Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

  • Announcements

    • Rick

      Members Only Fluid Forum View   08/08/2017

      Fluid forum view allows members only to get right to the meat of this community; the topics. You can toggle between your preferred forum view just below to the left on the main forum entrance. You will see three icons. Try them out and see what you prefer.   Fluid view allows you, if you are a signed up member, to see the newest topic posts in either all forums (select none or all) or in just your favorite forums (select the ones you want to see when you come to Fishing Minnesota). It keeps and in real time with respect to Topic posts and lets YOU SELECT YOUR FAVORITE FORUMS. It can make things fun and easy. This is especially true for less experienced visitors raised on social media. If you, as a members want more specific topics, you can even select a single forum to view. Let us take a look at fluid view in action. We will then break it down and explain how it works in more detail.   The video shows the topic list and the forum filter box. As you can see, it is easy to change the topic list by changing the selected forums. This view replaces the traditional list of categories and forums.   Of course, members only can change the view to better suit your way of browsing.   You will notice a “grid” option. We have moved the grid forum theme setting into the main forum settings. This makes it an option for members only to choose. This screenshot also shows the removal of the forum breadcrumb in fluid view mode. Fluid view remembers your last forum selection so you don’t lose your place when you go back to the listing. The benefit of this feature is easy to see. It removes a potential barrier of entry for members only. It puts the spotlight on topics themselves, and not the hierarchical forum structure. You as a member will enjoy viewing many forums at once and switching between them without leaving the page. We hope that fluid view, the new functionality is an asset that you enjoy .
Sign in to follow this  
Hammer Handle

Keeping bigger fish can create giant fish???

Recommended Posts

Hammer Handle    0
Hammer Handle

This article says that fish can grow faster if smaller fish are kept, but keeping only the "big fish" can cause some to grow into giants.

I think the article says that we don't know anything yet....

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/20037483/

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
polarsusd81    0
polarsusd81

Reading the story, it says the data was produced by a computer model. I am thinking that I will trust what is proven to be by the biologists that deal with the ecosystems on a daily basis versus a machine that will not function in water up to its knees. It sounds like a bs story with results that had to be published to get paid for doing a study.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Questor    0
Questor

It sounds plausible until you start to factor in fishing pressure. The big ones are usually the most vulnerable, so they don't last long when fishing pressure is applied.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
chrisduc    0
chrisduc

Very interesting thought. I have to believe each system is different and a lot of different factors will effect the outcome. Definately something to consider.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Fishin Beast    0
Fishin Beast

Bigger panfish do eat different things than smaller panfish so there is one point. But you will kill the genes in the fish. What happens when those few trophys die? The young of the trophy fish will automatically become stunted as there are only small fish left. What you do is just control the overall population. That happens by having big predatory fish in the lake. They will weed out the weeker fish and keep only the strongest panfish.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
slipperybob    0
slipperybob

Umm cannibals...giant fish eats big fish, big fish eats little fish.

Take big fish out of equation

Giant fish eats what? little fish...Ecosystem change/crash.... crazy.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
nofishfisherman    10
nofishfisherman

The logic just seems very flawed.

If you catch and keep the big fish what will be left to grow into giant fish?

There might be one or two elusive big fish that people couldn't catch which will probably grow into giants but they got that way becuase they couldn't be caught so from a fishermans perspective why would I want to manage a lake so that it maintains a very small population of giant fish that no one is able to catch?

I think the accepted method of releasing the bigger fish is working just fine and will continue to keep working.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
castmaster    11
castmaster

I think whats best is a balanced population of fish in all year classes and sizes.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
HateHumminbird    0
HateHumminbird

Most likely, there's a reason that the research in question was not published in a well-respected, peer-reviewed fisheries science journal. Rather, it was published in a very broad-brush journal with a less notable track record than many of the more mainstream fisheries biology publications.

Along with questions regarding modeling vs. sampling real populations, some of the major concerns I have are:

1. Interactive effects amongst different game species - i.e. predator/prey relationships - Cannibalistic or not

2. Assumption that fishing pressure, size structure, and environmental variables hold constant

3. Long-term sustainability of this approach

It seems to me that this flies in the face of years of fisheries research regarding selective harvest, fishing opportunity, and pressure. In other words, it's far too soon to suggest that harvesting large fish help what's left become giant; especially when based on an untested artificial sample.

Joel

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Dave B    0
Dave B

I dont think that they are saying that the overall fishery will have big fish, but that there will be a handful of fish that will be much larger than what is in a typical lake.

I saw an example of this growing up in Eden Prairie. We caught a ton of very small fish from Round Lake (which is about 30 acres, just under one mile around). They killed it off 2-3 times and there would be HUGE fish in there each time it was killed off. We would also stumble into schools of 1lb+ sunnies where the rest were tiny. It was extremely rare to catch a "regular" size fish, they were huge or stunted.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Muskiefool    0
Muskiefool

Computer generated Mother Nature confused.gif Heres a abstract of a study that shows how that theoretical computerized management system fails

Source: Blackwell Synergy

Populations where large fish were selectively harvested (as in most fisheries) displayed substantial declines in fecundity, egg volume, larval size at hatch, larval viability, larval growth rates, food consumption rate and conversion efficiency, vertebral number, and willingness to forage. These genetically based changes in numerous traits generally reduce the capacity for population recovery.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
papabear    0
papabear

It is intersting to try and theories fish size managemnet. We can guess and dream that wecan do things to produce trophies for us to catch. But genetics, lake classification, weather, overall fish population, development, and fishing pressure all have an effect on the lakes. We have lakes that will never grow trophies and lakes that consistently do. I wonder more of why must we produce trophies to catch. If that is your sole purpose of fishing you may be missing the boat. And we wonder why we are not recruiting as many young fishermen/girls.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  



  • Posts

    • monstermoose78
      Youth day is Weeks away !!! 
    • leech~~
      Sorry to hear. Being the guide-dad you want everyone to have fun. No fish on worms? Had to be the Eclipse!
    • JBMasterAngler
      Trip didn't go as planned. I had been asking some questions on here to get some info/ideas for the trip. Greatly appreciated all the stuff you guys shared with me. Unfortunately most of it wasn't in the plans  Camped at fall lake, as this was the first time my wife tagged along in a few years, and I thought his would be the most family friendly. After getting setup on Sunday, I launched the boat and goofed around for a bit, but didn't catch anything. My daughter was using worms, and she didn't even get a nibble. Is there not much for bass in fall?   Monday we had to spend some unexpected time in town, making certain purchases. Made it to snowbank late. Trolled for lakers, but only marked ciscoes. Once we started fishing for bass, we caught a few, but then the rain fell. Had it just been me and the 2 older kids, we could have fished through it. But with my wife and the youngest, it wasn't going to happen!   Pretty much the same thing happened on Tuesday. Went to burntside, but the lake was too windy. Went back to town, let the kids play at the park, then had lunch at the boathouse (I highly recommend the motorboat burger). Then we decided to keep it close and simple, and went to miner's pit. Weather got the best of us again. At least this time, my wife caught a few fish. No trout though.   Sometimes there's more to camping trips than good fishing though. We still had lots of fun, and I'm already making some notes for my next Ely trip, which I don't even know when will happen.
    • CigarGuy
      Tommy, can tell by your posts and photos that your dogs are very special to you and Bonnie.  I shed a tear or two while reading this.  I got a kick out of you telling me here after I saw you driving through Cloquet a couple years ago.  You saw my dog riding co-pilot and you mentioned that you also had a dog in the passenger seat (can't remember which one) and Bonnie in the back seat riding with the other dogs.  Good Stuff! Take care, Bill
    • TomWehler
      I pop in here a few times lately for some humor for myself, it is hard to do. No, very hard to do...but this sight makes me smile sometimes so here ya go...FYI.   Moe Rock passed August 14th  ~  4 days before what would have been his 11th birthday.
      He was our rock in many ways and was one of the smartest retrievers we have ever had in our family in 30 some years.
      If you knew Moe Rock you can understand, remember. He was so strong an fought the cancer just over FOUR MONTHS....
      Pills n tests an more pills an more tests...until well CANCER SUCKS.
      In the end the cancer wins no matter how hard he fought or how hard his TEAM fought with him and for him. Bonnie an I, the special vets an techs at Osceola Animal hospital and the top doc's, students and assistants and at the U of M vet center tried very hard and long to help him in his battle. He never changed, stood tall an strong, bright eyes an devilish smile.
      Truth is we only stayed a couple steps ahead of the cancer that took him that day at 5 PM.
      He was strong right up until he passed with Bonnie an myself holding his paws an making his passing go easy. Bother Polar Bear Boy looking on also.
      Don't make any of this easy saying this, but he was not doing good at 5 am Sunday morning as that cancer stuff just jumped him good this weekend an well,  he lost.
      We never gave in, nor did he. This weekend at the cabin he tried to enjoy himself, DID enjoy it all.  He swam, couple dock jumps, we fished morning runs an sunset, did boat rides, worked on some shore n boat small projects an ate pretty dang well. He was fine until bedtime when we knew an HE knew something was happening.
      Not good. CANCER SUCKS!
      We had a great time, Moe only showing to Bonnie an myself an his Brother Polar Bear Boy he was not feeling to good in the evenings the last week. Very sad. Never forget Moe Rock or his up north name of NoMoeToe given to him by long time guest in my boat from Capser Wyoming the late Mary Cob and his Chisago City area name the Fire Chief gave him of ThreeToeMoe. He was not only special to me but to a host of people in this area an on or around Lake Vermilion for his whole life.
      Good boy, darn good boy. One regret is not everyone that knows of Moe or knows him only online did not get to meet him in person.
      You would have enjoyed him in many ways as we all did.
      Loveable, big nut, sweet, smart, goofy, odd and a total tick that like to start fights with this brothers an then leave them to settle it while he went an ate their food or got best seat on casting deck my big black boat.
      Yup, Moe Rock was a Tick.   Any way....very sad are we, but he fought like tuff darts, a good long fight.
      Never whined a bit, did as was asked an stayed pretty much himself the whole time until that Sunday morning really.
      Not once showing anyone not in family he was sick, real sick. Still loved his truck rides, belly rubs, swimming his pool, wratling with me n Bear, watching TV, Playing on Kendel or computer with Bonnie an just plain being Moe to his brother Bear Boy...big smiles. Fishing, how he love3d fishen...mostly topwater of any kind, but he would go with me anytime, anytime....true fish hound was he, our sweet Moezy.
      I did not tell anyone about Moe rock but Mom Joanne as figured he might kick cancer to the curb an well..........
      Never gave up hope but most times cancer wins in retriever hounds, even our sweet Moe Rock.
      PEACE!
      Very Sad. Now running with his fellow Mallard Island Marauders that crossed over before him, Barney Toonder, Homer J., Bailey, Beckey, Buddy.....plus Jack n Ev the Kats.
      Some good party.....good food, big smiles and all that go with them....all very special. Lov ya Moe......I miss you my boy....rest easy until we meet again.   Keep on rocken!   Tommy
    • redlabguy
      W-W, and what kind of bottom, rocks? Dick
    • curt quesnell
      Here is the latest....it is changing quite a bit and the water is cooling off.  Check it out while you make your plan for Labor Day    
    • curt quesnell
      I have a few spots that I check but if you just go slow and keep your eye on the depth finder the schools of fish are scattered everywhere.  If you see fish, you will catch em  
    • Rick G
      One from Sunday
    • Cliff Wagenbach
      Fish Lake Baits in Harris had some nice large leeches a couple of weeks ago. Cliff