Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Craig_S

Fly Fishing

15 posts in this topic

It's open water season, and time to try new things. There's been posts here in the past, and I've responded about fly fishing options. It's better than the ice for me. I don't have the time to fish right now, but have experience. The next month and a half will provide for the best crappie fishing on fly in the world. Anybody else have experience here?

Craig and Kiddo

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well then. I'll talk to myself. Two years ago a friend (flyman, you out there?) clued me in on how to do this. Simple. Twist some stuff on a hook and see what it does. There's nothing like sitting amongst a bunch of minnow hangers and hearing, "what the hell is he doing? HELL he's fly fishing. Look...he's got one. He's got another. Another. What the *****?" I can beat a bait hanger most days. My own design. Me and my ball of fur. Try it!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Greetings, ay.

This is Bob... drop me a note on e-mail... scaupp@hotmail.com

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Craig S. I'll respond. I believe you recommended the clouser to me last year. Well I was at URL last spring and did manage to catch them on the fly. It was a red white clouser and it sure was interesting. I sure got some funny looks from people in boats around me, it was a bit windy so I didn't get to experiment much. The latest issue of Crappie magazine has a article on fly fishing crappies and recommended time tested flies. Guess what is at the top of the list? The clouser. Other flies mentioned are wholly buggers and beaded nymphs. The article was also pretty specific on what appears to be characteristic on fly fishing crappies. Jig fisherman and live bait in the long run will outfish the fly guy, but there will be those specific times when the fly guy will be the only one with the "majic". Sounds like you get a good chance to experiment, if you have any more recommendations I sure will try them.

Thanks.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Craig, thanks for sharing, it is much appreciated. Your right, most of the bites came right on the fall. Will definitely give a good workout this spring.

I was curious, have you found any differences in the success rate of fly fishing from early spring to late spring/early summer because of the obvious water temperature changes?

Good fishing to ya.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yep, it's true that about 50-50 bait might be better, but there's a few tips to beat the odds. 1. Get a rig that will cover some distance. Weight forward line and heavy to cover some water. Use a 9' leader and get the sink rate right - SLOW. Plop it out there and let it sink. Most bites will be on the fall before you strip an inch. Then strip real slow - 6" at a time. Never give up the cast. They might wait until boatside to hit. 2. The spot. Cruise slow with a depthfinder and locate a "pod" of fish. Usually 6' to 9' of water, away from other boats so they don't laugh at you. 3. The clouser. Size 4 hook, small yellow eyes, black on top, natutal brown bucktail middle, white belly with 4 strands gold crystal flash. Size 4 may sound a bit big, but the action is the key and they'll suck it right down to the throat. A size 6 you'll have to cut out.

Don't give up!

Craig and Kiddo

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Best time for me has been about walleye opener through the first week in June. After mid June, there's fish, but scattered. Big northerns turn on about the first of July, so there's not much reason not to be fishing. If my wife could just understand that!

Craig and Kiddo

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have never tried it, but I don't doubt that it would work wonderfully. The best trips to Red were when we could track the crappie movement through watching them "dimpling" as we call it. This is when they are on the surface feeding on insects, the numbers of fish doing this up there is amazing. A fly fisherman would be in heaven.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

huskminn,

I'm talking only about URL. I haven't done crappie on fly anywhere else. I also have a 5 weight, but wish I had more. I've used an 8 in the Bahamas and think that might be a bit of overkill, but nice to have along. Once you locate a "pod" of fish, they tend to move around on ya. Sometimes it's a fish every cast, sometimes you know they're just out of reach. I'm no expert and with the 8 can do about 50-60 feet. With the 5 only 35-40. If you're good with the 5, that may be all that's needed. Give it a try. You likely won't be disappointed.

Craig and Kiddo

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Craig,

In the above post, you mention that you've done best between opener and early June. Are you talking specifically of URL?

I'm a fly-fisher, as well. I've never been on URL in open water, but I am seriously trying to put a trip together up there soon.

Is my 5 wt too light? Should I use my 8 wt instead? The latter seems like over-kill to me.

Your comments would be appreciated.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Craig,

Thanks for the response. The more I think about it, the more I believe that the 8 wt is simply too much rod for crappies. The 5 should work nicely and be a lot more fun, which is the whole point. Perhaps my wife will let me borrow her 6 wt if she isn't along to use it.

Man, now I really have the bug to head up there. Hope it works out. Thanks for the help.

Good luck.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm tying flies. huskminn, gls, email me your address and I'll mail you a "crappiemaster". No other inquiries, thankyou.

crschmid@paulbunyan.net

Craig and Kiddo

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Fish around that area every year. Two years ago I had 14 crappies on twister tails and decided to use the fly rod...7 1/2' with a 5 weight line. Caught oodles of crappies but was disappointed in the fight. They tend to come up to the top and trash around cuz that is how fly rods work. People looked at me kinda funny, but I was catching 5 to their 1. Prefer the 1# gills on the fly rod.... Will be there one of the first two weeks after Memorial Day

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Bankdick (ah yes, W.C.Fields....)

Just wondering, were in you a boat or wading on shore? Care to divulge what you were using for the fly presentation?

I tend to agree with the sunfish statement, but when I'm on URL I'll take what is given and what is given isn't too bad.

Thanks for any response.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

No secret on the flies. They were stacked in the northeast corner as you come out of the river. Use the larger of my flies however. Size 8's in black gnat, yellow fly with black hackle and all white fly. Didn't seem to matter.

I make all my own "stuff"..flies, poppers ice jigs for panfish etc.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • redlabguy
      Nuts, I had to leave Fraser on Monday for some business and a trip, but I think your MO is the right one. However, there are a lot of small (10-12") fish on the reef tops as of Sunday. You might try deeper water just off the tops. I'm not a fan of bobber fishing (like to feel the bite) but it's been a consistent winning method. Dick
    • monstermoose78
      He is huge 
    • fisherjmb
      Thanks for the info guys. We did end up going and launching at Beanies. Ten bucks to launch. Not too bad. There is a for sale by owner sign posted there but it's obviously private for now. As for the fishing, it was slow. Pulled the plug at noon and headed for the Mississippi. Did much better there.
    • JB18
      i wanted a yellow lab and got over ruled on the chocolate.  Great looking dog!  Does not look 115 pounds
    • JB18
          Thanks!  She is only 40 pounds at 9 months old.  Don't think she will get much bigger. I was hoping to talk with some people at the game farm next month to see if i can get a great price on a pre-buy program.    I have some pheasant feathers and she goes crazy when she see me grab them.  I need to find a field that the grass is not chest high to plant them or better yet get some game birds and tie the feet off and plant those.    If you drive by Round Lake and see a red Tundra stop in and say hello. I am there most nights when it gets this hot.        
    • TNtoMN_HuntFish
      Awese thread! I take our golden/lab mix to Round Lake for training also. This pic is from May when it was chilly. We're having an absolute blast working together. She's a sweet dog, will do anything to please me if she understands. Only thing I have to do before the season is somehow introduce her to gunshots and that's not easy without private land. Watching her barrel through the cattails to find that dummy is awesome. 
    • leech~~
      There are a few small Trout lakes in there as well but not sure how they bite in the summer? I've only Ice fished them.  
    • mnfathead
      Thanks Cliff, weather looks dynamite so that's a good start!
    • airnuts
      Finally making it up for our first trip of the year. Strictly walleye fishing in Frazer Bay with slip bobbers around the reefs. Appreciate any fishing reports. Thanks!
    • ZachD
      I believe they take vets living in veteran homes around the area like Silver Bay veteran home ect