Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
eyepatrol

VMax Carb, VMax HPDI and 4-stroke F series ?'s

14 posts in this topic

Being I don't know much about the Yamaha line of motors, I was wondering if someone could explain to me the differences of the above brand motors and also how these motors would rank against each other in price.

Thank you!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The HPDI stands for high pressure direct injection, the carbed model is the "old school" in technology and the F Series are the four stroke models. The V-Max HPDI is an HPDI with a more streamlined lower unit, usually only comes in 20" and was originally designed for bass boats.

I've owned two HPDI's (a 2002 150 V-Max HPDI and a 2004 200 HPDI) These two are the best two outboards I've ever owned and I've owned a bunch. I had the 2002 V-Max HPDI on a 2002 Lund Pro-V that still had a 20" inch transom and that was a sweet running rig. Great hole shot and good top end.

I owned the 2004 200 HPDI on a Pro-V also and the 200 HPDI is one of the most reliable products Yamaha has ever made. A little less aggressive than a V-Max HPDI but still impressive in terms of performance.

With either HPDI, starting is instant. Even right after winter storage, they just start right now.

The HPDI's and the four strokes are virtually identical in terms of fuel economy with a modest edge in performance to the HPDI series. Either of these stand well above the carbed models which are being discontinued soon if not already.

Pricing difference between HPDI and Four Stroke is not much. Good deals are available on both if you time your purchase right. Both of these are proven products with excellent reputations. The carbed model was also in it's day but that's in the past now.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Bass a hpdi would be very similar to the Optimax that you have had and are familiar with. Then a 4 stroke is a 4 stroke of course quit and clean. The HPDI are also very quite and clean too. Kind of the ford vs. chevy deal 4 stroke or HPDI. Performance wise HPDI will probably have more top end etc. The the 4 strokes on the market are pretty darn good too in the performance end of things.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There was recently a shootout of the 250hp motors available in Bass and Walleye Boat magazine and it may be on their website also.All were 4 strokes except one and it was quite interesting how the comparisons blew holes in all the theories about fuel consumption/emissions/noise levels etc. of the 4 strokers. Check it out if you get the chance it's a good read.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hey, don't you wish they made a TDI (Turbo Diesel Injection)

It would have so much torque...... grin.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for the helpful info all. I had an incling that those were the differences, but wanted to be certain.

Speaking of motors, I received an E-tec dvd a week or so ago where they compared their motor to the Yamaha 4-stroke and the Verado. Some interesting differences, but the one thing I found most interesting was the race they had between 3 Triton bass boats all rigged with 225's. In 2 miles the E-tec outran the Yammi and Verado by 4 seconds (not much really), but what I really found interesting is the Yammi and Verado crossed the finish at basically the exact same time. Seems to me those Verados aren't as supercharged as they lead one to believe. A little unfair to be comparing 2-stroke DI's to 4-strokes IMO, but it was an interesting video.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Regarding the DVD you received... remember that the DVD is made by Evinrude... so the results very well could be biased a little... Bass and Walleye Boats is a good, objective magazine that typically has pretty good reviews and gives you all the numbers from their tests.

marine_man

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree. I thought the video was a bit biased and to some degree unfair trying to compare 2-stroke vs. 4's, but then again they don't make a 4-stroke so they're trying to sway opinions I think.

I went on that website last night and read all kinds of good info on the various comparisons, tests, etc. Very informative!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The supercharger in the Verado was to give it more punch out of the hole than a typical 4-stroke, which I think it does. It costs you some fuel economy at WOT though compared to other 4 strokes and DFI motors.

4-strokes are quieter than DFI motors, but at high rpms there is not that much difference in noise.

You know which way I went with my motor, the yamaha HPDI was my 2nd choice. If I wanted a 150 HP the F150 would have been my second choice, maybe even my first choice.

Stay away from the carbed versions.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Quote:

Thanks for the helpful info all. I had an incling that those were the differences, but wanted to be certain.

Speaking of motors, I received an E-tec dvd a week or so ago where they compared their motor to the Yamaha 4-stroke and the Verado. Some interesting differences, but the one thing I found most interesting was the race they had between 3 Triton bass boats all rigged with 225's. In 2 miles the E-tec outran the Yammi and Verado by 4 seconds (not much really), but what I really found interesting is the Yammi and Verado crossed the finish at basically the exact same time. Seems to me those Verados aren't as supercharged as they lead one to believe. A little unfair to be comparing 2-stroke DI's to 4-strokes IMO, but it was an interesting video.


God I hope they didn't show the guy in his pink thong in the Video grin.gif.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ok, I have another question related to this: I have a 2000 v-max 150 that is EFI, but not HPDI. What is the difference between these?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

EFI is fuel injected, it is not the same has HPDI which is direct injection. I can not explain in detail the differences between the two but it has to do with how the gas, air, and exhaust are treated and burned inside the engine. HPDI is the newer technology, much more fuel efficient, much lower pollution.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

They're both fuel injected but the HPDI stands for high pressure direct injection. Depending on the model year, the fuel is pumped into the cylinders at between 700 and 1,000 PSI by a fuel pump that runs off the flywheel.

The HPDI starts instantly compared to the EFI's habits (cold blooded sometimes) and the fuel economy of the HPDI is much better than an EFI.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

In EFI, fuel is usually injected to the cylinder thru the intake ports. In a HPDI, the fuel is injected directly into the cylinder.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • IRISHSOBNO4
    • Chill62
      Decided to fish Big Detroit saturday with a buddy.  Had bites but my 24 v 75#  trolling motor couldn't keep me in place so that sucked.  When we left the access to go fishing I asked the young man how late they were open till so I could make it back in time to get washed since I was going to fish a different lake on Sunday morning with the nephews.  I will be here till 5:30!  Sounds good see you before 5!  Fishing sucked, Wind BLEW, RAIN SUCKED!  So we packed up at 4:30 drove to access get there around 4:40 and they are gone!  Hot on my heels is a local fishing guide and he wasn't happy also because he had the same game plan.  Was told that there would be one at Melissa till 5 pm religiously.  Got there by 4:55 and they were gone from that lake too.  I honestly don't feel comfortable enough to do a safe job washing since I don't have a pressure washer and I really don't want to spread the Zebra Mussels from lake to lake and I know it was only a few hours 5-6 but honestly whats the point of AIS being there if they don't stay till the house they are supposed to be?  There was an easy half dozen boat trailers still at the access so it wasn't like we were the only two left at the access.  
    • huskybass
      Had some fun Saturday morning crashing through the lily pads on a small metro lake.  2 fish over 5 lbs and every fish absolutely choked the bait.  All I want to do is throw top water now, haha.  Wish I had longer arms or a partner in the boat for a decent photo.  
    • TNtoMN_HuntFish
      I really hope they don't screw this place up. I love it out there and have done a lot of hunting there. I sure wish there were fewer horse trails. It shouldn't be so easy for hunters to access all the woods. That makes it harder to get away from the guys who want to hunt no more than 50 yds from a gravel road.    The dunes seems like a pretty special place to me. DNR does a lot of things that leave is scratching our heads, let's hope they manage this place properly. 
    • 12345
      Im staying at Arrowwood July 2-5 and looking to catch some 'eyes for a fish fry or 2. Never been to the area before so I dont have much to go by other than my overall knowledge of Walleye fishing elsewhere. Ill probably be fishing early mornings and dusk for obvious reasons, but also because my boat will be used for the majority of the days for entertaining the girlfriends family. Im open to fishing not only Darling, but Carlos and Le Homme Dieu as well. 

      From what ive read and can see on Google Earth, the lakes are pretty clear, and from experience, usually means tough walleye fishing for this time of year. -I grew up fishing Woman Lake in the Longville/Hackensack area and that lake is as clear as they come. The only way we can snag some 'eyes in the summer is to fish the deep weed lines. Is that the approach I should be taking on these lakes? Does dragging rapalas across mid-lake flats produce? Any help would be greatly appreciated!

      Thanks,

      Gavin.
    • TNtoMN_HuntFish
      Ha, I've read stories about that lake being filthy. And I know about those warnings on the link you posted I just wonder if this stuff is blown out of proportion. Reason being I can't find any confirmed cases of people having mercury poisoning from eating freshwater fish. I know mercury poisoning does exist but can we really get it from fish? You'd think if we could then there would be cases down south where folks are eating catfish from the Mississippi.    We ate a few 30+" Pike during the ice season, I ate more than my wife, and I only did that from lakes that are safer according to DNR and MDH fish tissue surveys. I kept it to once a week for her and I ate the rest. I went over the one meal a week rule several times for myself, but then went a while without taking home fish while the season was closed. I'm not glowing yet haha.    I also don't understand why walleye are always the riskiest fish to eat per those surveys when Pike are above them on the food chain. 
    • h8go4s
      Surely they have a Terrova on the floor. Doesn't matter what size THEY ALL LOOK THE SAME. Also, boat dealers have showrooms with all kinds of stuff mounted on boats.
    • BringAnExtension
    • monstermoose78
      Stopped in this morning and it looks like it should be good to go. 
    • ZachD
      http://www.health.state.mn.us/divs/eh/fish/eating/kidmom/index.html