Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
smallie_hawgin

So is it the Regulations?

12 posts in this topic

Just wanted to put this out there to see y'alls thoughts. Is it the slot regs (12-20 protected, 1 over 20, with 3 daily bag) that have been in place since 1990 that makes the St. Cloud to Dayton stretch so good or is it something else? Just curious what all the river rats think?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think it certainly doesn't hurt things, and I would expect that it has indeed increased the average size of the bass in that stretch.
A case in point is the new experimental regs regarding northern pike, anglers tend to keep the nicer fish. Pike (similar to smallies) are agressive and if you know their patterns, are not really too tough to catch. I think anyone who has fished this state for a while would agree that we have seen a dramatic overall decline in average size for that species. I have no objections to keeping legally caught fish for consumption or mounting if it's a trophy, but I think we might be loving our sport to death in some cases. We fish the Rum with some regularity and strictly because the Rum is a much smaller river I would think it is a more fragile fishery than the Mississippi.
We have landed numbers of nice smallmouth in there and have not kept any, for us, the fun is in the catching. I don't like bass to eat, so releasing them is pretty easy to do. To me, it would also make sense to have some slot restrictions on the Rum.
I think we will be seeing many more lakes and rivers with special regulations and slot limits, and for the most part I am in favor of it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't profess to know the answer...but I believe the regs help. What I do think has a impact is the warm water discharge from the two power plants. Longer growth season...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I definitely think the reg's have had an impact. I've fished the stretch between 101 bridge to Clearwater for about 15 yrs., and the last 3 have been incredible!!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I say move the regs all the way down to the Coon Rapids dam.
I would think it could only help it get better.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'd vote for protecting them all over the river.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think smallies in general should be protected. Hey, it's my favorite fish smile.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Special regs work great in certain situations, the river notwithstanding. But I believe, the real reason this fishery remains such a smallmouth bonanza is not due so much to slot limits as it is to habitat. Up and down the Miss you've got perfect smallmouth water-- innumerable places they can effectively feed, avoid excessive current and obviously, reproduce.

Water quality, believe it or not, actually plays a large role in the bass' success as well. For many years, water quality has remained high throughout most portions of the Upper Miss. Smallmouth survival hinges on it. Loss of water quality spells doom for smallmouths, which is exactly what happened to a once thriving population in the Minnesota R.

More recently now, an alarming increase in the number of reported erosion cases-- most notably in the Grand Rapids area-- probably poses the greatest threat facing the river, ever-- much greater than the perceived threat of over-fishing. Erosion means excessive basin siltation, which spells a loss in fish habitat, as it nearly always also leads to a loss in water quality.

I'm certainly not saying we're going to lose this wonderful fishery anytime soon-- far from it. But the changes a river undergoes via siltation borne from excessive riparian development can be dramatic, and rarely pretty.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for that info Toad. It's easy for us to take it for granite this great body of water. I was wading and caught 2 nice smallies on luch break just today. Let's hope it lasts. <>< <>< ><> ><>

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Toad and others, If it was all habitat in your opinion, why has the population significantly improved since 1990? I am definitely not disagreeing on the quality habitat. But that habitat has been there for hundreds of years.

We all have seen improvements of smallmouth fisheries all across the state, but at significantly lower levels. Are there folks that noticed the same changes in the upper stretches (Brainerd-L falls, Blanchard to Sartell)? While I know a bit about the St. Coud to Coon Rapids stretch I have only limited knowledge of the others. Anyway it is still good to realize that habitat is by far one of the most limiting resources. If we all can do our part to educate others on proper land use (don't mow near shorlines, allow natives to proliferate, don't dump grass clippings on the shoreline, minimize runoff, etc., etc.), the river may be able to withstand development pressures from all of the sprawl. Good discussion!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I like others have fished the stretch of river in question for a very long time. I have also kept records of every single trip. I am here to say i don't believe the req. brought on by the smallmouth alliance have made a huge difference, if any. Why, simply because when these reqs. were imposed there wasn't alot of pressure to begin with. You would never see the boats you do now, and even back then catch and release was the popular thing to do. I knew and know alot of fisherman on the river and none of them kept smallies, cats, walleyes yes, but not s.m. Now there are more fisherman and I think almost all of you would say that even if these reqs. weren't in place you wouldn't keep any if but a few to eat. Smallies are delicious, and even if an occasinal one was kept by someone for the frying pan it wouldn't harm this incredible fishery. In my records spanning twenty yrs I catch more big fish now, but i am also a better fisherman then i was back then. It takes a long time and alot of work to learn how to catch big s.m. consistently. Last year i pulled in over 900 s.m. so i think i get a pretty good idea of what shape this fishery is in. Do these restrictions hurt a body of water, of course not. And in some bodies of water i believe they are a very important management tool. The reason i am catching bigger s.m. is beacuse i have a better understanding of the fish and river. The smallmouth fishing on the river has ALWAYS been excellent, it has been nationally acclaimed well before these restrictions were imposed. Gapen would bring russian diplomats here, as well as other celebrities to this area to fish, why? Because it was an awesome fishery. The river's eco-system, river cleanliness and that your a better fisherman has contributed to the increase in big s.m. caught. I have read many posts on here of local river fisherman saying that a 20" s.m. is a once in every 5 year fish, or they just got their first 20" after yrs of fishing or they can't believe that others are catching them somewhat frequently. Do you think these folks would be convinced that the restrictions have helped?.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The simple answer in my mind,,,,,

The regs can only help it get better; not worse.
Extend the regs down to the Coon Rapids dam.
If the regs save a fish today from being harvested, it saves the possibility that it can grow to be a trophy some day.
Maybe it was great years ago, and as stated very few people were seen fishing it many years ago. Today it IS getting fished more, so either try to protect it or let nature take its course.

Bring on the regs!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Cliff Wagenbach
      The walleye bite on the East end of Vermilion has been very good since the opener. Some days can be a little challenging but we have managed to limit out every day out since the opener! Not to often that that has happened! The average keeper size has been very consistent also. 14" to 16" fish most days out. Getting a few slot fish also. 26" is our biggest so far but quite a few 20" to 23" walleyes too. Lindy rigs with a glow bead and pike suckers has been my only presentation since the opener. Fish are being caught in 14' to 33' depths. Cliff    
    • Herky2002
      Herky Jr. picked up a couple nice white bass, one trolling and one jigging. We turned them into delicious fish tacos!
    • Cliff Wagenbach
      I heard today that he has a bad rotater cup and is scheduled for surgery. Cliff
    • Horseshoe_Don
      small mouth are still spawning
    • Wanderer
        Yah!  The foldable ones you can.    Or, if you don't get a roof carrier you could just leave one hanging out an open window or the hatch like you're making a lumber run.
    • CaptJohnWis
      They are BITING - bugs that is - har!   Bass have been very good some days and slooooow on others. Bugs have been awful last few trips. But the dragonflies have hatched out so they will be putting the gobble on the black flies and mosquitoes so things should improve.   Walleyes have finally showed up on the bank. Bass have been there awhile now. Went to Pelican one day and got some largemouths. The special regs there have really helped the bass fishing. Crappie are in spawning colors at several different lakes I have sampled this last week. Everything pretty much shallow but did get some walleyes in 15 FOW,    
    • Surface Tension
       Thanks for the report Randy!
    • JeremyCampbell
      So does this mean I should go shopping for a kayak?  But ya I should get one thoughWonder if I can fit one in a mini van.
    • Wanderer
      Yup!  I think that's where we're all heading!  'Cept I'll be in Ely.  Otherwise I'd join ya.   Have a good time, safe trip and catch lots! 
    • eyeguy 54
      I just wanna fish Saturday.