Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
NPG

Minn kota vs Motorguide

27 posts in this topic

I am purchasing a new trolling motor and have it narrowed down to a 55lbs wireless Motorguide or 55lbs co-pilot Minn Kota powerdrive v2. Any thoughts

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I guess I can't speak about those particular models but I have owned both brands and found them of comparable quality. Both performed as well as expected for me. The Motorguide I had was a stern mounted 36lb. and the Minn Kota I was a 36lb. stern mounted. I currently use a 40lb. bow mounted Minn Kota.

Bob

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I couldn't currently help you. I got a Motor Guide wireless from Valv last fall and havent put it on yet. I my father has a minn kota that has the auto pilot and copilot. works pretty nice. don't have any serious complaints.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i have been running minnkotas forever, and the reason that i do this is becuase if i do have a problem, there factory is in Mankato, or Motor Clinic in the cities.

I just like the way they run, and i like the foot petals better then the motor guide.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have run both - Motorguide authorized repair is Motor Clinic in Bloomington should any issue arise and their service is great. It's a Ford/Chevy deal. Either motor will do the job so take the one that is the best deal. I currently have a Motorguide wireless 70lb on the bow because I got it about $150 cheaper than the Minnkota version. Same price I would probably lean to Minntonka because every sporting goods store carries Minnkota props etc. Hard to find Motorguide parts. I have two spare props in the boat just in case.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for the advice everyone. Mark thats why I am leaning towards the Motorguide is because of the price difference. Great advice on the spare prop.---thanks

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

if you are worried about parts, get a couple props and a prop wrench kit. check out the online auction sites, i got some new parts for pretty cheap relative to the price in a store.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Can't speak about MinnKota, but Motorguide treated me right on a way out of warranty situation on one of their motors.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just a tid bit of info I got from a Motorguide sales rep. He told me that if you wanted a durable motor to go for the Minn Kota. His reason was that on the tournament scene, if a pro wants a Motorguide, they have to custom build the motor so that it will stand up to the abuse where as the Minn Kota can come out of the box and be screwed to the front of the boat and it is ready to go with no further modifications needed. Not all of us put a trolling motor through the abuse that a tournament fisher does, but it is nice to know that the durability is there if you need it. Minn Kota also owns Hummingbird so look for some of the same options on the Minn Kota that are available with Motorguide in the near future.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've ran both on our 20' Crestliner up north. First we had a Motorguide I think in the 70lb range 12volt. Worked great, never had a problem with it for years untill someone got a little rough with it and the gear that turns the motor stripped out (plastic). We probably could have brought it in and got it fixed but ended up buying a new Minnkota 70 lb 24volt powerdrive with the remote. I like the Minnkota better but it is new and the remote is awesome.

I think you'd be pretty safe either way.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Good input guys! Anyone else with feedback.

I am now trying to decide for myself between the two. Want to get with transducer that both offer. Is the AutoPilot that MinnKota offers worth it? How often does anyone use AP?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have used both MinnKota and Motor Guide in the last couple years. I believe that the Motor Guide ran nicer and was easier on batteries, but the MinnKota with a weedless wedge 2 definantly handled weeds much better. We had a 5 speed Minnkota and a variable speed motor guide and I think that the five speed was the reason it was harder on batteries.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The 5-speed Minnkota doesn't have the maximizer technology. I wouldn't get a Minnkota without AutoPilot. I use it 90% of the time I fish. I highly recommend it. What kind of fishing do you do?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've only had Minnkota, but the one I got (Bow Mount 55lb 12v) is over ten yrs old and still ran strong. I bought a new one because I wanted more power. I got the Minnkota 70lb Maxxum 24v with built in ducer (that's sweet) and cable drive since I bass fish a lot. I like cable drive since I'm standing and need a quick response on the river. That current seems to bring me into over hanging trees a lot. But with the power I'm able to go against the current (14' jon boat) or hoover at the same speed and fish the trees and not crash into them.

That's my bias .02

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have never used an autopilot but I can share what friends have told me.

Most of those that I know rarely use their autopilot. The reason is two-fold.

First, they find that unless you have the motor running at a rather stiff thrust, it can't compensate fast enough to counter the effect of wind. In other words, the motor doesn't realize that you have to oversteer a bit to offset the effect from the wind and so you still don't get the control you might be looking for. As a result they find that they need to manually adjust nearly as much as they do without using it. These guys are primarily walleye fishing and moving very slowly so maybe if they were trying to troll faster it would be more effective.

Second. It is rare that the structure you might be trying to work is a straight line edge. Most of the time you are likely trying to follow a contour or weedline and they almost never run straight. Again, you end up manually controlling it anyway.

About the only time they say it is handy is when you have to be momentarily pre-occupied with something else like tying on a lure. Then for those few seconds or minutes you can let the motor take control so the boat doesn't drift quite so far off track.

What these guys have all told me is not to waste my money. You pay a lot for a feature you won't use enough to justify.

Just their opinion for what it's worth.

Bob

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've also owned both and prefer the minnkota. I think the motorguide felt a little stronger in open water, because of the prop design and no flex with the steel shaft. After a while, it started to squeek (probably rusted the bearings) when I turned it. I finally fried it when I left the TM plug in the socket when I charged my batteries with an onboard charger. I like the MK much better for durability, and in weeds it never balls up so I can cut through them. With the MG if I ever got it in a milfoil pad I would have to pull up the motor and remove the weeds every 10 ft., very annoying! I also like the maxxum series but I've also had the PD/AP models. The autopilot is kind of like a compass and the motor just keeps pointing in that general direction. I really liked it when I was fishing by myself. I quickly hit the ap switch when I got a strike so I could focus on landing the fish(walk to the back and use a net)and not driving the boat.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have the Auto Pilot and I can tell you that I do not use the feature much, especially on Cass Lake, I am usually trolling and following a drop so it is not a straight line. The only thing I could think where it might be helpful was if you were Lindy rigging and pulling a leech or crawler over some flats and you had no wind to help. That's about it!

Windy

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I like the Minn Kota better, and I like the Autopilot feature. It will not correct for wind, but it will keep you heading in the same general direction. This requires less attention to the motor and lets me focus on fishing. It is also nice river fishing structure, point it upstream set the speed to match the current and it stays put. I would also reccommend the universal sonar feature, it looks cleaner with less wires. That being said I have not had any problems with past Motorquides either.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I use autopilot all the time. I love it. It would drive me crazy having to be pointing the trolling motor all the time.

One big advantage is if you are working a breakline and the wind keeps turning the boat, the autopilot will keep you moving in the right direction, while if autopilot is off, as soon as the boat pivots a little you are going in the wrong direction and off the breakline.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Awesome information, thanks for sharing. Okay if money was not the issue I would get the Autopilot, but cannot think of that many times that I simply just go in a straight line. Going to choose Minnkota for weedless prop. Defiintely will get motor with transducer so final decision is get Power Drive V2 with tranducer and AP for $800 and Terrova with tranducer but no AP for $800

Question of difference between Power Drive V2 and Terrova?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Another thing you might like to go with the autopilot would be to add the copilot to it.About $150 add on but well worth it.Its hard to beat being able to control the motor with remote controls.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I just ordered a 55# Minn Kota V2 without the AP. I can't wait to get it mounted and on the water!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Would you guys recomend the hand control or the foot pedestal? I dont use my trolling motor much since my varado trolls down to nothing to begin with but it is nice in some instances

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 Originally Posted By: Hookmaster
I wouldn't get a Minnkota without AutoPilot. I use it 90% of the time I fish.

Dido that.

I had a powerdrive without AP on my old rig. I popped for the AP powerdrive for my new rig and can say that it is awesome.

It is like having a guide in the boat doing the steering. I can fish, eat, tie lures, land fish and even pee while staying on course. I enjoy fishing more and come home less fatigued.

My only beef with the Minn Kota (legacy version) is the dang cradle slide lock feature. I about rip the motor off the bow trying to get that thing released from the cradle. The new motors a believe have a better release.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Wish, which model do you have? There are 3 lower unit sizes: 4" (74#+ thrust), 3 5/8" (44-70# thrust), and 3 1/4" (less than 44 # thrust). If you have one of the smaller motors, you can replace the motor rests with the next size. (The 4" motor rests are the smallest.) This will lessen the force to stow/deploy. But then beware! Be sure to slide the depth collar down to the lower unit and tighten the knob when you are traveling from spot A to spot B.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • leech~~
    • phishnerd
      Crawlers work great for a mixed bag of fish.  Fresh cut bait like suckers or shad work great for channel cats.  I've never fished North Lake in Red Wing. Have fun!
    • Chevy Nation
      Have you or anyone tried North Lake in Red Wing by Treasure Island?? Just curious if anything have been biting there?
    • eyeguy 54
      I seen this I seen that.....   I go and correct it once in a while... LOL  somebody has to help you peasants 
    • Chevy Nation
      Thanks a lot phishnerd! I will give it a shot and let ya know how I do! I am hoping to get out tomorrow if not hopefully this weekend! Thanks for the tips on baiting also! What would you use for live baits?
    • leech~~
        ikr, who let da dang englsh techer on dis fishn frum anways! Hck evn that pushbuttom guy whos a techer ant raggen onfolk! @*!&
    • Wanderer
      I would think so.  You still need a passport too.  Seems like the only change is loosening up on the mandatory check in.  You only have to if they ask you too.   I never took an RABC to exempt me from the check in requirement before this change.
    • Wanderer
    • Rick
      The Minnesota Department of Natural Resources has released a draft operational plan for management of the Sand Dunes State Forest, located in central Sherburne County, about 3 miles west of Zimmerman. The draft operational plan will undergo a 45-day public review from June 21 to August 4. Members of the public are invited to read the draft plan on the DNR’s website and provide comments through an online form; both are located at www.mndnr.gov/forestry/sand-dunes. The DNR will hold a public meeting to discuss the plan on July 10, 6 p.m. to 9 p.m., at the Big Lake High School cafeteria; 501 Minnesota Ave., in Big Lake. Members of the public will be invited to interact with DNR staff and learn more about the draft plan. The meeting will begin with an open house, followed by a brief DNR presentation about the plan and, conclude with an open microphone session. Last summer, the DNR organized a group of local residents, government leaders and other interested people to provide perspective and advice on management issues in the Sand Dunes State Forest. The group held six open meetings, and there were often additional people in the audience who joined in the discussion. These citizen-centered discussions helped shape the new draft plan released this week. Sand Dunes State Forest, established by the Minnesota Legislature in 1945, includes about 6,000 acres of land owned and managed by the state. It features pine plantations, rare sand dunes, wetlands, woodlands, oak savanna and prairie and is home to more than two dozen rare plants and animals. The forest is a popular recreation destination for hikers, horseback riders, hunters, campers and others. For ongoing news regarding Sand Dunes State Forest and future meetings of the advisory group, sign up for email updates . Enter an email address and then select Sand Dunes State Forest from the drop down list.  Visit www.mndnr.gov/forestry/sand-dunes for notes and resources related to the meetings.
        Discuss below - to view set the hook here.
    • phishnerd
      Welcome FM Chevy!  There's lots of fish to be caught in the Mighty Mississippi.  Plenty of spots to fish from shore right in or near Hastings as well as a little up river by the Wakota Bridge.  The great thing about the river is you never know what you are going catch. Carp, Suckers, Catfish, Walleye, Sauger, Bass, Gar, Big Ol' Snapper, Leather Necks etc..Cats are just starting to spawn so they might be a little challenging and inconsistent right now.  Try some live bait straight line rigs or cranks and keep moving.  I usually don't spend more then 20-30 mins in an area before I move on.  Good luck and let us know how you do!