Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
maros91

Crippled Deer

24 posts in this topic

What do you guys do when a cripple comes along? I was hunting today and at about noon I see a deer. It is hobbling bad towards me. It attempts to jump the creek/ditch and trips and falls. It gets up only to start hobbling again and only walking on 3 feet, carrying the left front foot in the air. It is a managed area and I decide to take the deer which was a doe fawn that was no bigger than my dog. I figured I will eat it rather than wolves or coyotes getting this little bugger when the temps get cold and the snow piles up. What would you guys do?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My opinion, you did the right thing. Tough to see a deer struggling/suffering like that.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

With the proper tag, I would have done exactly what you did. IMHO the fawns taste the best! grin.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I once shot a badly wounded deer one week after the season and left it lay. It was shot in the front shoulder and had gangreen (sp) really bad. Called the warden and asked first though. No sense in letting an animal suffer.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

shoot it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have to wonder about some of these posts. If you see a deer badly wounded and suffering you shoot it!! weather you tag it or not SHOOT THE POOR THING. Would you actualy let it go and die a very hard death or be eaten while still alive. Tag or no tag,,,,,,,,you finish off a suffering deer!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is the first one I have seen while hunting. I just couldn't take it anymore watching that deer gimp around. I'm am glad all you guys agree. Thanks for the replies. I did get her cut up and in the freezer. She will taste tasty soon!! I did look at her front foot after I shot and there was no bullet wound that I could tell. She must have broken it somehow.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Biff, I would have done what you did.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hats off to ya...

Wish there were more like ya out there........

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You did the right thing. I've had this same thing happen to me three times. Twice has been during the season and the third was in February during the last "bad" winter we had. I called the CO while watching her. He gave brought over a tag and to take a look at her. It turned out that she had a broad head partway through her shoulder. When I butchered her, she had lost about 95% of all her fat reserves, so she was going hungry and wouldn't had made it another month, 6 weeks at most. Glad to see there's others out there as well biff. Good job.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would have done the very same thing, good job.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks fellas, appreciate the comments!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Great work. Would have done the same thing. Perhaps the real question is, would you have done so without a doe tag? I would and then immediately call the CO as others noted or suggested. I guess I would find it hard to believe you would get anything more than a warning for dispatching an animal that was truly suffering with little to no hope of recovery. Especially if you called the CO and explained.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would put it out of its misery at once no matter what tag I have. I know a few people that are always willing to take a deer and put it on their tag. If I shot it and no one had a tag including myself, I would call the area CO and explain that I put it out of its misery and then let the chips fall where they may.

I dont believe that any CO would have one let a sick or wounded deer continue to suffer.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I guess if I didn't have a doe tag I would not have pulled the trigger for fear of what could happen. I was not hunting near the road so its not like I could have ran back to my truck and made a phone call to the CO and ask him if I could take it or not. If I would have taken a cripple before without a tag and explained to the CO and he said it was OK then I would have taken it. I guess I should contact the DNR and ask them if I see a cripple and I don't have the proper tag what should be done. I will call them today on that. From other peoples responses it sounds like they will let you do it and they will give you the proper tag for it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Quote:

I guess if I didn't have a doe tag I would not have pulled the trigger for fear of what could happen. I was not hunting near the road so its not like I could have ran back to my truck and made a phone call to the CO and ask him if I could take it or not. If I would have taken a cripple before without a tag and explained to the CO and he said it was OK then I would have taken it. I guess I should contact the DNR and ask them if I see a cripple and I don't have the proper tag what should be done. I will call them today on that. From other peoples responses it sounds like they will let you do it and they will give you the proper tag for it.


that's why we have the co's number. so we can call and check.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Biff,

I am with you on the tag issue. If you have to make a decision in the field and you don't have a tag, then what do you do? What if the CO doesn't believe you? I have never been in a negative situation with a CO because I follow the laws. I am not questioning that the right thing to do is to kill that deer, but if you can't do it legally and you can't just make that instant call to a CO, then is it really worth the fine, or some of the other things I read about like losing your weapon, truck, or hunting rights? It is not always as cut and dried as some on this thread have alluded. Let us know what the DNR says on this. I think it is sad that I actually have to take this position, when I know it is not the ethically correct thing to do. It seems that our world is becoming more and more this way.

Again - if it is legal, I shoot that deer everytime without hesitation.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Boom or whap depending if I'm gun or bow hunting & then tag it myself or try to find somebody who has one. If it's not any type of deer season & I'm armed I'd shoot it & call a CO.

If it's out of season & the deer's limping, but looks like it will survive, I wouldn't do anything except watch.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

you made the right choice...

Without a tag I am not sure but not putting it down would have to be first on the list. Maybe call the DNR to clarify your options if you see it again? Hard to watch an animal suffer...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My problem would be is that cell reception in many of the areas I hunt is spotty at best and what if you had a matter of a minute or two to decide? I'm not saying I would for certain. I'm just saying, would be hard to see a wounded or crippled animal suffer any longer. Especially if you did the right thing and called the CO afterward to explain. I'm sure they wouldn't condone you doing so but I wonder how hard they'd come down on you if you did something you thought was ethically right and were willing to accept the consequences by calling them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well I called the DNR today on the subject. I told her my story, I had a doe tag and I shot the cripple. My question is if I didn't have a doe tag and shot this animal would it be OK. Her response was,"No way"! I said so I would let this animal suffer and she said to call the local CO and he will take care of it. So I called the local CO only to get his voicemail and left him a message. We will see what happens.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would not have expected any different answer from a clerk/secretary answering the phone and she was correct in giving you that answer. Plain and simple you would be breaking the law and she can't tell you to break the law. Even if you contacted a CO, I'll bet at least half of them tell you the same thing. If the CO personally knew you it might be different.

Having said all that, I would definitely put it down.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If I didnt have a tag and was positive nobody could see me, and I mean positive, I would put it down and walk. Very personal decision though. No right or wrong answer in my opinion.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Do you think an injured animal will last long in the wild? With yotes, wolves and mountain lions smile.gif I dont think an injured/crippled deer will make it very long. Although, I do see the point in putting an animal down right away - no need for any animal to suffer.

(I would most likely put her down and call the CO to turn myself in)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • BringAnExtension
      My trophy would be the walleye, mainly because it is what I target but I have to admit hooking a 21" small mouth would be a fun battle.
    • Wheres_Walter
      So I saw this question posed elsewhere, and thought it was a fun one to get people talking as we wait for open water season.   Which trophy fish do you have on Vermilion?  Which do you want the most?  And why?   A- 30" Walleye B- 21" Smallie C- 40" Pike D- 50" Muskie   My goal is a 21"+ smallie.  I got a 20.5" last summer, which is 1/2" shy of Master Angler quality in Minnesota.  Why?  Because I can't get so close and not ultimately achieve the goal.  The 21" smallie on Vermilion is now my white whale.      
    • Rick
      Looking for an unforgettable outdoor adventure this summer? Sign up for one of the I Can! programs offered by Minnesota state parks and trails.   Reservations are being taken for the following beginner-level programs, which start in June and continue through the end of August: I Can Camp! – Develop (or brush up on) fire-starting and camp cooking skills and sleep on air mattresses in tents large enough to accommodate two adults and up to three children ($60 for one-night programs or $85 for two-night programs). I Can Paddle! – Get out on the water for a guided canoeing, kayaking or sea kayaking adventure (prices vary).  I Can Climb! – Experience the thrill of rock climbing with instruction provided by trained professionals from Vertical Endeavors Guided Adventures ($10/child, $20/adult).  I Can Mountain Bike! – Learn riding techniques and explore mountain bike trails with guides from the Cuyuna Lakes Mountain Bike Club ($15/child, $25/adult).  I Can Fish! – Kids will have fun of casting into the water and enjoying the excitement when there’s a tug on the line. ($5/person, children under 12 are free). The I Can! series also includes the Archery in the Parks program, which is free and for which no reservations are needed. “Not having the right equipment or know-how can be a barrier to spending time outdoors,” said Erika Rivers, director of Minnesota state parks and trails. “The I Can! programs make it easy for families to enjoy camping and other outdoor experiences by providing tents, canoes, mountain bikes and other gear. Friendly instructors also provide plenty of tips and encouragement so that adults and kids can both have fun learning new skills.” Registration and more information For more information including program dates, times, locations, and minimum age requirements—visit www.mndnr.gov/ican or contact the DNR Information Center at info.dnr@state.mn.us or 888-646-6367 (8 a.m.-8 p.m. Monday through Friday, 9 a.m.-1 p.m. Saturday). To register for a program, visit www.mndnr.gov/reservations or call 866-857-2757 (8 a.m.-8 p.m. daily, except holidays). This series of introductory programs is made possible with funding from the Parks and Trails Fund, created after voters approved the Clean Water, Land and Legacy Amendment in November 2008. The Parks and Trails Fund receives a share of sales tax revenue that may only be spent to support parks and trails of regional or statewide significance. The I Can! programs received a Government Innovation Award in 2015. More than 12,800 people have participated in these programs since they were first offered in 2010. Discuss below - to view set the hook here.
    • Rick
      Anyone living near bear habitat is reminded to be aware of bears this spring and check their property for food sources that could attract bears.  “Leaving food out in yards that can be eaten by bears can lead to property damage and presents dangers to bears,” said Eric Nelson, wildlife animal damage program supervisor for the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources. “Pet food, livestock feed, birdseed, compost or garbage can attract bears.” As bears emerge from hibernation, their metabolism gradually ramps up and they will begin looking for food at a time when berries and green vegetation can be scarce. Only black bears live in the wild in Minnesota. They usually are shy and flee when encountered. Never approach or try to pet a bear. Injury to people is rare, but bears are potentially dangerous because of their size, strength and speed. The DNR does not relocate problem bears. Relocated bears seldom remain where they are released. They may return to where they were caught or become a problem somewhere else. The DNR offers some tips for avoiding bear conflicts. Around the yard Do not leave food from barbeques and picnics outdoors, especially overnight. Coolers are not bear-proof. Replace hummingbird feeders with hanging flower baskets, which are also attractive to hummingbirds. Eliminate birdfeeders or hang them 10 feet up and 4 feet out from the nearest trees. Use a rope and pulley system to refill birdfeeders, and clean up spilled seeds. Where bears are a nuisance, birdfeeders should be taken down between now and Dec. 1. Store pet food inside and feed pets inside. If pets must be fed outdoors, feed them only as much as they will eat. Clean and store barbeque grills after each use. Store them in a secure shed or garage away from windows and doors. Pick fruit from trees as soon as it’s ripe, and collect fallen fruit immediately. Limit compost piles to grass, leaves and garden clippings, and turn piles regularly. Do not add food scraps. Harvest garden produce as it matures. Locate gardens away from forests and shrubs that bears may use for cover. Use native plants in landscaping whenever possible. Clover and dandelions will attract bears. Elevate bee hives on bear-proof platforms or erect properly designed electric fences. Do not put out feed for wildlife (like corn, oats, pellets or molasses blocks). Garbage Store garbage in bear-resistant garbage cans or dumpsters. Rubber or plastic garbage cans are not bear-proof. Keep garbage inside a secure building until the morning of pickup. Properly rinse all recyclable containers with hot water to remove all remaining product. Store recyclable containers, such as pop cans, inside. Store garbage that can become smelly, such as meat or fish scraps, in a freezer until it can be taken to a refuse site or picked up by refuse collector. Take especially smelly or rotting garbage as soon as possible to your local refuse facility so it can be buried. People should always be cautious around bears. If they have persistent bear problems after cleaning up the food sources, they should contact a DNR area wildlife office for assistance. For the name of the local wildlife manager, contact the DNR Information Center at 651-296-6157 or 888-646-6367, or visit the office locator page. For more information, visit mndnr.gov/livingwith_wildlife/bears. Discuss below - to view set the hook here.
    • Rick
      Registration is open for the 2017 I Can! programs Looking for an unforgettable outdoor adventure this summer? Sign up for one of the I Can! programs offered by Minnesota state parks and trails.
      Reservations are being taken for the following beginner-level programs, which start in June and continue through the end of August: I Can Camp! – Develop (or brush up on) fire-starting and camp cooking skills and sleep on air mattresses in tents large enough to accommodate two adults and up to three children ($60 for one-night programs or $85 for two-night programs). I Can Paddle! – Get out on the water for a guided canoeing, kayaking or sea kayaking adventure (prices vary).  I Can Climb! – Experience the thrill of rock climbing with instruction provided by trained professionals from Vertical Endeavors Guided Adventures ($10/child, $20/adult).  I Can Mountain Bike! – Learn riding techniques and explore mountain bike trails with guides from the Cuyuna Lakes Mountain Bike Club ($15/child, $25/adult).  I Can Fish! – Kids will have fun of casting into the water and enjoying the excitement when there’s a tug on the line. ($5/person, children under 12 are free). The I Can! series also includes the Archery in the Parks program, which is free and for which no reservations are needed. “Not having the right equipment or know-how can be a barrier to spending time outdoors,” said Erika Rivers, director of Minnesota state parks and trails. “The I Can! programs make it easy for families to enjoy camping and other outdoor experiences by providing tents, canoes, mountain bikes and other gear. Friendly instructors also provide plenty of tips and encouragement so that adults and kids can both have fun learning new skills.” Registration and more information For more information including program dates, times, locations, and minimum age requirements—visit www.mndnr.gov/ican or contact the DNR Information Center at info.dnr@state.mn.us or 888-646-6367 (8 a.m.-8 p.m. Monday through Friday, 9 a.m.-1 p.m. Saturday). To register for a program, visit www.mndnr.gov/reservations or call 866-857-2757 (8 a.m.-8 p.m. daily, except holidays). This series of introductory programs is made possible with funding from the Parks and Trails Fund, created after voters approved the Clean Water, Land and Legacy Amendment in November 2008. The Parks and Trails Fund receives a share of sales tax revenue that may only be spent to support parks and trails of regional or statewide significance. The I Can! programs received a Government Innovation Award in 2015. More than 12,800 people have participated in these programs since they were first offered in 2010. Discuss below - to view set the hook here.