Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
chucker34

Anyone Using Black Rifles For Deer?

9 posts in this topic

I saw the Star Tribune article yesterday where one of their Outdoors writers wrote about them and noticed a few articles now in my Outdoor Life and F&S after Jim Zumbo's snafu got him run out of Dodge.

I don't want to make this a debate so let's not make it one. I'm just wondering if many people use them and what the advantages are. The magazines make it look like hunters are switching over by the droves.

I don't usually gun hunt and I'm not planning on buying one (too expensive for this cheap guy), but wanted to hear if people are using them.

One other quick question, I noticed in the Strib article, it says some of the clips can hold 30 rounds, are you allowed that much for deer hunting at any one time or is there a limit like waterfowl hunting where you have to put a plug in?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If I had all sorts of money I would get say a Panther Arms AR type rifle in .260 Rem and hunt deer with it, could double as a yote gun. Would also be fun just to get the crew together and shoot paper/cans.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I hunted with a guy who had a DPMS in .243 this year. Interesting rifle but it was over 10 pounds with the scope. I'd probably go with a .260 as well but man, I wouldn't want to carry that hunk of metal around all day.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am considering the AR-10 (.308) for deer and plinking. I think if the .223 was legal in MN we would see many more "black guns" in the woods. On the DPMS Arms website they have links to all kinds of guns and optics.

I like the .308 due to the availabilty of FMJ surplus ammo and inexpensive expanding ammo for deer.

If the Rem. 6.8MM SPC ever makes it to military service like some hope, that could be a sweet little round for deer and plinking.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My coworker used his dpms .223 over in wisconsin this year. I think If you have a realtively short walk to your stand and you felt comfortable with it then I would say go ahead. I would use one in .308 or .260 if they were lighter. For now thought I'll take my 6.5 lb bolt over a 10lb semi any day. I have alo heard that DPMS' new .308 long ranger is almost if not as accurate as a bolt. but then again its like 11lbs. Some of my stands are a half mile in the woods and I really don't feel like lugging that much metal around.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'd give it a try if I had one in .243 or .308 instead of .223.

While it's not quite a "black rifle" as I take it you mean, but I have used my SKS quite successfully.

Oooohhhh how I wish I'd not sold that HK91 years ago...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Are even the .223 ARs heavy? Why all the weight? You'd think they'd be light....how heavy are the standard mil issue M-16's?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If I ever start deer hunting up north (i.e. rifle zone) I will get a 25wssm upper for my AR. If I was to do it all over though, I would definately have gone with the AR-10 in .308, just for the ability to use it deer hunting.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I used an AR10 for this years deer season.

I used to use a Mossberg 835 with a slug barrel. then a couple years ago, i bought some land by palisade. i figured i should get a rifle.

I picked the AR10 as i am very comfortable with the design as i shoot the AR15 competitively in OTC (over the course) shooting matches. so i am very used to the sights and everything.

the thing i learned is that with the rear aperture site, i can't see thru the site until a bit after legal shooting hours in the morning and i lose the site picture about 10-15 minutes after sundown.

i really liked it. i didn't use a sling this year, but the built in carry handle really came in handy. i used a 4 round hunting mag with it.

i think next year i will get a flat top upper and put a scope on it. i normally hate scopes, but maybe its time.

Cooter-you can get lightweight AR15's, IMO i think stock AR's aren't that heavy. now my comp AR is pretty heavy. i have a heavy barrel with lead in the buttstock. it's a heavy gun by design.

my friends that i hunted with were, "i can't wait to hear you fire that gun" or "if you see a herd of deer, you can flip to full auto and mow them down." LOLOL i kept on telling them it wasn't full auto and i only had 4 rounds in it AND it only sounds like a .308.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Cliff Wagenbach
      72 degrees again in Big Bay at noon today. Cliff
    • Cliff Wagenbach
      The local state parks are also an option. Very modest yearly fee there also. Cliff
    • TNtoMN_HuntFish
      Absolutely. I'd never get mad at a guy squirrel hunting while I'm deer hunting. Thats just public land hunting. Now if he shot at squirrels very close to me that's different. Maybe the guys I talked to had a bad experience but it isn't that frequent. That's what I hope anyway. 
    • delcecchi
      Looks like the forest service campgrounds charge a modest fee.  But the are pretty nice.   Fall lake, fenske lake are a couple to consider
    • Sunset Lodge
      Hello from the NW Angle of Lake of the Woods!

      We have had a great week of fishing with a few showers and strong winds.

      Up in Canada, jigging on reefs and underwater humps are producing the best in 22-28 ft. with gold, pink and orange jigs. Pulling spinners is also an option on reefs in 22-24 ft of water.

      In Minnesota, walleyes and perch have been caught pulling spinners in 18-28 ft. West of Four Blocks, East of Crow Duck and East of Garden Islands, with black and gold being the most effective.

      On both sides, muskies have been aggressive when throwing buck tails and top waters on rock reefs.  The algae bloom has slowly begun to pick up, however, fish are still visible.

      We hope to see you soon!

      Sunset Lodge
    • PSU
      Thanks Del, my son and some friends are coming up this weekend for water sports fun!!
    • Cliff Wagenbach
      I have had very good success the past few days using my standard lindy/1/2 crawler rigs. All fish were caught in sand/rock transition areas in 16' to 24' depths. Mornings were best from 8:00am to noon. Key factors were to look for pods of fish before even dropping a line! Some fish would bite and some would not. I did not spend much time on pods that would not bite! 2 passes and I was gone if we did not get a fish! Found many fish in spots that I have not fished all summer! Dumb ones I guess! Still tasted the same though! Cliff
    • Capt. Quicksteel
      I hunt these WMA's routinely. It's not as bad as they say. Most of the time you're fine but you have to be prepared to have your hunt completely ruined and be able to laugh it off and move on. The land belongs to all of us. That said, if someone actually shot at a squirrel in a tree I'm sitting in, I might be tempted to shoot back.(kidding!)  Hard to imagine that really happened! I would say 75% of the time you have these places to yourself. It helps to pick areas that are a little harder to walk into.
    • TNtoMN_HuntFish
      I'd love to do this. I've never hunted them as we didn't have any where I'm from. Do you know if this opportunity is for a wild pheasant or a pen raised bird? 
    • JerkinLips
      Tough weekend fishing for me.  Caught only 5 walleyes.  I didn't see anybody else find a good bite around me.  I couldn't keep the crayfish and perch off my crawler.  I must have caught 20 crayfish and 10 perch for every walleye I caught.