Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Bowfin

Non Toxic Shot Questions

6 posts in this topic

I've shot steel ever since the mandated switch from lead. This past year I started my nine year old son hunting with a single shot 20 gauge (Remington Spr 100) - shooting steel wasn't recommended in the instructions for this gun. I also wanted to maximize knockdown power so I lightened my wallet a bit and bought him some Bismuth and Federal Premium High Density (box stated softer than steel). He had a good 1st year in knocking down a woodie, bluewing. and a ringneck with his sngle shot. I have since heard Kent has tungsten matrix and Hevishot has come out with a softer tungsten shot (classic doubles).

Anyone have any experience with bismuth, Kent's tungsten matrix or Hevishot's "classic doubles" tungsten? What's the best as far as knockdown power? What is Federal Premium High Density and is it safe to shoot in barrels not rated for steel? How about choke patterns - I've heard Kent's tungsten matrix chokes like lead does? Any input is appreciated in deciding what to buy for next season.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

all of the non toxic stuff patterns pretty dense. im assuming that since its a single shot and not recommended for steel that the gun is of fixed choke tight constriction? or is it just an old firearm (not familiar with the spr 100) i shoot bismuth out of my old full choke wingmaster, with zero problems and good patterns. i personally didnt like the performance of federal hi density compared to federal steel in my regular goose gun.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Its a newer gun with a modified choke. I was somewhat surprised when I got it home and read the no "steel recommendation" in the instructions, Last year I had trouble finding bismuth - think the company sold or something. Hopefully this year it will be more available. Thanks for the response.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I believe the Kent T-Matrix is going to be your best option. The Bismuth is gone (sob sob) due to high demand in other parts of the world for a very limited supply of the stuff. Since I am one of those unreconstructed throwbacks who tried-and hated-steel from the start, I have been shooting Bismuth since it was available. Great stuff. Now the T-Matrix is my choice. I suspect the demise of Bismuth will bring more options.

I am surprised your shotgun requires a non-toxic shot. As you know, the gun is an inexpensive import from (I think) Turkey. It makes me think the steel in the barrel is not HARD enough to deal with steel shot. It IS surprising in a gun of modern manufacture. The SPR is also around the market place in other permutations.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I shoot a SPR310 O/U that lists the same limitations on shooting steel shot through anything but the C or IC choke. I spoke with the gunsmith at Gander Mountain in St. Cloud, and he indicated that as long as you do not shoot anything bigger than 2 shot steel through the M choke you will be just fine. Just to be on the safe side, I would check with your local gunsmith.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

To all - Thanks for the input. It's good to have options to steel although it would be nice if the price would come down on the new stuff (another benefit in limiting him to a single shot for his 1st couple years). I'll probably try Kent's T-Matrix and am intrigued by Hevishot's new "classic doubles" soft tungsten just out. Good to be on a forum site with enough users to get advice on questions such as this.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Getanet
      My buddy has the 5 w/GPS. When you combine it with a lakemap chip it's a really sweet set-up for ice fishing as you can pinpoint spots on lakes and mark your location for the next time you're out.  I don't know anything about the sonar vs. flasher issue or if there is a slight delay. All I know is I want one.   Also, there are down imaging and side imaging versions available, and ones with and without GPS. Be sure you take that into consideration when you're shopping. I've gotten excited about some pretty good deals I've seen on the Helix 5, only to realize it doesn't have GPS. If you're going to use your for ice fishing I think you would want the GPS version.
    • BringAnExtension
      Whenever I want to take a kid out fishing and keep them entertained, then I always go to Kelly Dudley.  In the summer, it is impossible not to catch a steady stream of sunfish.  I have never tried it in the winter, but suspect it would be a good place to keep an eight year old busy.   If you go out, make absolutely sure to bring ice cleats.   There is an indoor fish camp going on in Faribault this weekend.  http://www.maxsolutionsonline.com/cityoffaribault/Customer/ActivityDetail.aspx    
    • DrJuice1980
      So as long I throw one dead one over at a time, Im cool?
    • Fathom
      Are you looking for this summer?   Are you looking for cabin type resorts, camping, tent/RV?   Here is a place to start:   http://business.parkrapids.com/list/category/resort-cabin-327   I live in the area so haven't spent to much time at different resorts but I've always liked R&D Resort on Straight Lake in Osage, MN which is only 8 miles from Park Rapids. Isle O' Dreams is another very cool place to stay.
    • Fathom
      Lots of water on the ice now where people have their houses. Took my house off yesterday and the plowed roads were pretty slushy already.