Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Kyle

Rattling

9 posts in this topic

Is it a good idea to rattle at the very beggining of the archery season? I know the bucks are not heated up yet, and will most likely be in groups still, but I was just curious if anyone knew if it makes them curious at this time or if it scares them. Ive never had success rattling, but figured I would ask just in case the situation would present itself.

H4L

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What I have read and learned over the years is that rattling should be done during the rut period.One of the reasons that it sometimes seems to work so well on T.V. is that the majority of those hunts are on game farms with a buck to doe ratio of 10 or 11-1.Pretty hard to find that in the wild.I still do use the rattling horns at specific times during the rut period.I have had only limited success.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Harv is right, pre-rut and early rut, it's a territorial thing. I seldom rattle, so therfore have had limited sucess, I have rattled in two deer, one small guy and a doe that came running...that's it for me. You need a high buck to doe ratio like Harv said.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks guys.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What about calling? Do you guys use a call during the early bow season? If so, what type of call do you use (Fawn Bleats, Doe Grunts, Estrous Bleats, Buck Grunts or a combination of these)?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I personally dont use any calls at all.I just try to set myself up in a good location and wait.I have been bow hunting the same area for the last 15 years and pretty much know where the deer travel.I am not saying that calling is bad,I just try to do it as natural as possible.I will use some different scents during the pre rut and rut but that is about it.

There are many different calls out there to be used and I am quite sure some are good.Its always worth a try just like rattling or using scents.I would think that a doe in heat call would be worth a try during the rut.A fawn bleat might also be good for finding mama.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't rattle early in the season but I have found a fawn bleat early in the season will bring the Does running in if they think a fawn is in distress (motherly instinct).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I havee had two examples of each thing working.

First was the "Can Call" three years ago. I spotting a buck about 300 yards away and I tried to coax him in for a better shot so I starting dinging around with the can. He must have heard and he started toward me. He would travel about 30-50 yards and then stop and smell. Then I would hit him again and coax him in a little closer. I finally got him within about 75 yards and shot him. A nice eight-pointer. Nothing special, but a nice big-body deer.

The next was a bad/good exxperience with the rattle bag. First of all that has never worked. NEVER even looked up. Last year during second weekend I saw a buck cut accross the feild on my rigth and head into some brush. I tired to can call him to coax him out and no luck. So I rattled for a while. I kept watching that area that for about 15 minutes. Nothing

Then I got the feeling that something was watching me and I turned to see a buck off to the left pawing at the ground and looking pissed. I was pretty spooked. I didn't expect to see him 50 yards from my stand in the open. I reached for my shotgun and he was gone. Went into a full sprint accross the field.

It was shotgun zone there so I had no chance for a decent shot.

That boy was BIG. I mean BIG. He had a rack that looked like a mule deer. Tall and wide. He was either a 12 or 14 pointer, but his rack was so tall and wide.

I still think about what could have been.

My two stories on rattle bags and can calls.

Anyone else have similar stories?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I just started using a rattle bag two years ago. In early October about the 8th, I rattled in 3 small bucks in a 20 minute period. I've had does come in to check out the ruckus also.

I purchased a Whitetail and Elk Obsession video, produced by Wild Outdoors, Jay Gregory and there is a hunt on there where rattling is done successfully in Late September. All the hunts on the video are supposed to be "in the wild, no fenced in areas", etc. Two bucks are seen battling in an open field in the morning, across a typical-height 4-5 ft. barbed wire fence and a couple hundred yards away from the hunter. After some serious pushing each other back and forth for several minutes, the bucks get back into some brush out of sight of the hunter so he rattles some horns. A few minutes later, both bucks come in to investigate the sound. Based on this video, I would say that rattling MAY be effective prior to October. Once the velvet is off the antlers, bucks are going to be establishing the pecking order as the testosterone starts to rise. I plan on doing some light rattling early season to see what happens.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Wanderer
      Shagawa in Ely has a public beach.  That's the closest to Bear Head that I know of.  You'd have to launch a ways across the lake but you could just motor over to it.
    • mjk
      Sorry for late response.  The Gander in Eden Prairie had quite a few...
    • proguide
      Catfishing is pretty stable right now. The water is getting very low making the north end of Grand Forks begin to get sketchy for travel.  The lack of current has the fish spread out also.  Stay on the move and when you land of fish you should have no trouble catching them.  The best areas have been anywhere you can find more current than the surrounding area.  The middle of the River in mid range holes has also been a good place to look. 
        Bait has changed for me this week with frogs being the hands down number one so far.  Sucker and goldeye have been working too.  I still believe getting bait in front of the fish is is the key more than what the bait is but try it all.   Remember the I-29 Catfish Classic is in just 2 weeks.
    • paceman
      Made it out last night. Beautiful night. Caught a bunch of Crappies, sunnies, a norsky and a few walleyes. All CR. Amazing how quiet the lake was. I was the only boat out for the most part. First boat in parking lot at 5:30 and no AI inspector this time. Have not seen them for quite awhile now.... Water temp was 78. Panfish were caught on simple Jig/plastic in about 12 feet along shoreline weeds. Walleyes on spinner/crawlers in 17-20 on midlake structure.
    • CaptJohnWis
      Berserker Bass.   This is probably the most exciting hit I have ever had from a bass.   Had to slow it down to get the full effect .Berzerker bass video
    • ZachD
    • ZachD
      Have not fished down there but up river a little way in the Ramsey area I have been doing well on smallies Either trolling raps up river bouncing of the bottom or drifting down pounding the shorelines with meps spinners.   Meps are one of my favorite lures for the river that and buzz baits.   The Mississippi is fun because you have a chance at catching anything.
    • ZachD
      Go to the fields off hwy 10 where diamonds used to be and where the boat launch is in Ramsey. I plant feathers and stuff there sometimes there is a variety of tall grass around there.   the best pre buy program I have found is at golden meadows. if you put money on an account before aug 26 the prices are  depending on when you go Aug. 20 - Sept. 4
      Sept. 5 - Oct. 2
      Oct. 3 - Nov. 6
      Nov. 7 - Dec. 4
      Dec. 5 - Jan. 1, 2017 COST PER BIRD

      $16.50
      $17.50
      $18.50
      $19.50
      $20.50    
    • biff
      Hmmm...getting a prosthetic foot and attaching hooks now
    • fishingtime13
      Im wanting to go and fish the missisippi river by my place, there is a little inlet with some down trees, a drop off  and a little bridge that goes over the inlet. Its off of east river road at the end of 79th.  I believe its called riverview heights park. My questions is, has anyone gone fishing there? I see people there quite often and have chatted with them a little bit, but haven't gotten much out of them. It looks promising for some largemouth and catfish. if you have fished there what works good? and are they biting now? I will be there at about 5 am tomorrow morning.