Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

  • Announcements

    • Rick

      Members Only Fluid Forum View   08/08/2017

      Fluid forum view allows members only to get right to the meat of this community; the topics. You can toggle between your preferred forum view just below to the left on the main forum entrance. You will see three icons. Try them out and see what you prefer.   Fluid view allows you, if you are a signed up member, to see the newest topic posts in either all forums (select none or all) or in just your favorite forums (select the ones you want to see when you come to Fishing Minnesota). It keeps and in real time with respect to Topic posts and lets YOU SELECT YOUR FAVORITE FORUMS. It can make things fun and easy. This is especially true for less experienced visitors raised on social media. If you, as a members want more specific topics, you can even select a single forum to view. Let us take a look at fluid view in action. We will then break it down and explain how it works in more detail.   The video shows the topic list and the forum filter box. As you can see, it is easy to change the topic list by changing the selected forums. This view replaces the traditional list of categories and forums.   Of course, members only can change the view to better suit your way of browsing.   You will notice a “grid” option. We have moved the grid forum theme setting into the main forum settings. This makes it an option for members only to choose. This screenshot also shows the removal of the forum breadcrumb in fluid view mode. Fluid view remembers your last forum selection so you don’t lose your place when you go back to the listing. The benefit of this feature is easy to see. It removes a potential barrier of entry for members only. It puts the spotlight on topics themselves, and not the hierarchical forum structure. You as a member will enjoy viewing many forums at once and switching between them without leaving the page. We hope that fluid view, the new functionality is an asset that you enjoy .
Sign in to follow this  
FLaker

Activated Carbon Clothing

Recommended Posts

FLaker    0
FLaker

My camo is the same vintage as the 15 year old bow I just updated. I'm looking to get some new camo clothing and was wondering everyone's opinion on activated carbon gear (scent lok, blocker, etc. ). What do you have? When are the sales on? Do I need AC underwear and outerwear? Any advice would be appreciated.

FLaker

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
huntnfish    2
huntnfish

I personally don't believe in all the carbon clothing. I wash my clothes in scent killer and try to shower before I go out and then I just play the wind. The carbon clothing might be better but I don't think its all that much. I think if you try to be as scent free as possible you will be better off and save a little money.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Scoot    13
Scoot

I personally don't believe in all the carbon clothing. I wash my clothes in scent killer and try to shower before I go out and then I just play the wind. The carbon clothing might be better but I don't think its all that much. I think if you try to be as scent free as possible you will be better off and save a little money.

I agree with everything huntnfish said, except when he said "carbon clothing might be better"- that part I don't believe. Do an internet search on this and you'll see why it's a bunch of hogwash. Scentlok's in a huge legal mess right now, basically because they lied to the public about virtually everything their product does. All their product does is make them a lot of money. I'm sure plenty will chime in and say I'm wrong- that's fine- I won't argue the point or say any more. But... what huntnfish said is right.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
vister    0
vister

I agree with the last two fellas. To effectively "recharge" carbon, you'd have to burn it with a torch. Like mentioned, people will curse me for not liking a product they couldn't live without.

Last fall I too updated my old camo. I got rocky scent iq. I didn't buy it for it's scent blocking properties!!!!! It was the perfect camo pattern I wanted, mossy oak breakup, and it is so dang comfortable!! That was the selling point. By the way, I've had some strong bo before, and couldn't smell it through my camo. Maybe it does work?!?!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Bear55    0
Bear55

Carbon clothing may help a little but you are better off keeping your regular hunting camo clean, showering before the hunt, wearing rubber boots, and maybe spraying yourself down with scent killer. This alone will help you see and shoot more deer. Now if you are after a mature buck I don't believe you will be able to fool them, you may however buy yourself those few extra seconds to get a shoot off by keeping your body odor down. Most importantly always play the wind above everything.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
FLaker    0
FLaker

Thanks guys! I will buy what is comfortable and QUIET.

FLaker

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Rippinlip    0
Rippinlip

Great advice guys!

I look for the comfort, warmth(breathable), quietness first, play the scent game with washing hunting clothes in scent free laundry soap, showering and playing the wind..

Bought some nice clothes at your ...Marts, .....Farms,

Mark

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
GatorBait    0
GatorBait

Ya know, I was working at Gander when this stuff first came out. I purchased some this past year and tested it out. During our first part of bow season, it was a sweat fest, a great testing opportunity. Well, I hunted in that and in my regular non carbonated cheap clothes every other day and got the same results. Never spooked a deer or got winded during any of it. I did this for 2 weeks straight. It did't sell me enough to consider spreading the word. LIke above, I worry more about comfortable and quiet clothing, in which the gear was, but it's main purpose is a flaw imo. Fred Bear wasn't wearing all this hoopla and look at his success.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
harvey lee    13
harvey lee

I will use anything that may help me be as scent free as possible. I guess there is no way for the hunter to know if it helped them as deer can get spooked from many different situations.

As stated above, washing clothes will really help. I believe the biggest key is to pick a great stand location and get as high as possible and don't move.

Without a doubt, the higher one gets, the more one can get away with and playing the wind is even bigger.

Fred bear didn't use a compound either but I will.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
buckhunter21    0
buckhunter21

Like others have said go with quietness and comfort first and then just take as many steps as you can to keep yourself scent free. Not sure if the carbon works, the science suggests it doesnt but like Harvey said any little thing can help, if you are willing to spend some extra money I dont think a carbon suit will make your chances any worse.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
propster    0
propster

Scoot, love your disclaimer: "I'm not going to argue with you, I'm just telling you you're wrong." I also like how Scentlok is guilty because someone brought a lawsuit - I forgot our new slogan is guilty until proven innocent. And I'm glad to hear there's no frivolous lawsuits binding up our courts. I also get a kick out of people who will spend the money on and trust a little bottle of chemical spray but don't trust a full layer of activated carbon between them and their quarry. Just from a purely scientific standpoint, activated carbon has been proven time and time again to be one of the most effective and highest volume materials for adsorption of colorants and odorants and impurities that man has ever used. How many of you are willing to give up carbon filtration of your drinking water supply or wastewater treatment or countless other uses? The other comment about having to "torch" your carbon to recharge it is simply inaccurate, and trades on the common understanding that to reactivate carbon requires high heat in the neighborhood of 800-1100 degrees celsius to completely purge organic impurities. That may certainly apply to 100% regeneration, and especially to ac that is used to adsorb hazardous or industrial waste. In that scenario a chemical bond is actually created between the substrate (ac) and the impurity, and it does take very high energy (heat) to overcome that bond. But come on, we're talking about human odor here, one of the lowest level volatiles that exist, that binds to carbon with a physical attraction. The energy required to overcome that bond is pretty low. I certainly don't mean to come off as a know it all because there's all kinds of guys smarter than me that know this same stuff. I don't believe all the claims that these companies make, but I do have the kind of background where I can recognize that it is based on pretty sound science, and should maybe be judged on that vs purely anecdotal evidence. But if you want some of that too, I will say that since I've been using it I get away with murder in spots that I'd always get busted previously. Most guys I see, even some of the celebrities that endorse their product on tv, do all the right things then run into the fast food joint wearing their camo or wear it while driving or numerous other no-no's. It's no wonder people don't believe. But that's alright with me, all you naysayers keep on relying on hunting the wind only and hope it doesn't change on you. I'll keep using the stuff. Just my $.02.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Bear55    0
Bear55

propster I will agree with you that there probably is some gray area where human odor can be removed in the dryer but the question is how much is actually removed and how long before the suite becomes ineffective? Don't most carbon companies say you need to buy new gear something like every 3-5 years?

Also most all industrial use of carbon filters that I am aware of are used once and then thrown away or they have to reactivate the carbon at extremely high heat to reuse the material. Its not like the water or chemical filters are thrown in the dryer and reused.

I think was most of us are trying to say is that while carbon clothes may help some its not necessary and a lot of us have the same results by showering and keeping our clothing/gear as clean as possible.

I kind of classify carbon clothing with all the other legal hunting products out there, they can and do work but a lot of it is about marketing and sales and making $$$. There are also so many variables when we are out in the woods, for every person who claims to have had a deer downwind while wearing carbon I can find a guy who had a deer downwind of him while smoking or doing other things with no care for their scent.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Scoot    13
Scoot

Scoot, love your disclaimer: "I'm not going to argue with you, I'm just telling you you're wrong." I also like how Scentlok is guilty because someone brought a lawsuit - I forgot our new slogan is guilty until proven innocent.

propster, if you're going to quote me, please quote what I actually said. Writing it the way you did makes it look like I typed what you put in quotes, which isn't the case.

My comment about not arguing was intended to mean I wouldn't be interested in a back and forth discussion rehashing the "for vs. against" info about Scentlok. This is a tired, old discussion that I have no interest in joining in on.

If you think Scentlok works, buy it. If not, don't. I really don't care what you do. I'll take what I know about the product and conclude that it provides no benefit and is expensive. If you conclude otherwise, that's fine by me.

Also, I didn't conclude that they lied (i.e., were guilty) because they are in a legal battle. I said they are in a legal battle because they lied. I believe their product is a sham and that has nothing to do with the fact that legal action was taken against them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
vister    0
vister

Originally Posted By: propster
Scoot, love your disclaimer: "I'm not going to argue with you, I'm just telling you you're wrong." I also like how Scentlok is guilty because someone brought a lawsuit - I forgot our new slogan is guilty until proven innocent.

propster, if you're going to quote me, please quote what I actually said. Writing it the way you did makes it look like I typed what you put in quotes, which isn't the case.

My comment about not arguing was intended to mean I wouldn't be interested in a back and forth discussion rehashing the "for vs. against" info about Scentlok. This is a tired, old discussion that I have no interest in joining in on.

If you think Scentlok works, buy it. If not, don't. I really don't care what you do. I'll take what I know about the product and conclude that it provides no benefit and is expensive. If you conclude otherwise, that's fine by me.

Also, I didn't conclude that they lied (i.e., were guilty) because they are in a legal battle. I said they are in a legal battle because they lied. I believe their product is a sham and that has nothing to do with the fact that legal action was taken against them.

Im going to side with scoot here. i believe the money spent, 500 bucks complete, for a scentlock suit is outrageous, and unnecessary. everyone says play the wind. in the real world, while sitting in a woods or on a field edge, especially at dusk and dawn when deer are on the move, wind swirls and changes constantly, along with air thermals as the sun starts coming up. these thermal carry scent uphill just like wind.

take the worlds most renowned archer for instance. fred bear. did he wear scentlock. no. why, because it wasnt around for him while in his prime. but you know as well as I do that the hunting industry has become flooded with the must haves and other gimmicks. So fred would have been completely outfitted with the stuff. and im sure his furniture would have been upholstered in it too. only because marketing guru's would have gave it to him and said tell everyone it works! im sure it does, but i wont use it. i dress at the field approach. after washing my clothes scent eliminating detergent, drying them with earth scented dryer sheets, spraying them with earth scented odor eliminator, putting earth scented wafers in a tote with my clothes, rubbers boots from season start to finish, i think u get my point!! im very conscious of my scent elimination, so a 500 dollar suit i feel is wasted money. but, wear it if you want, theres a dozen other things i'll swear by before i swear by scentlock!!

the best cover scent out there is all over the countryside. walk through a dairy barn in your camo. you'll stink and deer are not bothered by it one bit!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
propster    0
propster

Hey Scoot, didn't mean to offend. It wasn't intended as a quote but as a paraphrase. I had hoped to make it obvious enough you could see I wasn't quoting you. Sorry, no blood no foul smile And I did misread your lied/guilty reference, I perceived it as more of a statement of fact.

Bear, I hadn't seen the instruction from either company that it lasted only 3-5 yrs, that's a new one on me. Must depend on how it's used, stored, and cared for. And as for the industrial filter use of carbon, I thought I agreed that was the only way to regenerate it was with high heat (or use a new one). Human odor is a very low level volatile and does not adsorb to carbon the same way as other stuff.

And I fully agree that much of what we buy for hunting stuff is based on marketing. How else do they get us to buy a new $800 bow every year when the one we have works perfectly well?

This stuff does work, but it's okay some others don't use it, gives me another edge - where I don't have to worry about the wind swirling. All good.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Scoot    13
Scoot

Hey Scoot, didn't mean to offend. It wasn't intended as a quote but as a paraphrase. I had hoped to make it obvious enough you could see I wasn't quoting you. Sorry, no blood no foul smile And I did misread your lied/guilty reference, I perceived it as more of a statement of fact.

No sweat. I think I was crabby when I replied to you... smirk My work is a mess right now, Fargo's flooding, and my kids don't seem to want to sleep-- yeah, I'm pretty sure I was crabby. blush

Like I said- if you like the product and believe it gives you an edge, then go for it. I don't believe that, so I won't. If people ask about it, I'll give my thoughts on the matter. If we don't agree... I'm ok with that.

I'm off to work and throw sandbags...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Wanderer    299
Wanderer

I think Scent-Lok was originally designed for those who wanted to hunt on the way home from work. No scent free wipes back then to wipe down the cologne or sweat after a full day.

Then the marketing geniuses got hold of the idea after they found out people were ready to throw money at em they way we did.

I have one of the original suits and swore by it the first couple years but don't even pick it up any more. I think part of the increase in success that I experienced had just as much to do with the fact I was getting more scent concious across the board and the suit was just one element.

I'm in the camp of "If you want to take every precaution you can and don't mind spending the dough - go ahead". But I wouldn't call carbon clothing a necessity anymore.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Bear55    0
Bear55

Bear, I hadn't seen the instruction from either company that it lasted only 3-5 yrs, that's a new one on me. Must depend on how it's used, stored, and cared for.

propster

This is from the FAQ page on the scentlok website.

Q: “How long will my Scent-Lok suit last?”

A: The lifespan of the product really depends on how you use it. We roughly say that it should last 3-5 years; about what you would expect from other hunting camo. If you are a knee walking, belly crawling extreme hunter in the woods five months a year, the life span may be shorter. If you are in the field for 20-30 days a year and follow our instructions, 3-5 years can be expected. Some hunters are still wearing our original suits today!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
vister    0
vister

This probably wont help any, but when i was in jr high school, i would go straight from the barn in my milking clothes to the bow stand. And to be honest, half the reason i went out there was to smoke so mom wouldnt catch me. sounds dumb, but i still saw deer. Little did I know having to wait for a deer to get so close would have me hooked for life. none of my friends bow hunted, and my dad shot in an archery league, so i was able to buy an old loud pse nova or something like that with arrows, flipper rest and sights with no fiberoptics. just metal pins. never killed an animal with that rig, but boy i lost lots of arrows!! My next bow was an old eagle oneida. i know some of you guys know of them, the recurve lookin limbs with the pulley system just above and below the riser. fast and loud.

i guess to get my point across, scent control has a lot to do with getting mature bucks into range. if anything is going to pick you off it will be an old doe. if you can fool them, you'll have a better chance at having an eary buck come by. if you feel scentlok will help, go for it, however, there are many other things you can and should do as well.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
ANYFISH2    375
ANYFISH2

I have worn my scentlok suit for 7 years now, and hope it holds up another 7. As far as its effectivness I can not say for sure, I wash and use other scent killing products just as if I was not using scentlok. It's never a good idea to leave every thing to chance.

I will tell you that it is the most comfortable and quietest hunting garment I have put on! It must have been cheaper 7 years ago because I only payed $150 for my suit, not alot more than alot of other camo nowadays.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
leech~~    439
leech~~

I thought that I read somewhere that they tested the suit's out with dogs, and the dogs found the person or what was wrapped up hinden in the suit everytime. I don't think it is as much of what the suit blocks, but what smells you got on the suit as you filled up at the gas station on the way to the cafe, with your buddy smoking in the truck and wearing your hunting clothes out at the fire or to the bar the night before! wink

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
propster    0
propster

I think that's a big part of it too Leech. As for the dogs, that doesn't concern me too much because it's not an apples to apples deal. Those dogs are unbelievably well-trained, and there's some that can track a person just by the grass or vegetation being broken, or by dandruff (and dead skin cells) falling off a person. Thank god deer aren't trained to find you, though sometimes it seems like it. I believe with care you can get it (your scent) to such a minimum that while they may still catch something it's not enough to spook them. Good luck up there in Fargo Scoot. We got our fingers crossed, relatives in Moorhead who live with this every year it seems.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Scoot    13
Scoot

Good luck up there in Fargo Scoot. We got our fingers crossed, relatives in Moorhead who live with this every year it seems.

Thanks for the well-wishes for Fargo. We're holding our own so far. Nothing like last year at this point, but still a ton of work and effort. I sure hope a long-term fix can be figured out that will work for everyone.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Sproguy    0
Sproguy

I will jump into this one, maybe I shouldn't! LOL

Carbon suits do work (or at least the testing shows they do) but only for a short time (1 to 5 seasons depending on amount of wear). The issue with Carbon suits is they can't be reactivated like we the consumer had originally hoped.

There is a solution, Silver! Silver is coming out in a lot of different options and in some cases it is good for the life of the garment and it works. (Again, the testing shows). I wore Medalist clothing with what they call Silvermax last season and had several different deer come in from down wind on me. Not always directly down wind and not always with nothing on their mind (buck with nose down!) so I feel it works. The best part is it works for the life of the garment. It also can be washed and worn like regular clothing, no really hot dryers needed.

I washed my clothes in Scent wash and used Scent killer spray and tried to make sure my body was free of orders with the proper soap and such so maybe it part of the process, either way, I am sold on Medalist. For now! 3 years from now we may be talking about something other than Silver as many are saying the same about Carbon. Kind of "older" technology, still works but has draw backs.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
propster    0
propster

Spro, just curious, what makes you say it can't be regenerated? Is it all the stuff you've read about regenerating ac that's been used to adsorb industrial waste, hazardous waste, or many things other than human odor? What are you basing it on? Also regarding silver, glad to hear you've had good luck with it, but what you seem to base it on is purely anecdotal experience. Which in today's age maybe that's as good as anything - if it appears to help, hard to argue. However, silver works as an antimicrobial, and it can only help prevent the formation of odor by bacteria acting on perspiration, but only if it is in constant contact with the skin. It does almost nothing in an outer garment because antimicrobials do absolutely nothing to most already-existing odors - they can't neutralize, adsorb, trap, oxidize, or prevent an odor that already exists. They do have their place, but here's a perfect analogy of how. If you go to work out in regular cotton gym clothes, work up a good sweat, put some perspiration odor into the clothes, then throw 'em in your bag and get home and forget about them for a week. Open it up and you go "Aaarggghh" - really smells. But if you were wearing an outfit made from antimicrobial fabric and do the same thing, you'll notice a little difference. Open it up after a week and it still smells, but not nearly as bad. It's because the am treatment prevented additional odors from growing in the fabric itself, unlike the cotton. What it didn't do though is get rid of the body odor you put into it a week ago, so while it can help, it really doesn't do everything most of them advertise it to do.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Sign in to follow this  



  • Posts

    • SkunkedAgain
      Jeez no. I can barely remember the netting discussion, let alone which side that I was arguing! Yup, you can see us cruising past quite often probably intent on satisfying the little one's quest for some ice cream at Moosebirds. She loves Sue and Ron. I'll definitely wave or stop by if I see you. I'll be up the next two weekends.
    • Wakemup
      How do you guys like to fish the west end as we transition into September and early fall? My next planned time at the cabin will be Labor day, I'm sure it'll be plenty busy on the lake but hoping to find a few quiet spots in the mornings and evenings to do some walleye fishing.
    • leech~~
      Plus+1  The size seems to drop off late in the year. Last year bait shops I went to were selling Large as Jumbos and small as large!
    • RuddyDuck
      Reminder, meeting tonight at 7:00pm in Annandale and written comment period runs til August 28th. The email addresses for comment are on pages 18-19. Comment now or the days of fishing your favorite lake anytime you want, will be over! I’m sure this is coming to a county near you if this goes thru out here.
    • gimruis
      Not uncommon at all for this time of year.  I used to try and find some regularly around Labor Day and always ran into problems.  I think its just the nature of the bait business.
    • BringAnExtension
      Does anyone know where I can get some jumbo leeches between the Twin Cities and Mille Lacs?  I would even settle for large.  There seems to be a shortage of supply. Thanks!
    • proguide
      Our prayers were answered from the south with some river flow. For now the river is back to easier and safer boating so we can get around.
        The catfishing has held steady, same as the past two weeks. The fish have moved to the shallow off current sides of the river since the nights have recently become cooler.  Sits have become longer to 25-35 minutes per spot to allow the fish to find the bait.  Mid-Day don't be afraid to find some current or move back to the middle to see if the fish have moved out to feed.
        Bait has been frozen suckers and frogs.  All other baits just don't seem to have the same effectiveness.
        We are entering into some transitions to fall and things will be changing over the next week or two.  The new flow should get the fish moving a bit more and that fall feed should ramp up over the next couple weeks.
    • PRO-V
      Also check for water in the fuel filter. At higher rpms water droplets travel to carbs and causes poor combustion. Happened to me some years ago. Had to drain water out of tank.
    • CigarGuy
      Skunked, It was nice meeting you.  I've seen you,  your wife and little one a few times, but you never waved-thought you might be mad at me after we had a little debate on netting.  Sounds like were good!  Stop by if you see me on the dock.  That was my wife and sister in-law assembling the bench. That pinch area on the river is tight and some folks tend to fly right thru.  Also, people fishing on that dock in the pinch down area in the spring, don't like to reel in their bobber when you try to navigate through the boats in the spring.  I used the fish the St Louis River a lot and fellow fisherman were terrible flying by you.  I too follow the no-wake policy when going through tight areas.
    • delcecchi
      Yep, done for the year.  Not much for heat or insulation in the cabin.  It's a real, honest to goodness cabin.   So, as of Thursday, adios.  Until next year, etc.