Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

  • RECEIVE THE GIFTS MEMBERS SHARE WITH YOU HERE...THEN...CREATE SOMETHING TO ENCHANT OTHERS THAT YOU WANT TO SHARE

    You know what we all love...

    When you enchant people, you fill them with delight and yourself in return. Have Fun!!!

  • 0
Sign in to follow this  
uffdapete

GPS advice

Question

uffdapete

Looking for advice on buying a handheld GPS unit to be used primarily for marking fishing spots. Are there decent units out there for around $150 or less, and if so, what are your recommendations? Also, any accessories that should be considered? Thanks!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

14 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

  • 0
huskminn

This is a topic I've been meaning to bring up for quite some time.

I have a cheapie Magellan Pioneer. It has been sufficient at finding spots on Mille Lacs, which is primarily where I have used it.

Scoot, you mentioned WAAS.....what is that? I assume it's a feature that utilizes the recent "de-classification" of more accurate GPS readings by the gov't.

I recently marked a hump on an area lake after finally finding it. I went back there last week, punched in the go-to spot and the darn thing was off by two tenths of a mile. That was the first indication that my unit is less than what I need.

I don't want to spend a lot of cash on a new GPS......in fact I've tapped my budget for the year, but how much better performance can I expect from a newer unit?

One more question, when I marked that spot recently, I hit the "mark" button and entered in the descriptors as I continued to drift along. By the time I finished everything, I was quite a ways away from the original spot. It was my assumption that the "mark" would hold the original spot unless changed. Am I correct in that assumption?

Thanks for any info anyone can provide!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
Guest

I have a Garmin GPS III and I like it. It has always been a trusty unit for year round use. Has mapping features, just about everything. Garmin discontinued this model a couple years ago or so and I still see them in the stores once in awhile for around $150-$175. The GPS III Plus is better and I have seen them as low as $250.
Garmin also makes other small units for under $150 (i.e. e-trek?) Check them out.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
Guest

scoot- what unit are you refering to? The global map is the size of a cell phone and yes most handhelds are battery eaters thats why the cig adapter is good to have. Also the Wide Area Augmentation System is currently avalible in the Raytheon 300-$569.99 and the garmin 76-$219.00. The ifinder has been out for awhile $249.99.

[This message has been edited by D-man (edited 07-26-2001).]

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
Scott

Huskminn, When you marked your spot it should have saved the coordinates immediately. I'm not familiar with the Pioneer, but you may have a staus screen that will display the number of feet that you could be off by. On my global Nav this is shown on the screen that marks the satelites. Good luck

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
Guest

Huskminn, whenever you quick save a spot it will save that spot when you save it. Is your unit 12 channel? Is it properly configured for the Mille Lacs area if thats what your fishing? The bottom line in electronics is you get what you pay for. WAAS units and a DGPS reciever are the most accurate but you have to spend some money. Do you really need to get right back on top of the same spot? Fish move so much spending the extra money does not seem worth it. As long as you get back in the same depth you should be all right. Good Luck..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
huskminn

Comet to think of it, my unit is configured for the Mille Lacs area, but the spot I had trouble with is in the metro area. Would that make a difference?

The unit is a 12 channel and does display the distance to the go-to coordinates. When I found the spot on my own, my GPS indicated I was .23 miles directly south of the coordinates I had previously marked.

I don't worry too much about getting back to the exact same spot, but at times, when I bobber fish at night, I do like to get to a specific hump, dip or ridge.

I can see that I may want to invest in a new unit sometime later this year. I'd love to have one that interfaces with a PC, too.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
Bodyman

I got a Garmin etrex this last winter and have been very happy with it. It's the bottom price wise of the etrex line, around $120. Some of the other etrex's (summit, legend. ect)run well over 250/300, but then your paying for the mapping program and digital compass which you don't need for marking fishing spots. The etrex does have 12 channels, will run 18 hrs on 2 AA's and the cig power cord is $40. accessories are not cheap.

It also has a track back feature that's very accurate and alot of the options of the pricer units. It will also interface with my pc for upgrades in it's software and Map programs like Lake Master. Very compact about the size of a pack of smokes.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
Dave

I played with my Magellan ColorTrak a few times. When I stepped of about a 1/4 mile and hit goto (back to my starting point), I ended up about 20 feet from the original spot where I started. That's when the counter on the unit zero'd out. I think 20 feet is pretty accurate. I did it several times.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
Scoot

Huskin,

As somebody mentioned WAAS is an ancronym for Wide Area Augmentation System- basically it's just another means of cutting the error the units have in half. It is, however, a totally different means of cutting the error via the descrambling of the signal, which happened a while ago now.

D-man- The i-finder is advertised in magazines etc. now (and has been for quite a while), but Lowrance has not actually released functioning units yet (unless you know something I don't know). They've had a series of problems with the unit that they've caught before they've released it. I called Lowrance a couple of days ago and a rep. there told me that it would be several months until they released the unit to actually be purchased. So... it looks like the unit is out if you look in Bass Pro or Cabella's, but you can't actually get them yet.
As for the Global Map, it was just my opinion- don't take it personally. I felt like the unit was too heavy and bulky for me. I agree that the powercord is worth it's weight in gold, regardless of what type of unit you own, but I did think the Global Map really sucked the life out of batteries fast. From the sound of it the i-finder will basically be a Global Map that is thinner, lighter, smaller and will have better battery life- basically all of my gripes about the Global Map. Maybe I'll get one if they ever have a unit that they release!
Scoot

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
Guest

Lowrance 200 is what i have been using for ice fishing, Good resoultion, plenty of memory, make sure you get a case, cig lighter adapter, ram mount. List for about 180.00-200.00.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
Scoot

Uffda,

Do you want to have mapping capabilities with your unit? If yes, I strongly endourse the Magellan 330. If no, I'd save the money and get a Garmin 12 for $100 or less (can get really good deals on e-bay- this of course comes with the potential problems of dealing with that system). The 12 is a very basic unit, but if you want nothing more than to mark some spots on water it does the job. I don't believe that it has WAAS capabilities however, so you won't be able to narrow in on a spot quite as close as you would with a unit that did have WAAS- probably not a big deal for most.
I'm on my 4th GPS unit in the last year and a half and I really wasn't satisfied with any before the Magellan 330. I really liked the Lowrance Globalmap, but it was so big, bulky, and ate batteries faster than I could buy them. If you want to wait for a while Lowrance's i-finder should be out in a few months, but they've literally bumped that back half a dozen times and over 1.5 years- so who knows when it will show up on the market.
Good luck,
Scoot

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
Guest

All GPS units have their good and bad points. Accuracy can vary greatly over a days time, due to your angle from the sats.
If they are direcly overhead or within the 45deg. circle your accuracy will be reduced. The longer the angle used in the triagulation the greater the accuracy. WASS uses a second signal from another satalite pair. It does increase accuracy BUT, there are only two satalites. One over the Atlantic one over the Pacific. The signals are not easy to recieve here in the midwest unless you are in an aircraft about 1000' up.
In the $150 range there are several models that work well Garmin E-Trex, Magellan 315, Garmin 12, ect. Look at all the options in the unit, how easy are the functions accessed, battery life, accessory cost, screen clarity. There is no "best" one each has its own functions to fit a different consumers needs.

Rob

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
uffdapete

Thanks for all your input and advice. It makes it easier to ask for advice here and be able to think about it and then also to know what questions to ask on the sales floor.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
legendelite

Garmin GPS12...Bar None! Execellent price for a great unit. Very easy to use. I've had mine for 4 years now and wouldn't trade in for another unit.

You can e-mail me at legendelite@yahoo.com if you have any questions or need more information.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  



  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • Cret Jigs
    • eyeguy 54
      quite a few drifts where we were at. no 12 inchers but came close a few times. Smokin time friday.   grandkids are here and really enjoyed the cleaning process. Edin says,  his mouth is moving.  I bet he is saying why are you doing this to me...  LOL  gonna be 4 on Sunday. 
    • Tom Sawyer
      Can't believe there's that much snow left today....
    • eyeguy 54
      Found some dandies today for the smoker. Snow covered areas better than bare ice. 14 feet. 
    • Rick
      Fixed, thanks for the heads up.
    • Rick
      A series of events celebrating the 10-year anniversary of the passage of the Clean Water, Land and Legacy Amendment will take place throughout Minnesota in 2018. The first of these events will be from 1 to 4 p.m. Saturday, Jan. 27, at Silverwood Regional Park, 2500 County Road E, St. Anthony.  Adults and kids who attend the Parks and Trails Legacy Celebration at Silverwood Regional Park can try kick-sledding, ice fishing, a snowmobile simulator and other indoor and outdoor activities. Visitors can also hike among art sculptures throughout the park. Between activities, there will be s’mores and other light refreshments around a crackling bonfire. “The passage of the Legacy Amendment was a game-changer for organizations working to support Minnesota’s outstanding system of parks and trails,” said Erika Rivers, director of the DNR’s Parks and Trails Division. “At this event, and the statewide events to follow, we will not only highlight what has been accomplished over the past decade with Legacy funding but, perhaps even more important, we will gather input from people throughout the state—adults and kids alike—to help shape priorities moving forward.” Staff from the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources, the Metropolitan Council and the Greater Minnesota Regional Parks and Trails Commission will be on hand throughout the afternoon to lead activities and gather ideas. Metro Transit is providing free rides to the event. Get a downloadable bus pass at www.legacy.leg.mn/ptlac/2018-regional-events. Future Parks and Trails Legacy Celebration events will take place: Friday, April 27, 4-7 p.m., at the College of St. Benedict in St. Joseph. Saturday, May 5, 1-4 p.m. at the Red Baron Arena in Marshall. Friday, May 11, 4-7 p.m., at Hyland-Bush-Anderson Lakes Park in Bloomington. Saturday, May 19, 1-4 p.m. at 125 LIVE in Rochester. Saturday, June 2, 1-4 p.m. at Itasca State Park in Park Rapids. Saturday, June 16, 1-4 p.m. at Prairie Wetland Environmental Learning Center in Fergus Falls. Wednesday, June 27, 1-4 p.m. at Essentia Health Duluth Heritage Sports Center in Duluth. For more information, visit www.legacy.leg.mn/ptlac. For accommodations to participate, please contact Paul Purman at the DNR, paul.purman@state.mn.us or 651-259-5643. Discuss below - to view set the hook here.
    • wildsmallie
      Which river is good for char?
    • leech~~
      Here's a little back ground. The Dakota originally called the lake Mde Maka Ska (modern spelling Bde Maka Ska, pronunciation: Be-DAY Mah-KAH-Ska)[5] meaning White Earth Lake,[6] or White Bank Lake,[7] a name that probably was given by the Ioway who inhabited the area until the 16th century. Another Dakota name for the lake may have been Mde Med'oza, which was the name initially adopted by settlers, either as Lake Medoza or in translation as Loon Lake.[8] The Dakota also described it as Heyate Mde, meaning "Lake Set Back (from the River)".[9] The United States Secretary of War, John C. Calhoun, sent the Army to survey the area that would surround Fort Snelling in 1817. Calhoun had also authorized the construction of Fort Snelling, one of the earliest Euro-American settlements in the state. The surveyors renamed the water body "Lake Calhoun" in his honor. The Fort Snelling Military Reservation survey map created by Lt. James L. Thompson in 1839 clearly shows the lake as bearing the name "Calhoun".[10] Minneapolis skyline reflected in the lake in 2010 Calhoun's legacy as a pro-slavery politician has led critics to question whether he is the best person to be honored. In 2011 the Minneapolis Park and Recreation Board visited the issue. Their legal counsel concluded that the board could not legally change the name, as state law gives that power to the Commissioner of Natural Resources, and then only in the first 40 years after the name was designated. Following the Charleston church shooting in June 2015, a fresh drive to change the name started via an online petition. The Park Board indicated it would look into whether they could change the lake's name through state action,[11][12] and in fall 2015 added the Dakota name to signage below the official name.[1] On March 22, 2016, an advisory group decided via majority vote to urge the Minnesota Park and Recreation Board to restore the lake's former name.[13] In 2017, the Minneapolis Park Board voted unanimously to change the lake's name back to that of Bde Maka Ska[14] and the Hennepin County commissioners approved it more narrowly.[15] The change needs final approval at state and federal level in order to go into effect.[16] There was also a proposal to rename the lake for Senator Paul Wellstone, who is buried in nearby Lakewood Cemetery.[17]
    • Rick
      The Minnesota Department of Natural Resources today announced the State of Minnesota has approved changing the name of Lake Calhoun in Minneapolis to Bde Maka Ska. The DNR’s decision follows a Hennepin County Board resolution requesting the change.  “The DNR respects the role of elected county boards in determining name changes for geographic features,” DNR Commissioner Tom Landwehr said.  “In this instance, I am confident the Hennepin County Board carefully considered community values and citizen perspectives in determining that this was the right action to take. DNR’s role is to ensure the county followed the proper process.” The DNR’s decision means the lake name change will become official in Minnesota when the DNR’s approval is officially recorded by Hennepin County and published in the State Register. Hennepin County commissioners voted to seek the name change Nov. 28. The DNR will submit the Hennepin County resolution, along with the state approval, to the U.S. Board of Geographic Names, which will approve or deny the name change for federal use. The DNR is the state agency that approves or denies name changes for geographic features, after Minnesota counties consider name change resolutions, gather public input and vote on proposed changes. In considering county requests to name a geographic feature or change a feature’s name, the DNR’s role is to consider 1) whether the county followed a proper public process prior to taking its action, and 2) whether the county-approved name complies with naming conventions. For example, names must avoid confusion with similarly named features, and names may not commemorate a living person. A copy of the DNR’s order for this name change and details on how Minnesota geographic features are named are available on the naming geographic features webpage. Discuss below - to view set the hook here.
    • monstermoose78
      Saturday is the day I will open blue lake wide open If I have to
  • Share & Have Fun