Guests - If You want access to member only forums on FM. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on Fishing Minnesota.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
chucker34

So What Do You Think About High Fence Hunting?

15 posts in this topic

Uncle Ted says get off your high horse in a recent Field and Stream interview published on his web site. He says hunting is hunting, fence or no fence. And that small-minded people or elitists, paraphrased, are against it. I'm against it so I must be elite. grin.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Personally, I am not as fan of it. Just not "my" cup of tea.

There are so many levels to this debate. How big is the enclosure - 10 acres, or several thousand? If you get into these huge ranches that are enclosed, it can probably get to be more of a fair chase situation.

If you start trading cervids and forth between hunting facilities, that could open up a whole new can of worms, ie CWD.

For handicapped folks, I could see where an enclosure hunt might be an only option for them to hunt.

I have hunted game preserve pheasants with my father when he was slowing down in his late 70's. It was about the only way he could get out anymore. It was a good experience to still be able to hunt with him. The true feel of the hunt was dulled somewhat by the fact that you knew the bird were there. It was also a nice way to get a young dog some good experience.

I have a lot of respect for Ted. He has written some good things, and done much for our gun rights. I do find his show entertaining for the most part. If that is how he chooses to hunt, so be it. For me, I just dont think deer running towards your stand when they hear the feeder motor spin would give me any satisfaction at all.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hunting in a high fence is a joke. My opinion.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

should the word "hunting" even be the verb that is used when speaking of enclosures or a pen situation...I personally think that is as far from "hunting" as you can get. In an enclosure situation, most of the time, it should just be called shooting or killing. Hunting is a word that means much more than harvesting or killing an animal! Save the high fence "shooting" for those people that can't "hunt" because of some illness, injury, age, or other misfortune...in that situation, I'm all for it!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I do agree that the line here has to be drawn based on the size of an operation. If I've got 5000acres and a fence on the outside, does it really matter? In general I don't hunt areas any bigger than 200acres. I wouldn't know whats happening in the other 160 anyway. Even if you own 40 acres and know it like the back of your hand isn't that the same?

I know there is a stigma with high fence hunting, but if it truly is fair chase, not shooting fish in a barrel, then I don't think it matters.

I think a bigger question is do they get put in the record books? Thats the sticky point of the arguement. Too much to prove and justify.

I say high fence hunts are fine say if over 640 acres (a square mile), but they are NOT allowed as registered trophies like B&C.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Great insight so far. I should clarify that I don't agree with it. But that doesn't mean if its legal and others choose to do it, that I'm going to blast them. That's when I do agree with Ted on being on a high horse, etc.

And I would agree with Ted that high fence hunting can be harder than open range hunting in many cases, especially when the high fence land in question is a huge acreage.

So I guess it comes back to what feels right to you. Fenced in doesn't seem wild or fair chase to me. Nor does "picking out" your trophy beforehand and spending $15,000 on a farm raised trophy.If I had that kind of money, I could go on several world class hunts with outfitters in Canada, etc., instead.

But its not black and gray. Some of these huge acreage places are in that gray area. Especially when there is no gaurantee or selection of trophy beforehand.

One such instance involved a large fenced in ranch I know of in Hawaii. They had a great write-up in Peterson's Bowhunting and I was fortunately in the neighborhood for work travel. I considered hunting sika bucks and does there as it was reasonable (compared to many whitetail hunts) and I was there but in the end decided against because of the fence.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think the term "high-fence" has come to mean anything with an enclosure. Unfortunately as you mention, that includes everything from a large ranch who has a fence, to the guy who bought deer from a breeder, raises them, culls out the poor genetics and charges folks thousands of dollars in trophy fees to hunt the one deer they paid for after checking out its portfolio. That to me is like going to the meat market. I don't care if you shoot it and eat it etc, but just don't go around bragging that you shot a B&C buck.

If I got offered the chance of a lifetime to hunt on one of these great preserves (not the trophy blah blah blah type) I don't know that I would say no.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I hear you powerstroke. I think what turned me off was little things like they talked about how good their staff vet was on their web site in terms of ensuring the health of the herd. I was like, hmmmm, seems more like a pet when you put it that way. But I would definitiely consider a hunt on a huge place with a high fence. I'd just be open and honest about everyone with how I took it and if they didn't like it, well, to heck with em'.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Interesting read, Size of the enclosure is a big factor, hundreds or thousands of acres you would'nt even know it's there so I dont' think that would be a problem for me. My family owns 80 acres of river bottom an if we fenced it off stocked it with deer an food plots an harvested only mature bucks an does thats another story. But on ther other hand letting only our elderly an under 16 years of age hunt in that way, I might be able to consider it. There is no way I'd pay money to do so though unless the acreage is big enough so it dosent have the fenced in feeling an a person can feel that sense of fair chase. I guesse if it dosent feel like your in a zoo to walking along with your guide an picking out the animal to shoot from a portfolio then whats the big deal, but I do agree with not allowing trophys into the the books that are harvested in high fenced hunts. The Pursute of Happiness, Freedom of Choice, as long as it's done humainly an by the law then have a good time. Later boar

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I hear ya boar. My old boss goes Bison hunting every year and brags about riding on the back of a pickup, picking out an animal, discussing cost and then shooting it with a rifle from a fixed rest on the truck. Where's the fun in that? I'm sure its fun to him, but I think its wrong. Kinda like picking your lobster out of the fish tank.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's also not my cup of tea, however, I wouldn't condem anyone for partaking in this hunting style. My biggest concern is transporting animals (who knows where from) and escaping animals contaminating the natural herds. I don't think there is a 100% escape proof fence.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just one opinion, but to me it is "shooting," not hunting. Whatever you want to call it, it is not the same as fair chase hunting. Anyone who thinks it is is kidding themselves.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think it makes a difference if its 100 acres here in MN or 10,000 acres in Texas or Africa. If its 10,000 acres, you could consider it a free range hunt. The recent issue of Bowhunter talks highly about going to Africa, and those are fenced in hunts, and I'd go in a heartbeat to Africa if asked!!!!

As far as canned hunts go, I think its your freedom of choice if you want to go and hunt behind a fence, I probably won't do it unless the area is huge (+1000 acres). Same with people people who want to have game farms, its their freedom to try and make a living.

Two things aboout preserve hunting that I do disagree with is 1) releasing shooter bucks/elk. That just gives hunters a bad name. 2) There should be lots tighter retrictions on game farms because of the risk they impose on the wild herd, like spreading CWD. Double fences should be mandatory so no nose contact is allowed, and to prevent escapees - you hear about that all the time!!!! Also don't allow wild hogs into MN, almost unpennable and the havoc they can wreck on a landscape is incredible.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

For me, I would have no interest in going to a preserve where a guide takes me out to where the herd is known to be and lets me shoot the animal of my choice. I can do that at my neighbors pasture of steers when their ready.

On the other hand, no matter where you hunt there is likely some form of fence or other barrier that contains the animals to some degree. I guess I don't buy the CWD or other disease issues when the area is large enough. These problems aren't necessarily caused by the fencing but more by the feeding that preserves probably do to maintain the herd. After all, they want their customers to take home the prize so they'll do unnatural things to help acheive that goal.

Even in SD where pheasant hunting is king, I wonder how many of those birds are naturally hatched on the property. I have some knowledge to suggest that many of those birds aren't even SD hatched and certainly not from the wild. Those ranchers want the repeat business so don't we think they'll take measures to improve the hunt, if you call it that?

Of course, none of this has been substantiated by true evidence but people are people, aren't they?

Bob

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It doesnt bother me at all if someone wants to hunt within a fench of any size. that is there choice. I probably would not do it but thats my choice.

As far as the fence, it should be secure enough to hold all animals within the area to prevent disease.

Some people dont have the extra time or just want to shoot a trophy any way they can and have the money to do it.

I really see no difference in a fenced hunt or a guided open hunt where you know you will get a shot at a real trophy for an added fee.

How about trail timers being used to know exactly what time that buck walks past a certain area? I see no difference between any method making it easier to harvest a deer.

Everyone has to make thier own choice.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Neutz68
      Yep that's us... Cabin #2 and #3...  You part of the other group we chat with up there??    
    • Walleyeslayer25
      Thanks for the reply.  Have had much time for research this year. Do you usually stay at pine tree cove? 
    • Rick
      People who enjoy the North Shore and Lake Superior and want to help shape its future are encouraged to consider volunteering to serve on the Governor’s Council on Minnesota’s Lake Superior Coastal Program.  This is a citizen advisory group that sets grant funding priorities, reviews grant applications and recommends projects to receive funding through the Coastal Program. All funded projects benefit Minnesota’s coastal area. The 15-member council is made up of three representatives each for Carlton, Cook, Lake and St Louis counties and three at-large positions that can be filled statewide. There are ten available seats on the council. The council meets about five times per year at various North Shore locations. Council members receive travel reimbursement and serve 60 to 70 hours per year while fulfilling a two or three year term. All adult Minnesotans are eligible to serve. Anyone interested can apply online at the Minnesota Secretary of State website or download a paper application. For more information about the Coastal Program’s work and service area, see the program webpage. Questions about the Coastal Program and application process can be directed to Amber Westerbur, Coastal Program manager, at 218-834-1445 or amber.westerbur@state.mn.us. Discuss below - to view set the hook here.
    • Rick
      The Department of Natural Resources will offer three northern Minnesota parcels in a public oral bid auction in June.  Two parcels in St. Louis County and one parcel in Beltrami County will be auctioned on Monday, June 26 at the DNR Office in Grand Rapids.  The properties include a developable lakeshore parcel on St. Mary’s Lake and a recreational parcel in the Kabetogama area, both in St. Louis County, and a 40-acre unimproved parcel in Lammers Township, Beltrami County. The area DNR Office is located at 1201 E. Highway 2, Grand Rapids, Minnesota, 55744. Registration will begin at noon, with auction at 1 p.m. Bidders are advised to obtain/view the property data sheet, be familiar with the property, minimum bid price, and terms and conditions of sale prior to attending the auction. Bidders must be registered before the 1 p.m. start time in order to bid. To obtain a property data sheet or terms and conditions of sale, call 651-259-5432, 888-646-6367 or email landsale@dnr.state.mn.us. The property data sheets are also available online at www.dnr.state.mn.us/lands_minerals/landsale/. Discuss below - to view set the hook here.
    • Rick
      There are plenty of fun places to go and things to do this Memorial Day weekend at Minnesota state parks and trails.  Here are some last-minute travel-planning tips: Camping. Sites are still available. Reservations are now required for all overnight stays at Minnesota state parks and recreation areas, and many sites are already booked, but here are some options: — Check www.mndnr.gov/reservations more than once. There are often cancellations, and the inventory of available sites changes all the time. –Take advantage of the long weekend to explore Minnesota’s northwest territory. Sites are easier to come by at the state parks and recreation areas in that part of Minnesota, and there are plenty of reasons why it’s worth the drive: — Zippel Bay State Park is located on south shore of vast Lake of the Woods, with a white sand beach. — Lake Bronson State Park has an observation tower that people can climb for a bird’s-eye view of the woods and wildlife below. — Plan a route to include visits to other state parks along the way, such as a stop to see the Headwaters of the Mississippi River at Itasca State Park. — Pitch a tent at a state forest, where no reservations are needed (or taken). Campsites at state forest campgrounds are all first-come, first-served. Naturalist-led programs. There are more than 100 programs taking place at state parks and trails over Memorial Day Weekend. For example:
      — Guided tours will take place throughout the weekend (and continue daily through Labor Day) at Forestville/Mystery Cave State Park in southeastern Minnesota and at Lake Vermilion-Soudan Underground Mine State Park near Ely in the northeast. Because the cave and mine tours are underground, it won’t matter if it rains. Reservations recommended; visit www.mndnr.gov/reservations for more information, including times and prices. —   Free guided tours over, under and through the fascinating rock formations known as glacial potholes will be offered Saturday, Sunday and Monday from noon to 1 p.m. at Interstate State Park. No reservations required. —  Plus, live reptiles, voyageur canoe rides, star programs, and more. For complete listings, check the online calendar. Discovery hikes. Look for deer, birds and wildflowers along one of the many scenic trails at Minnesota state parks and recreation areas. Pick up a Hiking Club kit ($14.95 at park offices), look for “secret passwords” on signs along specially marked trails and earn rewards. Two-wheel tours. Bike one of Minnesota’s many paved state trails. They’re free and mostly flat, because many of them are former railroad routes, and many of them now have trailside tune-up stations, if there is a need to tighten brakes or pump up tires. Find a trailhead at www.mndnr.gov/biking. Paddling. There are 35 state water trails, the newest of which is the 20-mile Shell Rock River. Many of the campsites along Minnesota’s rivers are first-come, first-served and free. See bison. See one herd at Blue Mounds State Park in southwestern Minnesota (and attend a program at 8:30 a.m. Saturday, May 27, about how the park’s bison herd links directly to the millions of bison that once roamed North America). Or drive through the bison range and see the other herd at Minneopa State Park in Mankato. Fishing. Minnesota residents don’t need a license and can fish for free at most state parks. Many park offices also loan out free fishing equipment for visitors to use. Or for people who have a license, they can wet a line at more than 1,600 fishing piers throughout the state. To find a nearby fishing pier, search by lake or county in the A-Z list at www.mndnr.gov/fishing_piers. Geocaching. Try this high-tech treasure hunt. Many parks loan out GPS units and offer programs to get started, such as the Intro to Geocaching program from 10 to 11 a.m. Monday, May 29, at Wild River State Park. For information, contact the DNR Information Center at info.dnr@state.mn.us or 888-646-6367 (8 a.m.-8 p.m. Monday through Friday, 9 a.m.-1 p.m. Saturday). Discuss below - to view set the hook here.
    • Rick
      Guided public tours of Soudan Underground Mine, the state’s first iron ore mine, will resume for the 2017 season on Memorial Day weekend. Tours will be offered from 10 a.m. to 4 p.m. daily, May 27 through Sept. 30, and on weekends only until Oct. 22 at Lake Vermillion – Soudan Underground Mine State Park near Tower.   Underground mine tours take visitors a half-mile down into the mine shaft in a hoisted “cage” and then for a three-quarter-mile train ride into the last and deepest area mined. Mine interpreters share information about the unique, high-quality iron formation and its contribution to the industrialization of the United States and the generations of people who worked in the mine from 1884 to 1962. “About 32,000 people take the underground mine tour each year, and it’s an experience you won’t find anywhere else in Minnesota,” said mine interpreter James Pointer. Guided tours are $12 for adults and $7 for children age 5-12. There is no cost for children under age 5. Hard hats are required and provided for underground tours, and visitors are encouraged to check the park Web page for suggestions about recommended footwear and clothing (it can be chillier than expected in the mine, because the temperature is 51 degrees Fahrenheit year-round). Visitors also can take a free, self-guided tour of the historic mining buildings that are above ground. For information about tours and reservations, visit www.mndnr.gov, email the DNR Information Center at info.dnr@state.mn.us or call 888-646-6367 between 8 a.m. and 8 p.m. Monday through Friday, between 9 a.m. and 1 p.m. Saturday. Discuss below - to view set the hook here.
    • Rick
      Attend an open house on Thursday, June 22, to help shape the future of St. Croix State Park. The open house will take place from 6:30 to 8 p.m. at the park’s St. Croix Lodge visitor center.  Staff from the Parks and Trails Division at the Department of Natural Resources will be available to answer questions and collect comments on the draft management plan for the park. The master plan will set the direction for the park for the next 15 to 20 years, with recommendations for managing natural and cultural resources and providing recreational and interpretative opportunities to park visitors. Recommendations in the draft plan include: Continuing efforts to restore pine barrens and oak savanna plant communities. Developing more staff-led interpretive programs. Renovating the Paint Rock Springs Campground. Creating new trails for hiking, biking, horseback riding. Designating trails for winter fat biking. The draft plan can be reviewed online. Copies are also available for review at the park office and at the DNR regional office, 1201 E. Hwy. 2, Grand Rapids. Anyone who can’t attend the open house can send comments to jade.templin@state.mn.us or to: MNDNR Parks and Trails Division
      St. Croix Management Plan comments
      500 Lafayette Road Box 39
      St. Paul, MN  55155-4039 The DNR will accept comments through Friday, July 7. Park visitors and the public have already participated in several ways during the development of the draft plan.  The DNR hosted an open house in June to gather initial input.  A citizen advisory committee then met four times over the summer and fall to identify issues and review proposals for the draft plan.  The DNR gathered additional input using an online survey and in-person interviews with park visitors. St. Croix State Park, established in 1943, is the largest Minnesota state park, with more than 34,000 acres of forests, prairie, wetlands and river shoreline. With many of its buildings and other facilities designed by the National Park Service and built by the Works Progress Administration and Civilian Conservation Corps, the park has been designated a National Historic Landmark.  After a 2011 windstorm caused significant damage, the park has been the focus of numerous restoration efforts. The park has miles of trails for hikers, horseback riders, bicyclists, snowmobilers and cross-country skiers.  Visitors can canoe, boat and fish on the St. Croix River – a National Scenic Riverway – and on the Kettle River, a State Wild and Scenic River.  There are three campgrounds, a horse campground, group camps, cabins and three modern group centers.  The park also has a picnic area, a swimming beach and a fire tower that visitors can climb for a panoramic view. The Matthew Lourey State Trail, which winds through the park, is open to hiking, horseback riding, mountain biking and snowmobiling. Visits to St. Croix State Park totaled more than 292,000 in 2016 (making it Minnesota’s eighth most visited state park) and more than 48,000 of them stayed overnight (second only to Itasca State Park). The park is located 20 miles east of Hinckley on state Highway 48.  For directions and a virtual tour, visit the park’s webpage. For information about the draft management plan, contact Jade Templin, principal planner, 651-259-5598 or jade.templin@state.mn.us. Discuss below - to view set the hook here.
    • Rick
      During the spring “cold water season” of Memorial Day weekend, boaters are reminded that wearing a life jacket is a safety necessity.  While boaters are encouraged to always wear a life jacket no matter the water temperature or season, public safety officials stress that wearing a life jacket – not just having it on the boat – is the one action that significantly increases the chances of surviving a fall into cold water. “The shock of falling into cold water triggers your gasp reflex, which more than likely means inhaling water,” said Lisa Dugan, boating safety representative with the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources. “Wearing a life jacket gives you a fighting chance to get your head above water, stay calm instead of panicking, and call for help before hypothermia sets in.” Despite recent warmer weather, water temperatures statewide are still below 70 degrees – cold enough to cause the gasp reflex and incapacitate even strong swimmers in less than one minute. In Minnesota, more than 30 percent of boating fatalities occur on cold water, and accident records show the victims are disproportionately male. “Over the past decade, we’ve seen a steady and troubling trend that indicates men between the ages of 20 and 60 are the most likely to drown while boating, and are the least likely to be wearing a life jacket,” Dugan said. “Cold water drowning victims in Minnesota are also much more likely to be anglers than any other type of recreational boater. Add this up, and it’s clear that if male anglers were to put their safety first and put on their life jackets, a significant percentage of boating deaths could easily be prevented.” Before the first launch of the season, anglers are also reminded to review boating regulations, inspect their watercraft and gear, enlist a mechanic to check exhaust systems for potential carbon monoxide leaks, and verify motorboats are equipped with the following: U.S. Coast Guard-approved wearable life jackets for each person onboard (children under 10 must wear a properly fitting life jacket while underway). A throwable flotation device on boats 16 feet or longer. A horn or a whistle. Type B, U.S. Coast Guard-approved fire extinguisher. Navigation lights in working order. Valid boat registration, with numbers visible. Watercraft can be registered in person at any deputy registrar of motor vehicles, at the DNR License Center in St. Paul, or online at mndnr.gov/licenses. Further details, including boater education requirements and information on preventing carbon monoxide poisoning while boating, can be found at mndnr.gov/boatingsafety. Discuss below - to view set the hook here.
    • Tom Buckles
      Any west end reports?
    • Neutz68
      Walleyeslayer25,   Group of us going up this weekend as well.. Sounds like Jig and minnow along shallow shoreline points, windswept shorelines and also some deeper water. We usually jig and pull Lindy rigs.. Always have decent luck fishing of the docks with slip bobbers too.  Check out www.gatewaygeneral.com.  There is a weekly fishing report posted on the website.