Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
big musk411

Catfish Spearing?

11 posts in this topic

A guy I know says he has been spearing Catfish on the upper Mississippi. He BS's A LOT so I don't know if it is for real. I also question the legality because there are also muskies roming the same waters. I have had cats chase small bass like a northern would in open water so it seems possible. Has anyone done this? It sounds like fun!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm about 99.9% certain it would be illegal. As far as I know the only fish you can spear are pike and rough fish. Cats are considered game fish in MN.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well, I'll be darned! Good catch. I've never seen that before. Has it always been allowed or is it fairly new? Good thing I didn't say 100%

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

yeah, I just don't get that.

It's a proven fact that flatheads pretty much go dormant in the cold water, so they are sitting ducks.

Not only that, but why would someone want to spear a cat, when they can stick a big northern. ;\)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

we had catfish planted in the horseshoe chain were i live an i heard that cats take a toll on panfish. i spear a lot and would not take a cat cause i dont eat them so i leave them for people who do.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 Originally Posted By: dtro
yeah, I just don't get that.

It's a proven fact that flatheads pretty much go dormant in the cold water, so they are sitting ducks.

Not only that, but why would someone want to spear a cat, when they can stick a big northern. ;\)

Sitting ducks if you cut your hole in the right place (and don't scare them away while cutting it) grin.gif

I would think it would be harder to spear a dormant fish rather than a fish that moves since the fish that moves has a larger chance of moving to your hole.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i would have to agree with you. I have never done this, but im sure it would be cool.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 Originally Posted By: merkman
 Originally Posted By: dtro
yeah, I just don't get that.

It's a proven fact that flatheads pretty much go dormant in the cold water, so they are sitting ducks.

Not only that, but why would someone want to spear a cat, when they can stick a big northern. ;\)

Sitting ducks if you cut your hole in the right place (and don't scare them away while cutting it) grin.gif

I would think it would be harder to spear a dormant fish rather than a fish that moves since the fish that moves has a larger chance of moving to your hole.

You are right, but, if and when, that wintering hole is found, everyone and his brother could chop a hole and throw darts. As for scaring them……..from what I’ve read, they are in a hibernation state, so there is a good chance they won’t be scared.

On the flip side they normally winter in deep holes so the chance of taking advantage of them is slim.

Must be better targets out there I would think.

On a side note, there once was a 153 Flatty speared on the MN river near Henderson, in fact it held the record for a while until it was discovered that it had been speared.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 Originally Posted By: dtro
You are right, but, if and when, that wintering hole is found, everyone and his brother could chop a hole and throw darts. As for scaring them……..from what I’ve read, they are in a hibernation state, so there is a good chance they won’t be scared.

Well you don't have much to worry about from me.

I buy my catfish at Wal-Mart. grin.gif

Farm raised, grain fed, cleaned, and ready to cook. mmmmmmmm

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

yummy grin.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • White-tips
      Thank you very much Outy22! 
    • TNtoMN_HuntFish
      In no way am I trying to fire up a catch and release vs catch and grease fight.  Admins, please delete any comments like that. I am curious about everyone's thoughts and knowledge on mercury in fish.    It seems Walleye are always the riskiest fish to eat via DNR and MDH surveys but I know the fishing for eyes is such a tradition up here. A lot of walleye are eaten in Minnesota every year as well as Pike and Bass which also can be high in mercury because they are high on the food chain. Does anyone worry about it or is this something that is overhyped? I'm a bit careful where I fish because my wife is pregant and I don't want her eating too much mercury. I'm still kinda new to the state so I trust the knowledge of locals more so than DNR in a lot of situations.    For example, in TN (where I moved from) our DNR says do not eat ANY fish from the Mississippi river. I'd say it's pretty nasty by the time it gets that far south but there are river rats as far down as Louisiana eating catfish and bass all year long and you don't hear of them dying from mercury poisoning or having other effects of it. At least not thay I've heard or read.    I'm very curious to know your opinions on the matter. I don't catch many walleye anyway but I do love eating Pike and other fish. It's so satisfying to work hard for a fresh meal but do I have to continue to be super cautious of what lakes I eat a Pike from? Seems like the closer to the metro, the more dangerous it can be...or is it? Some of the huge lakes up North are full of mercury too. 
    • Mossy19
      Well it end up being 2 broken live well pumps being broken.  The pumps would pump water into the live wells but also be spraying water into the back compartment of the boat.  That's where my water was coming from.  I would like to thank those that replied suggestions back.
    • HugeHogChaser
    • BringAnExtension
    • h8go4s
      This one? http://www.dnr.state.mn.us/lakefind/lake.html?id=31065300   Everything you need to know, paid for by your tax dollars.
    • Juan Grande
      What's the flow like on the Rum, Moose?
    • Avid Angler
      Hi guys and gals,   Does anyone know much about this lake? I don't fish this area of the state. We are looking to stay at Cedar Point Resort for a week. Just want to get to know the lake for what it is.   Is it a bass, northern, pan fish or walleye lake? Or all of the above? The surveys don't look that impressive.   Any good guides in the area?   Thanks.   Avid
    • portageguy
      The bite is on in Trout lake. Remote lake walleye fishing has been good. A leech or crawler has  been producing nice fish. This last week Trout lake has been good for lake trout, walleye and bass. A camper had caught and released a 44 inch pike. Bass fishermen reported 100 fish days.   The Y-store is looking into taking on BWCA permits. Please encourage and support them to do so. 
    • delcecchi
      On many lakes it is possible to rent a boat for a reasonable price.  Or to hire a guide who knows the area and the lakes.