Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
troutmaster

using tobacco while hunting

19 posts in this topic

How many of you guys use tobacco while you deer hunt (smoking/chewing) and do you think this affects your success or not. I chew tobacco and have for years, and i've been successful almost every year. in my opinion it seems to make them more curiouse than anything. whats everyones thoughts on this?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have smoked for years and without a doubt the smell affects your hunting. Every fall the three other guys I bow hunt with dont smoke and they see 4 times the bucks I do, year after year. I do smoke in the stand.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm a first year bow hunter, but have rifle hunted my whole life and I've seen a lot of deer while I'm smoking. However, I think its my movements rather than the scent that gets me busted.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i chew, on stand, but i don't spit, and i also throw it out and put in fresh at the same spot where i go "P" before heading to my stand. does this have some effect, probably. i ground hunt alot, and do my very best to keep my clothes scent free and watch the wind carefully. if they can smell the chew , they will smell me also. del

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I dont worry about the smoke smell to much when rifle hunting as my shots are usually very long distance and I always play the wind in my favor. For archery hunting and always having to have the deer at close range the smoke is killer for me.

I know, why doesnt one quit.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ya know I've seen more deer in the woods while I'm smokeing and running a chain saw,than when Im not smokeing and hunting,and at times loading wood with the radio on! I always wondered if their courious or just used to the loggers. confused.gifand I think in areas of Mn. they get used to smoke smell from heating fires,now can they tell the difference in cig. smoke and wood smoke ???

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I posted in the archery tip of the week that I use to chew Apple Jack while bowhunting, didn't worry about it during rifle season. I even put some of the Apple Jack on my baitpile (hunting in MI) and the deer went nuts for it. I certainly think deer can smell the difference between wood smoke and cig smoke, I know I can. I always have a piece of carpet on my stand that I spit on and keep my foot over. I know it doesn't keep the scent from getting out, but it helps and the carpet absorbs the noise from the spit. For all the kids reading this, I wish I had never started smoking or chewing. Keep that in mind.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Got mixed results and feeling of the whole "smokeing in the stand" topic. I have never NOT smoked in my deer stand. Bow or rifle. I have seen lots of deer and shot lots more while smoking/chewing. I think its keeping the movements to a minimum. My feeling is that deer don't associate that smell with danger. I may make them more allert but without seeing any movement I have had them walk right up to my ground blind while holding a hot smoke. If I would not have ever started or would quit who know maybe my trophy wall might be bigger. For me, as sad as it sounds, if i didnt get my nic fix, I would be thinking about it and probable figiting around with sticks and leaves and stuff. Now to avoid getting ripped apart from you guys. I dont sit there and puff away but I do have a smoke every hour or so. I do use sent blocker spray, play the wind, and use deer pis to help eliminate my "human oder" just the same as I would if I didnt smoke.

Just my $.02

Hoot

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well Hoot your not alone,cept I dont use any scent blockers,or deer scents,sometimes on my boot bottoms some fox urine for walkin in.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Last year while on stand, I popped some Kodiak wintergreen in. There was a cedar tree below me and to my right. I decided to spit on the tree in order to lessen the noise from the leaves below. After I was done with it, I pitched it out onto the cedar. About half hour later, two does walked right up to the tree and crawled underneath it. They hung around eating it!! I was trying not to laugh. The were directly beneath me eating my used snuff, so I had fun and spit a big goober right on one their heads! They jumped but did not know where it came from. I ended up with about 5 or so deer come right up to the tree. It was one of the funniest things I have ever seen in the woods.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Not that I am proud of smoking, but I do. I will say that I think it all depends where you hunt. If you hunt where there is alot of human to deer contact I think it lessens the effect of smoking and chewing.

If I was to hunt in some remote wilderness area I would be extremely cautious about scent control.

As someone mentioned earlier we have had deer walk almost right up to us while cutting wood and trail riding four wheelers at my friends place.

I try to be as cautious as possible during the archery season, just for the fact up the up close and personnel contact. I like mentioned before play the wind and thermals more than anything.

Good luck to all and lets have some relaxing hunts one way or another.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

when i chew in my stand, i always gut the stuff and keep my mouth shut as much as possible. i usually just breath out my nose. This seems to work well for me, last year i had multiple deer within 10yds of my stand while i had a big ol dip in. Maybe if i switch to scoal apple the deer would be attracted to it grin.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am bear hunting and going to get some Apple flavor chew; I admit I am very addicted and would not sit 10 minutes still

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you can find applejack buy it and put it on the baitpile and rub it on some trees and spit as much as you can grin.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I spit chew and pee by my stands and never noticed a problem...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ive smoked for over 10 years and have now quit for over a month now and never plan on touching another one!!! My theory is if you play the wind, nothing can smell you- no matter how bad you smell!?! So thats most important... even for people who think they have done it all to be scent free... I bet those deer will only get so close down wind before they WILL smell something!!!

As far as smoking or chewing in the stand.... there may be times where you can tell yourself its doesnt hurt you, but seriously... It will probably NEVER help you?!?! crazy.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I really enjoyed the snuse storys grin.gif

I too smoke , always have to do a wind check.

See a deer coming have to hurry and light one up so don't have to do it in slow motion .

Bear season I smoke swishersweets, bear love them, one I got came down wind ,ate the butt before I shot it.

I do love the ceder tree story.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i would say it has to do with what kind of deer you are hunting. a city buck probably knows the smells of humans but the deep woods deer would be more curious. i try to keep from chewing in the stand but come 9 a.m. I'm hard up for a chew and give in. i still see deer but i often wonder if id see more if i didn't. i also spit in a bottle, just to cut down on the smell. i wish they made a chew that tasted like wintergreen but smelled like doe-in-estrus hehe grin.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Years ago when i used to bow hunt i also worked for a farmer hauling his piggy manure.One day after hauling manure all day i left my work clothes on and was walking in a cornfield that the headlands had been removed.I had a young deer walk up smelling me.I could have poked him in the nose with my broadhead he was so close.I wreaked pretty bad of the manure.Soooooo if you want a good cover scent go haul a lil piggy manure

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Rick G
      Soooo many spots to hit, your going to love the yak, JC!   And Royce is right about an anchor. This would be my first investment.   
    • lawman
      My unit is not a link unit. I thought they worked the bugs out of these units. 19 years ago they recalled all of these when almost all of them failed. Fingers crossed I guess.  
    • Cret Jigs
             Hi guys - went out on Blue lake yesterday .... water temps around 61 -62 on the surface.    Tried for some walleye with ripple shads in the weeds with no success, did manage a nice Bass.  we switched to crappies and managed keeping a nice meal.  Let a nice monster Blue Gill go (9.75") and kept some nice Sunnies for the frying pan.   Pan fish were pretty active if you hit the right spots.  A lot of people out there and the access was not a place to be in a hurry!!   We had to work for the crappies and the ones we caught were 9"-10" crappies full of eggs.  I would guess that although the ice was out early, many of the species are now late and delayed on the spawn.   if this weather don't warm up quick, i think the bass will drop their eggs and it won't be a good year for bass spawn this year.    Talked to some anglers out their bass fishing and they thought it was very slow and were puzzled.   Cret
    • Sushilicious
      I apologize for my word choice. I'm from chisholm n most of my camping trips growing up were decided after work on Friday n we can't do that now. The only positives that have come from the reservation system is ppl who have never been 2 the park (5%) now don't have 2 worry about a spot n the fishing guides don't have 2 worry about finding a place 4 shore lunch.
    • Wanderer
      Sorry I had to edit your title.  I've been hearing some people are upset about the change.  But I also heard there were some positives about it too.  I can't say anything one way or the other since I'm not affected.
    • Wanderer
        It does have lakers but I think they closed it for harvest.  I thought I read it was due to those lakers being a different strain and getting fished down a little too much.   That laker Rob caught was a hawg!  Too bad he got it taken away.
    • Sushilicious
      The fact that ppl have to reserve a campsite is absolute BS. The only thing the park accomplished by making ppl reserve campsites is lowering the amount of ppl who visit the park.
    • slammer
      Ive had the same issue.  I turned both the motor and remote of for 30 seconds or so and then worked fine.  it has happened twice for me.  Hope its not reoccurring which would be very annoying.  For the cost,  this stuff should work.  I wonder if they are I-link motors?  Mine is.
    • eyeguy 54
      .
    • slammer
      How has the bite been this weekend?  Not able to fish this weekend due to graduations.  Shiners still working?