Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
nine-tiner

Killing northern pik on purpose in California

41 posts in this topic

check this link out

I especially like the statement that says they "regularly" grow to 55 lbs.

Of course I am not sure this is the answer to the problem, because if it was we would have to poison the entire Mississippi against the "flying" carp coming this way Yahoo

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would think the CA dept of fish and game knows what they are doing. It's an invasive species to that lake and needs to go. Not to different from what our DNR does here when they kill lakes to get rid of invasive fish.

This could be yet another result of amature biology where someone or some group thought it would be nice to have northerns in their lake. In the end it turns out badly.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is absurd in my opinion. California is known for wanting to produce world record fish, look at the bass they are growing out there in their lakes. Why not just have a trophy pike lake too.

And northern pike being an invasive species, I don't know if I would classify them as such. In all the fishing I have done this year, which has been a lot, I have caught one pike, and it was a decent one at 7 lbs. I guess I just don't see them as such a big problem.

Does the California DNR have way too much money or is it just another way to spend taxpayers dollars? 16 million to rid a lake of pike after they initially spent 20 million a few years back to try doing the same. Just seems like they aren't getting things quite right.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

WOW I came across this yesterday and was going to post it. Looks like you guys beat me to it.

Anywho, the pike have to go. They are decimating the trout population. http://www.dfg.ca.gov/lakedavis/

The pike in that lake aer obviously well fed. Look at these fatties!

12.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Let them pike eat them trout, buy the fishermen some nice flyrods with steel leaders and streamer flys and let em have at it. No I ain't a flyrod guy but I think thats what a lot of them western folks seem to like, they did when I was in Utah anyway so they could chase them 5# Rainbows. With that forage base a new world record is in the bag, and they'ld save a bunch of money. grin.gifgrin.gif

03.jpg

I D I O T S, but thats California. I sent them an email, I'll post the response if I get one.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hey guys, there is a good documentary from UC Davis on it, since the lake isn't too far from that institution. Pike are an invasive species over there. You have to understand what that distinction means. Invasive species, defined by wikipedia, is a non-indigenous species (e.g. plants or animals) that adversely effect the habitats they invade economically, environmentally or ecologically. Just because pike are from the U.S. and North America doesn't mean they are indigenous to California (they aren't).

Think about Rusty Crayfish in Minnesota. They are native to the Ohio River, but here in Minnesota, they are an invasive species.

It may seem hard to think of all those pike we can catch here as an invader somewhere else, but they are (same as the Largemouth Bass as someone pointed out). It is just a matter of priorities. It sounds like lakes out there are managed on a lake by lake basis, which is sometimes easier to do when you don't have 11,000 lakes to manage. In some lakes, California fish and game decides to stock trout in order to feed largemouth bass (I'm not kidding). In other instances, they rotenone lakes to kill invasive pike in order to restore trout. It's a matter of what they want in each lake.

The documenary on pike in Davis lake is really cool. I forgot the name of it. Basically, they tried rotenoning the lake but they never got all the fish. Pike are really tough...they tolerate some pretty harsh waters, it's how they become top of the food chain. It will be tough for them to appease all of their lake users because not everyone wants to get rid of the pike.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The MN DNR does the same thing here to stream trout lakes, if the pike population gets to large in a stream trout lake, they'll poison it, kill all the fish and then restock trout.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Slot the lake, let em eat the trout and look for a record Northern in the coming years, problem solved. Feed the Pike, get rid of the invasive trout, look for a new world record. smirk.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

that always seemed wrong to me when i first got here. they almost seem to want the bass to eat the trout, but not the pike. personally i think they should sprnd a little less time stocking these lakes with trout and focus solely on the mountain streams. it always makes me laugh a little to see these guys with their fancy flyfishing outfits chasing freshly stocked hatchery trout. there are several wild trout rivers in this area and they aremore fun to catch than the dog food fish anyway. i always thought that walleye would do well in these foothill resevours too. once these californians got a taste for walleye they would forget about trout. personally i would rather eat a 2 pound pike than a trout. they are a crazy bunch out here. cool.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The thing is if the pike get into those natural trout streams they will kill off the species. the trout just arent equiped to fight of northerns. They are an invasive species in that part of the country and do not belong there

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

How about we do an exchange. We send them all of our Smallies and we take all of their Northerns.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

No deal! mad.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Quote:

No deal!
mad.gif


I agree. No deal! Give them the LM instead grin.gif , and keep the SM ! smirk.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

As a tax payer, how would you feel if they spent 36 million to eliminate carp from minnetonka? And their answer was to poison the lake?

...

On a different note. I remember picking up a magazine at a doctors office that detailed the 100 largest northern pike ever caught. It's been several years, so my memory is a bit blurry, so forgive me if the details are a little off.

The article suggested that the top 70 or so pike, were from Europe, and many of those were caught during one two-week period out of one lake. Apparently this TROUT lake had no season for pike, and because of the trout population, it had developed some monster northern pike.

Some brilliant person eventually decided to have an open season on the monster pike for 2 weeks. Many of the largest pike ever caught were taken during those two-weeks. The idea was to eliminate these monster pike, so that the trout would prosper.

Well, guess what. They got rid of the monster pike, and shortly thereafter, there was a proliferation of little pike... and shortly thereafter, a CRASH in the trout population. It seems the monster pike were also controlling the pike population, perhaps through canabalism... the whole thing backfired on their fisheries management.

Kinda reminds me of the cormorants on Leech. Take the predators off the island that are eating the cormorant eggs, and a few years, and a few thousand cormorants later, and you have a walleye crash.

I don't think humans really know the effects of their endeavors.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

NOW WAIT A MINUTE HERE!! mad.gifmad.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Heres the reply to my email.

Mr. Martin,

We have often been asked what is wrong with pike. My reply "There is absolutely

nothing wrong with pike, what is wrong is when someone illegally introduces them

to waters they are not native to and the ensuing consequence of these introductions.

Several states have waters where they are experiencing this phenomena. Alaska,

a state which has pike naturally north of the Alaskan Range, has experienced what

the presence of illegal introductions of pike can do to fisheries. If you are interested,

I would suggest you check out their web page on pike to read further about the effects

pike have had on their salmon/steelhead populations in the Susitna River drainage.

http://www.wildlifenews.alaska.gov/index.cfm?adfg=wildlife_news.view_article&articles_id=50&issue_id=13

Colorado is also experiencing problems with pike in the Yampa River in the northwestern

part of the state. Here pike are threatening native species which may or may not

be endangered.

http://www.colostate.edu/depts/coopunit/research-northernpike.html

Nevada is having problems with the illegal introduction of pike into Commins Lake

near Ely, NV.

http://www.ndow.org/about/news/pr/020706_comins_pike.shtm

Maine is also experiencing problems with persons illegally stocking pike and they

suspect the presence of pike has led to the loss of an inland salmon population.

http://www.maine.gov/ifw/fishing/illegal_stocking.htm

I'm not so sure the pike would become a 'world class' sized fish in

Lake Davis. The forage for the pike is most likely not adequate to produce such

fish. The largest pike we have seen come from the lake was yesterday following

application of rotenone. This fish was approximately 46" long and weighed

approximately 22 pounds. It was 7 years old and would most likely have only lived

another 1 or 2 years before dying a natural death.

FYI, I will be retiring to the Leech Lake (Walker, MN) area in 10 days. I am looking

forward to enjoying the walleye and musky fishing. Both my wife and I are originally

from the mid-west.

Hope this gives you some idea about our Department's concerns regarding the

northern pike.

Ivan L. Paulsen

Senior Biologist Supervisor, Fisheries

Calif. Dept. Fish & Game

P.O. Box 1858

Portola, CA 96122

(530) 832-4067

FAX (530) 832-9706

Cell (530) 520-6704

ipaulsen@dfg.ca.gov

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

How come all of these non native Pike states have a problem with them and where they are native, there aint any?

I'd love to have a pike lake..... somehwere closer than 3 hours away.

Used to be alot of Northerns in the priarie basin lakes, but not no more.

I wonder if theyd let you fish for the Pike without a fishing license if you went to Ca to help ? hehehe

I'm planning a racing trip to Northern Ca next year. I'd love to help them out for an afternoon.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Why not use the Pike as a food instead of just killing them all. Why waste a resource? Im pretty sure they can come up with ways to harvest the meat and sell or give to charity or 3rd world countries that need food.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Quote:

How come all of these non native Pike states have a problem with them and where they are native, there aint any?


Where they aren't native they don't have any predators or controls and have a prey source that isn't adapted to their presence. Think of it as if you went from being a player in a blackjack game to the dealer. Instantly you have an advantage. Locally you can find pike in most lakes, catching them, or catching any with some size is a different manner, especially when they aren't on a diet of fatty rainbow trout.

Quote:

Why not use the Pike as a food instead of just killing them all. Why waste a resource? Im pretty sure they can come up with ways to harvest the meat and sell or give to charity or 3rd world countries that need food.


Rotenone is classified by the World Health Organization as a moderately hazardous chemical and is mildly toxic to humans and other mammals. Human deaths attributed to Rotenone are rare because its irritating action causes vomiting in cases where it could be fatal.

Fishing the pike out of the lake would be next to impossible, while there is a more realistic chance of removing pike with rotenone (although interestingly rotenone has already failed in removing pike on Davis Lake once). It's natural to not want to waste but in this instance there wouldn't be an efficient means of removal. People in China would probably think Minnesotans are wasteful if they saw all the carp that typically winterkill in some of our shallow lakes.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Have any of you ever caught a 55 lb pike before? confused.gif

I know I would sure like to.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Analyzer:

I think I remember that article. Fins and Feathers? Turns out the cannibal side of the Pike is a good thing. They figured the monsters kept the hammer handles in check.

There's a reason live bait isn't allowed on designated trout waters. If a state wants to maintain a certain body for a certain species of fish, who are we to complain? Overseas, carp are more desired than walleye. (I'd love to see a Zander lake close!)

TC

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

why do any of you really care what goes on in cali anyway....planning a pike trip here soon grin.gif let the ca dnr do what they know is right for their waters and stop bothering them with your e-mails. wish they would come over here and find a way to get rid of some of the little hammers in the metro.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

How come people dont complain when a lake gets over run with bullheads and carp they kill it out and put walleyes back in? Carp are a great game fish and are a much harder fighting fish than a walleye so what if some one told you well just put your lindy rigs and cranks away and go after the carp?

You probably wouldn't, you want your walleye fishery back well these people love their trout fishing and have limited places to do it so they want it back.

Arizona also has problems with introduced pike into trout lakes. Some southern states have problems with Flathead catfish introduced into certain waters eating all the native fish. Just be thankful its not happening to your favorite species of fish in your favorite waters.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Quote:

Analyzer:

Turns out the cannibal side of the Pike is a good thing. They figured the monsters kept the hammer handles in check.

TC


Hence, the reason for the slot restrictions on a lot of the lakes that could potentially produce trophy pike!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Why don't we import all of those monster fish back here to minnesota and stock them in the metro lakes that have been all fished out of big fish and have a ton of stunted pike and pannies! grin.gif That would be cool!

Tunrevir~ grin.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • ZachD
    • ZachD
      So I am torn I want to put a graph in my smaller boat.. I love my lx 6 flasher and am thinking about getting the high speed transducer for it and just going with that but I don't get why they charge $199 for it when bird and lowrance ducers are far less   I almost pulled the trigger on the lowrance hook 4 with down scan and chart plotter at gander for $179  I don't care about the chart plotter really as I have a big hand held gps that I use in that boat and that screen is larger than the hook 4 when you have it split plotter and graph they only had the display model left and wouldn't go lower price so I passed   If I can find the hook 4 at another gander that doesn't have the chart plotter for cheaper I may go with that   Does any one have experience with the lx on open water I hear it is at par with an lowrance elite 5 I am kind of wanting to go with that but don't know   What would you do run the lx open water or go with hook 4 with down scan  
    • bmc
      We survived our trip!  LOL   Fishing was steady.   We caught 30 walleyes in 3 days of fishing.  Usually fished from 11 am to 4 pm.  The 'eyes were running small, lots of 11 to 13 3/4" fish, but we did get 3 keepers.  We also kept a few nice perch and crappies.  We also caught a few snake northerns.   Jigging w/ chubs produced the best, but I did catch a few 'eyes on the crawler lindy rig combo.  Mid lake structure and underwater points off of islands all produced fish.  Mayflys were hatching, but the fish were still hungry. I did catch a 4-5 lb channel cat in the Savanna River one evening.   We stayed in the south loop of the Army Corp campground.  We liked that we were w/in about 30 yds of our boat which we kept at the dock.  The river on the north side of us and the lake on the south side offered a nice breeze to keep things cool and the bugs away for the most part.  Con's were the campsites are small and were too close together.  Also no turn around at the end of the south loop road.  The north loop was beautiful, spacious campsites, but surrounded by swamp and we heard the skeeters were bad at dusk.  Definitely want some thermacells or a screen tent to enjoy the evening by the sounds of things.  Also the docks aren't close/in view of the campsites.   We would definitely stay there again, on the north loop, in May or Sept. after the skeeters have died down a bit.   Staff was friendly, shower houses were nice, boat landings were nice.     Brian
    • MedicineMan
      Went out Thursday for a few hours. Caught a 28" Walleye along with a handful of nice sized Bass.
    • knoppers
      thanks for the report.
    • JBMasterAngler
    • JBMasterAngler
      Just got back from our 34th annual Grand Marais trip. Weather, and how bad it was, was the theme. At one point or another, it rained every single day we were there! The wind was miserable he last couple days as well. Really affected our fishing plans, as we had to cancel out on some of our normal lakes, and fish some less than desirable backup lakes.   As per tradition, we left in the middle of the night and pulled up to the Lester River just a few minutes before sunrise. Didn't catch anything there. Also got skunked at the Talmadge and French rivers. I got free admission at Tom's logging camp on account it was Father's Day  and as always, kids had fun feeding the animals. I did catch a few little rainbows out of sucker, knife, and Stewart rivers. Had our traditional "fisherman's breakfast" at McDonalds in Two Harbors. We stopped at the silver creek tunnel, and that was the first time I've been at the overlook since it was actually part of the highway back in '94. We rolled into Grand Marais at about 3:30 and had to wait out a rain storm before putting the boat out on Kimball Lake. We lost several trout, and in the end, only my 6 year old son caught 2 rainbows.   Monday we fished Greenwood Lake, and as was the case with my 2 older kids, my 3 year old daughter caught her very first fish here...a smallmouth bass! Between all of us, we caught about 130 bass, all of which were pretty small. Unfortunately no lake trout. However, a big surprise occurred...while casting for bass, I caught a herring! Then a few minutes later, my son caught one also! Never would have guessed I'd ever catch one in the summer, let alone 2!   Fished a "secret lake" on Tuesday and caught quite a few northerns. They were all either 5 pounds, or 6 inches long, nothing in between. My son caught an 8 pound, 33 incher, which ended up being the biggest fish of the trip. We was screaming, and excited, and wanted me to take his fishing pole. But after about 10 minutes he finally got it in so I could net it. He's still bragging about it. My 3 year old also caught her 2nd ever fish, a perch, which ended up being the only one of the trip.   Went up to Saganaga on Wednesday. I spent I don't know how many hours trying to catch lake trout, but didn't find any!  Finally gave up and ventured deep into red rock bay for the first time ever. Really nice back there, wish I would've went there first. Fishing was ok, considering the weather was starting to get bad. Caught the biggest bass of the trip, a hair over 18 inches. On the drive back we seen a bear. Ironically it was walking down the road to black bear lodge at Poplar Lake.   Biggest disappointment came on Thursday. The plan was to fish both Hungry Jack and West Bearskin lakes. The wind was terrible, and coming straight from the west. Had hungry jack not had the reputation as a big bass producer, I wouldn't have went here. Unfortunately the big bass weren't around, nor any bass for that matter. Only caught 4 small bass. Kids caught about a dozen or so sunnies from the dock at the resort, some of which were decent size. We didn't even bother with bearskin. There's no way we would be able to launch our boats in that wind. We went to Loon Lake instead. In the limited time we were there, we caught about 30 tiny bass. My 9 year old daughter also caught her first rock bass. I tried for lakers, and marked a lot of them, but didn't catch any.    So since we didn't fish West Bearskin as planned, we penciled it in for Friday. Knowing the weather was going to be bad, we picked Poplar Lake as our backup. I drove up to Mayhew Lake to start, because I wanted to check out the launch. I was able to get my boat down the launch, but it was a real tight fit. Nice little lake. We saw a mommy moose with 2 babies laying right on the shoreline. I got sick of trolling, so I decided to cast cranks along the drop offs of the one small stretch of shoreline that was out of the wind (relatively speaking). Hooked into a big fish! Got excited because I thought I finally had a lake trout! It was a northern!  never thought I'd be disappointed in catching a 5.5 pound pike, but that's what I was. Didn't bother going to Bearskin, as I knew the wind was too bad again. Went to Poplar, which is a lake I do not like! As is typical, the fishing was no good! He weather was bi polar! It would be bright and sunny, then rain for 20 minutes. Did that the whole rest of the day! Only caught 1 little pike and  1 little bass. Got excited for a minute, as whitefish started surfacing around my boat in the evening. I was hoping I could catch 1 or 2, but nope!    Saturday we were supposed to fish Two Island for a few hours before going home. But it was pouring rain. We didn't even bother driving around to different boat launches. So the trip ended on a sour note, but we still had lots of fun, seen a moose, had our donuts (I highly recommend the bacon maple longjohn by the way), and went to Sven & Ole's. I was going to go camping in Ely in July, but I think we'll come back to Grand Marais instead, and try to make up for what we missed out on due to the weather. IMG_6122.MOV
    • CaptJohnWis
      I have not been on Rainy much as of late. On June 12, I got 75 walleyes in about 6-8 FOW. On. June 15 (Sanctuary opener) I hit Stangi for several hours and only got four fish. June 17, got 20 fish in about five hours - mostly walleyes on a weed edge in about 8 feet of water. Many on jig with Lunker CIty trailers. Also some good ones on a feather jig. Bass were few and far between. Plus some pike but nothing huge. Biggest walleyes 24-25". Bass 18", pike 29". View my fishing report to see videos of lures that were working.   I did mark lots of fish in deeper water but they were dink walleyes so I did not fish them for long.The dinks are actually harder to catch on lures than bigger ones. They respond better to live bait which I don't use.
    • Cliff Wagenbach
      We had a good bite on 1/2 crawlers today! Boated 45 walleyes and kept our limits of fish that were all between 15-1/2" and 19-3/4 "! Released at least 6 slot fish. Largest was a fat 25-1/2 inch fish. Best over all sized fish limit all summer! The walleyes were stuffed with either May fly nymphs or molted crayfish.  
    • Michael Felix