Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
PikePatroller

Prior vs. Spring Lake Ice fishing

26 posts in this topic

I worked at an area bait shop and have heard both sides of this arguement and just curious to hear some more. If i want to catch a couple walleyes which one should i venture out on?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You would have a good chase on both lakes. You just need to know were to fish.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

spring if you can find them cus they are big fish, i caught numerous walleyes over 18 inches in that lake this summer.. and have recently caugt 2 over 18 this winter. and none one prior.... way to much angling pressure on prior its a joke... on spring the lake is yours right now.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Joe when are you gonna bring me out there?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

never the bite is horrible

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

One evening on Spring got 8 eye's between 2-4 lbs then the next three nights couldn't catch one to save our life fishing the exact same holes. This was 4 Winters ago and haven't fished it much since.

3 Winters ago on Prior slammed the eye's until the vehicles started driving out. First three nights got 10 eye's per night. Same spot next two years not much.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

what area are you in on spring was out there last sunday by the creek and got skunked. confused.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Prior carries a better habitat for walleyes than pea soup Spring. Your best bet is to laugh at the people trying to catch them on either of these lakes and go to a real walleye lake. Just my opinion though.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't think anyone was claiming that either spring or prior were "walleye" lakes. I'm not sure any lake in the metro would classify as that type of lake. But the DNR stocks them, so we may as well go out and catch the fish that we have already paid for. smirk.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Fished both through the ice quite a few times. My target is crappies but have "accidently" hooked a few eyes on each. Certainly more "accidents" on Spring than Prior. Especially as the season wears on. . .

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've caught just as may walleyes out of spring as I have out off Prior. I remember opener of 2005 I caught so may walleyes on Spring 14"-25" then I could handle. Thought I was in canada for a while. I have also had the the same fishing on Prior spring, summer, fall and winter. I did get a 9 1/2 lbs walleye out of Prior last winter. You just have to know were to look for them. I've had times on the big pond were the only thing you could catch was a buzz (Mille Lacs). They both are quality lakes, just on guys opinion. Good Fishin!!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm a little disappointed in all of your guys' grammar. A. both lakes are fished like the twin cities needs a suburb. B. Have you seen the boats out there? Or should I ask been on the water in the summer? You may as well drink from the toilet. A buddy of mine calls that "his" lake, of course, he has herpes. just my fyi.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

that has nothing to do with what fish are in the lake, or hpw they are biting krawdad...as for walleye bites the two points on spring are the best. the creek isnt so good. and also there is a nice trench in the middle of the lake that runs about 100 yards that is fun trolling over. as for prior how cares because once someone sees your catching fish, you have 30 guys lightin up there 40 year old eardrum shattering augers so everythings gone.... the best way to fish out there is to fine your own water and structure, that lake was made for walleyes, there is way to much structure and deep breaks and flats to think that prior is anythign less than a walleye lake, the reason its so bad is because you get the guys who get so eager to catch a walleye that they keep the 12 to 13 inch walleyes and think its a once in a lifetime fish out there. people have yet to realize that we live in minnneeeesoootaaah THE WALLEYE CAPITAL OF THE WORLD!!!! the dnr doesnt just stock walleyes for there health boys.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

listen to joe, you might learn something. Although I wouldn't consider prior a "walleye lake" they are in there. But throwing the same stuff at for the last 15 years isn't going to catch them anymore. i find prior a good testing ground lake for new tactics that are a little, shall we say, out of the box. And yes, please don't keep twiggy walleyes from prior. Those things are so jacked full of pcbs, mercury, and other contaminants by the time they get to about 13 inches, in just aint worth it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

sooooo true

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So your advice is to not keep any walleye on prior due to contamination? The DNR report would suggest otherwise.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

look at all the crap people leave on it in the winter?

i have seen a lot of stuff down there with my aqua view, and its nasty. beer bottles... trash.... propane tank.... i mean its a grimy lake. they all are around the metro...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I cooked up some crappies from prior last year and I'm still kickin! I noticed that you know a lot about catching unedible walleyes in that grimy lake, so you must be strictly catch and release.

I tend to think that most of the trash you described comes from the hardwater season.....which is too bad. I can't believe the shanty towns that pop up on that lake. It only takes a few seconds to do a quick sweep when you pack up to make sure you didn't leave crap laying around.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Shooter, I'm saying what joe was saying about people taking 12-13 inchers that are needed to maintain a good population. And, seeing as the walleye is a top predator in prior, it would be full of contaminants. Levels of contaimination get multiplied at each level in the food chain. Also, the last DNR report of Prior was in 2004. 4 years is a pretty long time for contaiminents to build up. Especially since pcbs, mercury, etc can jump in a week or two.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Crappies aren't as big of a deal considering they are a low level predator. I've had my fair share of prior lake crappies, dont get me wrong. I rarely target walleyes in prior, it's just logical thinking in my opinion. You'd be fine eating crappie all day as long as you avoid the belly fat.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm all about selective harvest; I threw back a couple of 12-13" walleyes on prior this winter already. In fact I've been out a few times and kept just a few crappies once; enough for dinner. So I do agree with you there. I just think you're overstating the contamination of the lake by calling the walleyes inedible.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Think off all the crap thats on the bottom of Mille Lacs with 5000+ houses out there ever year.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm not saying they're totally inediable, I'd just rather not eat them. I know tons of people eat them from there all the time. Its kinda like one cigarette isnt going to kill you, but 2 packs a day might. I agree with your ethics shooter, just trying to explain my opinion.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just sharing my opinion as well.....

Back to the topic at hand. I'm starting to lean towards Prior as the lake of choice for fishing, considering the horrible bite I've experienced on Spring lately. If only it wasn't everyone elses' favorite lake...... crazy.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Two years ago spring was the ticket, last year it was no good (for me), and this year has yet to tell. I think prior is more consistent as far as pannies go. It's just such a convenient lake that people just flock!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • busse3775
      Dad and I fished this past Saturday and Sunday with portables and saying the fishing was slow would be an understatement. Between the 2 days we hit the mud flats pretty hard and stayed very mobile. Didn't even set up a house during the day because it was so nice out. We fished the mudflats from East Flat down to Blue Jug, over to 8 Mile and back up to Matton Flat. The day bite was very tough, we would mark fish but they wouldn't want much to do with it. We picked up 3 eyes Saturday morning with the biggest being 17" then picked up only 3 more during the day. They only seemed to hit our dead sticks with a shiner on it. We used mainly VMC gold perch tingler spoons and flutter spoons without much luck jigging. On Saturday night we had a sleeper rented from Twin Pines Resort and our house was in 20'. We had 6 bites throughout the night with a bigger fish breaking off and a couple smaller ones being caught. We really had to give them a lot of time to inhale the shiner. On Sunday we went back out to the Mud Flats with little confidence and the fishing was pretty slow again. Didn't hear many good reports from this weekend, not sure if it was the warm weather along with the pressure system or what.
    • busse3775
      I think your best bet would be the narrows on Pelican. That can be pretty good crappie and walleye area. I usually fish it a couple times earlier in the season. Otherwise closer to Battle Lake you could give South Turtle or East and West Lost a try.
    • Chill62
      I thought Clitherall was pretty good but never fished panfish down there.  I fish mainly the Perham/DL area.   Panfish have been very skitish as of lately.  We have been using mainly 4mm and 5 mm jigs for crappies but the panfish are wanting 3 mm jigs.  Best luck has been with a horizontal shapped jig tipped with 2-3 wax worms (depending on hook and wax worm size) very lightly jigged.  Most of the action has been once they appear is to reel up above them 5-8 feet then slowly drop down stopping 1-2 feet above them and twitching the jig LIGHTLY.  Anything with a "GLOW" has been killer for paints.  The lakes I've been fishing have almost a foot of snow and the water was merky prior to freeze up so even though the sun is up I'm still hitting the jigs with the UV Light and the fish are instantly reacting.  I've been targetting deeper holes and finding them in that 20-30' mark but I've heard some reports that they have started coming back up into the shallows and hitting the green weeds again.  Crappies right away this year were liking the 5 mm jigs tipped with a wax worm and soft plastic suspended but they have started preferring smaller jigs also.  Hope this helps you some.
    • monstermoose78
      Where ya going or how did you do
    • Holy carp
      Caught a few walleyes on o'dowds this weekend. Was marking a lot of fish on the bottom but very skidish and not willing to bite very well. Anyone else have any luck on o'dowds?