Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

  • Announcements

    • Rick

      1st Please Post Your Fishing Report - Then Join the NEW - Private Fishing Report Clubs   01/24/2018

      Private Fishing Report Clubs - Click Here - Post Your Fishing Report Before Joining
      1st, be sure you post a fishing report in the forums, then ask to join after you post a fishing report in your area forum. The Private Fishing Report Clubs are where folks can share private fishing information with club members who have proven they know what's going on. Fishing Report Clubs Link also in Menu above. Apply to become a member today, while it's still easy. 
  • RECEIVE THE GIFTS MEMBERS SHARE WITH YOU HERE...THEN...CREATE SOMETHING TO ENCHANT OTHERS THAT YOU WANT TO SHARE

    You know what we all love...

    When you enchant people, you fill them with delight and yourself in return. Have Fun!!!

  • 0
Sign in to follow this  
sparkyaber

mercury rev 4 vs mercury trophy plus

Question

sparkyaber

Does any one know the difference between these two props?

I need to replace my 3 blade tempest because of blow out issues, and was told to try a 4 blade before I think of a jack plate. Now I just need to figure out which one?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

16 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

  • 0
Capt. Don*

I have rev 4's as well as 3 blade mirage plus. I run a heavy offshore boat w/twin 225's. The 4's give me more traction if you will and get on plane very quickly, very good lift on the stern, but I sacrifice fuel economy. I run 70-90 miles per trip so fuel consumption has to be factored in, I went back to the 3 blade mirage+ and get good results but need to run a little faster to hold on plane. Go to www.mercurymarine.com and use the prop selector tools, you can get a good start on what may work well for your needs.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
sparkyaber

I did try their prop selector tool and it really didn't work. It asks all of the information, and then I get an error saying that my pitch or top speed is out of expected range. My boat is very light so I can get away with running a high pitch prop and I think that is the problem with the program. I had to reduce my top speed 10 mph to get it to work.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
Whoaru99

What is the operating condition when it happens?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
kjgmh

If blowing out with a tempest I would stay away from the trophy, it is a small hub and probably would not work better. The Rev 4 would probably work better for you.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
sparkyaber

It does not matter where the motor is trimmed up down in the middle any corner with excelleration it will blow out. Really tough to pull a tuber or skier with this happening.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
Whoaru99

Sounds more like ventilation than blow out.

How high is the engine mounted?

Is the anti-ventilation plate equal to, higher than, or lower than the bottom of the boat?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
hydro

Your problem is cavitation (ventilation), caused by the prop sucking in air during turns. The suggestion above about engine height is a place to start since having the prop too near to the surface will cause what you have described. Try putting a straightedge on the bottom of the boat and measuring from the center of the prop to the straightedge. This is propshaft height and is the baseline to diagnose your problem. Post is back and we can help you fix things before you throw money at a new prop.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
sparkyaber

Yeh, that was the first thing I checked- I am 5 and one half inches below the pad with my prop shaft height. (center point of the prop shaft compared to the bottom of the boat.) I was informed that 3 inches is about the place to start and work from there. I can only go one hole farther down with the motor I am in the second to the top hole. With the addition of the 4 blade it stopped the blow out almost all together I had to try to make it blow out.

Thanks

Set up:

Triton fs190

mercury opti 200

23" tempest plus

66mph + running about 5300rpms

I could never get the boat all the way trimmed out beacause the boat would start to chine walk.

When I put the rev4 23" I could only get 60mph and running about 5200r's, but could get the boat all the way trimmed out.

I am trying the 21" rev4 tomorrow. I have heard you can get a "blowout ring" to use with the trophy to make up for the small hub.

Thanks for the help!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
hydro

Sparky,

This may give you a little info for comparison. I'm running a 20' Coral Fish and Ski hull, basically a pad vee hull similar to your boat and probably about the same weight. My motor is a 200EFI Mercury with a Tempest 23" three blade set to 3 1/4" below the pad. With this combination I get some cavitation on takeoff unless the motor is trimmed in but overall it runs very well. when I first got the boat the motor was set up like yours at about 5" below the pad and it chine walked bad. Raising the motor cured the chine walk completely. I still notice some cavitation on hard turns with the motor trimmed up but if I pull it down I can corner hard.

Keep up the experimenting and You'll get it figured out!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
sparkyaber

how much of a differance is there between raising the motor vertically and trimming it up. if it is really important I think I will be investing in a jack plate.

I tried a 21" rev 4 tonight and also a enertia 22". The rev 4 was close, but chine walked at about 50 mph- I did get it to 60.5 mph @5600 rpms, I was by myself, and with just me in the boat, with the batteries on the same side it really leans to the right side.

The enertia was not good, hit the rev limiter very easily, and only got 60.7 mph out of it.

The rev4 was impossible to get air under the boat, if I tried I could get the enertia to blow out.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
hydro

Sparky,

A couple of thoughts on your last post. First, there is a BIG difference between vertical adjustment (propshaft height) and trim. The trimming the motor will act like a lever, lifting the bow and, to a point, reducing wetted hull area and friction. The result is you will go faster until the trim gets too high and you wind up just throwing water in the air. A good indication of trim is a rooster tail about 6' high at WOT. A vertical jackplate will allow you to raise the motor on the transom, reducing the frontal mass of the gearcase, and also getting the top of the propeller free of the water. If you are still having problems with chine walking this is the solution. Also, the prop must be designed to operate in a semi-surfacing condition. The Tempest works well here.

You have also mentioned that you are seeing RPM in the 5300 to 5600 range. What is the recommended WOT range for your motor?

Another detail I thought of this morning is that you started out with a Tempest Plus prop. Were the vent holes plugged or open? They are designed to allow the prop to ventilate during the hole shot and get the motor into it's power band quickly. If too much of the vent hole area is open there will be excess exhaust over the blades of the prop and you will see all sorts of ventilation problems.

Good Luck,

Hydro

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
Whoaru99

If you get a jack plate (or start raising the engine much), be sure to get a water pressure gauge if you don't already have one. The higher you raise the engine, the more chance to suck air into the water intake.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
hydro

If you start to lose water pressure you can plug the top water pickup holes to prevent air from getting in. Mine are plugged and it worked slick. To plug them just tap the hole for a 5/16" setscrew and be sure to use loctite when installing the plug.

Also, if you put in a water pressure gauge it will probably freeze during storage and be destroyed. A gauge isolator or simply removing it prior to storage will protect it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
sparkyaber

Sorry to take to long to get back to this post- slayed the kings over in michigan this weekend.

WOT is supposed to be 5000-5750, but I would like to get close to the highest rpms possible.

Vent holes- Med holes in place now, kept them in in each prop that I tried.

I have never had a rooster tail with this boat.

I do have a pressure gauge on this boat, and I run 15-20 psi when flying across the lake.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
hydro

With what you have posted, I suggest the following:

Raise the motor so that the prop shaft is about 3 ½” below the pad. Try the Rev 4 again and I bet you will pick up some RPM and MPH. (You mentioned that the 21” Rev 4 ran 5600 RPM and did not ventilate) Try the Tempest again at that motor height and evaluate the two props for the best OVERALL performance (not just speed).

Good luck.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
sparkyaber

I think I will be getting that jack plate. I don't want to take the boat to the dealer to move the motor up and find out I have to move it back down. $$$$ mad.gif I was thinking that the rev4 would be the one, now I have to decide if it will be the 23" or the 21". I am pushing the upper limits of the recommended r's with the 21, and if I raise the motor I am afraid I will go over the 5750 that is recommended. How many rpms do you think I will gain buy raising the motor with a jack plate?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  



  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • papadarv
      Out Saturday afternoon doing some sight fishing with my camera on one of Chisago County lakes. Water was a bit dirty and with 26 inches of ice camera clarity was a bit lacking. Did get some nice video of the afternoon. Battery augers failed after a couple of holes so went with the Eskimo gas. Lots of fish above the weeds in 10 FOW.  EazyCam site fishingHB.mp4
    • LakeofthewoodsMN
      Weather forecast looks to be consistent starting Wednesday with average temps in the  mid 20's. Consistency typically good.  Right now anglers are working fish hard and putting fish in the pail. Electronics are playing a huge roll as some walleyes suspended as far as 10 feet below the ice. Most resorts are out in 31' with some in a touch shallower. More saugers in deep mud with walleyes shallower. Reefs to the west also productive with a few perch being pulled in as well. Rattle and flutter action spoons doing well. Gold, pink, and other glow colors best.  Pike already active in shallow water.  Auger extension needed if fishing on your own with 3+ feet of ice in most areas.  Snowmobilers stay on marked trail, big ice chunks off of trail. Ice houses allowed to be left on lake through March 31st, walleyes open through April 14, pike all year.   Rainy River pushing out some bigger walleyes in the morning/evening with an occasional sturgeon.  Local fish houses along the snowmobile trail from Wheeler's Point to Baudette Bay.  Morning, evening bite most effective.   The NW Angle continues to put nice fish in the bucket. Walleyes and saugers in good numbers.  20-24' early and late, 26-30' during day.  In Ontario waters, crappies in deeper holes of 28-32' on light tackle set ups. Mortality rate is high for released crappies in 25' or deeper, catch fish and move on.  Walleyes all over!  Snowmobile trails on and around the lake are marked and groomed.  
    • mrpike1973
      Hi all hope to make it this Saturday. Depending on the snow coming we should be able to drive on correct?
    • Hoey
      This past weekend, only two were caught by our group of three fishermen and they were small, in the 10" range.  
    • Hoey
      Why not go out of Swift?  I nothing about the Warroad access, sorry.  
    • Hoey
      OK - we made it back!!!  Every trip is different with it's own potential perils.   I finally got into my house on Friday around 11am.  My guests were rookies, so i spent time with each of them, getting setup, heaters started, Vexilars set, houses banked, lines prep'd and set, bait, etc...  The bite was somewhat slow and many small ones.  The day got better 3 to 430pm.  Ended up with 6 nice eyes (19, 18x3, 17x2), 13 jumbos (most ever for a day), 12 small sauger which we ate for dinner.   On Saturday we headed up to the south shore of the Angle, longer ride, so again did not get started too early.  Ended up with our 6 eyes for our limit, these ranged from 15 to 16 inches and a 4-pack of sauger.  Again the bite seemed to pickup at 3 or so and was done by 430pm.   Ice as 3 foot or so.  Snow depth varied a lot, depending on the condition of the ice.  Smooth areas were blown off to crusty 6 inches or so.  Rough ice surely held a lot of snow.   The drive back on Sunday was somewhat tough from Baudette to Emily, winter storm warning.  Slow go, low visibility, and icy roads, sometimes down to 15 mph.   Next scheduled trip is with my wife, son, and three of his Gopher swim teammates for spring break in three weeks.  
    • Naturboy
      Those were caught from a shallow lake (17’) in 9 feet of water at the bottom of the first shoreline break. I was using a UV buckshot and minnow head since the water was murky. The crappie is still swimming the walleye not so much. I didn’t get the exact location. Sorry  
    • Sunset Lodge
      Hello from the NW Angle!

      Minnesota fishing has been most productive in 20-24 feet of water.  Guests are bringing home their limits of Walleye and Sauger with the occasional Perch and Northern mixed in. Fish have been most active early and late in the day and the bite has been terrific. The use of electronics continues to be very beneficial with fish taking jigging spoons, jigg’n raps or rattle baits.  Snowmobile ttrails on the Minnesota side continue to be maintained and are in great shape. We are still making ice, with most spots at over 30 inches. 

      North and East of us in Canada, big Crappies are coming in on light tackle setups out of 30 feet. If you are looking for walleye, they are everywhere!

      Until next week, 

      Sunset Lodge
    • JBMasterAngler
      On the Bayfield side of the bay, the target depth is typically 10 to 40 ft. The basswood island area is where they go after lakers. There’s a plowed road that goes out there. As of last week the ice was about 20 inches in that area, might be thicker now. Check out the Bayfield webcam, you can see what kind of activity is going on.
    • Jarrid Houston
      Wanderer, stop in at the River Rock bait shop in Ashland and they will get you pointed in the right direction.  They are always pretty cool about that.  Fishing near Ashland off of 2nd landing can be good.  Don't need nothing more than regular walleye gear, and some tip-ups and really there is no rhyme or reason where a guy should set up shop. Its a pretty wide open water and the fish that live there are always on the move. For us, most often, the sit and wait pays off.  It has been slower as of late, but still some fish..  Good luck, JH
  • Share & Have Fun