Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Mike Wallace

Composting Toilets

11 posts in this topic

I posted this under home improvement, but I figured this might be a better forum

Anyone have any first hand experience with composting toilets in cabins or hunting shacks? I'm looking for a way to have indoor plumbing without plumbing indoors.

I have done some research online and know there are several vendors for these products, but I thought I would check here for information.

Anyone?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My neighbor up at the cabin couldn't WAIT to get thier brand new composter out of their cabin.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My inlaws have one in their cabin, it sure beats walking outside, it is high maintenance, depends on how many people will be using it. If you are having a party with 6-8 people and they all are drinking, it will be a sloppy mess, if its a couple people should work fine, they have a fan to exhaust the smell, as long as that is running, and you empty it when you leave no problems!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Irvingdog; Why?

Finns.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Smell and maintenance. To much thinking involved. For the BS involved, it's easier to carry a heater to the outhouse and keep all the issues outdoors.....

Not my words. This is second hand. YMMV

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

We've had one for a year now at our cabin and although it looks nice it's quite a pain to maintain and unload, etc. Ours is not actually in the cabin it's in a shed right outside. It doesn't seem to smell much at all as it's vented out the ceiling. I just wish it was easier to unload the thing. We're weekenders at the cabin and normally it's just my father and I. The wives seem to like it a bit more than a regular old outhouse however.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You could go the counter culture route and use a simplified version of a composting toilet. Skip the manufactured contraptions for sale in the big box stores that require maintenance and chemicals entirely.

Toilet style seats are available from cabelas that attach to 5 gal buckets and also close tight to serve as a lid. Use that with some biodegradable liner bags and a good supply of sawdust. Lots of sawdust in the mix will keep odor issues to a minimum. Your 'mix' can then be transfered to a true outdoor compost pile that can be later used to feed ornamental trees and shrubs.

Any composting toilet, even the Cadillac version, is going to have a limited duty cycle. Parties and drinking don't mix with composting toilets. Too much of anything and you will have a stinking mess and want to take it out and go back to the old 3 gal/flush models. From the feedback here, and other discussion I have had about manufactured composting toilets, they just complicate something that should be very simple. For a party, you could get 5 buckets and lids and a chainsaw - self serve.

I believe that sometime in the future, sending human waste down the drain using clean fresh water to be mixed with more fresh water to later be cleaned and sanitized using expensive and complex systems and chemicals will be viewed as a huge folly. We are lucky, in Minnesota we have plenty of water and it is easy to disagree with about anything. Especially since we all have a couple of porcelain throwns mandated by code and a great supply of reading material..

LB

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Quote:

Your 'mix' can then be transfered to a true outdoor compost pile that can be later used to feed ornamental trees and shrubs.


Big accent on the word ORNAMENTAL! Also, I was under the belief that waste from omnivores and carnivores was not deemed suitable for composting practices.

Who would want to /ahem/ turn that "pile"?

I think I just threw up a little bit in the back of my throat.....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Quote:

I think I just threw up a little bit in the back of my throat.....


Nothing lots of sawdust won't fix.. grin.gif There is a book called The Humanure Handbook that is quite popular with permaculturalists and other tofu types. It dispels the myths associated with composting carnivore waste. Don't get me wrong, there are certainly issues in handling human waste, but it not being suitable for composting is obviously not true. Composting human manure has been done for centuries.

Yes, turning the pile will make it 'dirt' sooner than leaving it in an unturned pile. Both methods work. Put yer boots on!

LB

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

We have had one for five years in our summer cabin and first of all, it doesn't smell. We never get any odor from ours. If you have a lot of liquid volume, you can attach a drain hose and empty a five gallon bucket every five or six days. Maintenance is a little work. You have to follow directions from the manufacturer quite closely, but not having to go to the outhouse at three in the morning is worth the effort.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

A friend and I built a "deer shack" for him and his family,we cleared the land, excavated, installed the plumbing and electrical lines from the generator, and prepared the road for the modular home he bought and had placed on the site. It is a two story with 4 bedrooms. Since it is used primarily on weekends during the spring, fall and winter and for several weeks upto and including deer season. Conventional plumbing was not possible unless he wanted to heat year round and install a septic system. He opted for composting toilets, we installed them in both bathrooms, one of the critical things during install was the 4" vent pipes going high enough to clear the peak of the roof. It wasn't easy but we were able to get them high enough. In the 4 years they have been operating with a minimum of 2 adults and 3 kids using them, they have been great, I've never noticed smell, mess or any issues, and they have been simple to maintain. They are Sun-Mar Excel non-electric models without fans. They are spendy at almost $1400.00 each, but fit the bill for this place as there is no power other than running the generator when they are using the place.

Hope this helps.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • JeremyCampbell
      Saw a group  like you described a couple weeks back below the Sartell dam while fishing.They didnt have head gear though.They were playing by the dam gates riding the flow from the open side.Then they hung out by the closed side and I learned that its only about knee high on a certain area  that in my mind thought it was much deeper.Looked like fun for sure
    • lawman
      I have a Minn Kota Ulterra and am not having any problems. In last two days I have seen two fisherman struggling out on the water trying to stow their units that failed to auto stow. There is an emergency procedure described in digital manual but it is not very helpful. I have looked for a video of this procedure on You Tube but couldn't find one. Has anyone had any luck finding such a video??
    • Tom Sawyer
      Dandies! What did those big girls want to eat @Wanderer?
    • Wanderer
      Back to fun pictures and the reason I love coming to the Tower/Ely area!   There's just an amazing difference in the environment up here.  It's something I miss pretty much every day I'm not here.  And when you have as beautiful of a Saturday as we had yesterday, I just gotta say "Ahhh, this makes everything else worthwhile."   And when I go back through my best fishing memories, SO many have been made here, and yesterday I added another.  These girls in consecutive casts:  
    • eyeguy 54
      yesturday we were about 1/2 mile below the sartell dam and 4 jet skiis headed north to the dam area. the kind that yo stand on. looked like they all had go pros on helmets and looked like they were on a mission to have some fun. would have been nice to see what they did up there.
    • eyeguy 54
      great fishing so far   
    • ANYFISH2
      Couple from 5/27.  
    • ANYFISH2
      A few from 5/27  
    • workin4bait
      On Thursday I caught many crappies and sunfish that had not spawned yet. None of the bigger ones seemed to have spawned at all. We also caught almost no males.
    • Casey Sunsdahl
      I don't know what's wrong yet but I'm guessing it's not good. More pictures and drs in coming weeks.