Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

  • Announcements

    • Rick

      Members Only Fluid Forum View   08/08/2017

      Fluid forum view allows members only to get right to the meat of this community; the topics. You can toggle between your preferred forum view just below to the left on the main forum entrance. You will see three icons. Try them out and see what you prefer.   Fluid view allows you, if you are a signed up member, to see the newest topic posts in either all forums (select none or all) or in just your favorite forums (select the ones you want to see when you come to Fishing Minnesota). It keeps and in real time with respect to Topic posts and lets YOU SELECT YOUR FAVORITE FORUMS. It can make things fun and easy. This is especially true for less experienced visitors raised on social media. If you, as a members want more specific topics, you can even select a single forum to view. Let us take a look at fluid view in action. We will then break it down and explain how it works in more detail.   The video shows the topic list and the forum filter box. As you can see, it is easy to change the topic list by changing the selected forums. This view replaces the traditional list of categories and forums.   Of course, members only can change the view to better suit your way of browsing.   You will notice a “grid” option. We have moved the grid forum theme setting into the main forum settings. This makes it an option for members only to choose. This screenshot also shows the removal of the forum breadcrumb in fluid view mode. Fluid view remembers your last forum selection so you don’t lose your place when you go back to the listing. The benefit of this feature is easy to see. It removes a potential barrier of entry for members only. It puts the spotlight on topics themselves, and not the hierarchical forum structure. You as a member will enjoy viewing many forums at once and switching between them without leaving the page. We hope that fluid view, the new functionality is an asset that you enjoy .
Sign in to follow this  
Iron Cowboy

Powder or Pellets

Recommended Posts

Iron Cowboy

Loose powder. Easily adjust loads, more of a complete burn, better accuracy AND about half the price. Go to a few Muzzleloader forums and it becomes obvious that 90% of the pellet users are beginners or someone that never took the time to learn about the gun.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
bigg edd

The problem with pellets are that they give you one or two options- 100 grains or 150 grains. I have 3 guns that all shoot a different bullet with a different powder amount. you would be surprised what 10 or 15 grains of powder will do to your group.
I use from 80 to 90 grains of 777. The two .50's use 80 grains. One a 385g. Hornady Great plains bullet, the other a Buffalo Bullet Co.'s 245g. ball-et. The .54 uses 90 grains of 777 with a Buffalo Bullet Co.'s Maxi ball-et.

[This message has been edited by bigg edd (edited 11-24-2003).]

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
HunterLee

Have any of you guys that muzzleload noticed or tried both the pellets and loose powder. Are there any major changes? HOw many grains you guys use. me 100 grains and shot a deer walking at bout 150 yads during the shotgun season.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
SCCO9803

I use regular black powder, 110 grains is what I deer hunt with. I prefer the regular powder because I like to carry a ditty bag and powder horn. More traditional, I guess

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
jigglestick

i use (and have for years) a cva 50 cal traditional percussion rifle with a hunert grains of ff black powder. i cast my own round balls and visually inspect them for imperfections. it seems once the mold gets good and hot, the balls come out so much better. at 70 yards with open sights i hav a 3-4 inch grouping that is feared by the likes of a poorly timed white tail smile.gif
a friend bought a new style break action rifle this year that uses the 209 primers. we have had a hell of a time getting any kind of consistency out of two 50 grain pyrodex pellets. he was using two different sizes saboted projectiles. he then went to just one 50 grain pellet, and could drive tacks. i would not recomend throwing that combination at a deer however, and suggested some where in between. there lies the problem with pellets. he did find some 30 grain pellets, and is going to try them. i also suggested loose powder, but the problem i see is the hole for the 209 primer is so big that powder will fall right through. maybe he could put the primer in first?? doesn't sound like the best idea to me.
i'll stick with my cva smile.gif
good luck every one!!

keep your smoke stick in your hand!! jigglestick I.B.O.T. #5

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
bigg edd

Hey jigglestick,
you could plug the hole with a spent primer until you were ready to hunt. I know this would be a pain but there is no way I would load the gun with a live primer in the gun. You might be able to get a breech plug that uses a nipple and #11 caps, ths would solve the powder through the primer hole issue. I have never used pellets and I don't shoot in-lines, not that I have anything against them, but I never thought about the problem of loose powder falling through a breech plug that uses 209 primers. has anyone else run into this problem?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Iron Cowboy

I have an inline with the 209 primer system and this is not a problem at all. I even shoot the real fine FFF triple 7 and have never had one issue with it over many rounds. The hole that the primer fits in is only as deep as the primer itself, then theres a real tiny pin hole the rest of the way thru the plug for the fire to travel. Its too small for powder to get in. The inline makers obviously have it figuired out. Otherwise they would have big problems. There are thousands of people with the new inlines shooting loose powder

[This message has been edited by Iron Cowboy (edited 11-25-2003).]

[This message has been edited by Iron Cowboy (edited 11-25-2003).]

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
delmuts

we shoot both granular and pellets. agreed, we get a little better groups at longer ranges( 100 +) with granular. but my daughter now hunts with my 50. shooting pellets she can hold a three in group at 75 yds.most of her shots are less than 75. to reload she don't have to worry about pouring the powder . i do plan to go to the 30 gr pellets and shoot a 90 g. charge, after we burn up the 50 g. ones. del

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
bigg edd

I went to gander this afternoon and Iron Cowboy is right- the in-line breech plugs taper down to a very small hole that would not be a issue with loose powder, at least not in any of the guns I looked at.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
icehousebob

I've built, competed with, and hunted with traditional Hawken style guns for 30 years. I use a powder horn with FFG plus a short starter - powder measure combination of my own design. With those and a loading block for patched round balls, I can get off a really quick second shot. I work up loads a few grains at a time with each new gun. That's something you can't do with the pellets.
One thing I would warn you guys of; someone suggested leaving the old cap on the nipple while you reload. Big no-no. The trapped air can pop the bullet back up after you've rammed it down. If there is a gap between the powder charge and the ball, it can cause a bulge in the barrel. I saw a couple of barrels that needed replacing because of that. The nipple hole has to be open to vent the air.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
jlm

Hey Jiggle-
I don't know alot about muzzel loaders as I am just getting into them but somthing caught me funny about what you were talking about. If your friend had a break action, isn't that a magnum muzzle loader? AS far as I know only CVA and T/C makes them and I know all CVA's are magnums which enables them to shoot 150 gr. of powder. Perhaps your freind was underloading hte gun which produced bad groups. Just my thoughts, I hope he get the bugs worked out!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
say_der

jlm - I don't believe all CVA's can take magnum charges. Their break action Optima Pro can handle them, but they do make non-break open designs that are not rated for magnum loads. All in-lines might, but only newer ones. Might want to check on that.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Borch

I currently am using two 50 gr 777 pellets. With the 295 powerbelts I'm shooting under 2" groups at 100 yards. With loose powder I might be able to improve the groups. But really, It's acceptable to me as it is.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
jlm

Sayder-
I guess my post is a little unclear after reading it again. That is what I meant, if it is a break action, it should be a magnum load. All CVA's are not magnums by any means, only the break actions like the Optima, Optima Pro, the PR3000 or whatever, and the others they have. Sorry if I confused anyone!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  



  • Posts

    • Hoey
      Wow sorry to hear that.  It must of been busy there for it to be picked up so quickly.  I hope you get it back.  
    • Hoey
      Seasons Greetings to all.  It is ice fishing season!!!  Hurrah. I fished Friday and Saturday.  I arrived on Thursday evening and found a lot of opinions on the safety aspect of the ice.  The resort is ultra conservative in their assessments, and this should be expected as they have a lot at risk.  First ice explorers always push the limits.  For example one sled is on the bottom after breaking through 2 inches of unexpected weak ice, a week ago Sunday.   I found 11 inches were I traveled and fished, only going out a couple miles.  There is a lot of eight inch thick broken ice chunks to work around and through.  The bite Friday was very good.  Catching numbers were high, but size kept it from being great to excellent.  I ended up one fish short of my walleye/sauger limit.  My four sauger were 15 to 16 inchers - nice.  My three walleye were 15 to 17 inchers.  I had two for dinner.  So on Saturday I was looking for three nice walleye.  The bite was much slower.  We had an east wind with rising temps.  I was anticipating another Friday type bite.  It was generally zero to eight degrees every morning.  I finally ended the Saturday with two 17 inch walleye, one short of my limit again.   I plan to be back during the week following Christmas through New Years with family and friends.   Good Luck and practice safety!!!  
    • monstermoose78
      Yeah Borden Can be good.
    • Rick
      By Kristi Coughlon, DNR information officer Minnesotans are a generous lot. For the past 40 years, they’ve made it possible for the Minnesota Nongame Wildlife Program to help thousands of native species survive and thrive – including animals that are threatened, endangered and rare.  The program is now wrapping up its 40th anniversary with hopes that supporters will wrap up an end-of-year donation to put under the holiday tree in celebration of the many wildlife success stories it’s helped create, like the comeback of bald eagles and trumpeter swans. Success comes with a price tag, and rare species don’t collect a paycheck. They rely on our help. Unlike other DNR programs, the Nongame Wildlife Program doesn’t get general tax money; it receives no fees from hunting or fishing licenses. It’s funded almost entirely by voluntary donations made by people who want to ensure that Minnesota continues to have healthy natural systems that support a wide diversity of wildlife. Many of those donations are made when Minnesotans file their state income taxes, designating an amount on the line with the loon to go to the Nongame Wildlife Program. But people can donate anytime, online or by mail. Donations fund critical habitat restoration work, research projects, surveys to assess the status of threatened and endangered species, and outreach and education such as the popular eaglecam that reaches into millions of homes and classrooms in all 50 states and at least 160 countries around the world. Donations are tax deductible and matched dollar for dollar by the Reinvest in Minnesota (RIM) license plate fund. Donations also are used as match to federal grants and other outside funding sources, leveraging additional money to support nongame species conservation, research and habitat protection projects Looking for other reasons to donate? Here’s forty – one for each year of the program’s efforts: Monarch butterfly, bald eagle, forcipate emerald dragonfly, northern barrens tiger beetle, moneyface native mussel, Roger’s snaggletooth snail, tiger salamander, timber rattlesnake, jumping spider, common loon, red-tailed prairie leafhopper, wood frog, great plains toad, Blanding’s turtle, skipjack herring, tricolored bat, trumpeter swan, eastern bluebird, osprey, mudpuppy, golden-winged warbler, eastern hog-nose snake, pileated woodpecker, smoky shrew, wood turtle, American white pelican, piping plover, headwaters caddisfly, black tern, peregrine falcon, northern goshawk, slender madtom fish, boreal owl, rusty-patched bumble bee, red-shouldered hawk, yellow rail, plains pocket mouse, Juanita sphinx moth, northern bog lemming. And many more. During this season of giving, consider giving $40 for forty years to help Minnesota’s Nongame Wildlife Program continue its critical work to conserve wildlife species that aren’t hunted, from songbirds to salamanders, from butterflies to bats. Learn more at mndnr.gov/nongame. Discuss below - to view set the hook here.
    • Rick
      Special fishing regulations will change March 1 on a number of Minnesota waters following an annual public input and review process, according to the Department of Natural Resources.  “Anglers need to know special regulations because they take precedence over statewide regulations,” said Al Stevens, fisheries program consultant with the DNR. “We have special regulations to improve fish populations and make fishing better or more sustainable.” Special regulations for individual waters are listed in a separate section of the Minnesota Fishing Regulations booklet and at mndnr.gov/fishmn, and are posted at public accesses. For this spring, new statewide northern pike zone regulations that take effect on inland waters will make it possible to do away with several previously existing special regulations that apply to individual waters and aim for similar outcomes as the zone regulations. The new statewide pike regulations go into effect in time for the fishing opener on Saturday, May 12. On waters that have a special fishing regulation, anglers are required to follow the special regulation and unless otherwise mentioned, all other regulations apply. Public process for special regulations
      Special regulations are put in place after fisheries managers write plans for the lakes they oversee and each provides objectives for achieving management goals. Before changes are made to special regulations, the DNR evaluates each regulation, shares what’s found in the evaluations and angler surveys, hosts public input meetings in the fall and reviews comments from the public about the regulations. Goals of individual lake management plans also are considered. “We need the public to tell us what they want for the process to work well, and we do value the input,” Stevens said. For this spring, 29 lakes and connected waters were reviewed. Changes detailed
      Pelican Lake in St. Louis County: A special regulation on bass will be made permanent, while a regulation on northern pike will be dropped. An evaluation of the regulations showed that the 14-20 inch protected slot limit with one over 20 inches in possession on bass maintained a quality bass fishery, while allowing for an opportunity to harvest smaller bass. The regulation was generally popular with anglers and will continue. The 24-36 inch protected slot limit on northern pike provided some benefit to the pike population; however, the benefits of the regulation are similar to the new statewide zone regulation, which provides the opportunity to drop the regulation and simplify regulations complexity for anglers. Sand Lake and connected waters (Little Sand, Portage, and Birds Eye lakes) in Itasca County: A special regulation for northern pike will be dropped, and the lakes will change to the statewide limits. The new statewide zone regulation for northern pike will likely be just as effective as the special regulation in encouraging harvest of abundant small pike while improving sizes of pike. Big Swan Lake in Todd County: A 24-36 inch protected slot limit with only one fish over 36 inches will be made permanent after the review showed sizes of pike have improved. Also, the regulation’s expanded possession limit of six, with only one fish over 36 inches, will remain in effect as the number of small pike has continued to remain higher than desired. Balm, Big Bass, South Twin and Deer lakes in Beltrami County; Portage Lake in Cass County; and Flour, Hungry Jack and Two Island lakes in Cook County: These eight lakes with restrictive size regulations (either a 12-20 inch protected slot or catch-and-release only regulation) on bass will be modified to a less restrictive, 14-20 inch protected slot with one over 20 inches to allow additional harvest of small bass while still protecting quality sized fish. Although the existing regulations were shown to be effective, the new protected slot is expected to provide a similar protection to quality fish and with the added benefit of allowing additional harvest of abundant smaller bass. Itasca, Ozawindib and Mary lakes in Itasca State Park: Special regulations on sunfish, black crappie and bass for three lakes in the park will be standardized among the lakes. While the existing regulations largely have been effective and have been generally popular with park visitors, the DNR will standardize sunfish and crappie possession limits to five, drop a minimum size restriction on crappie for Ozawindib Lake and modify the current restrictive bass regulations (catch-and-release on Mary Lake and the 12-20 inch protected slot on Ozawindib Lake) to a 14-20 inch protected slot with one over 20 inches for both lakes. The goal is to simplify regulations for park visitors while maintaining fishing quality. Sissabagamah and Long lakes in Aitkin County: Special regulations on northern pike will be dropped in favor of the new statewide zone pike regulation. Some benefits to the sizes of pike have been seen since a protected slot regulation was enacted; however, the north-central zone pike regulations may provide a similar or even better outcome and also serve to reduce regulation complexity. Bass Lake in Todd County and Cedar Lake in Morrison County: Trophy regulations (40 inch minimum length requirement, possession limit of one) on northern pike will be modified to a 26 inch maximum with a possession limit of three. While trophy northern pike still exist, growth rates of smaller pike in these lakes have declined. Allowing harvest opportunity on pike under 26 inches may help the population while still protecting medium to large pike. Kraut, Peanut, North Shady, Squash and Tomato lakes in Cook County: Catch-and-release regulations on trout in these five lakes will be dropped this spring. Additionally, the ban on winter fishing and special tackle restrictions for these lakes will go away. The catch-and-release with tackle restrictions and the winter fishing closure did not meet management goals for these stocked trout fisheries. They are remotely located and special regulations and the closed winter season did not provide quality fishing in these lakes. But the same special regulations will continue on three other lakes – Thompson, Thrush and Turnip lakes – that were reviewed at the same time. Moody Lake in Crow Wing County: This lake will reopen to fishing after having been closed to fishing since 2001. Entirely located within an aquatic management area, the lake has been used as a fisheries research lake and at times was used for rearing walleye. It no longer is needed for that purpose and plans are to reclaim the lake by using rotenone to remove undesirable fish and then restock with walleye, yellow perch and bass, and implement a catch-and-release regulation to maintain quality sized fish for anglers to enjoy. Little Boy and Wabedo lakes in Cass County: These lakes will have an 18-26 inch protected slot, with one over 26 inches, in a possession limit of four walleye – which will be in effect for 10 years and then re-evaluated. The regulation was proposed in response to local requests to improve and protect the walleye population, which will likely benefit from restrictions on harvesting walleye longer than 18 inches. Visit mndnr.gov/fishmn for more information on special fishing regulations. Special regulations that change March 1 will be listed in the 2018 Minnesota Fishing Regulations booklet. Discuss below - to view set the hook here.
    • Chill62
      We made our annual trip up to Red Lake Indian Reservation on Saturday.  Fished the whole day chasing rainbow and brook trout.  Before anyone tries to call me out it's legal to fish trout on the reservation during the winter and it's actually the only thing you can legally keep on the tribal waters during the winter.  We did have a guide and he was amazing and was cheap!  14 adults and 2 kids and we ended up keeping 65 trout out of 76 possible.  We left the ice by 2 so could have finished out the day and easily "Limited out" but we had enough to make us happy.  Its so weird being in 8' of water catching trout when you think they should be in 30-60'.  I'm done working for the year so its time to drill some holes locally and try to have some fun.  Local reports are hit and  miss but seeing friends catching stuff and a mixed bag.  Its awesome to see guys with 3-4 different species that they are catching.  Buddy was on Melissa last night and found 3" of ice.  So please be careful and I read an article today that someone went through on Mud Lake by Big Floyd and someone went through on Little Cormorant.  FYI those that fish Big Floyd a buddy reported to me that the deep hole just froze over end of last week and he was saying there was a 75 x 75 opening that wouldn't freeze up. Hopefully with cold air coming in over Christmas we can get lakes to be drive-able shortly. 
    • wallyeye
      My rod bag with 5 rods in it fell off my sled while walking out from the public access on Sat. afternoon.
      I didn't notice until I had walked out to a spot and drilled some holes and started to get set up to fish.
      By the time I walked back to shore the bag had been picked up.


      Please let me know if you have any info.
      Thank you,
      Guy Walburn
      Owatonna, MN
    • crappie king 42
      Looked like a good time guys. Wish i could have been there unfortunatly i had to work. I hope i can make the next one. 
    • bjamin
      Got out Saturday afternoon and after putting in some time drilling holes finally found panfish in 20-24 ft, almost in the basin areas I'd look mid winter.  Crappie and sunfish were mixed and we caught almost all of our fish on a small jig and waxworm.  Tried minnows and only caught a couple fish that way, even when we were catching fish on waxworms in a hole 3 ft away.  They seemed to want something to chase so keeping the jig moving and pulling away from them helped quite a bit.  Had 10" of ice where we were fishing and was pretty consistent, but there's lots of reports of extremely varying ice thickness so keep checking ice thickness on your way out. 
    • Chill62
      WARNING a buddy was on  MELISSA and was aiming towards the crappie hole in the NE Corner/First break to fish out there last night.  He was checking ice and was having 10" of ice then hit 3"!  Please be careful out there.  Needless to say he turned around and went back to the access.