Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

  • RECEIVE THE GIFTS MEMBERS SHARE WITH YOU HERE...THEN...CREATE SOMETHING TO ENCHANT OTHERS THAT YOU WANT TO SHARE

    You know what we all love...

    When you enchant people, you fill them with delight and yourself in return. Have Fun!!!

Sign in to follow this  
Coach1310

Which state would you choose....WHITETAILS.....

Recommended Posts

Coach1310

I would like to plan a hunt in a different state in the next few years and am looking for input as to where you would recommend. I would really like to hunt a state with good trophy potential in the chance I may take a real bruiser. It would be a do-it-yourself type hunt as I can't justify, much less afford any guided hunt through an outfitter. I am looking for states with decent public land opportunities and some clout in the whitetail world....my favs would be Kansas, Illinois, Iowa .... Thanks for any response.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
matthothand

Bow or rifle? For a DIY hunt with rifle I would go to Kansas. Second pick for bow or rifle would be Pike Co. Illinois. Kansas would be a good place to spot and stalk and hopefully look over a few animals to find the one you want...that's how they do it on tv anyways!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
harvey lee

I personally would hunt the Milk river area in Montana. I hunted there a few years back and am now planning another trip for next season. They do have some beautiful county there and some awesome whitetails also.

Iowa would be my second choice. Iowa is a little high on non res licenses though.

Bufflao county in Wisc. would also be a great choice as many book bucks are taken there. Problem with this area is land access. License fee isnt to bad for a non res either.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
maros91

I have seen the Milk River on TV and can't argue with that. I have hunted Mulies in Central Montana near Lewistown. I did notice that the river bottoms were full of whitetails and there were some bruisers in there but mostly on private land. Lewis and Clark National Forest is the bulk of the public land.

My second choice: Saskatchewan, Alberta

Third choice: Iowa

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
RBuker

If the key really is do it yourself, then Montana is the answer. They have enough public land to make your idea of getting a real trophy all on your own a reality. Kansas and Iowa have some real nice bucks but getting on good property is the hard part. I hunt Montana for coyotes and see a lot of really nice bucks when I'm out there... all on public land.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
DonBo

I agree with Montana. All the other choices thrown out here are great trophy producing states, but access is tough. Montana has tons of public land in great areas. Check out all of the Eastern part of the state. Milk River and Powder River areas would be a great place to start.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
GoggleEye

I can't believe that nobody has even mentioned southwestern Wisconsin!!!! This is one of the top producing areas for big bucks in the whole U.S. and believe it or not, there is a good amount of federally and state owned land. Just to name a few.....the Tiffany state wildlife area, the Kickapoo Valley Reserve, the LaFarge Reservoir. These public lands are crawling with bluff-dwelling monsters. You gotta be a smart and in-shape hunter to hunt them though, this land ain't easy to hunt. But then again, that's why these old mature bucks are there. Good luck finding decent land to hunt on in Iowa!!!! Unless you have 5,000 to 15,000 dollars to shell out. Kansas too. Montana would be my second choice, but then the cost goes up with gas and travel costs. Another bonus about wisconsin, you can do the gun hunt and still gun hunt in minnesota because the seasons are at different times. Hope this helps you with your decision. wink.gif

GoggleEye

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
picksbigwagon

My home area, NE Iowa, Allamakee County, on the ridges and bluffs, there are der there that has never seen a person before

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Coach1310

Thanks for all the responses. Keep them coming. Has anyone done a DIY hunt that they would or wouldn't do again? My hunt is probably a few years off, but I figured it is never too early to start doing some research. I am just excited about hunting whitetails in a new place. Thanks again.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Cooter

Boy, the public land criteria has me stumped...get back to ya later!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
james_walleye

I had some friends that went too IA a couple years ago too try too get permission too slug hunt. They finally did find a place and did well. The 3 guys that went all had opportunities at wallhangers. But everywhere they went they got similiar anwsers. People said "well our family gun hunts the land, but if you want too bowhunt you can". So if anyone is looking too IA too bowhunt keep this in mind.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
mattf

Have you hunted wis. before??? Where???

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Coach1310

Thanks for all the posts. If anyone has some tips as to where to start researching let me know. I have been to countless state sites looking at public tracts of land, license fees, lottery dates etc. so if anyone knows of way to make it easier I am all ears. Thanks again!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
picksbigwagon

not a lot of land in NE IA that is public, there is some, unfortunately it is all bluffs and bear to walk. You could probably find some private land that would let you deer hunt for bow hunting or for a small fee. I will ask around the next couple days, I am at my folks in Waukon and I will head to the local sporting goods store tomorrow and ask

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Coach1310

Great. Thanks a lot. IA is close that would make some scouting easier. Thanks again!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Rost

I'd go to Saskatchewan, Canada.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
GoggleEye

Matt F, I am originally from Wisconsin and have been hunting there all my life. In fact I am still hunting there in Polk County right now for the bow season. I work in WI, so I hunt there before and after work because I have no land to hunt here in MN. I grew up in the southern part of the state though, so most of my deer hunting has been done in Crawford, Vernon, Rock, and Jefferson county. I hunt private lands back home in Rock County and lots of public in Southwestern Wisconsin. There are some monsters in Southwestern WI, but my biggest buck to date was taken right outside of my hometown of Milton, in Rock County.

GoggleEye

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
picksbigwagon

coach, I just stopped at the local sporting good place, and the guy behind the counter said that Iowa does produce a map that shows public hunting areas. you could contact the Iowa DNR or go to their website and start your search there. I know there are some areas north of Waukon that is public but it is all bluffs, straight up and straight down. I am squirrel hunting in yellow river state forest tomorrow, I will ask the CO's there about deer hunting in that forest. That would be a great place, lots of land, there are deer there that have never seen people before and if they have, the people just said "Ooooooooo a deer" not "thwack" grin.gif

Good luck, what ever state you decide on, contact the state DNR and even the local CO's in the areas you are interested in

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
GoggleEye

If there is a public spot in Iowa that is all bluffs and what most would think is "too hard" to hunt due to the physical challenge of it, I hear the sound "Chaaaaching!!". Those are the areas where you are going to kill an animal of a lifetime. Get a good game cart for hauling your kill out and you are good to go. I just may take a road trip and check this place out for a possible future Iowa hunt. PicksBigWagon, How many acres is this public area north of Wahkon?? smile.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
picksbigwagon

goggleEye, It is about 6 miles south of the town of dorchester or one mile north of the upper Iowa river. Not sure of the acres I don't know how you would climb that ridge, as I drove by it I could only see 60' up the ridge without craning my head through the window of my truck, it is right on Highway 76. By the way, that town near mille lacs spelled it wrong, it is WAUKON!!! grin.gif

Yellow river state forest would take some time to scout and familiarize yourself. I would start this winter in that park with a map of the hiking and horseback trails( I now have one, and a gps to mark your way. Definately a scout trip before the snow get in there, the scenic point road was pretty steep in parts and the firetower road was an adventure in F150, only one lane wide. It is a state park so there is camping, not sure about hook ups but it does have at least 3 seperate campgrounds. Oh yeah, a trout stream runs through it too. Yellow river state park is about 13 miles southeast of waukon on highway 9.

okay just looked it up online, two areas around waukon in Allamakee county, French creek area, NE of waukon, 1300 acres. and waterloo creek north and south sections 1800 acres. add to that the 8500 acres in Yellow River state forest and there is about 12,000 acres of public land to hunt, trout fish, and camp on. Guess I was wrong about there not being a lot of public land in my county. I would suggest hunting during the week, it is public land afterall. Good luck and if anyone is going to try this area for hunting, keep us updated. French Creek area is unbelieveable. I would start there, I have seen some bruisers while trout fishing there

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
frogtosser

what are the odds that someone would draw a tag in Iowa? I have family down there and have thought about tring to hunt it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
GoggleEye

Picksbigwagon, WOW! Thanks for all the detailed info. and help. This sounds like it could be a very worthwhile DIY hunt. Do you know if you have to apply for a bow tag in Iowa or can you just buy one over the counter? I know gun is definitely an apply thing, but I have never asked about bow.

GoggleEye

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
picksbigwagon

ya got me on the bow thing, I would assume there is some kind of process for it, I am sure their dnr website would have something on, oh wait I have the regulations right here, let me check (tick tick tick tick......)ugh, can't find them, let's try the website (tick tick tick....) no luck, I would contact them and see what they have to say, they are pretty helpful

ya know the really bad thing? I never hunted when I was a kid, my dad used to in his youth but I think mom stopped that for him. So I spent about 18 years in Allamakee county and never hunted until I moved to MN. Man what a waste of time, it is now tooooo expensive for me to go back an hunt there, at least for deer with horns that is

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
GoggleEye

That's too bad Picks. I'm sure you would have had some memorable moments hunting the bruisers of Iowa. At least you are a hunter today and able to do it now. Better late than never! I am sure grateful for a buddy of mine getting me into hunting when I was younger. If he hadn't done it, I would probably not have picked it up myself. My dad didn't hunt either as he was a city slicker from Chicago. In fact, I think I am the only hunter in my entire family, both sides included. That kind of sucks too when you need land to hunt and all your family members are a bunch of city dwellers with no land. Not to mention there is no way I could afford any hunting land with the prices today!! Thanks for all the info! grin.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Coach1310

Picks...thanks so much for all the info. I may have to make my way down there to check it out. I have some in-laws who just moved to Iowa and I may have to swing in there on my way down to check it out. Thanks so much for all the info. I didn't expect all the detail. I think my first DIY out of state whitetail hunt will have to be in Iowa due to the proximity and reputation.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  



  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • oilandwater
      Only ice is in McQuade harbor and Knife River, and not much at that.  Cohos are biting really well on some days for guys fishing off the Two Harbors break wall. Pretty miserable conditions in which to fish, though....    South shore has good ice around Washburn, and a few cohos mixed in with good catches of Browns, spoke, and whitefish. Cohos on MN side have averaged 13-14" this winter.
    • Bass Thumb
      I have been using a Strikemaster Lithium Lazer 50v electric auger the last couple years. Very happy with it, but I'm limited to about 70-100 feet of ice drilled per charge, depending on temp/hardness of ice. That's more than enough for most bluegill trips, but it's lacking when the ice gets thick and I'm trying to find walleyes on big water during full-day trips. I find myself not drilling as many holes as I would like in an attempt to ration the charge. I just picked up an Eskimo P1 Rocket 8" propane auger. My buddy has the 10" and it's the best auger I've ever used. If anyone wants to really aerate a lake, the Rocket fits the bill. I'll use this along with the Strikemaster electric to meet all of my drilling needs. I haven't used the Rocket yet. It's in the mail. I'm excited at it's light weight in particular. 26 pounds. 
    • leech~~
      Next time you give it a try. Take a flash light and look up to make sure the throttle flapper is returning to the closed position when you let off the gas and it dies. I have had them stick open or half open then your more or less trying to restart it at half or full throttle which may just be flooding it out. It's either starving for gas or flooding.  Let us know if you solve it.  Good Luck.
    • huntnfish
      I never fished north of Wahpeton. When I fished down there I'd go south. There's normally some walleye biting early in the year south of the main road through town. I don't know how it would be this time of year. I always fished it first ice because that was usually fishable before most lakes. If you do go out I'd recommend bringing someone along and having a chisel along to check ice. That river ice can be very inconsistent. 
    • sparetime
      I ordered a rebuild kit from amazon for less than $5.00, so hopefully that will help.  YouTube has some videos on installing it.  It is an odd thing, if it sits for a while it will start and I can run it.  Once I take it off full throttle, it will die and I can't get it to restart.  Thanks for the posts so far, I appreciate it. 
    • fishin_magician2
      Anyone ever fish this lake? Buddy of mine wants to try it?
    • leech~~
      For cleaning carbs I use Gumout spray with the tube on it to shoot through all the passage ways. If I'm finding one not flowing well or clogged I like to use a gas welding tip cleaner. There are a lot of sizes and you don't have to jam something to big through it which could widen and ruin the flow. I got a nice pretty new little chain saw from a guy who just could not get it running for Free. Found that no spray would go through the main jet when I was cleaning the carb. Used the tip cleaner to knock out a piece of saw dust, and clear our Deer trails out really nice this year! Like Wanderer and Borch said, rebuild kits are cheap and a good thing to do if it's been gummed up.  p.s those little piss-ant needle flow valve springs are really fun to get back in place with fat fingers! They like to jump off the work bench and hide!!  
    • Tom Sawyer
      Sounds fun Jeff!, The way the ice has set up this year maybe it will happen after all. I would like to start getting a few prizes together for Biggest Cat, and also a kids division. Hopefully someone can bring a few good ones to the scales...
    • Wanderer
      @donethat Where is this access you speak of?  I’m not familiar with “bullhead bay”.  Is there a problem with people trespassing? The access I was referring to last year looked pretty public to me.
    • Borch
      Carb kit may help.  It's plugged or gasket/diaphragm dried out or cracked.  Alternating between choke and open when running will sometimes help if diaphram.
  • Share & Have Fun