Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

  • Announcements

    • Rick

      1st Please Post Your Fishing Report - Then Join the NEW - Private Fishing Report Clubs   01/24/2018

      Private Fishing Report Clubs - Click Here - Post Your Fishing Report Before Joining
      1st, be sure you post a fishing report in the forums, then ask to join after you post a fishing report in your area forum. The Private Fishing Report Clubs are where folks can share private fishing information with club members who have proven they know what's going on. Fishing Report Clubs Link also in Menu above. Apply to become a member today, while it's still easy. 
  • RECEIVE THE GIFTS MEMBERS SHARE WITH YOU HERE...THEN...CREATE SOMETHING TO ENCHANT OTHERS THAT YOU WANT TO SHARE

    You know what we all love...

    When you enchant people, you fill them with delight and yourself in return. Have Fun!!!

Sign in to follow this  
frummybear

Scent of Choice???

Recommended Posts

frummybear

I know there are a lot of different scents to buy. Some may be better than others, some are a lot more expensive than others. What are some brands of scent(urine) of choice that people have had success with?? Do you like to use the scent dripper of just walk the area with the urine on your boots??? Fire away with your choice and a story if you like.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
roosterslayer

I like special golden estrous. I drag it behind me to my stand and hang it up. I shot a real nice buck 3 years back that followed the drag right the the branch it was hanging on. But i may try whittcombs this year, i heard their scents are greatr and it is hard to get anything that doesn't have artificial additives and from what i understand whittcombs is 100% real deer urine and each bottle is from the same deer.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
JDM

Whitcombs all the way.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
harvey lee

When I do use scent it is from James valley.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
ddp

Speaking of Whitcomb's... Last year I stood infront of the freezer at Gander until my fingers were numb from the frozen scent trying to figure out which one I wanted. Buck or Doe urine. What is the best choice if I were to get one or the other? I hunt the big woods north of two harbors so the deer population isn't the largest. I do target the bucks more than the does. Do I get the buck urine to irritate the bucks or get the doe urine to attract the bucks? ah decisions smile.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
96trigger

During the rut, I've only used Doe urine, I have seen them come to it on it a string. I might try buck uring at a scrape or during prerut, but I almost exclusively use doe pee, or no pee at all.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Jim Hudson

James Valley here too.. Lethal Weapon and Full Draw to be exact in gel formula.. Also, have had good luck with Mrs Doe Pee.

In my own hunting game, I use my scents not only to draw deer in, usually through a trail laid down on the ground, but to also position deer for a better shot.. Always trying to make the deer to turn their heads the other way... With the James Valley scents, once a buck locks into the trail they seem to follow with intent and at the end of the trail they smell the other way to the wick I have hanging off a limb to position the shot.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Jigging Bob

Is there a such thing as to much scent in trees? I usually set up sent wicks all around me & the 3 other guys that hunt our land also set up perimeter wicks around them using different brands. I guess the idea is to make it smell like a whore house. wink.gif Not sure if this is good idea or bad idea. We hunt in a slug area so like I said there is 4 of us in a area of trees. Helps knock down the human scents also. I have also started putting up drip bags around on there trails. Usually just use doe pee thats on sale. Haven't really noticed if any are better than the other? I also make sure to use cover scents. The drags are also a very good idea. I don't waste money on buying anything. I just cut some cloth off something, soak it in doe pee in a sealed tupaware for a few days prior to hunting. The morning before I go to my stand I open up the container (be sure to stand back when opening this baby, if you catch a direct wiff it may knock you out) then hook it to a shoe lase and tie it to my boot then let it drag to my stand then I let it hang from my stand also. However, I have had the bad luck the last few years. The deer always seem to run to the other guys stands. One of the years the luck will come back to me & da tirty pointer will be in my sights. smirk.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
gizmoguy

Here's a money saving idea. Tampons work great for sent wicks. Basic non-sented type. Just tie a loop in the string and hang.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Jeremy Donabauer

Check out "Craptonite" on Ebay. I know these guys and they consistently put big whitetails on the ground. Or google craptonite products. I use the scent and it is second to none.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
DRH1175

I have used Whitcombs once. Golden estrus many times. I honestly have yet to prove to myself that they work. Though every year I still end up buying for the chance that one time having a buck come cruising in.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
UdeLakeTom

The fact is ...urine is urine. Deer cannot tell the difference. Some companies even make artifical urine. If it is an active scrape, human urine will work just as well.

This isn't just my opinion, seminars are teaching this...save your money, drink lots of coffee and have at it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Shack

Whitcombs is the only stuff I have used, if I use a sent. They give you sent wicks to tie to your boots for free (no hanging tampons grin.gif ). I would never live down a buddy of mine catching me with tampons tied to me and boots, let alone a CO grin.gif .

Whitcombs is a great place this time of year! You can bring kids up and look at trophy bucks and (if you want) watch them extract deer urine from bucks and does (have not done this yet). Kids will buy some feed from the gum ball machine and feed the deer. There archery area is pretty cool also. They have some monster buck mounts on wall and a tone of pics on wall. I think monster bucks come from a privet hunting area or Camp Ripley hunt!

When I have used Whitcombs, I have had good luck with does following trail and then bucks followed!

I am not much of a sent guy, but Whitcombs is sure a nice place to stop with family if you are a hunter and have hunter kids. They have a blast! Live deer and live monster bucks!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
DeanoB

I have had numerous bucks come and sniff the wick using trails end 307. This year at the archery pro shop i heard some guys talking about scents, and they all agreed on the James Valley, i think it was, which has already been mentioned. the pro shop in Roch charges 9.99 for it, but 4 guys were swearing by it, one guy saying he just opens the bottle and sets it on a cow pie, and bucks will come out across the pasture, drop their head, and sniff all over till they come right up to the jar and lick it, and paw at it, totally engrossed in the stuff. the other guy said he uses a stick to apply it on licking branches and another guy drags it behind him. They all said they have taken bucks using the stuff. I bought some, but forgot it when i was out on sunday. I'm not sure I think they said the full draw, was what they had been using, and also if it is kept in the fridge after use, i guess it can last years.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Shack

Do they really lick up pee/urine?

I have seen deer go nutz for deer cane and other mineral toppings, but I think all they do for urine is follow sent to were ever its coming from. I could be wrong, but the couple times I have used sent and it seemed to work was like I said the doe followed trail I poured coming out of thick wood cover. Doe came right out in a large open field right were I poured sent. I did not see doe pawing at ground, just her head bobbing up and down and slowly coming out into open. Then a little 6 pointer came after words, again slowly with head bobbing up and down!

I think the guys who sell the scents come up with all kinds of lines to sell their product to whom ever ask's...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
DeanoB

the James Valley isn't pee, it's a gel, and yes i would say 3/4 of the stuff out there is designed to lure the hunter not the hunted. watch out for the gimmicks!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Shack

Quote:


and yes i would say 3/4 of the stuff out there is designed to lure the hunter not the hunted.


That made me LMAO grin.gif!!!!!!!

Quote:


the James Valley isn't pee, it's a gel


Sorry, I never heard of it before! I asumed it was a some type of urine lure!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
DRH1175

So if pee is pee does it hurt to pee off your stand? I have always got down dug a hole then buried it. Does this have to be done or can I just pee off my stand?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
DeanoB

i think it depends on who you ask, human pee is, well human, deer are "programmed" to retreat from human odors. Some people i know, use one of those urinals from the hospital, you can pee in it, and empty after your hunt. Personally I always bring a 1 litre bottle of pepsi or dew, cause they have the wide opening. Then after drinking, you can fill that up, cap it off and pack it out with you. grin.gif i value my time out in the woods, and would hate to have deer not come in , cause they smelled pee, but then again, people say don't smoke when hunting, and I've shot 10 or so deer with a marlboro hanging out of my mouth.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Phill Aldahl

Until this year I have been wherry of peeing around where my stand is located, but this year I have been reading from multiple sources that deer will come in to investigate where you pee, especially if it is in a mock scrape. Their theory is that all in all pee breaks down to be the same thing, ammonia. So, I decided to try it out, a few days ago I made a mock scrape 25 yards from my stand on a well traveled deer stand. I guess I will see if it works or not, although when I was out yesterday in the rain it looked like there was a track on one of the sides of the scrape. It hadn't been reworked, so I took a stick and reworked it and peed in it again. I haven't seen a buck on this piece of land yet, so hopefully it works. I will let you know.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
DuluthGuy

I wouldn't pee around my stand. However, here is my 1st hand Story.

2005 season - I am making a deer drive to my brothers. Now and then I will use a deer grunt while stalking through the woods. I was walking alond a Norway ridge when I needed to pee. I was just finishing zipping up when I heard grunting ahead of me. I assumed it was my brothers messing with me on the stand. However, it was coming closer... Sudenly a 8-pointer is walking down the ridge in front of me grunting with each step. I almost started laughing. He had his head down and mind somewhere else. I let him come to 20 yrds away and shot him in the chest facing me. He ran forward (almost hitting me and died 10 feet away. Now, I KNOW that buck came to the urine! At first I didn't believe it, but after looking at the facts... wind, noise, my back trail, etc. That was the one thing that would have returned that type of behavior.

my 'pee' story. (yes, the Rut was on!)

I still wouldn't pee by my stand - but maybe would try to create a scrap & see what would happen????

Butch

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
UdeLakeTom

The difference is, you have to use the scrape, or be good at

making a mock scrape. Use the Dew bottle or equivalent, then if you find the scrape, dump it. You are correct in not doing it from your stand.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
brassman

I pee off my stand all the time, never once have I had a deer sniff it and bust out of there. I had a small buck come down wind of me one day right after I peed off my stand and of course it all didn't land on the ground but hit tree branches on the way down and he didn't even flinch. thats my experience.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
GoggleEye

For scents, I always make sure my clothes are washed in scent-free detergent to start out. I then spray myself down with a scent eliminator with the earth musk added to it. I also spray the bottom of my boots and pant legs with racoon or fox urine (unless it is the rut and I am trailing a doe estrous to my stand). I usually use the cheaper doe estrous because I have shot a few bucks with them and they all seem to work if they are fresh and stored properly. Sometimes they do make the does act a little skittish and they actually will sniff it, run away, come back, sniff, run away and so on. I don't know why they do that, but I suspect that maybe I put it out too early or something. Lastly, I have found that the deadliest weapon you can use for scent during the rut is an actual tarsal gland off a deer that you or a buddy has shot in the past week or so. Take the tarsal gland and cut it open and rub it all over a scrape or mock scrape and then hang it from a limb somewhere close to your stand. I have had bucks literally come ramming through looking for the source of the scent and tear scrapes apart with their necks just flaring. They will usually do a bunch of lip curls and thrash their head around too, it's absolutely hilarious. It's the best thing you can put in the air during the rut, hands down. Just remember to take it down each time and stick it in the freezer over night so you can get a few uses out of it. I actually will go to a registration station at rut time if I have not filled my tag yet and hang out there for a while in hopes of a hunter coming to register a buck and I will ask if I can cut the tarsal glands off. Most don't care and will let you cut it off their deer. Good Luck all.

GoggleEye

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  



  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • derbier122x
      Mine says it expires 2/25 this year. Either that or it' too work out to read.
    • mrpike1973
      Fished 4 days this last weekend. 1 tullibee, 1 walleye, sun up to sun down drilled and moved several times. Fun to fish but came home and limited out on sunnies on a small lake near me the allure of the big pond is over for me. Just my 2 cents good luck and have fun if you go.
    • Ron Vroom
      When I purchased them at a sports show, the guy doing the demo recommended the small duckbill pliers he was using sold by Menard’s. I tried using a small needle nose as well as a leather man, and ruined quite a few. I got the duck bills at Menard’s and that was the ticket, just like the guy said! I think the pressure is spread more evenly over the stop.
    • Alex wilhelmi
      That's what I want to hear. Thank you sir
    • monstermoose78
      It’s still a blast to fish
    • Alex wilhelmi
      thank you tom sawyer good to know,
    • Tom Sawyer
      Walleye numbers are strong. Unfortunate for the fisherman, the perch forage base on the lake has exploded. Lots of 3" - 5" food for the walleye = a tough bite....  
    • Alex wilhelmi
      Ok guys just a question not looking for places to go or tips. Just a question about the fish numbers. I've read multiple reviews that are good and bad, some say the Indians are over fishing it, others say all the sleeper houses are over fishing it. That and when the DNR does their number count. Walleye numbers are really low. Others say it's awesome fishing. But the bass and big walleye and Pike are eating all the young eyes. It's a huge lake it has to be good! Friend of mine went up with a portable Last weekend for the tournament and a 2.5 lb tullibee won the whole thing. And he didn't catch a thing. Long trip from Iowa to get beat down like that. I want to fish this lake so bad, with a portable or sleeper. But is it worth it? Fish numbers good or not? Thanks guys
    • Wanderer
      Yah, that lake is going to be crazy busier than normal this weekend. Another poster asked about rental wheelhouses a week or so ago and they were pointed toward C l I s t.  You could try that as well since they’re dealer based.
    • Sculpin
      Not sure who you have tried,  but it can be difficult as a result of the Perch Extravaganza. I have to believe somebody has a shack yet. I'll throw out some name's: Jerry Brandts,  Eddy Lybacks, Kevin McQuoids (Macs Twin Bay), Hunter Winfields, Dickies, Castaways, Agate Bay, Hunters Point, Barnacles, Red Door, Twin Pines, Garrison Sports, Rocky Reef, Appledorns, KJ's Ice fishing, Randys Rentals. Good Luck, hope you find a shack
  • Share & Have Fun