Lunker CIty trailers. Also some good ones on a feather jig. Bass were few and far between. Plus some pike but nothing huge. Biggest walleyes 24-25". Bass 18", pike 29". View my fishing report to see videos of lures that were working.   I did mark lots of fish in deeper water but they were dink walleyes so I did not fish them for long.The dinks are actually harder to catch on lures than bigger ones. They respond better to live bait which I don't use.
    • Cliff Wagenbach
      We had a good bite on 1/2 crawlers today! Boated 45 walleyes and kept our limits of fish that were all between 15-1/2" and 19-3/4 "! Released at least 6 slot fish. Largest was a fat 25-1/2 inch fish. Best over all sized fish limit all summer! The walleyes were stuffed with either May fly nymphs or molted crayfish.  
    • Michael Felix