Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
JBMasterAngler

Ice Armour Suit vs. Vexilar Ice Suit

19 posts in this topic

Looking to buy an ice suit, would like to know which is better? Ice gear seems to be more popular and available, however vexilar looks to be around $40 cheaper. Would like to know what all your guys' opinions are on the 2 suits?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Don't know about those two or what their prices are, but I would go with Arctic Armour. Warm and it floats you if you fall in. You get warmth and safety all in one.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The vexilar bibs are simply awesome. I don't like the new color schemes they have, but I have last years models (which will prolly last 5 years). No shortcuts on velcro, zippers, or material like some others. No it does not float, but 32 years on the ice I haven't needed to float.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have the Vex bibs & coat from last year. Warm and wind proof, Can't beat it or the price.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

( Note from admin, please read forum policy before posting again,Thank-You.)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I had carhart's they get wet and frozen....bought the vex suit last spring for like $110(bibs and jacket) used it a few times to clear the driveway and such and it is awesome!!!! The carhart's can stay in the closet cause they aren't getting used.........Very warm alot of pockets and zippers and very comfortable (I used in the rain once this spring and it kept me dry also). I guess by lucy1205 's way of thinking I am a yuppy, but a warm and dry one......get off the political way of thinking and enjoy life!!!!!! tongue.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've been using the "generic" stuff for about 15 years now, and for the most part have stayed moderately warm. The last couple years I've wanted to get an ice armour suit (they look better), but money is an issue so looks like I'm pointing at a vexilar suit. So far it looks like the popular choice anyway.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

you won't regret it......I got my suit and put it on and the bibs seemed to rip...contacted strikmaster and they sent out a new pair and returned the ones I had....haven't had a problem since.....good bang for your buck

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Got a good chuckle there. Early ice sucks! LOL!

Vexilar's Cold Snap Suit, Strikemaster's Icessentials Suit, Clam's Ice Armour, Cabela's Guidewear, and IDI Gear's Arctic Armor are all of the same design for the most part.

The basic idea with all suits is lightweight, windproof, waterproof, breathable, technical outerwear. I'm really not sure why some suits, such as the Vex suit, are so cheap other than you have to wear a big old Vexilar logo on your back. Pretty cheap advertising for them.

I'm an Arctic Armor guy. Got on the "bandwagon" about 1 year ago shortly after the product hit the market. Its the only suit that will help save your life (it floats!) if you ever fall through. For a bit more money than the competitor's products, thats a great insurance policy!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well I went to joe's sporting goods and bought the ice armour suit. Wore it while shoveling once I got home...LOVE IT!!! I bought an XL, which is just a bit big, although I didn't have as many layers as I would while on the ice. This year's vexilar suit is just not attractive to me at all...I just couldn't resist the ice armour blue...now I have to figure out how to explain this $250 purchase to the mrs. frown.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've seen these suits at various places, and have never owned one. I have a hard time believing the jackets can be that warm when the material is so thin (seems more like a windbreaker than a winter jacket). Maybe somebody can explain this to me. Or atleast convince me that they will keep me warm.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I can't speak for the other suits but if I wear anything more than a T-shirt and Hooded Sweatshirt under my Arctic Armor jacket, I'll be too warm in fishing situations.

The insulation in Arctic Armor, along with a lot of other technical outerwear, is designed to trap your body heat in.

Ideally, one would wear a technical base layer (Under Armour Cold Gear) which gets the moisture off your skin, then an insulation layer (Fleece), followed by your shell.

What I've noticed with my Arctic Armor jacket is I don't really need that insulation layer. The more active I am out ice fishing, the warmer I get, and that is regardless of the outside air temp and wind chill. I've spent plenty of days on Upper Red Lake last winter fishing from sunrise to sunset on the ice with no shelter. Good outerwear can change the way you fish as you don't need a house, unless the conditions are seriously poor.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I thought about getting a vexilar suit and then decided to upgrade my deer hunting stuff to Browning hydrofleece. It rocks, Waterproof, Warm and I can use it for more than just icefishing. Check into it, You won't regret it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I just bought an Artic Armour suit last weekend at the Ice Fishing Expo. I have worn it on Saturday night, all day Sunday and Wednesday for snow removal and just getting my ice fishing gear in order. I am completely impressed with warmth of the suit. It is hard to remove the mindset of thickness of the suit equates to warmth, but this suit really does work. I definitely am liking the buoyancy factor. Wow - that will keep the Mrs. from giving me the speech about falling through the ice. Now I'm waiting for Insultex to be installed in cars so she won't yell at me for that too.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Walleyerube-

Welcome to FM! You are going to love your Arctic Armor suit!

I wore my AA jacket the other night while shoveling the driveway and I worked up a sweat that almost completely soaked my hooded sweatshirt that I was wearing underneath!

The jacket traps and holds your body heat, the more heat you build up, the more it retains.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

bought the vex bibs on sale the day after thanksgiving for $49. They are now $109 at FF. They are great!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I picked up the whole Vex Cold Snap suit on "Black Friday" for $100 at Fleet. Saved myself over a hundred bucks thanks to one of my buddies who was out there shopping hard looking for deals and gave me a call. cool.gif I put the suit to the test the next morning walleye fishing. I think it was about 20 degrees and windy at 6 am and I felt fine the whole time. I really would have liked the Artic Armor suit, but this one will have to do for now. I'll just have to use a life jacket early ice so I can float. tongue.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Not happy so far with Arctic Armor. Way too wet, regardless of the combination I wear. (I have extensive experience with cold weather gear). I've used silk. polypro, and a variety of fleece and other base layer sets and I'm still soaked when I get off the ice. Advertised as breathable, and I know that nothing is truly breathable, but I hadn't banked on this level of moisture retention. I like the bibs, and the surface is very durable, and it's well made, but I haven't tuned in the proper combination yet short of swapping out underlayers in the middle of the day.

ice

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

one question I have about arctic armor and maybe others is ... you are not supposed to put them in a dryer or get them to a certain temp otherwise u wreck the insulation? So you are in a portable one man with a heater where do u sit without wrecking your $300 suit? would have bought a suit already but I always see steam coming of a warm pantleg sometime during a sit in the portable. Good luck

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • cookie129
      Well its been a interesting few days to say the least. The main thing were all the fishermen and customers were safe as well as the houses The standing water on the lake started to find more areas to drain causing a fishing frenzy for Marty and his wife shelly Monday night. The mother load swam right under marty and shell and boy did they have fun. They caught more then a few elusive yet still catchable upper red lake crappies. Mean while Dave and his crew stood outside and managed to land 11 yes 11 elusive upper red lake crappies fishing in the rain. They also did real well on the walleye fishing with Kyle landing his first ever walleye. Tuesday morning I was off to the dentist early then arrived back home to say good by to marty and shell. I was going crazy to get back on the lake and see what the conditions were like. Closer to shore and most of the water has had drained down the cracks and holes. The biggest hole I have found so far   was where old minnesota was and is about 20 inches wide. Driving out to Montana and Florida I stayed to the right of the road to conserve the road. I have a hard time driving by liter so a couple stops were made . I few wood blocks, a couple pop cans, a beer bottle. All and all not to bad as I have seen a lot worse over the years. Buddy Hillmens bridge is in good shape. Getting the skid houses over the pressure ridge is still possible and Buddy has started bringing some of his customers house's home as well as one or two of his own. He has a special way of towing them over and was nice enough to call me when they were in the process of bringing one across so I could observe there system compared to how I got old Minnesota and north Dakota across two weeks ago. Man did that way work well as I pulled  a old house from the past over with his system with no problems.  Trying to bring north Dakota and old Minnesota back out may not be a option though . Every year I chase the mother load of the elusive yet still catchable upper red lake crappie but this year I may have to get montana and florida back over the pressure ridge rather then taking the whole fleet back out there. Common sense needs to prevail on this decision . I was planning on spending some quality time napping and fishing in old Minnesota but time and mother nature will tell how it pans out. Jake and his crew are still planning on coming in march and I see no reason we will have any problems looking for the mother load as there's still plenty of ice out there. Out where montana and florida are there's still some standing water but nothing like it was on Tuesday. With the cold temps coming back every thing should tighten back up in the next day or two. I have a big crew with my son John coming today for the final weekend of game fish season. They have florida, montana and North Carolina plus the cabin. I was in the process of hauling north Carolina out there yesterday when I remembered Jeff mentioned the ceiling fan was loose . I stopped to check it out and its hanging by one wire? For some reason I have 4 screw drivers in my tool box and not one of them is a phillip's so I had to leave the house where it was  un tell I can get out there this morning and secure it. As The temps drop we should be in good shape for the final weekend. Buddy hillmens road withstood what mother nature had to offer . The good news is the red baron is repaired. Its just 50 miles away and I will not be able to go pick it up un tell some time  tomorrow.    
    • Mike89
      call Head of the Lake Resort.
    • jerkbait
      We did get an inch or so of snow yesterday.
    • ZachD
      You are paying for it one way or another it is worked in the rental fee or you pay at the road I guess its a matter of preference. Places I go at milacs always had the road pass "included" I think when I rented from up north rental on red I had to buy a pass going out of rogers.   Beacon Harbor it was included  
    • eyeguy 54
      made some spread with mayo and diced up yellow peppers and pepper. Had 2 sandwiches today. Outstanding.  Home from fishing and put some on a couple honey graham crackers......  man oh man !!   good stuff ! ! !   great taste combo !