Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
sticknstring

Big Muskie on Tonka Post?

12 posts in this topic

Saw a post a week or so ago re: a big muskie that reportedly was caught on Tonka and everyone was wondering if it was released or not. Some pictures were shown of a large fish being released through 5 or 6 drilled holes. I was looking at Cuffs & Collars in today's outdoor news and apparently the 52"er in question was kept and later seized by a local CO. So evidently those pictures were of someone else... fake pictures on the internet! HA yeah right!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

oh jeesh...here we go again....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

good job dnr! love to hear about poachers getting caught

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am not sure the guy neccessarily knew he was "poaching" as the regulation changed this year, during the middle of the season. I would think the DNR would have some discretion in punishing a guy who caught a fish out of season, when it was changed as stated. Now if it was released, kept, whatever...the true story will be difficult to nail down. We might just have to put it to bed as a big fish caught without knowing what happened after that. If it was released, great, if it was kept unknowingly and the DNR seized the fish and went easy on the guy, great. Lets not jump to conclusions and automatically assume the guy was targeting a musky out of season because that wouldn't be fair.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I was emailed a picture of this huge muskie that was caught on Minnetonka, I dont know how to post pictures on here so if you would like to see it post email and I will send. its a 54" and he said it took 20 minutes to bring it up.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Pretty sure it is the same fish we are talking about. The other thread said any and every number between 50 and 54.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I was out with my buddy round the holidays and saw a 46" not tail pinched Muskie caught out of Crystal bay.. The guys took cellphone pics and put it back in the hole.. Didnt hardly fight coming up, looked like a leg coming out of hole... Grabbed a tip up set up. NICE FISH!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I saw the picture and also heard the the DNR fined the guy. I also heard the season had changed so I went to the DNR website to find the regulation. I looked all over for a statement that the muskie season ended on a date other than 2/24/2008 and I found nothing. I looked a the special regulations page for lake Minnetonka and found nothing. The website even says that these are the most current regulations. How can they ticket a guy if their own rules state that the season ends 2/24/2008. I believe the story is probably true because the DNR's weekly activity posting mentioned a guy catching a 52" muskie on Minnetonka and getting ticketed. Personally I don't think Muskie should be taken through the ice but if the guy was within the rules you can't give him a ticket. The fishing reulations are starting to look like the tax code.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I stand corrected. It is on the website under this enlightning title:

12/10/07 - Some fishing regulations to change on Dec. 10

It was posted on the site on December 4th. The regulation took effect on December 15th. So you had 11 days to find out, seems kind of bush league by the DNR

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree about the fishing regulations. Some are written so ambiguously, and so inconsistently, that reasonable mistakes of interpretation can easily be made. I think the DNR has out-sourced its regulation-writing to drunks housed in the Detox Center of the Ramsey County Jail!

If I was the angler that caught the Muskie, I would would fight the ticket much like fighting the big Muskie itself -- by applying steady upward pressure. I would have told the CO to kiss my @#s! The Muskie that the man caught is his property, and should be fought for by him.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 Originally Posted By: Macattack
I stand corrected. It is on the website under this enlightning title:

12/10/07 - Some fishing regulations to change on Dec. 10

It was posted on the site on December 4th. The regulation took effect on December 15th. So you had 11 days to find out, seems kind of bush league by the DNR

I agree. Most people are not like us who post and spend a lot of time on the internet. A "normal" guy who reads the regulations booklet is not going to know about reg's changes 11 days after they're announced.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Like it or not those are the rules. If you catch a musky and then release it no problem. Rumor has it this guy kept the fish and that's against the regs. It may sound unfair with the Dec 10 change but how many fishermen really read the reg's anyway? I know a lot of guys would haven't read them in over decade and just assume everything is still the same. No reason to bash the DNR here and it would also be unfair to bash the guy who caught the fish either. So let's move on.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Cliff Wagenbach
      If the hoses or hose connections are not leaking check : Live well intake connection, make sure that it is screwed on tight into the transom and that it is sealing. Could be live well splash over also if you are in rough water, but probably not with your type of leak. It may still be leaking rivets as they may not leak unless you put a lot of water inside of the boat. It does sound like you have a bad connection in one of your live well connections! Cliff    
    • Mossy19
      Just wondering if any one will give me pointers on this lake??  Not specific spots.  Going to be at Pocahontas Resort July 1 - July 8th.  I am bass guy for most part but have kids (6 & 4) that love to fish for panfish and want them to keep entertained.  Any tips or information would be greatly appreciated!!!  Thanks! 
    • Mossy19
      Hello FM family!!  I HAVE A 2000 18.5' Fisher DXV boat and am having problems of water getting into the boat.  I have filled up the bottom of the boat with water to see if something is cracked on the boat itself and have found nothing.  It seems like the only time water comes in is when I use live well pumps. I have a guy replacing all the hoses that would have water going through them to see if one is cracked.  The water that comes in is enough that I have to run the bilge pump about every half and hour.  If I forget to run bilge then I have so much water I can't get up on plane when I take off.  Once the hoses are replaced and water still gets in, what would be my next step??  Cracked livewells??? I have two of them in this boat.  Any ideas??  Thanks!
    • birdguy
      I'm doing a day trip there on Saturday, will post afterwards. I plan to just fish the big basin area humps and points.
    • Poutwhacker
      Just looking for general advice... Taking our grandson on his 1st Rainy Lake boat camping trip, 7/01-7/05. We'll be near Kempton Entrance on the east side. I've been here many times before, but never over the 4th. Plan to target all species, but want 'eyes for supper. Are the walleyes on the reefs yet or still transitioning? Depths? Leeches or minnows? Bass/pike still in shallows? Main goal is to give him some opportunities for some fish. Thanks 'Pout
    • Luttes
      Hay Creek in Red Wing is probably your closest option.  Otherwise the Kinni, Rush, etc, just over the boarder in Wi is a good fishery. 
    • paceman
      I was kind of restless last night so since it was a bit windy I decided to go for a quick trip to a nearby small lake that I rarely go to. Tried lindy rigging leeches but the sunfish were on the chomp! I eventually went to a shallow weed point and marked a bunch of fish. Started pitching small jigs/plastics and absolutely pounded the crappies. I have never in my life caught so many small ones. Lots of 5-7" with the occasional big one 13-14" mixed in... I did not feel like cleaning fish so tossed all back. Should be a phenomenal crappie lake in a couple years...
    • Cheers
    • leech~~
      Welcome Rachelkate21 to the forum.  "brooks/steams/rivers that would be full of trout?" That is a pretty high order around Lakeville or anywhere. You may have to go south of you around Whitewater or up north in the arrowhead area. Best bet is check out the MN DNR site for Trout streams and their locations within the state. Good Luck!
    • Sleder
      Wanderer ,I believe Ely seizure was something to do with the BWCA . Lots of articles in newspaper .Some law about no commercial activity ( an active viable fishery) in side of park unless it enhances park like canoe rentals ect.... They were trying to stop Fishery for last number of years. I believe DNR does not want to do away with Frozen Bait Market , they just don't want fish from the Great Lakes or other contaminated areas to bring diesese to inland lakes.  If fish does not have a VHS Certification Number on its package , I would not be using it for bait.  Grocery store stuff totally Illegal ...  I emailed a Bait Company that has VHS Certified Smelt and Alewifes   info@awesomeadventuresfisheries.com     They gave me a list of stores that carry their products ... Save hunting around for Legal Bait   Hope this Helps