Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

  • RECEIVE THE GIFTS MEMBERS SHARE WITH YOU HERE...THEN...CREATE SOMETHING TO ENCHANT OTHERS THAT YOU WANT TO SHARE

    You know what we all love...

    When you enchant people, you fill them with delight and yourself in return. Have Fun!!!

Sign in to follow this  
wallter

Expensive Goose Calls. Are they worth it?

Recommended Posts

wallter

Out looking and man they seem to look and sound good. Any thoughts?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
jblabsnduck

Depends what you buy.

My opinion, worth every penny you have.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
wallter

I need more information. For example I want a short reed that sounds GREAT which is made for a beginner (easy to use). One that includes a CD would be good. Otherwise can someone recommend a good CD?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Bushwacker

Quote:

I need more information. For example I want a short reed that sounds GREAT which is made for a beginner (easy to use). One that includes a CD would be good. Otherwise can someone recommend a good CD?


There have been a lot of great CD's that have come out in the last year or so. Bad Grammar by Scott Thrienen is my favorite. He's a MN guy that has hit the big time in the goose calling world. I also like Dave Smith's Breakthrough II. Both go from the basics to some advanced stuff. As far as calls go, for a starter call I could really strongly look at the Winglock short reed that is made out of Delrin. It is a great started call that is as easy to run as they come. It is backed by excellent customer service, and best of all it is in the $60 price range. Virtually an indestructible call. I started with one and since have acquired 25+ calls. 90% of those are high end acrylic calls, but to be completely honest, my Delrin Winglock can keep up with the best of them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
smg04

the look and sound of those expensive calls will impress judges at a contest.... but, i would be willing to bet $$$ that there has been just as many if not more geese killed with $15-$50 calls, you can go fancy if you want but the geese "the real judges" seem to like my $20 polycarb just fine

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
wallter

Bushwacker,

Now that's information. Any other calls you know of rival your favorite? Do they have them at Gander & Cabelas?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Fish&Fowl

I bought Shawn Stahl's Honker Talk DVD and got a lot of good info and techniques from it.

As far as calls, I just bought my first acrylic and instantly fell in love. I had been blowing a TG poly SuperMag, and really liked the call, but when the insert cracked I decided to buy an acrylic (Tg Real Thang) and sold the new replacement call to my dad. The sound of the acrylic plus the design of the call are both big reasons why I like it so much. If you're just beginning, don't buy acrylic, but after you blow a bunch of calls and get good, don't be afraid to give one a try.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Down2Earth

Long Honker Goose Flute by Big River!!!! $20. Comes with a tape. Me and my 4 buddies have been using them for over 10 years. If you want I can add pictures to back that up. I'm sure the $100 and some dollar calls will work just as well though grin.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
bear204

I think a good beginner call is the RNT Goozilla very goosey call and can get pretty loud for around $25 i believe. Some of the low end poly calls just dont comepare sound wise with the acrylics. Your best bet is to go to the store and blow some of the calls decide witch one you like and practice practice practice.

I would stay with a short reed call though, you can make so many more sounds on them then a flute.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
trailratedtj

i had a tg super mag. great sounding call. crappy material. snapped the p.o.s. around the band.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Swampbusters

Once I bought my first acrylic i fell in love and havent touched another call that wasnt acrylic. But I bought a Foiles Strait meat honker and loved it. I bought a Zink moneymaker this year and cant wait to bust the geese this fall. Its all in how much you want to spend. but I would recamend getting a acrylic call. just my 2 cents

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
carpshooterdeluxe

last fall i blew an acrylic h.s. slammer custom, but i wasnt very impressed with it. this winter i bought a winglock short reed acrylic and after some practice i thought i was pretty good with it. and after a little tuning and a lot more practice, i think im great with it. but i feel that ive learned all i can learn on that call, so i picked up a zink moneymaker a few weeks ago. all i can say is wow. after an impromtu lesson from a zink pro staffer, im hitting different sounds and variations that i couldnt do with the winglock. any goose call will kill geese some of the time. theres really only three notes you need to know for hunting. but having the knowledge of other notes and a great call can give you the edge on pressured refuge birds and late season birds like what we hunt. hopefully the moneymaker does that for me.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
ironman

Honky Tonk...by primos. They are cheap, easy to blow, come with a dvd...or at least mine did...and sound pretty darn good. When I was just starting I ran into this pro hunter dude and asked him for some tips...he wanted to see my call. I told him it was a cheapy and he blew it...looked at the thing and said..."wow..who makes this?!" He was pretty impressed. For the price I dont think it can be beat. I believe it was under twenty bucks.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Sartell Angler

Quote:

i had a tg super mag. great sounding call. crappy material. snapped the p.o.s. around the band.


mine is going strong smile.gif

before that I blew a Sean Mann Eastern Shoreman flute...both retail around $60, both have been known to pull in the birds from time to time

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
hanson

Just curious as to what you guys think...

Does good calling (calls) trump location & decoy spread?

I know... tough question. grin.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
surewood

I like my winglok derlin great for clucks and double clucks but it could be better if it had better range on the low end. It's a little trickier to pull off the low murmur, which I love to use. I think I payed about fifty dollars for it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Down2Earth

Quote:

Just curious as to what you guys think...

Does good calling (calls) trump location & decoy spread?

I know... tough question.
grin.gif


I would def. say location, location, location.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
bear204

Location is definatley key, then i would say setup of decoys and concealment. then calling. But on days where your running traffic on birds or hunting migrators you need to be able to call

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
grousehunter

Location is definatly the number one factor, but after that i would say calling takes second. Geese respond to calling, ive even called them over me with no decoys. With ducks its definatly location and then decoys/setup to me.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Abrams

Goose calling is not very important, IMO; location, concealment, decoys, and then calling. The thing about calling is that it helps guide the birds into where you want them. It does help finish them off into the decoys.

I have tried just about ever goose call made a few of the best: Giant Killer LG-1, Bay Country Calls Shore Thing, and C&S Custom Calls Prophet. And yes they are worth the money.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Bushwacker

Quote:

Bushwacker,

Now that's information. Any other calls you know of rival your favorite? Do they have them at Gander & Cabelas?


I think both Cabelas and Gander have Winglocks. I know Gander had them for an unbelievable price last winter after the season, but I haven't looked this fall yet. Otherwise they have a website that you can search for and Rick Perry, the owner, is about the most helpful guy you will find in goose calls. If you give him a call he will set you up and tune the call to your exact liking. Low end, middle, or high, easy blowing or hard blowing.

Fish&Fowl mentioned Shawn Stahl's DVD Honker Talk and that has been the single most helpful thing I have used to learn how to blow a short read. I actually had it on video and upgraded to the DVD when they came out. It is a few years old, but has definitely stood the test of time and I think is probably still the most used goose calling video out there. Definitely worth its weight in goose meat!!

Other calls to take a look at are the GK Giant Slayer. It is a Acetone call, that is a plastic similar to Delrin. Another indestructable call from a great maker that will get you going for around $60-$75. Other than that my favorites are the Foiles Migrators Strait Meat Honker, GK Giant Killer, and the GK Little Giant.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Bushwacker

Quote:

Just curious as to what you guys think...

Does good calling (calls) trump location & decoy spread?

I know... tough question.
grin.gif


I would say location #1, decoy set up #2, concealment is #3, and calling would be #4. That would be my order for getting 15 yard shots with landing gear down. The more you are hunting traffic bird the more important calling is. I have had times when we have shot birds by me just getting on the call and turning a flock to come over and check out our duck decoys, but that is rare. An ideal situation for me is to have to give a few simple confidence clucks, moans, and murmurs, and call out "take 'em". Is it Saturday yet??????

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Down2Earth

Any possibility in concern to borrowing one of those DVD's you guys have for a day or two if you're not using them any more?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Rost

Quote:

Quote:

Just curious as to what you guys think...

Does good calling (calls) trump location & decoy spread?

I know... tough question.
grin.gif


I would say location #1, decoy set up #2, concealment is #3, and calling would be #4. That would be my order for getting 15 yard shots with landing gear down. The more you are hunting traffic bird the more important calling is. I have had times when we have shot birds by me just getting on the call and turning a flock to come over and check out our duck decoys, but that is rare. An ideal situation for me is to have to give a few simple confidence clucks, moans, and murmurs, and call out "take 'em". Is it Saturday yet??????


I agree with this. I would also add that good flagging can make a huge difference.

Back to the original question on the expensive calls and whether of not they make the difference, I am not so sure that it necessarily has to be expensive. I believe that there are plenty of short reed poly carb calls that will get the job done as well.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Eric Wettschreck

Location, location, location.....good flagging, and a little luck. I have the cheapest goose call I could find on the rack. It kind of sounds like a sickly goose, and I shoot plenty of them.

I'm not saying the high grade calls aren't good. I'm sure they are. However, If I had to make a decision between a dozen decoys or a spendy call, I'd go a dozen decoys every time.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  



  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • SkunkedAgain

      I took those pictures probably seven or eight years ago. If I remember correctly I was heading up north solo, and decided like many others that I'd never fully read the spectacle and would capture it for posterity. I've never met or seen the guy, but I'm sure it would be an interesting time if you drank a few cold ones together. Speaking of Cotton, does anyone have a report on the El Toro lounge? I've always meant to stop in there but have yet to do so.
    • SkunkedAgain
      Losing Sue is a great loss to the lake community and all of those that had a chance to interact with her. My young daughter has had to deal with a few close losses in our family this year/winter already, so she will be really sad to find out next spring that her favorite "ice cream lady' is no longer with us as well. Sue and Ron were always part of the experience of coming up north. Like many others I'm sure, my wife got corner by Sue last summer about how we needed to buy Moosebirds! I'll miss seeing Sue's smile each time we walk in the door to pick up some random forgotten item, for ice cream, or to find something "Moosebirds" to take home and support a good friend.
    • BriGuy88
      Not sure how everyone else is drilling their holes with the k drill, but I have the 8" on a clam drill plate with the M18 fuel drill and don't have any problems with the drill overheating or the bit not cutting.  In 20" of ice, I clear the shavings 2 or 3 times during the cutting process and the drill cuts like a hot knife through butter.  Instructions on the k drill float are pretty clear that you should clear the shavings to prevent the drill from binding when cutting in thick ice.  Love my k drill!
    • smurfy
      depends on what lake you go to i guess. i was up the weekend it was so bitter cold. very few lakes have plowed roads like winnie, red, mille lacs. there was probably 6 inches of snow on the ground and lake. the snow on the lake was drifted and had a bit of a crust to it. not sure what the warm strech did to it though. there are several bait shops you could call!!!!!!!!
    • smurfy
      wow.........i'm shocked. its 27 miles from our cabin. stopped there also snowmobiling and coming thru fishing. quiet the place. so sad to hear.
    • h8go4s
      It's all on the DNR website.  Get out your map and check it out. Or you could take advice from strangers on the internet. Or you could hire a guide. "Trout Fishing: Seasons and Possession Limits - Streams Today's date: 1/22/18 SpeciesSeasonPossession Limit Inland except southeast counties Brook, Brown, Rainbow, Splake4/15/17 - 10/1/175 combined, not more than 1 greater than 16" Southeastern Minnesota counties of Dodge, Goodhue, Fillmore, Houston, Mower, Olmsted, Wabasha, Winona Brook, Brown, Rainbow, Splake1/1/17 - 4/14/17Catch-and-release only Southeastern Minnesota counties of Dodge, Goodhue, Fillmore, Houston, Mower, Olmsted, Wabasha, Winona Brook, Brown, Rainbow, Splake4/15/17 - 9/14/175 combined, not more than 1 greater than 16" Southeastern Minnesota counties of Dodge, Goodhue, Fillmore, Houston, Mower, Olmsted, Wabasha, Winona Brook, Brown, Rainbow, Splake9/15/17 - 10/15/17Catch-and-release only Southeastern Minnesota counties of Dodge, Goodhue, Fillmore, Houston, Mower, Olmsted, Wabasha, Winona Brook, Brown, Rainbow, Splake1/1/18 - 4/13/18Catch-and-release only East Beaver Creek in Beaver Creek Valley State Park; Forestville Creek in Forestville/Mystery Cave State Park; Canfield Creek in Forestville/Mystery Cave State Park; South Branch Root River in Forestville/Mystery Cave State Park; Trout Run Creek in Whitewater State Park and Middle Branch Whitewater River in Whitewater State Park. Also, within city boundaries of Chatfield, Lanesboro, Preston and Spring Valley. Brook, Brown, Rainbow, Splake9/15/16 - 4/14/17Catch-and-release only East Beaver Creek in Beaver Creek Valley State Park; Forestville Creek in Forestville/Mystery Cave State Park; Canfield Creek in Forestville/Mystery Cave State Park; South Branch Root River in Forestville/Mystery Cave State Park; Trout Run Creek in Whitewater State Park and Middle Branch Whitewater River in Whitewater State Park. Also, within city boundaries of Chatfield, Lanesboro, Preston and Spring Valley. Brook, Brown, Rainbow, Splake4/15/17 - 9/14/175 combined, not more than 1 greater than 16" East Beaver Creek in Beaver Creek Valley State Park; Forestville Creek in Forestville/Mystery Cave State Park; Canfield Creek in Forestville/Mystery Cave State Park; South Branch Root River in Forestville/Mystery Cave State Park; Trout Run Creek in Whitewater State Park and Middle Branch Whitewater River in Whitewater State Park. Also, within city boundaries of Chatfield, Lanesboro, Preston and Spring Valley." Brook, Brown, Rainbow, Splake9/15/17 - 4/13/18Catch-and-release only
           
    • leech~~
      Well that is pretty sad. Had a lot of good times, burgers and dinners up there snowmobiling and 4 wheeling.   www.grandrapidsmn.com/...hill...squaw-lake/article_aa3b5546-f7ed-11e7-b45d-c34d... https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=4&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0ahUKEwjnv_rsyOrYAhUGEawKHV-ECfoQFghCMAM&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.grandrapidsmn.com%2Fnews%2Ffire-destroys-the-hill-bar-in-squaw-lake%2Farticle_aa3b5546-f7ed-11e7-b45d-c34d5b1f648a.html&usg=AOvVaw1LRiuHCFf3M7Xusreg7vdH
    • Tom Sawyer
      Nice Bluegills Ricky! Those thumbnail sized opercular flaps are super special. H e l l those are thumbers!
    • Pat McGraw
      Well, check that one of the list. After trudging through the slush Saturday we were rewarded with a handful of undersized crappie. We'll have to try some of the options around Pelican next time. Happy, safe fishing everyone.
    • Cliff Wagenbach
      Beautiful weather on Sat and Sun. but plenty of traffic! No traffic today but still a very slow bite this morning. Could just be the weather change!??? Cliff
  • Share & Have Fun