Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
LwnmwnMan2

Green Lake - Chisago

11 posts in this topic

Here's a report from Green.

Fishing out in the hole, the crappies are stacked up.

However, you have to fish about 8 hours to get 5 that are over the 9" minimum.

They'll come through, you catch 10-15 in 10 minutes, then you're waiting for 20 minutes. Then they'll attack the bait again, then wait. You'll get about 1 fish every 60-80 minutes that's legal to keep, if you're lucky.

Last night I got 2 back to back, and for that stroke of luck, my cell phone went down the hole. mad.gif

Always a price to pay.

Anyways, anything that glowed red with the minnow hooked through the tail, or anything that glowed green with the minnow hooked through the head.

I was out from 4 pm Tuesday until Midnight, 6 fish brought home, probably 70 thrown back, with zero floating at the top, from bringing them that far up.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Nice post lawnman. I remember fishing in the spring or later ice on green and having a lot of success in years past. The hole is a very good destination if you have a graph and are seeking numbers.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just got back from Green. It was my first time on the lake and it may become one of my new favs. I caught 25-30 bluegills and crappie starting at noon. The crappie bite started up around sundown. All were released. (None were hurt.)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Welcome to the site Matt.

Yep Green can be a really great lake for numbers, but it's rare to find any gills much over 6.5-7" though. It seems like most of the crappies I get there are at 8.75", just under the limit to keep (not that I always go to keep fish, but they always seem like they are just under the slot.) I did have a really nice crappie on a couple months ago. It was probably 13", but it unhooked when I got it to the top of the hole. \:\(

If you go to the left from the access along the shoreline, back to the corner, that can be a pretty good spot. I took the kids there one day when it was sunny out and we fished in the portable and were able to sight fish the sunnies and a couple crappies during the day in about 6-7 FOW. We also saw some bass and pike come through which was cool to see.

There was a really cool looking bass that we saw (didn't bite). It was pretty good sized, probably 4-5 pounds and it had a dark black spot covering half of it's back. It was pretty distinctive. I wonder if any FMer's have caught this fish before? (Maybe Dietz? He's caught almost every 2+ pound bass in the Chisago chain right?)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I wouldn't put it past him. I know I haven't caught that one in particular, but my buddy and I did catch a few out there this year.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Has the 9" minimum made any impact on the overall size of the crappies? Seems like this has been in place for quite a few years but the quantity of "keepers"is still sparse.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 Originally Posted By: hugonian1
Has the 9" minimum made any impact on the overall size of the crappies? Seems like this has been in place for quite a few years but the quantity of "keepers"is still sparse.

My dad and I talk about this all the time when we're out there fishing. Just like lotsofish said, it seems like 1/2 of the fish you catch out there are 8.5-8.75".

My personal opinion is that you catch so many fish, and that most people are there to take fish home.

I realize on this board, there are many people that will catch and release, but let's face it. There's alot of people that like to eat fish as well, including myself, so I'll catch 3-4-6-8 that are over the slot and bring them home.

You know darn well that I'm not the only one, and I would bet that there aren't too many that are thrown back that are over the 9" mark.

I feel, personally, that with having the 9" limit, it almost makes people feel they're required to take home anything over that size, almost like it's a trophy, because "we finally got one!!!" As soon as one hits 8 7/8", there's a good chance it's getting thrown in the bucket, not with me, but when you talk to guys on the lake and they say "yeah, it's been a feeding frenzy here for 4 days now"..... well.....

I'm not drawing any conclusions, or making accusations one bit.

That's just my opinion. Personally I HATE cleaning fish, so normally I'm just out there to prove to myself that I'm smarter than a fish. The last time out, my cell phone ended up at the bottom of the lake, so I and the fish are still in discussions on who's smarter.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 Quote:
I wonder if any FMer's have caught this fish before? (Maybe Dietz? He's caught almost every 2+ pound bass in the Chisago chain right?)

LOL--- I wish!!! and I will continue to try 8-)... On a serious note, I have caught quite a few fish in Green that had a "birthmark" on it.. but none as large as you are saying. Green lake here I come, there is a bass in there I havn't caught yet.. LMAO!!!

As for the size of the crappies... I think in Green lake.. with as much pressure as it gets.. the slot has helped, but if they want it to help more.. they would have to make it even larger.. as it seems any fish caught over the slot now goes home in a bucket. Hence, very few fish over the slot... same way with walleyes on Green, or so it seems.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree with you Deitz, but if they increased it to 12", everyone would complain, "[PoorWordUsage], 11.78", and the whining would start how you have to catch (30) 11.78" crappies before you get (1) 12" crappie to take home.

I personally don't see how Green gets any less pressure than Chisago / S. Lindstrom, yet there's not a size limit there.

But then again, there's a size limit on Bass on Chisago, and I know that structure on Chisago is quite a bit different than Green, but still..... from my perspective, I think alot of these slots / size limits are more of a trial and see what comes of it, than an actual thought of we're now going to be able to have "Red Lake" type crappies on Green, or "Florida-sized" bass in Chisago.

I suppose most of it gets down to having a larger fish to be able to reproduce, therefore increasing the chances of a lake being more sustainable, while not having too large of a fish that would compete too much with the smaller ones to grow as well??

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That would be interesting to see a 12" limit on that lake to see what happens. I'm no marine biologist so I don't know if all the crappies would get that big or if they would get stunted because none are coming out of the lake. I like to eat fish..more than average guy even...but I wouldn't mind going to a lake where I had to throw all the crappies back if I had a chance at catching a few big ones around 12". There's a lot of other lakes in the area to go get a meal if you really want one. It sure would be nice if someone at the DNR could get mother nature figured out!!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm maybe not saying 12".... 11" I think would be fine.. Myabe it doenst need to be a trophy crappie fishery? Which is fine...

Chisago is a trophy bass fishery.. and I htink the large bass help and keep thes mall crappies in check. Green too has a very very decent large bass population. But doesnt have the structure that chisago does.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • eyeguy 54
      what model ryobi?  lots of them  
    • JerkinLips
      Based on Cliff's water temp of 38°F, I'm not too sure about Dec. 3-5.  Think it will be more like Dec. 7-9.  I have ice fever and I need a cure.  Last year's first ice PB of 29", 8½# shown below would definitely cure that, but it may not be until Dec. 15-16 now.  
    • kunzi26
      Hey all,   I'm sure everyone has heard, but we're finally getting some nice freezing weather heading in from up north (https://weather.com/weather/tenday/l/56303:4:US). Early next week nightly lows will be sub 10's. So with ice season quickly approaching, I'd like to know what everyone usually does getting prepared to walk on water. As a newbie to ice fishing (only done it the last two seasons), I'm curious to see how everyone preps their gear and what other things you all do before going out on the ice. I finally got my hands on a nice flasher and power auger to add to the rest of my gear, any suggestions for nifty equipment to help make things easier?    This is open for any discussion on any ice fishing tips for newer fishers! Please feel free to ask questions or discuss your prep process for the season. Let's all hope for this forecast to follow through and get some good ice out there.    -JK
    • Hoey
      Forecast temperature-wise looks favorable for ice mid- to late-next week, but it does not look like the winds are going to cooperate.  
    • fishersofmen
      Would be nice to get some ice that's for sure. No doubt these forums have gone cold. 5-6 years ago there would be dozens of posts daily just on this thread. Maybe the newness of these forums has wore off or because everything has been hashed over a couple hundred times I don't know. I'm ready for some ice fishing I know that.