Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Crappiechaser

how do you feel about?

12 posts in this topic

My girlfriend is going to school to be a vet and she said something about the state banning aggresive dogs such as pitbulls and dobermans, ect. (spelling sorry). I know this is a hunting dog forum but just wondering how you feel about this. I didnt bother me much untill i got to thinking that what if they banned a breed that I had. They would have to pry my dog from my cold dead fingers. How do you guys feel about this topic? Im not trying to sound like a tree huger but come on.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

As this is a hunting dog forum, let me say this. Hunting grouse behind my Pitt/Rott mutt is way better than hunting grouse behind my Lab/Springer mutt.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Huh? confused.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I guess I would be for it.

I hope the state would say "No more new sales of the dog" and if your dog is registered and you already have it...you can keep it.

No new dogs sold and no new dogs brought into the state with families moving in.

If you have one of these dogs, you have to know something like this may be coming someday....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is a good topic. I can see both sides of the story here. People can't continue to be injured by these "aggresive dogs" due to lack of owner responsibility, but in hind sight some responsible dog owners of "aggressive dogs" are put into the same category. They will be the ones losing out an family member.

I'm interested to read others opinions. Good Post!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My question is, "When/where does it end?"

I'll bet a box of beer that more people are bitten by golden retreivers than by pit bulls. Having said that, I hate pit bulls. My neighbor (elderly woman) was attacked by one, and all she was doing was walking down the street. Is this the dogs fault or the dog owners fault? I dont' know. My dad had a pit bull and I hated the thing, and the feeling was mutual.

I'm all about the government NOT being involved in my life, or my home, or what type of dog I own.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I totally agree.

I am sure the % of bites from dogs are even less from pit bulls than other breeds...but they are a breed that has been know to attack for the "heck of it". Well behaved pit bulls can turn in an instant.

The government does not have to step in, but if someone has one of these dogs that is friendly and it suddenly turns on me or a member of my family and hurts us...I will sue the pants off of them. Why raise a dog that is know to be dangerous?

I was attacked by a "wild dog" in our woods one winter. I was 17 or 18 years-old. I didn't get bit due to quick thinking and it being a medium-sized dog, but I sure got scratched up. Later, the dog was found in my dad's fox traps and we shot it. It was so skinny, I could fit my hands around its waste.

So, any dog that is mistreated can attack...but a pit bull can "just attack". If that would have been a pit bull in the woods, would I be here today?? They won't stop the attack like other dogs, even ones that are mistreated.

To this day, I am very afraid of large dogs unless I get to know them. Funny how one incident can change your feelings towards other people's pets.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I bet boilerguy is right saying that more people are bitten by golden retrievers than pitbulls. I would bet that this is because there are WAY more golden retrievers than pitbulls. How many young kids have been mauled to death by golden retrievers?? The difference between mauling to death and biting is enormous.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for the replies guys. Nice to hear how others feel about this.

Do you think harrsher punishment to the owners would help the situation. I think less people would by an aggresive breed because there "cute" as puppies. My gf thinks that in order to have a aggresive breed there should be guidelines, obedience classes, a permit ect.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

While I don't want to sound soapboxy, or speaking for others, many of the people I know, around where I live have aggressive breed dogs for only a couple of reasons. 1. They think the dog makes them cool. 2. They are sellin dope. If they are dopers, the biggest fine in the world, need for permit, mandatory obediance training would'nt do any good. If it's the cool factor they have bigger issues than needing a permit.

Before you attack me for saying that, remember I said the people I know, around where I live. That's a tiny percentage. There are totally crappy owners of Black Labs, too.

Earlier I said I hate the breeds and I stand by that. That doesn't mean I want more laws.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Boilerguy,

I completely agree with you about owners of aggressive breeds. I saw the same thing where I used to live.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I actually agree with what you said to (for my area).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • skibass
      We talked to a guy who did very well in 16 FOW by Frontier on Monday. Also heard from a group who did well near Birchdale (not sure on depth).  Our best luck was in 21-25 FOW
    • megofishing
      I am planning on kayaking and fishing the Cannon River this season--between Cannon Falls and Hwy 61. I just want to know if the current is generally swift or lazy, i.e., can I paddle BACK to my entrance spot or do you  need to drift downstream and do the two vehicle thing. I understand it may depend on how low or high the river is at any given time, but in general, when things are 'normal', can you paddle back with little difficulty?
    • maxpower117
      I'll keep it short and simple. The causes of boom and bust on Mille Lacs.    1. Improperly managed slot limits. Too many large fish are allowed in the lake.  2. Netting during spawn. Poor spawning success.    The recent years of high catch rates rates indicate a good 2013 year class but most importantly it is a red flashing light for anyone paying attention. High catch rates are a result of good population AND low or decreasing forage. I put AND in caps because fish won't bite like they have  when they're not hungry.    Cut down that year class class before it's too late. I give it 2 more summers before another crash is inevitable.    Round and round we go, where it stops, nobody knows. 
    • megofishing
      After using most of the brands you've mentioned, I absolutely love Lunkerhunt frogs...real lifelike, and don't seem to fill up with water as much as the others. They also hold up really well--caught some pike and bowfin without them getting destroyed. I have been using the "Croaker" color exclusively, but definitely picking up some other patterns. They also make a popper frog which is great if you want to make a little more noise.
    • megofishing
      I agree with AlwaysFishing--you can come down in line weight for braid if you're just straight up bass fishing. I personally like 30lb if there are a lot of toothy critters around. I use 50-60lb when going after pike and muskie. Have you ever tried fireline for your spinning rod? When jigging, wacky worming, etc., I use 8-12lb fireline exclusively--you can feel EVERYTHING and no stretch is an added bonus.